10 ms·
What happened to Motorola
- sirkneeland 12y agoAs a Nokia employee, reading this article is like viewing my own corporate history through a funhouse mirror.
- marban 12y agoAt least Motorola didn't make tyres, right?
- johansch 12y agohttp://www.nokiantires.com/winter-tires/nokian-hakkapeliitta-8/ http://www.nokiantires.com/winter-tires/nokian-hakkapeliitta... :)
- ajb 12y agoHeh. A while back it looked like Nokia's market cap was on a trend to dip below that of Nokian Tyres, but it seems to have turned around now.
- akgerber 12y agoAlso available for bicycles! http://www.rei.com/product/792644/nokian-hakkapeliitta-w240-studded-tire-26-x-195 http://www.rei.com/product/792644/nokian-hakkapeliitta-w240-...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 12y agotl;dr: We gave away our competitive edge to the Chinese in return for goosing short term profits, and are now paying the price.
- ojbyrne 12y agoThats pretty tl;dr. Just looking at the graph I'd say this part was more important: "Motorola poured $2.6 billion and countless engineer hours into a $5 billion consortium to develop it. But once Iridium was finally operable in the late 1990s, its bulky $3,000 phones and $7-a-minute calls proved prohibitively expensive. Iridium declared bankruptcy in 1999 and sold off the bits for $25 million." Because that was when the decline started.
- ansible 12y agoI accidentally down voted you... But meant to up vote. Anyway, that is exactly what happened. We've transferred so much technology so quickly to China and India. The only hope for g the USA now is that standards of living rise in those counties enough that the wage gap isn't so bad, and more high tech can stay here.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- cwal37 12y agoThis is really a fantastic, in-depth article, and highlights a lot of pieces about Motorola's history of which I was totally unaware. The breadth of their innovations was far greater than I realized, and the early decision to set up a world class shop in China seems to be very visible today in that area of the world. That the internal competitions eventually led to internal war between different "tribes" doesn't totally surprise me. It seems you always read about that eventually happening in the post-mortem of any company with that type of structure. I wonder if there's a good way to balance internal competition. I imagine you would have to keep close watch on the overall silo-ing of each department. I'm from the Chicago area, and I remember driving by their campus many times over the years as a kid, only really having an idea that they were somehow involved in phones. I was in high school when the Razr came out, and based on how popular it was I thought Motorola was an absolutely world-dominating company, not a business on the rebound from extremely heady heights.
- derekp7 12y agoI used to work in their cell phone sector, then moved to corporate IT. The joke at the time was: A meeting was called between Chris Galvin (the CEO at the time), and the heads of the various departments, to show their new technologies. The cell phone guy says "We have a new cell phone, that you can also send and receive pages on it". The guy from the 2-way radio sector says "We have a new radio, you can use it to make cell phone calls on too. And we are working on adding paging capabilities to it". Then the guy from the pager sector plops his device on the table, and says "Our new pager is 2-way, and we've add the ability to make calls on it, with a earpiece attachment. And it has a built-in FM radio". And all the devices took a different power adapter, and different battery.
- salem 12y agoI was in Motorola labs until 2003, and the article is spot on. I had heard crazy stories back then, for example how the handset division (PCS) had to reverse-engineer Motorola Semiconductor products after buying a phone on the street in Hong Kong because they could not get the specs internally. The whole idea of Motorola competing with itself sounded as crazy to us then as it does now. Motorola was way too silo'ed and metrics driven, with a ruthless focus on efficiency, that was often short sighted. I guess no one there read the Innovators Dilemma.
- bane 12y agoIt really is shocking what a shadow of its former self Motorola has become. There was a time, not all that long ago that Motorola CPUs were a really valid alternative for a huge percentage of personal computers, that's really impressive. Atari, Commodore, Sega, Apple, SNK, Sharp, Texas Instruments, Sun, and more all made significant systems with their chips.
- joezydeco 12y agoMotorola Semiconductor was spun out to become Freescale. They're very much alive and kicking. Their i.MX series of application processors are in a lot of devices. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I.MX http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I.MX The old 6800/68000 cores live on in the S08/S09 and Coldfire lines.
- silverlake 12y agoI was at Motorola from 90-98. I recall that they were a bloated engineering bureaucracy that didn't understand software at all. The other thing is everyone knew Chris Galvin was going to run the company. Lots of executives left during that period. Finally, the iPhone killed everybody: Nokia, Ericsson, Blackberry. It was inevitable. When markets make big shifts, big companies can't adapt.
- marban 12y agoHowever the mid 2000s were the period of the highly successful Razr series which is still the #1 clamshell phone to date in terms of sales numbers. The very first Android phones weren't that bad either.
- joezydeco 12y agoThe RAZR succeeded on design, the software sure wasn't the key attraction of that device. Motorola's phone O/Ses (yes, plural) were all very underpowered. Something the Chicago Magazine article doesn't really mention is the death of Geoffrey Frost in 2005. Frost spearheaded the RAZR's marketing and started to turn Moto's fortunes around in the early 2000s. After Frost passed, things went rudderless on the eve of the iPhone and Android. http://archive.fortune.com/2006/05/31/magazines/fortune/razr_greatteams_fortune/index.htm http://archive.fortune.com/2006/05/31/magazines/fortune/razr... "He also had spun an appealing narrative about how Motorola was cool again, and a myth about the slick downtown Chicago design studio where the phone had taken shape." (Which never existed)
- Scuds 12y ago> The RAZR succeeded on design, the software sure wasn't the key attraction of that device. Yup. Synergy was probably fine for little B&W lcd screen devices, but they kept hacking onto it... > Motorola's phone O/Ses (yes, plural) were all very underpowered. More on this: "What killed Motorola? Not Google! It was Moto's dire software" http://www.theregister.co.uk/2012/11/29/rockman_on_motorola/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2012/11/29/rockman_on_motorola/
- 12y ago
- m_throwaway 12y ago(Sorry for the throwaway; I still work for the same company and we we still have various relationships with each other.) I worked in like '04-'08 building third party mobile software for a large variety of manufacturers and devices. Remember, this was pre-iphone, so there was a big business in building component X for device Y on platform Z. In my experience of device manufacturers: Nokia was insanely arrogant; the google of its day. Sony Ericsson were quite good, it showed that they wanted to build a quality experience. The Japanese manufacturers were absolutely insane. They would routinely produce P1 bug reports in the style of "we opened the X application repetatively. On the 1154th time it crashed on start-up. Sometimes." We had a few projects with Motorola together with US carriers. They were total nightmares - the Motorola engineers seemed like they had been picked up from the streets of Hyderabad the day before. (This is not a racial prejudice: most of the Indian engineers I've come across in the industry have actually been remarkably talented. This is not valid for the Motorola engineers though.) Most of these device projects were very high profile in the US, and presumably important for Motorola; yet they couldn't or wouldn't muster better staffing.
- Roboprog 12y agoHmm. Maybe that's why Google kept about 600 or so out of 17,000 or more. The streets of Hyderabad, eh? I can only imagine, having been there about 2 years ago. The level of construction and build-out is amazing. Where are all of the "trained" workers going to come from?
- MIKEMAC972 12y agoGreat article and very interesting comments. One big takeaway for me is the fact that Google retained ownership of all patents after they sold the business to Lenovo. It'll be interesting to watch Google utilize those across their entire business, not just on the mobile side.
- wutbrodo 12y agoThe patents were one of the main reasons the Motorola buy/sell was such a net win for Google (and that's without considering the benefit of strengthening the diversity of the Android ecosystem, tho we obviously don't yet know how successful that strategy was). When you factor in the value of the patents, the sale of Motorola Home, the tax benefits they got from Motorola's losses, and one last bullet point that I simply can't remember right now (ugh): what looked like a big loss for Google ended up making them something under a billion dollars (and again, this is before considering the value of the actual strategic intent of the deal).
- eru 12y agoThat's strange, they made money on the deal, but got tax benefits from the losses?
- mikeash 12y agoThe rise and rapid fall of Iridium fascinates me. They poured so much money into something with so little chance to succeed. And yet, it survives to this day. Essentially, the original investors inadvertently gave the system as a gift to the world. One story that has stuck with me goes that there was a presentation pitching the business case for Iridium. One part of the presentation goes, cell phone usage is projected to rise by X by the time Iridium becomes operational, leaving the market of Y - X for Iridium. Another part of the presentation goes, cell phone usage has consistently outstripped expectations by a factor of four, therefore our upside is even greater than we might expect. Apparently not realizing that the two claims contradicted each other, and that if cell phones really were growing so fast, it would mean little would be left for Iridium, which is of course what happened. But I can't remember where I saw it, and I can't dig it up now. Anyone happen to know if I'm remembering anything remotely close to reality, and where I might find info on it?
- mikestew 12y agoThe story I heard, and I don't care enough to even go looking for a link, was that some executive's wife couldn't make a phone call while on their yacht and thus the idea of Iridium was born. Whether or not that is true (and I would guess it's either not, or heavily exaggerated), either your story or mine does seem to drive home the misplaced optimism of the Iridium investors. Speaking for myself, when I'm touring the US on a motorcycle I can make do with some lack of cell coverage. If I really cared that much, and needed emergency communication, I'd bring a handheld amateur radio with which I can just about always hit a repeater when a cell phone has no signal. If I were to absolutely, positively have to have some means of emergency comms, I'd go buy a SPOT for a lot less than Iridium. And if Iridium ever had a chance to at least be viable, SPOT seems to have put a nail in that coffin. So the market we're left with is folks that have a need to vocally chatter to someone else no matter the circumstances. There are only so many war zone reporters and mountain climbers to go around, though.
- ihnorton 12y ago> There are only so many war zone reporters and mountain climbers to go around, though. The U.S. Department of Defense is Iridium's largest customer by far, and kept them alive with a large cash infusion at one point (if memory serves). Also, fun fact: iridium modems provide the only continuous data link for the U.S. South Pole station. There are 12 modems ganged together, used for e-mail and weather info transfer. Bandwidth: 28.8kbps. (the station also has several high-bandwidth uplinks, but the coverage windows for those are limited, and they have to compete with NASA/ISS for bandwidth).
- immy 12y agoI interned in PCS 2002-2004. Android wasn't out yet (but Danger Sidekick was) and Moto was already working on a Linux+Java OS. That project was the division's great hope, but missed deadlines on and on. Cramming a Java OS onto 2004 mobile hardware, very risky choice of a savior. Half the interns used Treo, Sidekick, LG. Half had a Razr.
- fndrplayer13 12y agoAs a Chicagoan who worked in another closely related telecom company, the presence of Motorola was huge. Not so anymore, but its certainly a 'hallowed' name in the area. You definitely hear a lot of stories regarding the way bonuses used to work, and what it was like working for a company that was sort of "Google-ish" for its day. Its sad whats happened to Motorola, but that is the way the economy seems to work. Another great unmentioned Chicago Telecom name here is Bell Labs. Chicago Mag could certainly write an entire article about the storied rise and fall of that company too. It just seems like all the Chicago technology greatness has melted outwards to the coasts. Silicon Valley and NYC (as well as foreign businesses) tend to dominate the areas that Motorola, Bell Labs, etc used to rule.
- aidenn0 12y agoAs someone who went to Purdue and would have liked to stay in the Midwest, it astounded me how few tech jobs were available in the Midwest (I graduated in '04). I didn't get a single callback of any sort from a company in the Midwest until 18 months after my graduation and it was to interview for a 1 year contract position at less than half what I was making at the job I accepted in Southern California. Nearly all my friends had similar situations, ending up on one of the coasts, or Austin.