5 ms·
As you point out, most people are critiquing the state intervention for being woefully outdated and not inline with market economics (as they always seem to end
by dmix 12y ago
As you point out, most people are critiquing the state intervention for being woefully outdated and not inline with market economics (as they always seem to end up being overtime thanks to technology). No-one really thinks the Taxi companies are the "evil" ones because they were handed monopolies on a platter then got comfortable and fat with their position.
If the local administrators have the power to hand out monopolies, they should also have the responsibility to retract it when it no longer makes sense. A repeated and long-delayed failure to do so is harmful to society, whether or not it was had good intentions at the beginning doesn't absolve it of criticism now.
- serve_yay 12y agoIt's a bad law, but as people point out downthread, breaking a bad law is not in itself a good deed, it is simply a neutral one.
- jvoorhis 12y agoThat's a good soundbite, but I don't like it. Breaking a bad law can be virtuous, but I suspect in this case it's neutral at best.
- ZachPruckowski 12y ago>Breaking a bad law can be virtuous, but I suspect in this case it's neutral at best. It's not "breaking a bad law" that can be virtuous, it's the case. Sit-ins are/were virtuous because the cause (civil rights) was just. The cause here is primarily "Uber and its investors want to make more money".
- rayiner 12y agoI do think the local municipalities have a responsibility to revisit the regulations in light of a changing market, and frankly I believe a lot of the "universal coverage" motivations of the original regulations are misguided and never should have been in place to begin with. That said, the narrative painted by the tech press has focused mostly on the efforts of cab companies to "stifle innovation" without acknowledging that they are defending legitimate rights. They paint Uber as a scrappy startup trying to compete with "fat" cab companies that have regulators in their pockets. The tech press narrative is simultaneously baseless and self-aggrandizing. The real narrative is less sexy: technology is enabling companies like Uber to eat up markets previous served, rather inefficiently, by modestly profitable small businesses. It's no different than what Wal-Mart did to mom and pop shops, or what Amazon did to small retailers, or what Starbucks did to local coffee shops. A national corporation can offer better service and lower prices, and can exercise quality control that obviates much of the need for regulation. This is both good and bad, but mostly, it's just the way the world works. There's no reason, on top of all that, to demonize cab companies for trying to force municipalities to hold up their end of the bargain.
- dmix 12y agoI feel like you're trying to paint the inverse picture where the taxi company is the 'little guy'. > It's no different than what Wal-Mart did to mom and pop shops, or what Amazon did to small retailers, or what Starbucks did to local coffee shops. Mom and pop shops rarely had regulators preventing Walmart and Starbucks from touching their market share. We're talking about very large centralized taxi companies that run entire cities. Most cities have 2-3 large companies dominating the entire city with a few minor players running limo services. Even in small towns the companies are hardly small friendly businesses. My father drove taxi for years for multiple different taxi cartels and they all paid their workers poorly, withheld funds for weeks whenever customers used credit cards, and often only hired new drivers within their family/network. He loved the freedom of driving but hated the companies. He only enjoyed it when he could become a broker aka owning his own car and being able to distance himself from the company. I hear similar stories from every Taxi driver I speak to, which is often. They see Uber/Hailo technology as liberating. I see neither Uber nor the Taxi companies as the David vs Goliath. But Uber-style technology has given drivers the opportunity to make higher wages AND be independent from local cartels, while opening the door to new entrants in the market both for new drivers and new tech, even decentralized tech in the future. So I do agree that the tech/news industry should make sure the real issue being debated is technology vs the nature of regulation, and stop looking for archetypical narratives. Instead of trying to reverse the narrative in favor of the other side.
- spullara 12y agoActually, in many places, Mom and Pop stores have regulators that stop Walmart and Starbucks from opening stores near them.
- adventured 12y agoVery few locations in the United States have regulations protecting mom & pop stores from Walmart or Starbucks. You're exaggerating by an extreme factor. You can count the number of municipalities with such actual laws to the tune of less than 100 out of 19,000 cities in the US.
- baddox 12y agoThe problem is that local politicians have little incentive to retract an inefficient monopoly enforcement (even one that we assume was previously efficient), because the taxi companies' special interests tend to win out over the dispersed interests of all taxi customers. This isn't some specific flaw with taxi regulations. It's a basic economic reality of government regulation.
- CaptainZapp 12y ago... for being woefully outdated and not inline with market economics Why do regulations have to be in line with market economics in the first place? Most, if not all regulations should serve and protect the citizenship and not private interest. That Uber so vehemently lobbies against sensible regulation, like an obligation for commercial insurance, speaks volumes.
- ZachPruckowski 12y ago>Why do regulations have to be in line with market economics in the first place? Yeah, I think this is something a lot of folks overlook - regulations exist because society has decided its interests are better served by making folks play by a certain set of rules than by hitting peak market efficiency or whatever. Now you can argue that a given regulation is not the best way to achieve a societal goal (for instance that limits on cab numbers don't reduce congestion much) or that they have worse externalities (medallion systems squeezing out the little guy in favor of big companies that can afford 6-figure medallion prices) or that the lost efficiency isn't worth society's goals, but straight up saying that they're "inefficient" isn't a case for anything.
- dlss 12y ago> regulations exist because society has decided its interests are better served by making folks play by a certain set of rules than by hitting peak market efficiency or whatever This is technically correct, but is forgetting that society is often wrong about what serves its interests. For some popularly unpopular examples: homosexual marriage being illegal, a drug war instead of drug treatment programs, putting fluoride (a neurotoxin) in the water. Edit: those are current laws, for more popularly unpopular laws see slavery, the 18th amendment, the banning of blood transfusions, etc, etc
- discardorama 12y ago> regulations exist because society has decided its interests are better served by making folks play by a certain set of rules than by hitting peak market efficiency or whatever But society (and times) change. If there was a regulation that said 'the rightmost lane must always be reserved for horse-drawn carriages', we'd all be laughing about it.
- dspillett 12y ago> critiquing the state intervention for being woefully outdated and not inline with market economics Regulation is often not about being inline with market economics - it is often used to enforce things that companies would not do (because of cost) that have significant impact on employee, customer, and public safety. The regulations in place vary from city to city, but Uber and co are not just arguing against the out-of-date bits (knowing "the knowledge" which some argue is irrelevant with technological help, and so forth) but the whole lot including drivers having adequate insurance and relevant background checks. I'm very much in support of new business models thriving, even if it eventually kills the old ones (progress is a good thing) so I'll back Uber wanting a piece of the pie, but I don't agree with the complete circumvention of the existing regulations so I wouldn't currently feel safe using them.
- masklinn 12y ago> Regulation is often not about being inline with market economics Regulations usually aren't about being inline with market economics, otherwise they'd be unnecessary. Regulations are only inline with market economics in some instances of market failure regulations (e.g. monopoly regulations such as local loop unbundling mandates). Usually, the whole point of regulations is to create incentives which don't match straight market economics in order to effect different behaviours from companies (such as improved service or standards of conduct)