6 ms·
My favorite "layman's" argument for why time travel, as it's been classically described in science fiction, can't exist is that we haven't been overrun with tou
by aaronbrethorst 12y ago
My favorite "layman's" argument for why time travel, as it's been classically described in science fiction, can't exist is that we haven't been overrun with tourists from the future.
- randallsquared 12y agoSure, but CTCs only allow one to travel back to a time when the CTC existed, so I don't think that's a good argument unless there was a CTC-generating device in our neighborhood. Of course, as far as I know, all CTCs require infinities (Tipler cylinders, for example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tipler_cylinder http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tipler_cylinder ), which is an argument against constructing one...
- pyre 12y ago> CTCs only allow one to travel back to a time when the CTC existed So... Quantum Leap rules of time travel then? Oh boy...
- th3iedkid 12y agobut the full question being is we = all ?
- beachstartup 12y agoand my favorite refutation is that they've been here for a while now.
- ghayes 12y agoE.g. the fellow in this photo from 1940: http://www.dailygalaxy.com/.a/6a00d8341bf7f753ef01347ff60cea970c-pi http://www.dailygalaxy.com/.a/6a00d8341bf7f753ef01347ff60cea...
- ekianjo 12y agoNice fake picture :)
- ghayes 12y agoConsensus seems to be that the photo is actually real, just not so out of place. From the Wikipedia page "Time travel urban legends" [1]: > Further research suggests that the modern appearance of the man may not have been so modern. The style of sunglasses first appeared in the 1920s. On first glance the man is taken by many to be wearing a modern printed T-shirt, but on closer inspection it seems to be a sweater with a sewn-on emblem, the kind of clothing often worn by sports teams of the period. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_travel_urban_legends#Modern_man_at_1941_bridge_opening http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_travel_urban_legends#Moder...
- ekianjo 12y agoNot sure how one can confirm the photo is actually real, it's so easy to fabricate picture nowadays and to add noise to make it seem like it belongs to the original. It's be interesting to actually have an in-depth article on the methods to detect fake pictures, I have seen a couple on HN but they only focused on a few examples.
- eridius 12y agoIt strains credulity to believe that we do in fact have time travelers living among us and 100% of them have managed to completely escape detection. For what it's worth, there actually have been serious attempts at determining whether there are time travelers living among us, including at least one study[1] looking at Twitter for evidence of time travelers tweeting [1]: http://www.cnn.com/2014/01/03/tech/innovation/time-travel-twitter/ http://www.cnn.com/2014/01/03/tech/innovation/time-travel-tw...
- Amezarak 12y agoWho says they have escaped detection? There have been alleged time travelers like John Titor. Additionally, Titor and some other claimed time travelers have said the many-worlds hypothesis is correct, meaning that own history and experience does not necessarily provide them with the ability to make accurate predictions about our future. Additionally, we don't actually have any way of detecting time travelers if they decide not to do silly things like leak future information on Twitter. To be clear, I don't actually believe there are time travelers living amongst us, but studies of Twitter posts are very far from being conclusive, and there might be very good reasons why time travelers do not or cannot predict the future or just aren't very common anyway. For example, perhaps time traveling technology is legally controlled and extremely expensive, like nuclear weapons. The future of humanity is not infinite, so there's no guarantee that even if time travelers exist they should amount to any substantial number of people visiting any substantial number of times for trivial reasons like time travel conventions.
- eridius 12y ago> There have been alleged time travelers like John Titor John Titor is the only one I've heard of, are there others? And Titor's predictions, even the really short-term ones, were so off the mark that there's no reason to think it's anything other than a prank. Note that even the many-worlds hypothesis would have the short-term predictions coming true and only the longer-term predictions becoming more and more inaccurate (more importantly, any differences should be due to his presence, and his presence did not e.g. cause CERN to fail to discover the basis for time travel in 2001). > Additionally, we don't actually have any way of detecting time travelers if they decide not to do silly things like leak future information on Twitter. We don't have any way of detecting time travelers if they behave in a fashion indistinguishable from people who aren't time travelers. But it's pretty safe to assume that's not the case. They are, after all, from the future, and had a reason for coming to the past. That reason alone should cause observable differences in behavior. In addition, knowledge about future events should be detectable in some fashion, their lack of a real fleshed-out personal identity. Heck, even just their manner of speech should give them away. > For example, perhaps time traveling technology is legally controlled and extremely expensive We'd still see people breaking the rules, and such people would in fact be far more likely to attract attention. We live in a world where teenagers have successfully built nuclear reactors; no matter how legally controlled it is, someone is going to figure out how to do it anyway. If it's a matter of cost, some billionaire would figure out how to build it even without government approval. If you had billions of dollars to your name, and time travel was real, wouldn't you be tempted to build a time machine no matter what the government says? --- As far as I'm concerned, the only two really valid reasons why we haven't seen time travelers are: 1. Time travel is impossible, or 2. Time travel is possible but you can only go back as far as the point where the machine is first switched on.
- tzs 12y agoI'm sorry I cannot give a better cite than this, but sometime in the last 20 years there was a terrific short story, probably in Analog (but possibly in Asimov's) about the first time traveller. His first shock was when he found that the person in the past they selected to visit, Shakespeare, did not seem at all surprised when visited by a time traveller. In fact, he seemed to find it routine. The traveler at one point says he doesn't understand how Shakespeare can already know about time travelers, since he is the first. Shakespeare tells him that he may have been the first to leave, but he wasn't the first to arrive. Shortly after, many time travelers arrive...but not to see Shakespeare. They are reporters, from all throughout the timeline, coming to try to interview the first time traveller, and Shakespeare, an old hand at dealing with time travelers, steps in to protect the first time traveller and prevent him from being overwhelmed.
- atmosx 12y ago"The Merchant of Stratford" by Frank Ramirez (amazing approach, really unique and ingenious).
- andyjohnson0 12y agoLooks like it was in Isaac Asimov's Science Fiction, July 1979 [1]. [1] http://www.abebooks.co.uk/book-search/author/ramirez-frank-r/sortby/3/page-1/ http://www.abebooks.co.uk/book-search/author/ramirez-frank-r...
- tzs 12y agoThe internet tells me it was in Asimov's, in the July 1979 issue, so I was way off on the time frame.
- RyanMcGreal 12y agoReminds me of this classic: http://www.abyssapexzine.com/wikihistory/ http://www.abyssapexzine.com/wikihistory/ "Everybody kills Hitler on their first trip."
- Sukotto 12y agoLooks like this thread is gathering the list of good Time Travel stories. So here's one I like: "Dinosaur Beach" by Keith Laumer. A delightfully twisty and multi-layered novella. Read: http://www.baenebooks.com/10.1125/baen/0743435273/0743435273__18.htm http://www.baenebooks.com/10.1125/baen/0743435273/0743435273... Reviews: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/584217.Dinosaur_Beach https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/584217.Dinosaur_Beach
- rtpg 12y agoI've always found this argument a bit bizarre, because in my mind any time travelling device would work via a pair of machines: a sender and a receiver. So nobody could come to the present simply because there's no receiver yet. The reason we haven't been overrun by tourists because there's no stop in this time period.
- coldtea 12y ago>I've always found this argument a bit bizarre, because in my mind any time travelling device would work via a pair of machines: a sender and a receiver. Were did you get that impression from? Not most Science Fiction or Physics, because neither postulates such a thing.
- afafsd 12y agoActually the only vaguely plausible-ish (though by no means convincing) designs I've heard of for physically realisable time machines work like this. You do some horrendous things with spacetime curvature and you get something that can send you back in time, but no further back than the point at which you constructed your horrendously curved spacetime thingy. Paul Davis has a short book How To Build A Time Machine which does it this way, if I recall correctly (it's been a while since I read it).
- snowwrestler 12y agoIsn't it the premise of the movie Primer?
- dark_photon 12y agoScience Fiction is not relevant here. As for physics, you are mistaken. The only kind of "time travel" that has any basis in physics is the one using Closed Timelike Curves (which is what the article is about) and those are limited to the time the CTC was created in the past. So, in fact, this is a very good reason to reject the argument of "If it is possible, where are the time travelers?".
- inclemnet 12y agoI hate this argument, not because it isn't correct as far as it goes, but because it's very often represented as much more broad than it really is. That is, yes, we can be reasonably sure that time travel mechanisms whereby tourists definitely could and would become known in our time period will not exist (even this isn't the same as can't exist). But this is a very small sampling of time travel scenarios you could imagine, and I think it's far from the only thing described 'classically' by science fiction.
- gambiting 12y agoAnd my favourite "layman" counter argument to that is that plenty of time travel theories only allow travel as far back as to when the time travel machine was first created.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]