7 ms·
I am continually astounded by the amount of support Russia receives from HN commenters. Is it that the Russian propaganda so strong that it reaches all the way
by IgorPartola 12y ago
I am continually astounded by the amount of support Russia receives from HN commenters. Is it that the Russian propaganda so strong that it reaches all the way to the Bay area, or are there a lot of Russians on here?
What I am wondering is when Russia will completely take over Ukraine and what will be the NATO position at that point? I have no delusions that NATO will not engage in any military conflict, since nobody wants to start WWIII, but this has to be disturbing developments for countries like Poland, Romania, etc.
Also, I wonder if Putin is really willing to continue this invasion at the cost of being ex-communicated by the US and parts of Western Europe? I suppose he is currently banking that most of Western Europe depends on his natural gas, so they cannot completely shut him out.
- JacobEdelman 12y agoI am disappointed by the fact that while their are several comments supporting Russia almost all of them have been down voted a ton. You shouldn't down vote people just because you disagree with them.
- bpodgursky 12y agoIf it's an issue which is remotely controversial and they are making useful contributions, I agree. If they are astroturfing for a country which is actively invading another sovereign nation, and lying through their teeth about it... I'm sorry, but you're not contributing to the discussion but instead are just spreading misinformation and your comment is not useful. Not all opinions are equally valid.
- venomsnake 12y ago> If they are astroturfing for a country which is actively invading another sovereign nation, and lying through their teeth about it... All of US circa 2003? No downvotes back then.
- IgorPartola 12y agoWhat bpodgursky said. Also, note how these downvoted comments typically include no sources, and are usually a one sentence attack on Ukraine, or a one sentence defense of Russia's actions.
- korzun 12y agoOpposite to your 10 sentences attacking Russians and painting Ukraine as a saint via multiple comments. IF you were Ukrainian you would not be defending it's government after they have been milking every citizen for their own purpose within the past 10 years. So I'm confused by your agenda, but it's obvious you are here to post garbage that blindly fits your agenda.
- legohead 12y agoit's hard to support either Ukraine or Russia - you definitely can't believe what either have to say. Ukraine is still having protests in Kiev, and calling for impeachment of the person they just fought to have put in place there... we can't cry foul at Russia arms/tanks showing up, considering what we give to Israel et al. also, considering Putin's track record, this is too brute force for him. he does things in such a way that make him look justified. it's hard to swallow. NATO can't do anything. they say "no war", but how do you enforce no war? sanctions hurt, but can be lived with, that only leaves...more war
- IgorPartola 12y agoThe situation in Ukraine is complicated, I agree. However, I believe Ukraine has the right to deal with their internal problems internally. This is like China saying "well, there are protests in DC, so let's roll the tanks right in and clean this mess up for them." > we can't cry foul at Russia arms/tanks showing up, considering what we give to Israel et al. also, considering Putin's track record, this is too brute force for him. he does things in such a way that make him look justified. it's hard to swallow. Yes we can. Just because someone is doing something bad/stupid elsewhere does not mean that everyone should do it. One country invading another is wrong, no matter how you put it. Moreover, this is not "military aid". This is Russian troops going into Ukraine. This is an invasion of a sovereign country. So no, it is not hard to support Ukraine in this: Ukraine is being invaded by a bull with big plans for how to re-shape Europe. Ukraine is far (very far) from perfect, but that does not mean it's up for the taking.
- rational-future 12y ago>> Ukraine is being invaded by a bull with big plans for how to re-shape Europe Yeah, you're completely right. That bull is our MIC complex, that needs fake enemy to continue stealing over a trillion dollars annually.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- foobarqux 12y ago
- spindritf 12y agoMany people are so dismayed with the US foreign policy and actions in the past years that they will (or at least seem to) support anything that isn't US. It's also true that for all their faults Russians were right about Syria for example. Or maybe they just lucked into being right by doing the opposite of what the USG wanted. Still others just don't want to be involved at all and are bothered by interventionist rhetoric. Or worried that involvement will only incite the situation. The latter seems to be a popular view in the EU.
- korzun 12y ago> Is it that the Russian propaganda so strong So you are just listening to the propaganda from the other side. And you think you are right? > What I am wondering is when Russia will completely take over Ukraine This is not about this. Things are not black and white. The situation there is extremely complex.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- IgorPartola 12y agoWould you say this map is propaganda? By who? The Ukrainian government? The one that can't get it's shit together to oppose this invasion, or really do much of anything managed to set up a whole bunch of very credible looking Twitter accounts, faked NATO satellite photos/reports, etc.? Ukraine has no propaganda because Ukraine doesn't have much of anything. These reports are very far from perfect, but they do seem to be coming from people with feet on the ground.
- korzun 12y ago> Ukraine has no propaganda because Ukraine doesn't have much of anything. Yes. This part sums up how un-biased you are.
- IgorPartola 12y agoFrom comments currently further down: > Shameless plug - try grasswire's crowdsourced feed, curated and fact-checked by hundreds of people in real-time. https://grasswire.com/#/newsfeeds/1fece014-714a-4cd9-a9dd-6b.. https://grasswire.com/#/newsfeeds/1fece014-714a-4cd9-a9dd-6b.... by austenallred
- korzun 12y ago> Shameless plug - try grasswire's crowdsourced feed, curated and fact-checked by hundreds of people in real-time. You do realize it's fact checked by people on computers who are probably sitting on their ass in US? Do you think people in the conflict zones are fact checking it? Seriously? You are playing telephone, that's what you are doing. We all know how that turns out.
- vezzy-fnord 12y agoThere's disinformation coming from both sides. It's pretty hard to have any nuanced debate on this subject, as you'll inevitably be branded a shill.
- vdaniuk 12y agoSure, as soon as you say something along the lines of "oh, you can't believe anyone" or "all media does it" or "the propaganda is coming from both sides" you are branded a shill. Because it's a shill tactic intended to silence a discussion and spread FUD.
- nobodysfool 12y agoThat's true. My wife is from Tajikistan, she called her mom and asked about that Malaysian airlines flight that got shot down, and it was like they were speaking two different languages. She goes 'did you hear about that plane that Russia shot down' and her mom says 'oh you mean the one that Ukraine shot down because they thought it looked like Putin's plane?' we were quite confused about what she said until we watched the Russian news and they had a completely different story. The Russian news agencies are state actors, and that's all they ever were.
- foobarqux 12y agoDid you know that the United States navy shot down an Iranian commercial airliner in 1988? How do you think that was reported in western media compared to how MH17 was reported?
- philwelch 12y agoCompared to how MH17 was reported in Russian media? I think the Iranian incident was pretty admirably covered by that standard.
- foobarqux 12y agoNo, how western media reported each incident. Virtually identical incidents (as close as you can get in history anyway), but completely different portrayals.
- pimlottc 12y ago> I have no delusions that NATO will not engage in any military conflict, since nobody wants to start WWIII, but this has to be disturbing developments for countries like Poland, Romania, etc. Don't you mean that you have no delusions that NATO will engage in conflict? Otherwise you're saying you think they will.
- IgorPartola 12y agoI think NATO would, under some circumstances, engage militarily, but not in this conflict. If, for example, a small non-NATO country with no nukes was to attack a member state, NATO would respond pretty quickly. In an alternate universe, if Ukraine (without any support from Russia) was to attack Poland, NATO would respond. But NATO is not strong enough to oppose Russia without major casualties. I believe that if all NATO member states were to at once attack Russia today, they would win but it would be a war, not a surgical strike. This is why we won't see that happening.
- jwr 12y agoI am Polish. It is extremely disturbing. What I find most appalling is that Western Europe seems to have learned nothing from our shared history. We already had crazy leaders invade small neighboring countries, and we tried to appease them without raising too much of a fuss, so as to preserve economic interests. This is how it begins. Now — we start to see history repeat itself, and what do European countries do? France seems to be fine with continuing to sell warships to Russia. Germany is mostly worried about economy and what the lack of Russian gas will do to it. Great Britain seems to be mostly occupied with thinking about whether to leave the EU. We don't necessarily need a full-blown conflict, but I'm of the opinion (that seems to be the majority opinion in Poland) that Europe should immediately impose serious sanctions and implement a plan to stop buying Russian oil&gas within, say, a year. Yes, it will tip economies into stagnation or even recession, but to hell with it: we should not be complacent and just watch as history repeats itself!
- dennisgorelik 12y agoWould you say that when Germany and USSR invaded Poland in 1939, UK & France should have started a war against Germany and USSR at the same time?
- explorigin 12y agoAs an American... Please don't read it as support for Russia but standard geopolitical fair. Because of the leaked Victoria Nuland phone call (http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-26079957 http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-26079957), it's pretty clear that the US is engaged in some clandestine nation-building in Ukraine. This is not democracy but corruption of democracy. In this situation, Russia is being an opportunist by securing its interests in the area. the US holds no moral authority over Russia in that regard. Putin knows that westerners are war-weary. And compared to ISIS, Russia is still a saint. So it's the right time for them to support their rebel allies. Poor Ukraine is being torn apart between 3 world powers.
- aagha 12y ago3?
- mpweiher 12y agoUS, EU, Russia?
- lcedp 12y ago(As a Ukrainian) I wonder what kind of secret nation-building activities could US be engaged in? Last events that raised the patriotism level were annexing of one region and bringing deadly unrest to another and both had come from the same world power. I can't see the other 2 tearing us apart. Not that they had to. People are shifting towards West even more thanks to east neighbour's aggression.
- zorbo 12y agoI'm in a position where I'm mostly exposed to non-western information regarding the situation in Ukraine, since my girlfriend is Russian. It's funny to see the exact opposite story as the western media is giving. Stories about pro-russians being harassed by pro-western Urkainians and the government were (and are) abundant. From their point of view, a pro-russian government was illegitimately overthrown. General opinion seems to be that democracy only matters to the west as long as it's not too inconvenient to them. Constant allegations and sanctions against Russia while they feel they have very little influence on what pro-russians are doing in Ukraine. Mostly, it seems like there's a feeling of pro-russian sentiments being repressed, the west not giving a damn and Russia's hand being tied via international pressure. Meanwhile, when I look at the western media, it honestly disgusts me. While pro-russian media generally seems to ignore a lot of stories that put them in a negative light, the western media seems to actively be painting pro-russian and Russia in a bad light. It's a general trend I've noticed in where western media is often on the offensive, and the "counter-party" on the defensive. I guess it's a cultural thing. Regardless, the Ukrainian government has been making a fool of itself in both the western and eastern media. Since this whole thing started, they've done nothing but make unfounded allegations, trying to "poke the bear" (Russia) and instigate unrest. I feel that they're responsible for a large part of the needless escalation in this conflict. PS: Your use of the word "propaganda" is an excellent example of how we view things. Everything the "other" side says is propaganda, anything "our" side says is necessarily the truth. This happens on both sides of the conflict, and I think it's a large barrier to actually start solving the problems. Rather than claiming "propaganda", we should consider it points-of-view, and the first thing we should do is ask ourselves: why does the other side hold this point of view, and how come they view it as a completely legitimate moral view to have? PPS: My girlfriend is, at times, greatly distressed by this whole thing. Like many Russians, almost half her family is in fact Ukrainian. Surprisingly, this seems to cause feelings of sympathy for those family members by both sides, yet they remain quite harsh against other Ukrainian or Russian viewpoints.
- varsketiz 12y agoThe "counter-party", which is Russian media is on the defensive for a good reason. They have a lot to be defensive about, ie http://www.businessinsider.com/nato-satellite-photo-evidence-russia-lying-about-ukraine-2014-8 http://www.businessinsider.com/nato-satellite-photo-evidence... Russia is offensive in their actions and defensive in the words covering it up. Would you like to provide examples of Ukraine's unfounded allegations against Russia? Would you like to explain how this is needless escalation, when part of Ukraine is occupied by Russia?
- jwr 12y agoIn Polish online press under every mention of Ukraine you will see lots of anti-Ukraine comments. These are written in broken Polish with errors hinting to Russian origin. The amount of these comments is way too high for grass roots support. They are clearly sponsored. What I find most amazing, though, is that somebody somewhere thinks that it is worth paying money for comments on portals like gazeta.pl — this is like sponsoring YouTube comments! Nobody sane ever reads them, it's a cesspool anyway.
- foobarqux 12y agoThe problem is that the same actions are interpreted differently based on who is doing them. If Russia were to support an overthrow of the Mexican government with one having a military and economic alliance with Russia the same people who bash Russia now would support the United States backing rebels, annexing territory and doing a military invasion. edit: I expect a lot of downvotes but no rational arguments.
- obvious_throw 12y agoIs it that the Russian propaganda so strong The opposite, actually. Many of us see through the transparent and obviously ham-fisted attempts of the U.S. propaganda machine to drive us into another war.
- bjourne 12y agoI think many hackers like me are quite anti-authorian and anti-establishment. The establishment and the media have clearly decided who the bad guys in the conflict are (Russia) and it's obvious from all the reporting. We remember what they reported in 2003 about wmd:s in Iraq so everything they say today must be read with suspicion. In many former USSR countries there are large Russian minorities living which was moved there by the Soviet Union to "dilute" ethnic groups. A form of demographic warfare. They still live there and aren't always treated well by the ethnic majority. So when nationalists topple the government they get worried. It's a much more complicated situation than the media reports even if it still doesn't justify a military invasion by any means.
- waps 12y ago> We remember what they reported in 2003 about wmd:s in Iraq so everything they say today must be read with suspicion. I still don't get why people say that : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Anfal_Campaign http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Anfal_Campaign http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=40142&Cr=iraq&Cr1=#.U_-UMGCx15Q http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=40142&Cr=iraq&C... http://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/jan/17/chemical-ali-death-sentence-halabja-attack http://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/jan/17/chemical-ali-de... And yet the idea that Saddam did not have - or use - chemical weapons is treated as gospel today. WTF ? I don't understand this. Suppose you are standing near a corpse, with a bullethole. You see smoke rising from the hand of a person who claims to have shot him. But the gun ... there's no gun. My conclusion would be : obviously he did something to the gun, let's go search, if necessary search the neighbor's house. The apparent conclusion I'm supposed to take away from that : "there never was any gun !" Really ?
- exelius 12y ago> Also, I wonder if Putin is really willing to continue this invasion at the cost of being ex-communicated by the US and parts of Western Europe? I suppose he is currently banking that most of Western Europe depends on his natural gas, so they cannot completely shut him out. Yes, he is. This is as much about internal Russian politics as any international issues. The Russian economy is doing well, but most of the gains are concentrated in the hands of the ruling oligarchy. So the people haven't seen much benefit, and are angry about their economic situation. Putin has put out a lot of nationalist propaganda blaming NATO (specifically the EU and USA) for any economic hardship the people face. This distracts from the fact that he and his buddies are basically robbing the country blind. He has cast himself as the "defender of Russia" in a geopolitical battle against the US and EU. A large part of this nationalist campaign has focused on building a "new Russian empire" from the former Soviet bloc countries. They've used the auspices of protecting "native Russians" in these countries (even though the idea of a "native Russian" is laughably absurd since the USSR forced everyone to learn Russian anyway) by providing Russian passports to anyone who wants one. They use the threat of invasion to extort cooperation from these countries and keep them in the Russian sphere of influence. Ukraine overthrew its Russian-puppet government, which prompted the whole invasion of Crimea. Putin knows that the EU needs his oil, so he's testing his limits to see how much he can get away with. The EU has shown no signs of imposing any real sanctions because if they did, the EU would go through a similar situation that the US did in the 70s. So Russia's infractions have to go so far that the EU is willing to plunge itself into recession. I don't know where the limit is, but it's not anywhere close to where we are now.
- tiatia 12y agoI don't know where to start. Crimea? Always was Russian. Once given as a "present" to Ukraine. Do you doubt that a second referendum would give a different result? What did the west do in and with Yugoslavia? What about the NATO expansion towards Russia? What would the US do if Russia starts fucking around with Mexico? Read this book and understand the foreign policy of the US and all the conflicts happening near Russia (Georgia, Ukraine etc.) http://www.amazon.com/The-Grand-Chessboard-Geostrategic-Imperatives/dp/0465027261 http://www.amazon.com/The-Grand-Chessboard-Geostrategic-Impe... Or a little bit information from "the other side" http://www.vineyardsaker.co.nz/ http://www.vineyardsaker.co.nz/ The EU has nothing to do in Ukraine. And if people want to secede, why not let them? Instead of the US/EU Freetrade agreement, the EU should have offered the deal to Putin and the problem if Ukraine does the deal with the EU or Russia would have been non-existent. A freetrade zone from Vladivostok to Lisbon would have been created.
- ceejayoz 12y ago> Crimea? Always was Russian. Once given as a "present" to Ukraine. You must be awful at Christmas. "I'm glad you enjoyed your present. Give it back now."
- philwelch 12y agoAt the risk of Godwin, "Danzig ist Deutsch!"
- tiatia 12y agoNothing hurts more than the truth. They had a referendum. Remember? Are you telling me the result would be different if done again? If so, why is the west not asking for this? I don't believe in slavery. "Let my people go" is a phrase from the bible.
- ambler0 12y agoI would never say that I support Russia in any of this, but it's important to put the hypocritical Western pearl-clutching in context: The near-universal Western condemnation of Putin includes citing the "emotional address" in which he complained bitterly that the U.S. and its allies had "cheated us again and again, made decisions behind our back, presenting us with completed facts with the expansion of NATO in the East, with the deployment of military infrastructure at our borders. They always told us the same thing: 'Well, this doesn't involve you.' " Putin's complaints are factually accurate. When President Gorbachev accepted the unification of Germany as part of NATO -- an astonishing concession in the light of history -- there was a quid pro quo. Washington agreed that NATO would not move "one inch eastward," referring to East Germany. The promise was immediately broken, and when Gorbachev complained, he was instructed that it was only a verbal promise, so without force. President Clinton proceeded to expand NATO much farther to the east, to Russia's borders. Today there are calls to extend NATO even to Ukraine, deep into the historic Russian "neighborhood." But it "doesn't involve" the Russians, because its responsibility to "uphold peace and stability" requires that American red lines are at Russia's borders. http://www.chomsky.info/articles/20140501.htm http://www.chomsky.info/articles/20140501.htm
- philwelch 12y agoGee, I wonder why Poland and Lithuania might have wanted to join NATO in the first place. It's almost as if they didn't trust Russia! How dare they. Russia would never invade a neighboring country.
- dzhiurgis 12y agoYou little ones are so ungrateful, sometimes I wonder why I ever kidnapped you...