3 ms·
Imagine I give you $20. Then I tell you that you have to spend all of that $20 on x, y, and z. Are you penniless? Yes. You have no money. All of the government
by onion2k 12y ago
Imagine I give you $20. Then I tell you that you have to spend all of that $20 on x, y, and z. Are you penniless? Yes. You have no money.
All of the government's $3.4 trillion is budgeted for, allocated and spent. What makes the government penniless is the fact that they can't do anything else because they have no budget for it.
- refurb 12y agoBut the gov't creates the budget. They choose what to spend that $20 on.
- marcosdumay 12y agoAnd then we go into the usual falacy. No governemnt is a single coherent entity. The people creating the budget aren't the ones doing the spending. And the ones planning the outcome of the spending are even a thrid, disjunct group. If you try to sell something to the first group, you'll discover they are separated from the outcome by (at least) two layers of intermediaries, and probably have no idea about the problem. If you try to sell it to the third group, you'll discover that they have no power at all to put resources onto a solution. And if you try to sell it to the second group, you'll discover that they only care about accounting, and have no desire do think about resource allocation or real-world problems.
- PeterisP 12y agoThe whole point is to look at the budgeted allocations - if it has budgeted $100 million on foobar, then that's a $100 million marketplace for foobar-replacing products and services.