6 ms·
Detroit Is America’s Emerging Market
- cylinder 12y agoArticle cites cheap rent as a reason businesses are flocking there, but I don't buy it. Houston's downtown, which has excellent office stock and is in the center of an exponentially stronger economy, has median rents at about $25 per square foot. Detroit's CBD median is $23 per square foot. Plenty of cheap office space all around this country so I reject that this is the reason.
- bluedino 12y agoMany midwestern cities have an over abundance of office space. If you drive down I75 through the Detroit metro area you'll see buildings that have been empty for years.
- angersock 12y ago...where else can you reside in Enron's old offices? :D
- nilkn 12y agoThis page is citing $39 per square foot for all "central business district" Class A office space in Houston: http://www.slideshare.net/AmberRuggles/q1-2014-officemarketresearchreport http://www.slideshare.net/AmberRuggles/q1-2014-officemarketr...
- sixbrx 12y agoTrying to figure out what exponentially means there. "Much"? Or is something varying that I'm missing?
- adventured 12y agoI suppose if there were such a scale for economic strength, that you could boil down to a 1 to 10 scale... In the US economy as a whole, Detroit would rate about a 2 or 3, Houston would be a 8 or 9. Exponential is an obvious exaggeration if we're being literal, but given the disaster that is Detroit, overly strong words may make sense to do the mess justice.
- bilbo0s 12y agoHeh... Visit Downtown Houston... then compare it to Downtown Detroit... I think you would rather be in Downtown Detroit. I live behind the gates on Sunset... and I'm sitting in the Museum District as I type this. So don't misunderstand me... there are a lot of nice places inside the 610 in Houston. Downtown is not one of them however. I'm a Houston guy... but I have to say... if you ever actually visit Downtown Detroit, you will find it is MUCH more clean and attractive than Downtown Houston. It was a visit to Detroit that made a lot of people around here kick in to redo or demolish a lot of the eyesore abandoned towers in Downtown Houston. There are just too many of these abandoned buildings in Houston's Downtown right now... so it's slow going.
- cylinder 12y agoWell fair enough. Houston's downtown is pretty boring but not too much blight although that abandoned Days Inn needs to go. My point was just that downtown Houston is the center of a much stronger and larger economic area.
- jngreenlee 12y agoIs there a PR firm behind the effort to make stories about Detroit appear here from time to time, or is it actually that compelling of a city-story? I have to think that there are many US cities equal to or superior to Detroit in just about any balance of livability metrics one could produce, including cost. Very abstractly speaking, I can't even see it being a local maxima for any particular basket of criteria...help?
- graeme 12y agoPeople find Detroit interesting because it was once a leading city, and then feel into a deep decline. People like stories of rise, fall and rise again. A city that is merely "better than Detroit" is not particularly interesting. The anchoring bias is certainly at play here. I imagine others contribute as well. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anchoring http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anchoring People also are interesting in the potential of Detroit. Detroit was founded where it was because it is on a river and the Great Lakes. It has good farmland (I'm guessing on that point). It is amidst other major cities. It has history. So if Detroit recovers, there is a natural support structure around it that will make it an interesting city.
- kelukelugames 12y agoWhen was the last time Detriot was a leading city? Early 90s to late 80s? I'm surprised most people on here are old enough to remember that.
- TwiztidK 12y agoI live just over an hour outside of downtown Detroit (with no traffic), almost took a job there a few months ago, and plan on spending a decent amount of time there in the over the next year. Detroit definitely isn't the best city, but there are lot of people heavily involved in making it a lot better. If the local government can miraculously get its act together, the city stands a chance to significantly improve over the next 10-15 years. Also, I see many more negative articles about Detroit than positive. The city water fiasco that is currently ongoing comes to mind.
- 12y ago
- protonfish 12y agoThis is certainly what Dan Gilbert would like you to think so he can resell his cheaply purchased real estate at a profit. Detroit has poor infrastructure (responsible for recent flooding,) high taxes, no public rail transport, poor roads, rush-hour traffic congestion, poor parking, some of the worst schools in the country, corrupt local government, is full of blighted neighborhoods, and I am sure many other terrible things. I am trying to see the reason why anyone would think it was a good idea to live or work there in its current condition.
- enraged_camel 12y agoYeah. Anyone who talks about how great Detroit is and how it is making a "comeback" is most likely living in either the small portion of the downtown core that has enjoyed some investments recently, or in one of the wealthy gated neighborhoods. They haven't traveled outside those places to see the real Detroit, which consists of rundown and abandoned neighborhoods as far as the eye can see and an incredible amount of poverty that permeates them.
- personZ 12y agoIsn't it possible that such a comeback is reflected in small areas at first? That the city isn't going to wake up one morning restored to its former glory? Comments such as yours (and the parent above it) seem to believe that Detroit is down and must stay down. That any negative in the town anywhere invalidates any positive elsewhere. But that is, of course, nonsense. Indeed, we heard exactly the same sort of noise about New York City in the 80s which, while clearly never hitting anywhere near the bottoms of Detroit, many wrote off as beyond repair, settled into a cesspool of crime and decay. The "real" Detroit includes an invigorating downtown, growing investments, and an actual tech community. That, too, counts as Detroit, and it doesn't not count simply because you can point to negatives elsewhere.
- enraged_camel 12y ago>>Comments such as yours (and the parent above it) seem to believe that Detroit is down and must stay down. It's not that it must stay down, but rather that it most likely will. The only reason it was a successful city at one point is manufacturing. Manufacturing has since left, and it's very unlikely that an equally lucrative industry is going to be able to fill the gap. In general, it's much easier for small towns to become successful cities (as Detroit once did), than for decaying cities to make a comeback (as some people think Detroit will do soon).
- sgt 12y agoSo is it a good time to start investing in property in Detroit?
- Shivetya 12y agodoubtful, even if they rename it Delta City. This piece came across as a feel good piece, if anything its a familiar story. Town goes down the tubes, yuppies move in and renovate old housing and such pushing what few remaining stragglers there are left out and help recreate a few revitalized islands amongst the rest. Usually led by a few strong business interest who promote the idea to get further concessions and good will all the while the decaying neighborhoods on the perimeter of these areas just stagnate
- mwfunk 12y agoThat sounds...great? You just described urban renewal. It's got to start somewhere, it's not going to happen all at once all over the city.
- Shivetya 12y agourban renewal does sound great until you realize the only people who suffer are those who are already suffering. So you have depressed prices which means large swaths of property can be bought out on the cheap. Then those areas get developed and local property values increase. However, instead of buying out the dieing islands of poor they are driven out either through increased taxes, zoning, or imminent domain seizures, which turn the property over to the very same people who would not buy it when they know government will take it for them
- adventured 12y agoNo, if you were so inclined, the time was several years ago at the bottom of the real estate crash. And in that situation, ideally, you just knock over the buildings and hold on to the land betting on a recovery one day. (knock over the buildings because the neighborhoods you'd be buying hyper cheaply into - for $1,000 a lot - if you don't knock them over, you're going to have extreme problems with upkeep, vandalism, squatters, homeless people taking up residence, drugs, etc)
- olegious 12y agoI visited Detroit for the first time this past weekend, I was surprised by how much I enjoyed it- beautiful, clean downtown area (much cleaner than SF), a very lively art scene (many artists ARE moving there for the cheap rent), many new bars and restaurants, a growing community of people that care and want to see the city improve.
- mikestew 12y agoIf you just visited the downtown area, some would argue that you didn't see the "real" Detroit. I might be one to make that argument had I been to Detroit in the last 15 years. Tell you what, could you do me a favor and catch a bus up to around 6 Mile Road and Woodward Ave. and let me know how things are looking? :-) (Seriously, though, unless Detroit has undergone some hard-core gentrification in the last decade, please don't do that.)
- olegious 12y agoI visited the abandoned neighborhoods as well and saw some terrible blight and impoverished areas- my point is that as an outsider, that's all you expect from Detroit, which is only part of the picture.
- burgers 12y agoI'm just not sure how Detroit ever comes back as any type of manufacturing / industrial center in the NAFTA era. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canada%E2%80%93United_States_Automotive_Products_Agreement http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canada%E2%80%93United_States_Au... There is no longer any real benefit to dealing with the additional expense of the weather issues with current trade agreements. Add to that the continuing expansion of contract manufacturing in Mexico. It just doesn't make sense for companies compared to Texas, Alabama, Mississippi etc. It's a great story, but I just don't see how it is possible beyond a small boutique city center for special cases.
- MichaelApproved 12y agoOne of the big problems with Detroit is that it's missing people to pay taxes into the system. That means the remaining people have to pay higher share of taxes for infrastructure that's supposed to support far more people. A solution could be asking immigrants to live there and giving them an accelerated citizenship schedule. If they live in Detroit for X years, they qualify to become citizens. That'll bring an influx of new people who will pay taxes, start new businesses and work at all levels of the economy.
- bilbo0s 12y agoI think this is the same as the idea of the Governor and the President. There are a lot of issues with it, but the main one I see is the jobs issue. Typically, immigrants move to places where jobs are plentiful. With a program like this, you are moving immigrants to a place, and then ASSUMING that jobs will follow. I'm not sure it works like this. I think places like San Fran, Chicago and Boston for instance, all draw a lot of immigrants because there are a large number of open jobs in these places. Historically speaking... setting up immigrant neighborhoods in the absence of jobs has proven to be a bad idea. If you have to use governmental incentives, and I'm not saying you do, but if you are going to use governmental incentives... I think a BETTER approach would be to give the incentives to companies and startups. If companies and startups come to Detroit, then people will follow to fill any jobs these enterprises create. I don't think you need to put forth more governmental incentives to INDIVIDUALS to live in Detroit. (In fact, I think that's been a big problem in Detroit in recent history). If you want healthy growth... it really does need to be predicated on a diverse and vibrant private sector. Now if you are absolutely bent on providing incentives to individuals, then Detroit should provide the incentives to recent college grads, or other young people to come to Detroit to try to make a go of a startup. Everything from free healthcare to nearly-free office space in some of the many available buildings just outside the development zones, (or even inside of the zones???), could be offered to them on a first come first served basis. Such an offer would, I think, be well received by today's young people given the troubles they are experiencing in the job market.
- MichaelApproved 12y ago
- infinitebattery 12y agoThe Madison Block[1] has a lot to do with the growth startup-wise in Downtown Detroit. Also, there are more and more meetups going on. For example, Detroit Soup[2] is a growing event and calls people to join, pay $5 for soup, and vote on a project that will benefit the city (people present their projects). Even MHacks, the premier college hackathon run by students from the University of Michigan, was held in the Quicken Loans headquarters this spring. I have also been to a few meetups such as one from the Detroit NodeJS group, and the Detroit Drones group- the meetup groups are active and growing. The city has had its ups and downs, but things are on the rise. Take it from someone who has lived near the city for 17 years. I think there are a lot of assumptions about Detroit, but there are a few things that are true: We have a 14.5% unemployment rate, a post industrial culture (culture of employees expecting to work for the Big Three immediately, instead of a culture of entrepreneurs), a financial problem, and poor Detroit schools (however the schools in suburbs are much better). I think that the combination of a lot of opportunity, and recent support from people like Dan Gilbert gave Detroit a huge start with the Madison Block, and that is the reason that people look at Detroit and what is happening in the city now. 1. http://www.madisonblock.com/ http://www.madisonblock.com/ 2. http://detroitsoup.com/ http://detroitsoup.com/
- tim333 12y ago>Many emerging-market cities, from Istanbul to Lagos to Mumbai, share similar characteristics, good and bad. hmm... Istanbul, Lagos and Mumbai are each the largest city and main commercial centres for large developing countries. Detroit less so.