5 ms·
The problem is people don't pick their routes based on cost, they pick their routes based on where they're trying to go to.
by eridius 12y ago
The problem is people don't pick their routes based on cost, they pick their routes based on where they're trying to go to.
- Fishkins 12y agoExactly. If this were implemented, it would affect me one of two ways* 1) The cost variation would be small enough that I'd ignore it. 2) The cost would sometimes be high enough to dissuade me from taking a bike where I wanted to go, in which case I would quit the program completely. I don't want to have to change my travel plans at the last minute. Even if the extra cost were non-trivial but acceptable, the mental overhead of having to decide whether it's worth it would make the program much less appealing. * If I were actually participating in a bike share program. Currently I own my own bike, but I could see using a bike share program in the future.
- xanderstrike 12y agoI think what he means by "negative cost" is that you actually pay people (in credit), to take the bike to the desired station.
- eridius 12y agoYes that's what I understood as well, although that's just one component of "dynamically price". And even that isn't really going to work. That's equivalent to just paying someone outright to rebalance bikes, except it's ad-hoc, only moves one bike at a time, and significantly complicates the process.
- SilasX 12y agoI agree that making money through riding a bike from a low to high demand station would be an edge case, but I don't see how it adds significant complication. You just list what the price would be at different stations if they return the bike there, with some being refunds.
- Scoundreller 12y agoWhich is what they do already, except they pay employees/vehicles/fuel. The providers have some philosophical problem with paying regular people to do the very same. Once they overcome this, the system will work a whole lot better and more profitably.