3 ms·
I feel like you're trying to paint the inverse picture where the taxi company is the 'little guy'. > It's no different than what Wal-Mart did to mom and pop sh
by dmix 12y ago
I feel like you're trying to paint the inverse picture where the taxi company is the 'little guy'.
> It's no different than what Wal-Mart did to mom and pop shops, or what Amazon did to small retailers, or what Starbucks did to local coffee shops.
Mom and pop shops rarely had regulators preventing Walmart and Starbucks from touching their market share. We're talking about very large centralized taxi companies that run entire cities. Most cities have 2-3 large companies dominating the entire city with a few minor players running limo services. Even in small towns the companies are hardly small friendly businesses.
My father drove taxi for years for multiple different taxi cartels and they all paid their workers poorly, withheld funds for weeks whenever customers used credit cards, and often only hired new drivers within their family/network. He loved the freedom of driving but hated the companies. He only enjoyed it when he could become a broker aka owning his own car and being able to distance himself from the company.
I hear similar stories from every Taxi driver I speak to, which is often. They see Uber/Hailo technology as liberating.
I see neither Uber nor the Taxi companies as the David vs Goliath. But Uber-style technology has given drivers the opportunity to make higher wages AND be independent from local cartels, while opening the door to new entrants in the market both for new drivers and new tech, even decentralized tech in the future.
So I do agree that the tech/news industry should make sure the real issue being debated is technology vs the nature of regulation, and stop looking for archetypical narratives. Instead of trying to reverse the narrative in favor of the other side.
- spullara 12y agoActually, in many places, Mom and Pop stores have regulators that stop Walmart and Starbucks from opening stores near them.
- adventured 12y agoVery few locations in the United States have regulations protecting mom & pop stores from Walmart or Starbucks. You're exaggerating by an extreme factor. You can count the number of municipalities with such actual laws to the tune of less than 100 out of 19,000 cities in the US.
- calvinbhai 12y ago"Taxi company is the 'little guy'" analogy is wrong. There are many different structures of taxi companies. Some Fleets are owned by drivers (similar to employee owned companies). Some fleets are owned by a single company, who got into the business at the right time to benefit from it (of course with a high upfront investment). And then there are some groups of fleets owned by a single company, sometimes across many cities. So a 'Taxi Company' can be worth anywhere between a $100,000 company to a $100 million, based on the structure. The 'little guy' analogy was false for sometime since Uber and Lyft disrupted the market. But now, compared to Uber and Lyft at current valuations (multiple billions), these fleets (any type) are certainly "tiny" if not "little guys". TNC disruption has been necessary for a long time, since regulations didn't evolve continually to reflect market demands/requirements. Now its time to turn the heat on the TNCs to ensure the driver/rider is not screwed due to lack of valid insurance and licenses. I foresee a point where Uber and Lyft will get more regulated, existing taxis will get a fair playground in terms of insurance and pricing flexibility, and more transport options will become available for everyone.