8 ms·
A girl with three biological parents
- iopq 12y agoYou have to wonder how far people are willing to go to declare things defects. At first it's just serious diseases. But then people will want their children to have correct color vision and other nice things. However, on the other hand, this could actually be a good direction to move in. We can not only eliminate genetic diseases, but also genes that predispose us to other common diseases like cancer.
- jacquesm 12y agoThere are other, less nice implications too. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugenics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugenics Is a good read, also the movie Gattaca (obviously fiction, but raises some interesting questions).
- netcan 12y agoEugenics is one of those words steeped in 20th century baggage. I think there is a parallel to geo-engineering. It sounds like it'll lead someplace troublesome. people can't be trusted with it. OTOH, we have international conferences where they're trying to reach some sort of decisions about how much carbon there should be in the atmosphere. Maybe they'll be deciding how warm it should be, or how much rain europe should be getting. Once we have the ability to influence these things we are geo-engineers, eugenicists, etc. It's not a choice. Not any more than we chose to take horses, ship rats and house cats to every part of the world.
- jacquesm 12y agoMost words that were not invented in the last 15 years are steeped in historical baggage. That doesn't mean that we should not learn from that history. In fact, if people start inventing words for things that we already have words for it's a good time to start paying attention, likely you're being sold on something.
- netcan 12y agoI think its more than just the words, it's the concepts themselves. Eugenics is scary, morally complicated, exciting and possibly inevitable. It has some historical associations with fascism and 20th century modernism in general. The whole thing make people uncomfortable. It's hard to criticize when people just get creeped out by the idea. Perhaps this is best left to our grandchildren.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoSo because Hitler wanted to wipe out Jewish people we shouldn't suggest that those with hereditary genetic diseases don't have children, or for example make genetic tests available to those who are [hoping to get] pregnant? All of these are called eugenics (though the first is not really focussed on genetic traits); pretending that "eugenics" doesn't carry any baggage because of it's association with Nazi Germany seems pretty disingenuous.
- arethuza 12y agoAny mention of eugenics makes me distinctly queasy as I learned from my mother in my mid 20s that I was almost aborted as an embryo on the recommendation of doctors as two of my older siblings are (mildy) physically disabled and they judged there was a risk I could suffer the same problem. Fortunately for me, my mother's GP discussed the matter with her and actually argued against the recommendations of specialists and I turned out perfectly healthy. This matter only came up in conversation when she mentioned that the GP in question had died and I said I had never liked him as a kid and she pointed out how ironic that was as he saved my life.....
- jacquesm 12y agoLucky you. Lots of kids were not that lucky. The problem with any kind of structural attempt at removing undesirable traits/children with defects from the population before they are born is the false positive rates are very high. Fortunately for you you're here and healthy. The flip side is that you might not have been healthy and then there would be a significant burden on those around you and society. These are very difficult problems and the harshness and ease with which people talk about them and pass judgement are in stark contrast with what a more informed person would probably conclude. The wikipedia article is particularly precise when it comes to articulating the problems stemming from slippery slope arguments around this subject. In the end, Eugenics is a tool that can be used for good and bad, just like every other tool. But it needs very good oversight and the use cases displayed so far are not all positive in my opinion.
- tiatia 12y agoDo you know what a disease is?
- tiatia 12y agoI don't get it why I am always getting voted done. And the parent poster of my comment obviously does not understand anything about what a disease is (feel free to give a definition without googleing it), why genetic variance exists and pleiotropic genes. But thanks for voting me down. Hint: What a disease is and what not, depends a lot on the environment.
- geographomics 12y agoI suspect it was because your comment was quite unconstructive, and comes across as a mildly sarcastic taunt rather than a genuine question. If instead you had explained why you disagree with the parent poster and offered some information on how best to define a disease, you most likely would not have been downvoted.
- tomp 12y ago> this could actually be a good direction to move in. We can not only eliminate genetic diseases, but also genes that predispose us to other common diseases like cancer. But where does this stop? Replace a gene -> replace mitochondria -> replace a whole chromosome -> replace the sperm/egg -> replace the whole child. We've come back to the real world, i.e. adoption.
- guard-of-terra 12y agoHowever, adoption is not quality controlled, and with the "whole child", we are presumed to control the outcome. However if this becomes widespread, we should be fighting to preserve diversity of benign genes.
- baddox 12y agoI'm not sure why you think adoption is at this end of the continuum. I would say that complete genetic engineering of a zygote "from scratch" would be at this end of the continuum. Somewhere in between would be selecting exactly which of your and your partner's genes go into the zygote.
- jebus989 12y agoMost uses of "gene" in this thread should be replaced by allele.
- emilsedgh 12y agoAs a third party observer, I think I agree with you here. However, when I put myself in place of people actually being harmed by this, I think it totally makes sense. And this process you (and I) are afraid of...This is not the beginning. It has begun since we started to vaccinate people.
- blueskin_ 12y ago>At first it's just serious diseases. But then people will want their children to have correct color vision and other nice things. ...and they should. Nobody deserves a suboptimal quality of life due to genetics.
- jychang 12y agoBut then we go full GATTACA.
- blueskin_ 12y agoAKA Affirmative Action Is Good: The Movie. We already bar people with heart defects from participating in space programs.
- maxerickson 12y agoI thought the whole point was that the main character got into space on merit, even though all the fancy genetic screening predicted that he wouldn't be able to. The human spirit of an individual triumphs over a short sighted and capricious society. You mention the heart defect. In the movie, the heart defect is only genetically potential, it is implied that if the character had it they would be dead before the events of the film.
- adrianN 12y agoHe does cheat on both the medical and the physical exams.
- maxerickson 12y agoSure, I guess I would refine it and say that he made it into space based on some standard of merit that I was defining, not based on the one the short sighted and capricious society defined.
- Filligree 12y ago
- exratione 12y agoEveryone should have the option of upgrading to better, damage resistant mitochondria, or the option to purchase effective maintenance of mitochondrial function. Some haplotypes are objectively better than others, allowing greater athletic ability or resistance to age-related disease, but we can go beyond even just picking haplotype. Progressive damage to mitochondrial DNA is an important contribution to degenerative aging. Wholesale replacement of either mitochondria or mitochondrial DNA (via any one of four or five different approaches) is a very viable near term goal. All of the necessary component of such a treatment have been demonstrated in animals and human cells in the laboratory over the past decade, leaving just the painfully slow regulatory and development process.
- reqres 12y agoPerhaps an expert could weigh in here, because I don't really understand the controversy. The "third parent" provides mitochondria which, by my understanding, doesn't affect the genetic makeup of the baby. In other words, the parents' genes which form the nucleus are intact and unmodified. Isn't this more akin to receiving an organ transplant than genetic manipulation/selection? Or am I missing the point here.
- zeynalov 12y agoAlthough most of a cell's DNA is contained in the cell nucleus, the mitochondrion has its own independent genome. And it affects the General genomic characteristics of an organism.
- jebus989 12y agoThe mitochondria has a genome (mtDNA). Not my area but I think while we initially thought it was a fossil of the mito's prokaryotic history and we'd subsumed all the good stuff, there are genes there that may be of interest for exploring ageing and metabolic disorders. It's also quite interesting genetically, as only passed down the maternal line, so can be traced back to a single "mitochondrial eve" (MRCA). This brings up some neat ideas in selfish gene theory wrt battle of the sexes etc.
- geographomics 12y agoAs a point of interest, there have been some rare cases of mitochondria being passed down paternally, most likely due to incomplete destruction in the embryo.
- sampo 12y ago> Isn't this more akin to receiving an organ transplant A "cell organelle transplant" is a good description, I like that!
- iamleppert 12y agoJust imagine that mitochondria are an API to a power system and the nucleus is the control system. Sometimes it works out that a foreign mitochondrial component (i.e. 3rd party) works well, or maybe there are even whole classes that work well. But we just don't know. Maybe they are directly swappable, but since we don't even understand all the processes that go on and what communication (exactly) takes place we can't say for sure, we just have to go on primitive black-box cohort studies.
- jebus989 12y agoI'd say you're massively selling current knowledge short. Of course in biology you can always go a level deeper and say "but how exactly... " however there's been a lot of research on mitochondria and there are entire centres that study it. In comparison to complex eukaryotic cells, the mitochondria have been see as relatively low-hanging fruit in terms of systems-level modelling (e.g. http://www.sciencemag.org/content/340/6140/1567 http://www.sciencemag.org/content/340/6140/1567) due to their simplicity as a regressed prokaryote with a short circular genome. adden.: here's a nice overview of the biochemistry of a mitochondrion, which has been known for at least a decade (and is taught at A-level or early degree level biology): http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3350335/figure/F3/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3350335/figure/F...
- guard-of-terra 12y ago"Sometimes it works out that a foreign mitochondrial component" Every embryo has 1/2 of genes foreign to mother's mitochondrias - with no gene or combination is guaranteed to be non-foreign. If it doesn't cause problems, why would having all foreign genes suddently cause them?
- fasteo 12y agoI did not want to comment in this thread as I am heavily biased and my opinion cannot be very objective, but let me just try to clarify some facts: About me: I do have a mitochondrial disease. In some of my cells, my mitochondrial DNA is not complete. If you think about it as a circle, about one third of that circle is missing. It is called a "heteroplasmic single deletion mtDNA mutation". 1. The mitochondrial DNA, much like the nuclear DNA, is a blueprint for building bits and pieces of our body. 2. The mitochondrial DNA encodes parts that are necessary to build the electron transport chain, i.e., to derive energy from food. In the car analogy, it encodes parts of the core engine (spark, combustion chamber, etc); the last step in the whole metabolic process. 3. The mitochondrial DNA does not encode anything outside of the electron transport chain. So, no blue eyes, no blonde, no smart. Nada. 4. This law will allow some kids to have a normal metabolism and a normal life. Nothing more. Nothing less. 5. I am well aware that this will open lots of possibilities for future genetic manipulation, but bear in mind that mtDNA is much more simpler than nuclear DNA and they are two distinct entities, so this law has no application in the field of traditional (nuclear) genetic manipulation. Hope this helps.
- iwwr 12y agoMaybe whole chromosome replacement can also be a starting way to cure some genetic diseases. In particular the Y-chromosome, which does not undergo recombination and so changes to it could be easier to predict.
- pbhjpbhj 12y ago>4. This law will allow some kids to have a normal metabolism and a normal life. Nothing more. Nothing less. // I don't get it. Of course on a personal level we have a biological drive, like a hunger, to have children. But on a group level I don't understand why we find it necessary to satisfy that need? The problem of children with mitochondrial problems being born, as in Bernardi's case in the article, could seemingly be solved by her having had a test to determine if she had mitochondrial disease (ie she would, in the future, qualify for this cytoplasmic transfer treatment) and then her not having biological children of her own. That would also rule out the potential for unknown complications later To me our current population seems barely sustainable and we already have plenty of orphans in need of families to care for them. It doesn't add up. Now, I'm sure if I were in the situation of this enabling me to have a biological family then I'd want it, that seems entirely natural. But objectively how does that benefit my community, country, the world?
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoOn a narrow view why have Dr Morrow's concerns been rejected if because his studies include lots of species but not humans. If, as the article says, there has been "a lack of funding" to do studies on the children who have survived following cytoplasmic transfer? Isn't this an important enough issue to do a study? Why would you say "there have been problems with all species undergoing this procedure who have been studied" and "humans having this procedure haven't been studied [in depth]" and conclude that the procedure was "not unsafe"? Who gains from pushing this through??
- maxerickson 12y agoIt says The HFEA's scientific reviews dismissed Morrow's findings as not relevant to humans because they were done on inbred animals. I think that the animals were inbred was probably important to that decision. There's also a paragraph where another scientist says: "Whereas the original techniques were used with only [experiments from] mice, rabbits, lab animals... the big difference here is we also have issue of human embryos and this work has been tested in macaque monkeys in primates. All those were very useful, reassuring… hence why we came to the conclusion that this is not unsafe." So "there have been problems with all species" is not a fair representation of the information given in the article.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoAgreed with your last sentence, I clearly skimmed over too fast - but that doesn't alter the conclusion for me; surely you'd want to actually look at the human subjects (at least) that resulted from this procedure in depth before concluding that it's not unsafe?
- maxerickson 12y agoI tend to give people the benefit of the doubt. As it is, "not unsafe" is a pretty soft statement to make, it isn't a declaration that there will be zero problems, it just reveals a certain amount of confidence that the procedure will be successful in humans. Perhaps they could have found a better way of phrasing it, but I don't see it as intentionally misleading.