7 ms·
I thought the Tor project sort of agreed that Hidden Services could be discovered by a not-that-awesome adversary. Doesn't that vastly increase the risk of bein
by MichaelGG 12y ago
I thought the Tor project sort of agreed that Hidden Services could be discovered by a not-that-awesome adversary. Doesn't that vastly increase the risk of being found? After all, with The Silk Road, part of the evidence was that they had imaged the VM -- but they didn't say how they found that VM in the first place.
- jamoes 12y agoYeah, Tor as a whole, and Hidden Services specifically are very vulnerable to traffic analysis attacks. I'd love to see a project with a real focus on anonymous publishing of content. Tor's original goal was anonymous retrieval of content, with anonymous publishing just added on as a secondary goal. In order to make anonymous publishing robust against traffic analysis, it may be necessary to sacrifice the "real-time" goal that Tor has.
- api 12y agoIMHO you'd have to distribute the data and the computation so that there is no single point to find.
- contingencies 12y agoAgreed. Some ideas for the resistance of traffic analysis in the provision of Tor hidden services: layered architecture with aggressive caching at edge nodes, non-deterministic latency or update fetch algorithm (eg. random) between nodes, use of push rather than pull (edgier nodes have no knowledge of the location of content-publishing parent, only its key to auth inbound updates as they are supplied from unique addresses periodically) where feasible.
- EGreg 12y agoFreenet and now Maidsafe
- hackerboos 12y agoFreenet is only good for static pages as I recall.
- dublinben 12y agoStandard OPSEC for transactions on Tor markets is to GPG encrypt all communications. If you're just a customer, you have very little risk.
- curiousDog 12y agoThat still doesn't mean traffic isn't traceable right?
- duaneb 12y agoYes, but if you encrypt your drug request you won't have the evidence binding you to the purchase without some kind of bitcoin trace.
- corford 12y agoSurely if the feds bust the seller they'll then have access to his private key and be able to decrypt all his buyers order requests?
- aianus 12y agoThe sellers are supposed to delete personal information once the item has shipped. You'll have to take their word on it though.
- MichaelGG 12y agoOTOH, if the encrypted request is found, and you have a key that matches, that's very strong evidence you made the request. This line of reasoning was included in the Silk Road indictment.
- MichaelGG 12y agoI was referring more to the operators of the site. LE probably isn't going to go after individual buyers all that often. But the site will have a record of Bitcoin payments made, so you can link up sellers and buyers. And most people probably don't have untraceable Bitcoin. (I tried to buy $300 of BTC anonymously, and it took hours of work, and still reveals which post office I used.)