8 ms·
Roadmap to Alpha Centauri
- idlewords 12y agoIt's sad that the biggest barrier to space travel remains the inability to mobilize large amounts of money to fund ambitious projects. We have no difficulty funding the most nugatory military operations at ten times the cost of a manned mission to Mars. But peaceful projects, whether on Earth or in space, run out of political support at a fraction of that price. It's a lot more fun to focus on the technology because the technical obstacles to space flight are potentially tractable. The human obstacles seem to resist any solution.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoYes. If history of aerospace teaches us something, it's that humans can make pretty much anything from scrap metal and duct tape if they care enough about it. Lack of advanced manufacturing techniques didn't stop Soviets from building awesome supersonic jet fighters from plain steel and with hydraulic controls. Lack of computing power didn't stop us from landing on the Moon, even though the machines that got us there are a joke compared even to a pocket calculator. The sad thing is, it's the same phenomenon that gave us all the growth and awesome technology we enjoy today that prevents us from ambitious space missions. Progress of technology is in a tight feeback loop with the economic system, and from the point of view of the latter, space exploration is a big no-no.
- TheOtherHobbes 12y agoThe economic and political system is Problem #1. It's not fit for purpose, and humans can forget about becoming a successful space-faring species until it's replaced by a system capable of rational long-term project planning, and which also rewards inventiveness, creativity, intelligence, and other talents.
- andrewflnr 12y agoI think it's a variant of bikeshed syndrome. It is (or seems) easier to understand the pros and cons of a military operation than a trip to mars, so it's easier to approve. Something weird will tend to get ignored to death. The cost figure doesn't even enter in, and is so huge to be out of the realm of reckoning for most people. This happens for earth-bound weird projects, too.
- QuantumChaos 12y agoThat argument is not logical. Military spending may or may not be justified, but if the whole world cut all military spending, it's not like space travel would get dibs on that money. Space travel has to justify its existence on its on terms. Right now I'm pretty happy with NASA's science based program. The Mars rover strikes me as a great way to get a lot of science for the money, and learn a lot about operating autonomous robots in space.
- idlewords 12y agoYou're rebutting an argument I didn't make.
- tptacek 12y agoUneducated guess: Military spending hits a sweet spot of being a tried-and-true generator of middle-class jobs, responding to a perceived urgent national need, and also functioning as a sort of insurance policy, in the sense that we're often paying for something not to happen, making it hard to assess value. A space program doesn't necessarily hit any of these notes. It requires specialized talent, responds to no immediate need, and, perhaps perversely, because you can measure the success of a space program, it's too easy to foresee things going wrong. I think you could make a similar case for why we don't plow $500bn into curing cancer, which is a manifestly better idea (even just from an actuarial perspective) than spending 10x more than the rest of the word on defense.
- idlewords 12y agoI'm not sure what you would do with billions of dollars thrown at cancer. At least with guns and rockets there's hardware to build. I suspect breast cancer research, for example, can't usefully absorb more money. I think you're overlooking an emotional component to military service. For a lot of people it ties into issues of heritage, national and personal identity. For many Americans it's synonymous with the idea of national service. If our grandfathers' Space Corps had stood strong and unbending in the face of the Martian landing pods, we would likely not have any trouble getting the cool missions funded now.
- mikeyouse 12y ago>I'm not sure what you would do with billions of dollars thrown at cancer. Giving every cancer research on earth the freedom to actually research instead of preparing grant submissions would probably be enough to substantially decrease the amount of time before significant strides are made. Especially if the money would pay for research assistants, statisticians, and quants to parse the data being collected. Outfitting labs with the latest in high throughput robotics, microfluidics, sequencers, etc. would amplify their efforts.
- marcosdumay 12y agoI doubt all that would take more than a billion or two. For the entire world. And giving more liberty to researchers will probably lead to savings, not expenses. It's both sad and great that we probably can not spend those $500B in cancer research, yet there is so much to improve.
- jp555 12y agoMoney is just the unit we use to measure what we value. The less we value space travel, the harder it is to do. It's a marketing problem, not an engineering one.
- chc 12y agoI don't see why it can't be both. If advanced space travel weren't a ludicrously expensive way of committing suicide, I'd support it more. But as best I can tell, the engineering reality is that we aren't ready to start accomplishing anything meaningful off the earth, so pouring money into that before the foundational technology exists is like funding alchemy. We don't currently have people living in a sealed-off bubble at the bottom of the Southern Ocean or something like that, so why are we trying to market a Mars mission or something even more outlandish? In short, I think the problem is that the evident state of engineering makes the venture look somewhat unlikely to succeed. So no matter how awesome your marketing makes the cause sound, it has to be marked down in the final equation in proportion to the likelihood that it is just an expensive way to die.
- Shivetya 12y agoI seriously doubt the lack of space travel is because we spend money on the military, if anything it might be the only reason development is still being done. Social programs are where the money is truly going, in the US alone there are over two thousand assistance programs at the Federal level. Space doesn't get money because space doesn't get votes. Military accounts for a large portion of the science of similar hardware because its development and deployment can be spread around and people can relate to it easier. Still giving the every day person a choice, go to the moon, protect us from the bogeyman, build schools, or free prescription drugs, I know pretty much the order it will go in.
- BugBrother 12y agoThe amount of money involved is not really the problem. I've seen arguments from the end of the 80s (sci.space.tech, Henry Spencer et al) that if the launch costs went down, the costs of building hardware would go down. From that, there should be elastic demands when e.g. universities can send their own probes. They also discussed how to do it (Big dumb booster etc). The point was, not that much more money would be needed for this (just check the really expensive launcher being developed by NASA now!). To lower launch costs is the key and it might be rocket science but, well, not rocket science. The reason this haven't happened until Space X seems to be mainly NASA's need to protect the shuttle (which was really, really expensive) and oligopolies in the launch business for military contracts. So maybe not the military, but the military contractors are involved.
- eudox 12y agoMissing: Project Valkyrie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Valkyrie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Valkyrie http://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/slowerlight.php http://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/slowerlight.php
- kabdib 12y ago(not original with me): "The fastest way to travel to the nearest star is to wait 100 years and then go." That's kind of depressing. But it's a lo-o-o-ng way to Alpha Centauri . . .
- tunesmith 12y agoI've wondered about that, and how the break even point would be calculated. The soonest date that someone could get to Alpha Centauri wouldn't be on the same trip for the soonest date someone could leave for Alpha Centauri (and get there successfully).
- rbanffy 12y agoAnd that will probably remain true at least until we have a functioning jump drive.
- rbanffy 12y agoInteresting there is no mention to EmDrive or Q-Trusters.
- dredmorbius 12y agoRead Charlie Stross's "High Frontier Redux". It's simply not that easy (and a. cent. is the wrong target). And no, it's not a simple matter after budget priorities either. Physics, bitch. http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2007/06/the_high_frontier_redux.html http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2007/06/the_high...
- BrandonMarc 12y agoWhat would the "right" target be?
- dredmorbius 12y agoStross answers that. My response is "under your feet".
- afafsd 12y agoStross says Gliese 581c on the grounds that it's the closest currently known vaguely-habitable exoplanet. Most likely there are others closer and we haven't found them yet. Probably not Alpha Centauri since it's a binary system.
- dredmorbius 12y agoA habitable plainet would require a vaguely Sun-like star. Odds of one hiding between us and a. Centauri are low. Gleise or a neighbor are best bets, and near exoolanets are also generally easier to spot.
- afafsd 12y agoNot one hiding between us and Alpha Centauri (which is unlikely), but one of the hundred or so stars between us and Gliese 581. Closer exoplanets aren't necessarily easier to spot, we've spotted those around Gliese 581 because they have a nice short period of a few days.
- kazinator 12y ago> Load your starship with 300,000 nuclear bombs, detonate one every three seconds, and ride the blast waves. Ooops! I cannot find the words "stop", "brake", "decelerate", or "slow down" in the article. I guess it is to be understood that you carry 300,000 more nuclear bombs with you and blast them in front so that you don't blow right by Alpha Centauri when you reach it.
- eudox 12y agoOr a magnetic sail to slow down. For that you might need a longer runway than Sol-Alpha Centauri though.
- ricardobeat 12y agoAlthough the article doesn't mention it, the original idea, having been worked on by a host of scientists and not a random person on the internet, does take that into account: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_%28nuclear_propulsion%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_%28nuclear_propul...
- rm445 12y agoDecelerating in space is the same as accelerating, you just face the other way.
- qwerta 12y agoIf you send automatic probe, you do not have to decelerate to take a few pictures and measurements.
- chisophugis 12y agoThe biggest barrier to space travel is our biology. We must create non-biological humans that can shut off and wait for the entire trip.
- enraged_camel 12y agoOr cyrogenics. It's all starting to come together guys!
- chisophugis 12y agoIt's about more than just shutting down though. Biological complexity makes it infeasible to significantly engineer our biological bodies to e.g. make them smaller to reduce fuel costs, or make backups so that we can easily do potentially dangerous experiments involving ourselves (also reproducible experiments). My prediction: humans will have to be 100% human technology to free ourselves from the Earth.
- TheSpiceIsLife 12y ago"What is more, the ship would be impossible to steer, since control signals, which are restricted to the speed of light, wouldn’t be fast enough to get from the ship’s bridge to the propulsion system located on the vessel’s perimeter." Would someone mind elaborating on what the author is saying here. I would have supposed the warp field would surround the entire craft. If this weren't the case the ship would be torn apart, no? Everything I think about warp drive is so coloured by Star Trek I observe myself having difficulty imagining it could be any other way.
- CWIZO 12y agoImagine a ship travels at 1.5x the speed of light. Now imagine the signal from the "steering wheel" travels to the ruder with light speed. You turn the wheel. Before the ruder gets the signal and turns (and let's ignore human reaction time) the ship has already traveled however much distance you cover when traveling at half the speed of light. You would have an enormous lag basically. Something like that :) I'm rubbish at physics :)
- alexyes 12y agoIt is extremely sad that we have not traveled beyond Earth orbit since the end of the Apollo program in 1972. Space exploration inspired many of us to study math and CS and fostered innovation. The majority of the most relevant people in tech in the last 30 years (Bill Gates, Jeff Bezos, etc.) have repeatedly commented how the Apollo missions were inspiration for the their studies and careers.
- dredmorbius 12y agoCorrection: humans haven't travelled beyond low Earth orbit since 1972. No human has ever travelled beyond Earth orbit. I believe the Apollo missions may have achieved Earth escape velocity, though their destination was Lunar orbit, which remains within Earth's.
- michael_nielsen 12y agoIt's a marvellous fact that the Apollo missions achieved escape velocity, or close enough that they could have done so with small design modifications. The calculation is fun: The kinetic energy required to escape Earth's orbit entirely is: G M / R, where G is Newton's constant, M is the mass of the Earth, and R is the radius of the Earth. The kinetic energy required to get to the Moon is: G M / R - G M / r, where r is the distance to the moon. To compute the ratio of the second quantity to the first, note that the GM factors cancel. So the ratio is: (1/R-1/r) / (1/R) = 1 - R / r The distance to the moon is about 60 times the radius of the Earth. So: Kinetic energy required to get to moon / Kinetic energy required to escape Earth's orbit entirely = 1 - 1/60 ~ 98 %. In other words, the Apollo missions had at least 98% the kinetic energy required to escape Earth orbit's entirely.
- xorcist 12y agoThe program did serve as inspiration, no doubt, but the fair question to ask is whether it was a better way to spend money than .. you know, actual science. Was society better from this than for example developing nuclear fusion or cancer treatments, which probably weren't more outlandish ideas at the time than going to the moon? What truly boggles the mind is that the US at the time was a country of housewives, racial segregation and prosecutions of gays and bisexuals. Yet, or perhaps because of that, they decided that the way forward was to build a moon ship. It says a lot about society at the time.
- Vektorweg 12y agoLets hope this doesn't start like Sid Meiers Story ...
- bane 12y agoA little closer, I wonder how far we are from making something a little more mundane like a Babylon 5 spinning habitat, or even a 2001 spinning wheel station. Are these just a matter of money, or is there some other fundamental technology challenges to getting those things built? I bet future Asteroid miners wouldn't mind a cheap place (relative to going down then up a planetary gravity well) to R&R between digs.
- BrandonMarc 12y agoI've wondered the same - why don't we make artificial gravity up there? The best answer I can find is experts saying, "What's the point, after all the trouble of getting to space?" The point is, living in zero-g is destructive to humans. Living in even 1/3 g makes a lot of things a lot better ... and a space station with a zero-g part as well as a small-g part would have the best of both worlds.
- idlewords 12y agoOr spin it at 2g and raise a generation of ripped space bros. Let's think big!
- lucaspiller 12y ago"Do you even lift?" has a new meaning in space.
- afafsd 12y agoDepends what you mean by "just a matter of money". If you could enslave the entire population of Earth to work full-time on the project for a couple of decades or so then, yeah, you could do it easily. In a world of free will and competing priorities I don't think it'll be possible until we reduce our cost-to-orbit. Certainly there are no big technological show-stoppers though. As a vague guesstimate, I've read 1km proposed as a minimum viable radius for one of these things. So you'll need a rim about 6km long. The International Space Station is about 100m long, so if you staple sixty of those end-to-end you'd have a minimum-viable 1g station, at a cost of about six trillion bucks. But of course it would basically just be a thin tube, not much living space. As for asteroid miners: I can't possibly imagine that this is the sort of thing that we're ever going to send humans rather than robots to do.
- qwerta 12y agoIt was calculated that 2 people would die from exposure every time Orion spaceship takes of. It is hardly 'nuking the earth' as article suggest. Millions of people die every year from background exposure.
- dghf 12y agoIf you're going to use a warp drive (or any other means of FTL travel), you'd better hope that Novikov's self-consistency principle [1] holds, or else be prepared to deal with the ensuing causality violations [2]. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Novikov_self-consistency_principle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Novikov_self-consistency_princi... [2] http://www.askamathematician.com/2011/09/q-hyperspace-warp-drives-and-faster-than-light-travel-why-not/ http://www.askamathematician.com/2011/09/q-hyperspace-warp-d... [Edited to add second link.]
- mrfusion 12y agoWhy can't Orion take off with conventional rockets and then switch to nuclear drive once in space? Wouldn't that address the main drawback?
- hcrisp 12y ago"(The stars) remind us of the puny distances we men travel; the nearest one, Alpha Centauri, is four light-years away, far beyond our capability to visit today or in our lifetime, yet beckoning, mocking us and our dreams." - Mike Collins (Apollo 11 astronaut)