8 ms·
Is De-Skilling Killing Arts Education?
- BruceIV 12y agoI visited the Tate modern art museum in London while on vacation this summer, and left bothered by the idea of modern art. I could put a collection of furnace ducts in a corner, or hang a mirror on the wall, or bedazzle an internal combustion engine (all exhibits), but it wouldn't be art, because I don't know why it's art, and neither would it take any particular skill. It bothers me that this 'art' lacks both skill and approachability. As a PhD student, I'm no stranger to obscure academic fields that can't be understood by anyone outside your narrow specialization, but at least even the most obscure theoretical work in computer science might actually be useful to people who aren't theoretical computer scientists, and that possible future approachability to people outside the field seems to be lacking in modern art.
- anigbrowl 12y agoI feel the same way, despite being a fan of Dadaism and Marcel Duchamp. You might find it interesting to investigate the Stuckist movement, made up of artists who are similarly exasperated by institutional hostility to representation.
- groby_b 12y agoLike obscure results in computer science, (post-)modern art requires the observer to actually engage with both the field and the art object in question. Like obscure results in computer science, few will bother to do so. Of those few who do, even fewer can translate it into something that has any impact on the general populace. Dali was one of the few surrealists that connected to a large audience. Kandinsky is one of the few Bauhaus people to produce art accessible to a larger audience. Andy Warhol left a huge impact on the public as well - but again, not many pop artists did. All the above qualify as modern art, and all of them are approachable to a wider audience. I'd argue that we see the same in CS. And I suspect that "approachability" is a function of time - we forget about all the ones who had no success, and remember the ones who did. It'll be interesting to see what people say about modern art 100 years hence.
- BruceIV 12y agoIn computer science, the later approachability comes from people finding ways to use the work, and eventually we get to the point where the people using the work aren't specialists anymore (one of my professors used to say that if you're the first to do something you're a scientist, if you're the second you're an engineer, and if you're the third you're just a technician). With modern art (my impression at least) is that the art is contained in the commentary on society and the dialog with other contemporary artists, and that will never become more relevant or approachable, you'll just need to be an art historian to understand it in a century. That said, what I find approachable is not a terribly important criterion for art, I just found the it irritating that the actual art was in the process but the context of being in a gallery suggested that the artifact was the art. (For what it's worth, I also find theoretical computer science papers that produce unimplemented and likely unimplementable algorithms which shave log factors off existing bounds irritating as well, but that is again a matter of personal taste - those at least might give some later researcher a hint about how to actually build a usably better algorithm, though.)
- cardiffspaceman 12y agoThe difference is, if you don't understand or care about the lambda calculus, the computer scientists who do won't judge you. The practitioners and patrons of the arts who go off on these rarified tangents that require "engaging the field" do judge and dismiss those who don't understand or care for the creations of these practitioners. Thesis: if you did decide to "engage the field" of modern art, it would take about a year (i.e. equivalent of one serious college course of two semesters) plus intermittent reading from a popular journal such as ARTFORUM to stay current.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- lstamour 12y ago+1 for the correction. -1000 for missing the point. When I last checked, synonyms for modern include contemporary, current, present day... I'm having a hard time drawing a comparison to CS terms, but I'm sure there are at least a few similarly ambiguous to outsiders. Edit: I'll write here, since I do think it was worth stating, that the original correction was that "modern art" in this context is often called "contemporary art" to distinguish it from art from the period "Modern", which is then referenced in "Post-Modern" art. Yes, history can be confusing, art history just the same. I don't pretend to understand it either ;-)
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- normloman 12y agoLet's play devils advocate: If spilled paint on a canvas, and accidentally produced a fresco by Raphael, would it cease being beautiful (because it took no skill to make?). Do you go to art galleries just to be impressed by someone's skill? Is art a talent competition? Furthermore, what is unapproachable about a collection of furnace ducts? It's not to hard to understand. Just a pile of ducts. Does art always have present you with a puzzle to figure out, or contribute to some theory? Why can't I say "Look, a pile of ducts. Neat, huh?"
- IgorPartola 12y agoBy that logic, you should come see me play the guitar and sing. I am terrible at both (really, truly terrible; not being shy, objectively, you-would-rather-listen-to-nails-on-glass terrible). But you should come see me express myself and attempt to do this. It will be super artistic, I promise. The thing is, we agree that there is music and there is noise. People draw the line in different places, but we all agree that it exists. Why is it that I can literally shit on the floor in front of you and when you yell "what the fuck is this?" I can answer "it's art" and have the audience go "oh, he's good!"? Is it perhaps because, no matter what, I can say that my brand of art is just so new, so advanced, that nobody has understood it yet? Then have some PhD candidate years from now write a dissertation on how I managed to portray the human condition to validate the shit I put out. Wow, that turned into a rant...
- scotty79 12y agoI define art as creation that does not have to do anything but could invoke some feelings in the recipient. What's important is that you don't have to like art. If it evokes feelings in you that you don't like then just stay away from it. Appreciating art is not a contest. If someone expects you to appreciate same art as them that's their problem with expectations management not yours with performance. I would come to hear you play but if your music would invoke feelings in me that I wouldn't want then I'd leave. Some other person might like the chaos brought by lack of skills crossed with enthusiasm. The problem starts when people start talking about art ... they say dumbest things and often get away with it.
- anon4 12y agoRelated: How to Deconstruct Almost Anything http://www.fudco.com/chip/deconstr.html http://www.fudco.com/chip/deconstr.html - basically a detailed explanation of the equivalent of modern art in modern literary theory from a scientific person who went to great lengths to dig into it and understand what these people are talking about.
- vilhelm_s 12y agoI think we will probably be fine, for the reason the author mentions in this paragraph: > Just walking down the halls you could tell which classes were those of the fine art department. They were always sitting in circles and talking. In the foundation, illustration, and design classes the students were working; drawing, painting, designing. I had great students who went on to become successful fine artists, but who had to enroll in the illustration department to get the necessary skills (anatomy, perspective, painting technique) to produce representational fine art. Ironically, but not surprisingly, this famous school's most famous fine artists stem from the illustration department, not its theory heavy fine art department. I.e., skill in representational art is still being taught and valued. It just changed label, from "fine art" to "illustration".
- primelens 12y agoMost contemporary art needs to be illuminated by some mumbo-jumbo narrative about what it "means" before one can appreciate it. I get the fact that one of the things that makes art great is that it pushes the envelope on accepted norms - stretches the bounds of tradition. To have mere skill and craftsmanship and no individual vision does not make great art. But for me, the reverse should also hold - you can't have a total lack of coherence or skill and just get by on a pretension of "edginess." Unfortunately that is all that seems to matter in contemporary institutionalized art. I am repeatedly surprised by how contemporary early modern art (a.k.a. renaissance art) -- both literature and the visual arts -- seem to me at time and how they can combine truly radical innovations with an unwavering commitment to basic skills. Write that searing tragedy about the frailty and absurdity of the human condition ... but make sure you absolutely master your iambic pentameter first!
- groby_b 12y agoI'm surprised by this repeated statement that modern art doesn't hold skill. Most of the artists I know have enjoyed a very good education in the underlying skills, but then chose to break the rules. Is there a lot of pretense trying to sell art? Yes, absolutely - but it never lasts. Good contemporary art is exactly what you ask for. A solid foundation of skills used to completely abandon any conventional display of these skills.
- lmm 12y agoLet's get concrete; do you have examples? Particularly painting. I went to the Pinakothek der Moderne a few months ago and was really struck that, whereas in most "modern art" galleries I can find paintings I like, in one that restricts itself to post-1920 there was really nothing thought-provoking, nothing beautiful, nothing that even seemed like an expression of skill. There were interesting works in other media, but it really seems like painting has fallen by the wayside.
- lstamour 12y agoIf you're seriously judging all post-1920s art, or painting ... take a step back. There's plenty of art out there, more everyday. A short search on Google helped me discover this one, for instance: http://fineartamerica.com/featured/arc-de-triomphe-leonid-afremov.html http://fineartamerica.com/featured/arc-de-triomphe-leonid-af... Not to mention all the examples presented in this huffington article. There's plenty of skill in painting, the question perhaps remains, and has for some time -- if you have new tools, like computers, photoshop and photography, does that change the skill or quality of a painting or other artwork? Does it devalue it? Place greater emphasis on it? Perhaps what's sad is that universities are required to produce fine art in the first place, now that we've so many new models to follow for education...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- te_chris 12y agoIn New Zealand we have two main types of post-secondary institutions: Universities and Polytechnics. Polytechnics used to be technical training institutes offering qualifications up to diploma level (2 years FT study); due to some policy changes and liberalisations in the 1990's however this all changed and they started being accredited to give full degrees (Bachelors and Masters). A lot of my friends are artists and this has enabled me to observe the results of the different training people received. My friends who have been through their BFA/BVA from polytechnics are much, much more accopmlished now, post-school, than those who went through high-brow, university art schools (particularly ELAM, in Auckland). The emphasis on concept at the university schools is so overwhelming and (apparently) contagious for these students that they forget about craft. The friends at the polytechnics received a more balanced education, with a heavy emphasis on craft while still covering concept, and they're doing far, far better now. The only ones who seemed to survive the concept-heavy BFA and actually produce sustainable work seem to be those who were so technically accomplished going in that they could afford to take a few years off, thinking lofty thoughts, and not affect their craft too much.
- nether 12y agoI expect a discussion here as fruitful as one composed of fine arts majors talking about programming languages.
- QuantumChaos 12y agofine arts majors talking about user interface design would be a better comparison. The programming language used to create a program does not directly affect the user. The skill of an artist does does directly affect the viewer of art.
- lstamour 12y agoProgramming languages, like art, or concepts, don't spring out of nowhere. Both end up specializing to better solve the problems they're oriented to, and the biases of the person employing or creating techniques for them. That said, there's a counter to this "everything matters" argument -- that nothing matters, perhaps especially in art. I mean, while artists may invest personally in their works, end users or viewers will make up their own minds. The same can be true of software works (software works of art?). And yeah, sadly, I had two artists for parents; plenty of crazy to go around there, and theories at University didn't help any. ;-)
- pessimizer 12y agoThanks for announcing that, in case it ever had a chance of going a different way. Anyway, how could fine arts majors ever become programmers, or CS majors ever become fine artists? That's just crazypants.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- antinescience 12y ago@yellow_and_grey, I had the same reaction, relatively sure it was all wrapped in a sarcasm tag.
- dbbolton 12y agoReminds me of the sentiment in "No Skill No Art": http://www3.sympatico.ca/manideli/noskill.htm http://www3.sympatico.ca/manideli/noskill.htm
- dredmorbius 12y agoFascinating topic. But flagging for HuffPo's persistent social icon bar on mobile. Lose that shit.
- manachar 12y agoI know an artist. My favorite statement he repeated was, "It isn't art until it's sold, until then it's a storage problem". Highbrow modern art has a very very very tiny niche market of people who mainly invest in art of large sums of money for complex and personal reasons that normally boil down to looking for the next Pollock, Warhol, etc. There's an entire ecosystem of galleries, showings, parties, and auction houses devoted to these highly wealthy patrons. It's a pretty insular and self-involved world. An artists biggest skill in this market has little to do with their technical skill. Technical skill is easy and can be purchased on Fiverr if you need. Art schools are part of this market. Most people on the other hand don't go to galleries. They buy prints, hallmark cards, download wallpapers from DeviantArt, etc. Illustrators and graphic designers are thriving in this market, but are totally ignored by the high brow market (unless you get big enough). Basically, it's just artists following market demands.
- rdtsc 12y ago> An artists biggest skill in this market has little to do with their technical skill. Would it be accurate to complete the idea and say that it is about marketing & networking instead? The personality of the artist is just as much for sale as the "art".
- anigbrowl 12y agoThis is sadly true IMHO. In many respects, the marketing campaign is the artistic endeavor. I can sort of see how this fits into the historical continuum, eg in a few centuries ago the church and the aristocracy were the commissioners and arbiters of art and in that highly politicized context artists produced portraits of the powerful and religious allegories because that was what the market demanded. Nowadays artists produce work that is reflective and glorificatory of global manufacturing supply chains and ultraspecific brand identity and are handsomely rewarded for their personification of otherwise abstract corporate values - Damien Hirst and Jeff Koons being the leading British and American practitioners of this post-modernistic aesthetic. I think these artists are making a serious and successful artistic statement, albeit a highly indirect one. At the same time I find it sort of deplorable because I think art should be an intimate personal experience rather than a spectacular sociological one. Somehow I derive much more enjoyment from my own failed or inchoate than I do from most of what is promoted to me as art, with artists' statements that read like so much ad copy.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- lstamour 12y agoI completely agree. But I had to poke this with a stick: "Without exploring feeling, meaning, and imagination" (a) you don't need to drop practical exercises to add theory and (b) how does that compare to other types of "creating". I can't remember the last time I asked myself if I had enough "imagination" in my software code, yet it's true I expect that nearly everywhere else in anything I do. I wonder if this is part of the relative immaturity of software development. I mean, in math, sciences and design, all perhaps far from being "fine art," I can think of plenty of examples where imagination plays a role, if minor. But outside of design or UX, the closest code gets to imagination is perhaps UML, and that ... did not succeed very much. To counter my own argument, after thinking about it more, perhaps refactoring and TDD introduce a bit of imagination -- writing code that doesn't yet work, doesn't yet exist, or can be moulded into something else gradually, instead of treating a first draft as perfect. ... whatever. I've thought about this too long here. Moving on. Can you tell I had two artists as parents? And they both had degrees from the same university yet very different opinions on their art. I can't pretend to understand, I figure, without the background. But I like to consider whatever I'm doing to be in some small part, art. I don't think it's a crime to find math artistic, even. I happen to be in undergraduate Digital Media, half fine arts, half computer science courses. I'm thoroughly confused, these days, because it's untamed territory to combine the two in ways that give both an even shake. I've yet to fully embrace the fine arts side, particularly creating performance art, but maybe I've never taken it seriously yet. I've never liked how subjective its evaluations can be. Go figure, I've subjective evaluations at work all the time, and that's as procedural as it gets. Life is complicated, art reflects that.
- noelwelsh 12y agoThere certainly is imagination in creating software, from deciding on architecture, to micro-refactoring and optimisation. If you just work on the typical websites you perhaps don't see this, because the domain is very well explored at this point. You have frameworks that solve most common problems and you just need to paint within the lines they draw. Hence the emphasis on UX as that is where there is still rapid change and the chance to innovate. However, change your requirements and things get interesting. What if you want your website to respond within 50ms to anyone anywhere in the world? Suddenly you have a very interesting problem. You had better get creative with your architecture, because a bunch of stateless webservers talking to a relational database isn't going to cut it.
- IgorPartola 12y agoIt seems that the modern idea of "art" is something that (a) has not been done before and (b) something that makes you pause and think "is this art?" To me this is a very bad way of separating art from failed attempts. First, I do not think that you can objectively call something "art" just because it's creator called it that. They can be an artist and call it whatever they want, the same way that I can write a bunch of 1s and 0s and say "that is a beautiful computer program"; in other words some stuff artists create is not art, it's attempts at art. Secondly, art need not be novel. I enjoy sculpture, such as marble and bronze statues from Ancient Greece and Rome, as well as the Renaissance era Europe. There are lots of very similar pieces here. They all use the same mediums, similar techniques, very similar themes, and share an overall style. Yet, I enjoy this type of art. Why? Because it is so difficult to make rock look like a moving human body. Throwing dog vomit on the floor of an art gallery as commentary on the current geopolitical situation may be novel, but it is not art in my book. Edit: as an exercise, compare Rodin's sculptures to those of Joel Shapiro. Can you really say that these are somehow on the same level?
- Detrus 12y agoIs Joel Shapiro special and famous? His work looks boring but there is more than enough aesthetic mastery in art today, someetimes on par with Rodin. Abstract, surreal, real, take your pick. Just took a quick scroll through a popular portal: http://butdoesitfloat.com/The-question-of-integrity-will-get-finer-and-finer-and-more-delicate http://butdoesitfloat.com/The-question-of-integrity-will-get... http://www.xavierhufkens.com/exhibition/2006-09-antony-gormley http://www.xavierhufkens.com/exhibition/2006-09-antony-gorml... http://butdoesitfloat.com/The-bastard-form-of-mass-culture-is-humiliated-repetition-always-new-1 http://butdoesitfloat.com/The-bastard-form-of-mass-culture-i... http://butdoesitfloat.com/The-randomness-to-which-mutation-testifies-is-implicit-in-the-very http://butdoesitfloat.com/The-randomness-to-which-mutation-t... http://www.stephan-balleux.com/index.php?id=2 http://www.stephan-balleux.com/index.php?id=2 There is so much of this it will take one weeks to wad through just the quality work. And then there is a huge sea of ugly dog vomit. Just as with any product category, if you put enough crap out there, someone will bite. If everyone sees mostly crap, they think this is as good as it gets and bite en masse. The schools producing dog vomit artists are providing a valuable service to the art market by adding variety.
- kqr2 12y agoPeter Bagge's comic critique of modern art: https://web.archive.org/web/20080517130730/http://www.reason.com/0408/bagge.shtml https://web.archive.org/web/20080517130730/http://www.reason...
- yarrel 12y agoYes.
- asgard1024 12y agoMaybe it's unrelated, but I have a real beef with modern flat UI design and icons. For worst examples, look up the modern Microsoft production, such as VS 2012 or Lync 2013. Is the future really that ugly? These just seems to me, compared to old, nice colorful icons, as drawings of 6-year olds. I can't shave off the feeling that they are just cheap. Or maybe it's the consequence of de-skilling the article is writing about?
- sitkack 12y agoThis doesn't have anything to do with "modern art" it is a backlash against accuracy, precision and at the root, intellectualism and power derived from skill. Pol Pot and Punk Rock have a lot more in common than one would first notice. Originally, Punk was about the message and the adherents looked past the technical flaws, they viewed have skill as an un-necessary toll on communicating your art. If you are "raw" your message will shine through the flaws. But this rawness became calcified in the genre causing it to be a core tenet rather than an artifact. One could not be Punk and be good (skillful) at the same time.
- ArkyBeagle 12y ago"I'd rather look at Leyendecker ads all day than Picasso for five minutes. " http://sippicancottage.blogspot.com/2014/08/like-watching-alphonse-mucha-do.html http://sippicancottage.blogspot.com/2014/08/like-watching-al... (loves me some Sippican, for the curmudgeonly Yankee aroma it inspires )
- loomio 12y ago> Maybe worst for me personally was most all straight forwardly representational work was labeled "illustrative" and discounted as "commercial." While I find the "deskilling" of arts to be troubling, and experienced frustration at the lack of technical education as a fine arts student, this line made me realise that what might be deep underneath this is a rejection by those in search of "authentic" art in the face of rampant commodification by advertisers. In a world where the true human value of art is judged by the proxy of commercial value, and many of the greatest talents are using their abilities not to further human culture but to sell products, it's not irrational for people to seek art that cannot be commodified. It's a collective search for authenticity that's unfortunately flailing and grasping at straws instead, of unpacking the deeper causes caught up with larger social and economic currents.