16 ms·
Some Dark Patterns Now Illegal in UK
- whyleyc 12y ago"Quite simply, businesses who don’t comply face a loss of revenue. If you make a purchase, whether that’s buying goods or a service, on a non-compliant web site, you have the right to recourse through your nearest Trading Standards office. A failure to comply cancels the transaction. You can get your money back and keep the goods. If the sale was for a service or a digital download, the contract is cancelled and no further payments are due." ... has anyone successfully tried this in practice yet ? It would be good to know of "test cases" on sites potentially in breach. You can bet if complaints are upheld those sites will suddenly experience overwhelming interest from consumers :)
- epaga 12y agoSounds like an excellent law to stop the horrid practices in so many online shops. Let's hope a form of this law spreads throughout Europe and the U.S. This caught my eye, however: "A failure to comply cancels the transaction. You can get your money back and keep the goods. If the sale was for a service or a digital download, the contract is cancelled and no further payments are due." Wow. Seems like it would make a ton of financial sense to go hunting for online shops located in the U.K. that are not complying with this law yet and take advantage of this, helping them learn "the hard way"?
- Someone1234 12y agoIt is a good idea, but in practice getting them to return your money before you return the goods might involve a small claims court. This directive actually has a lot less "teeth" than you'd think from reading this article. It is good that it exists, but aside from class action style lawsuits, few companies will get hit by individual customers seeking refunds+goods.
- Pxtl 12y agoPerhaps including the credit cart "dispute charges" process into this discussion would help?
- tehwebguy 12y agoThat was my guess as to where enforcement takes place. But this is already a great way to "reeducate" terrible retailers since there are often expensive chargeback fees even if the vendor wins the dispute ($15-25 in the US)
- Silhouette 12y agoChargebacks are a significant risk as merchants, because if you start to rack up too many of them then it won't just be the individual chargeback fees for each of those transactions that you have to worry about. As I understand it, you can also wind up paying higher processing costs generally, or even being kicked by your payment services and/or not accepted by other services in the future if your track record gets bad enough. Then again, even my tiny little start-up manages to advertise an honest recurring subscription fee, tax-inclusive, with no other charges added on top later. In our entire time trading, I think we've had exactly one person complain that they didn't realise it was a monthly fee when they signed up. I'm not sure how they managed to miss it -- we tell them right next to the price, in full size text, throughout the sign-up process. But even so, we just refunded their second payment and cancelled their ongoing subscription to avoid the argument, and that was the end of the matter. We never got as far as any sort of formal dispute/chargeback process via the customer's card company. So I guess I don't have much sympathy if the kinds of big businesses mentioned in this article can't figure it out and wind up suffering for it under these new laws. These "dark patterns" are obviously deceptive and obviously unfair to consumers, and I'm glad the big businesses are going to have to play by the same rules as the rest of us in the future.
- rmc 12y ago> Let's hope a form of this law spreads throughout Europe Ummm... this is a EU wide law. The UK, as a member state of the EU, had to implement it into UK law (that's how EU laws work). This is already the law of the land in all EU countries. Nearly all good consumer rights laws are done at the EU level.
- Someone1234 12y agoYou misread the quote. They said "Europe" not the EU. So presumably they were hoping it would spread to non-EU European countries also.
- pdpi 12y agoI find that it's increasingly the case that "Europe" gets used in place of EU in much the same way as people will say "America" when they mean the USA.
- Someone1234 12y agoThen people are "increasingly" using it incorrectly. Europe is a continent, the EU is a political alliance. There are too many countries within Europe but not in the EU to use the terms synonymously. For example: Albania, Andorra, Belarus, Bosnia-Herzegovina, Croatia, Iceland, Liechtenstein, Macedonia, Moldova, Monaco, Montenegro, Norway, Russia, San Marino, Serbia, Switzerland, Turkey, Ukraine, Vatican City I think it is pretty interesting that I got heavily downvoted for pointing out that the person above me conflated Europe and the EU and then tried to correct someone else based on that misunderstanding. This place is turning into Reddit more and more day by day, people are using the down arrow as a "I disagree" button... Which is exactly why Reddit has gone right down the toilet.
- kome 12y agoCroatia is part of the EU.
- 12y ago
- anigbrowl 12y agoJeepers. I can think of several big US commercial sites that would turn unprofitable overnight.
- switch007 12y agoThe part about keeping the goods seems unbelievable. I've skimmed the act, but I can't find a reference to keeping the goods. It's very easy to link to sections in acts, so I don't know why the author did not add references.
- mseebach 12y ago> You can get your money back and keep the goods My guess is that's a journalistic misinterpretation of what canceling a transaction means. It's very common in the law that when a transaction is cancelled, not only do you have to return the product, if you've used it, the seller can make a reasonable deduction in your refund. If the consequence indeed is as stated, it's not like customers would benefit much in the long term, as the newly introduced risk would render most online shopping totally uneconomical: what if someone successfully sues you for utilizing a "dark pattern", now all your customers can demand a refund "for free" -- without having to return the product? Lose all your past revenue AND your product stock overnight? That's unheard of as punishment in commercial law.
- twic 12y agoOn the contrary, this appears to be exactly what Ms Burns suggests: In my book I talked about “trading trolls” – people who would surf the web specifically looking for noncompliant sites so that they can place an order, get the stuff, report the site for noncompliance, get their money back, and keep the stuff. After all, if the site is breaking the law, they have no recourse there.
- mseebach 12y agoI think I know what is meant now. The directive (http://ec.europa.eu/justice/consumer-marketing/rights-contracts/directive/index_en.htm http://ec.europa.eu/justice/consumer-marketing/rights-contra...): (60) Since inertia selling, which consists of unsolicited supply of goods or provision of services to consumers, is prohibited by Directive 2005/29/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 May 2005 concerning unfair business-to-consumer commercial practices in the internal market (‘Unfair Commercial Practices Directive’) (2) but no contractual remedy is provided therein, it is necessary to introduce in this Directive the contractual remedy of exempting the consumer from the obligation to provide any consideration for such unsolicited supply or provision. The way I read that is if you add an item to the customers cart automatically, then you have no legal claim to get paid for that item. The sale of the stuff you actually wanted is still valid.
- rmc 12y ago
- brey 12y agoThis almost exists already, in a slightly different form - it's the same principle as the unsolicited goods laws codified in eg. the UK's Consumer Protection Regulations[1]; if I send stuff to someone without it being asked for, they legally own it and I can't insist on payment. Same thing now applies to bundling unwanted extra crap in with a real order - it's just the extra stuff which may not be charged for. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consumer_Protection_(Distance_Selling)_Regulations_2000 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consumer_Protection_(Distance_S... > If goods are sent to a consumer without a contract asking for them, the "recipient may [...] use, deal with, or dispose of the goods as if they were an unconditional gift to him" which happens to be an incorporation of a 15-year old EU directive: http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=CELEX:31997L0007 http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=CELEX:319... > Article 9 > Inertia selling > Member States shall take the measures necessary to: > - prohibit the supply of goods or services to a consumer without their being ordered by the consumer beforehand, where such supply involves a demand for payment, > - exempt the consumer from the provision of any consideration in cases of unsolicited supply, the absence of a response not constituting consent.
- harrybr 12y agoHi Everyone, in response to the great reception her interview has received on HN, Heather has created a discount code for her ebook. Use the code 'hackernews' at the checkout to get 50% off. If you work on any ecommerce products based within the EU then it's a worthwhile purchase. Get the ebook here: http://www.consumerrightsdirective.info/ http://www.consumerrightsdirective.info/
- jiggy2011 12y agoI wonder what effect this will have on ryanair ticket prices? As I understand it the tickets themselves are not profitable, it's the extras.
- tim333 12y agoRyanair have been moving back towards clear pricing. I guess it will be more like flight £25 rather than flight 99p, charges £24.
- Vespasian 12y agoHonestly I hope they will finally have to label them correctly. When I booked flights to Dublin recently, I felt being cheated on even though I checked everything twice and googled some. The insurance trick is among the worst practices I had to encounter personally. I'd prefer to have the official prices being hones even if they are somewhat higher. Their business model of offering only the minimal thing should work nevertheless and laws like that does not forbid them to offer extras which many people would choose nevertheless.
- mikestew 12y ago> When I booked flights to Dublin recently, I felt being cheated on even though I checked everything twice and googled some. Why on earth would you do business with a company that makes you "<feel> cheated"? RyanAir ran off all of the other airlines? They had the only flight to Dublin to see your poor, sick mother? Flights so cheap that you're willing to put up with the bullshit? It's an honest question, and I've heard some answer it with "they're so cheap, I'm willing to put up with dealing with weasels." But it sounds like the whole weasel-dealing thing isn't for you. One of the reasons I fly SouthWest, even when they're not the cheapest or most convenient, is because I don't feel like I need to watch my back when dealing with them.
- icelancer 12y ago> Why on earth would you do business with a company that makes you "<feel> cheated"? Because everyone bitches about them but everyone still uses them, since after all, they are the cheapest. They just like to hurl rocks from the top of the mountain without actually doing anything productive about it - i.e. taking their money elsewhere.
- mcv 12y agoThe title says UK, but the article says it's for the entire EU.
- harrybr 12y agoIt's an EU directive which has recently been enacted into law in the UK. Sorry, we should have made that clearer in the interview text.
- techmatters 12y ago"A failure to comply cancels the transaction. You can get your money back and keep the goods. If the sale was for a service or a digital download, the contract is cancelled and no further payments are due." I would think that, under contract law, you get your money back and you return the goods - that would be cancelling the transaction. Likewise for digital downloads or services. Can anyone explain why the provider would be penalized further ?
- Argorak 12y agoBecause that could create a situation where the seller can put a burden on you. (arcane rules on how to return goods, trying to get shipment expenses from you, etc.)
- idea15webdesign 12y agoWe probably should have clarified that this is an online and and offline law affecting all sales and purchases, not just e-commerce ones. The law provides better protections to consumers, but it also provides some protections to retailers against some of the dodgy practices they've had to deal with from consumers. Returns and expenses are a HUGE part of the law. My favourite bit is what I call the "anti-wardrobing provision". Under the new law, when you return an item, retailers can now deduct a fair percentage of its cash value from your refund if you have returned it clearly damaged or un-resellable. This is because of wardrobing - the practice of buying an item of clothing, deliberately keeping the tags on, wearing it once, and returning it for a refund stinking of your night out.
- DSMan195276 12y agoI don't claim to know for sure, but it seems to me like the reason for that is because all of these laws are restrictions are companies trying to do shady stuff to sell you more then what you wanted. Allowing the person purchasing the goods to keep them as well as get money back encourages companies to not break these laws since they don't want to lose their stuff. If they got their goods back then there really wouldn't be any repercussions toward the company for breaking these laws since the transactions would (presumably) be cancel-able within a specific time-frame already.
- idlewords 12y agoA good example of beneficial government regulation, for people who refuse to believe such a thing exists. (Another good example is the Internet itself, but it's best to start small)
- poof131 12y agoYes, a good piece of regulation, but who believes in no regulation? To me, no regulation means no law, which means anarchy. And the only people who want anarchy are the same types of people who would be dead the first day it broke out. But much of the regulation in the US is regulatory capture. We need regulation for the people, not for the companies. Moving in the right direction is a challenge and we need to break down the illusion that half the population is for good (those on our voting team) and the other half for bad.
- protonfish 12y agoHow ironic that the only way to get rid of objectivist libertarians is to give them what they want. Still, it is probably worth it.
- kzrdude 12y agoAnarchy doesn't really exist. It's just that people want to go back to a state before the current contracts and laws were passed. What would happen? The same kinds of associations, rules, and laws would form again.
- coriny 12y agoAnarcho-collectivists, which as far as I understand, represents the dominant modern anarchistic philosophy, examine alternative methods to central government for generating laws. So they don't argue for an unregulated society - which is obviously a non-starter under the lens of reality - or a return to pre-government, but rather a complete replacement of the law-making mechanism. Basically, they're all over complexity theory and how to use strong local interactions to develop self-organising non-local societies. Which I personally think makes anarcho-collectivism possibly the most sophisticated and futuristic of current political models. They were two decades ahead of the "localism" and "direct democracy" ideologies, and with a far better understanding of the maths.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoI wonder why there seem to be no companies that use "not being cheating bastards" as a marketing advantage. I'd gladly pay more to buy from a shop that emphasizes transparency and fairness.
- rtb 12y agoHuh? There are loads. I can think of several companies that I buy things from because I know I won't get messed with even if the headline price might appear a little higher than their competitors (think EasyJet v.s. RyanAir).
- TeMPOraL 12y agoFrom my relatively small experience I remember EasyJet trying to upsell random crap in a similar way to RyanAir. I might be misremembering though, I haven't flew with any of them since last year. Anyway, I meant why there are no companies with marketing messages that would amount to "we're not going to fuck you over like the Other Company We Can't Name".
- rtb 12y ago> I meant why there are no companies with marketing messages that would amount to "we're not going to fuck you over like the Other Company We Can't Name". Probably because they can't name them in the ads, which would make the message rather confusing :-)
- TeMPOraL 12y agoWell, if the other company is doing something bad, it wouldn't be difficult. Actually, to provide some sort of an answer to my original question, we had sort-of this style of marketing with domain registrar, i.e. "hey, we don't try to upsell you crap, don't support SOPA and definitely don't shoot elephants for fun!".
- Wohui 12y agoI can only think of DuckDuckGo ("we won't track you").
- spindritf 12y agoFinancial services are exempt under the Directive Great. Let's take all the downside of heavy regulation but give up most of the upside.
- sentenza 12y agoIf I, as a consumer from continental Europe, can't be subject to what is essentially a rippoff by UK online shops any more, then it is a win. It even makes it easier for UK online shops to be compliant with consumer protection laws within the rest of Europe. I fail to see the downside.
- spindritf 12y agoDownsides are the same as always. The higher the regulation burden, the fewer new companies and products we will see. This is how we ended up relying on Americans for almost every service online, computers, phones... Even with all the upside, I don't that's the right trade-off. But once you start piling up exemptions, and industry-specific rules, you forgo most of the benefit you could have achieved with uniform regulation. This was the whole point behind letting EU set up the regulatory regime: to create a single EU-wide market. It's self-defeating to unify it across countries and then break up into hundreds of industries.
- ZoFreX 12y agoIf a company that formerly would have existed will now not spring into existence because it breaks these new regulations, then I say good riddance. One less scam merchant looking to make a fast buck by ripping off their customers. That's an area we really don't need any more innovation in.
- spindritf 12y agoIt's not about breaking this or that particular regulation. It's the sheer number you have to comply with. Even if every single regulation was positive on its own, in aggregate they could still stifle economic development and lead to perverse results. Take web for example. Of course it would be better if every website followed standards, was available to impaired users, and over ssl. But if you started fining people who fail to live up, you would make it prohibitively expensive to run a private site outside of a handful of massive platforms established by large corporations who can afford developers and usability testing. We understand that in this context. The advice to start with whatever works and iterate from there is common. It's the same with running a company. The more requirements there are, even if each one is perfectly reasonable, the fewer people will be able to afford to start them, the less innovation we will see, the more we will rely on foreign products from countries with lesser regulation burden.
- tim333 12y agoThe worst one I had was Vistaprint. I bought some business cards then found a mysterious £9.99/month charge disappearing from my credit card which turned out to be for some discount club they'd signed my up for in the small print without me being aware. Bastards! I never did get that back. Hopefully the new laws should help stop that.
- sentenza 12y agoOy. That was legal? It seems that I have been cross-border shopping a bit too carelessly. I know that the English Newspapers will manage to put an anti-EU spin on this, but cross-border e-commerce has to become easier. From regulation to shipping cost, there are a lot of things that need to be harmonized.
- PeterisP 12y agoThe actual EU directive is from 2011, but it takes some time for it to get adopted in local legislation; more time for any transition periods to pass (as in, here's the law, change your process by yyyy/mm/dd), and even more time while the habits change.
- suvelx 12y ago> As a part of that, retailer fees and surcharges must be brought out into the open and explained. Retailers can no longer charge “processing fees” in excess of what it actually costs them. Does that mean charging me to print out my own ticket is now illegal? Because it certainly doesn't cost 2 quid to generate a pdf.
- skynetv2 12y agowhen will the US adopt a similar law? Ticketmaster will be first one to go bonkers if this law ever makes it to the US
- eli 12y agoI'm more annoyed by telecom, internet and other utilities that add fees for "regulatory compliance" or for other costs that the provider had to pay. If you want to pass your costs on to your customers that's fine, but then raise your prices. Don't advertise a fake, unobtainable low price and then add fees disguised as government mandates.
- tormeh 12y ago"Oh, poor us! The guv't wants our money! May you perchance help us? It was a total surprise, honest!" It's an easy sell in the US, I imagine.
- eli 12y agoIt's an easy sell because they stick it right next to "Sales Tax" and make it sound like something the government is requiring the customer to pay.
- MichaelGG 12y agoQuite frankly, all business should have to advertise a final price. "Fuel surcharge" on a transport product ... as if fuel wasn't an intrinsic part of their service. It's true that there are stupid things like USF which is like 17%, but that's well-known. The only "surprise" stuff are things like assorted locales deciding to charge you fees. Like some podunk county in Missouri will decide you now need to pay a $1/month 911 fee if your number is from there, even if you aren't there. But it's nowhere nearly as bad as the big telecoms make it out to be.
- rmc 12y agoA lot of these EU laws exclude tickets to music/sports/leisure events/
- 12y ago
- idea15webdesign 12y agoHi all - glad to see the interview creating such a buzz! Regarding all your questions, I've listed all the original source texts of the law and its implementing guidance here. http://www.consumerrightsdirective.info/links-and-resources http://www.consumerrightsdirective.info/links-and-resources
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- njharman 12y agoTIL there's a thing called "Dark Patterns".
- mcintyre1994 12y agohttp://darkpatterns.org http://darkpatterns.org is an interesting read.
- cessor 12y agoI feel really bad about the fact that this is a thing. Apparently there are a lot of "entrepreneurs" that will always choose to annoy and damage others for a little currency. Why do these things have to be made illegal? They were immoral to begin with, that alone should stop people from doing it. Shame on you, people who sneak insurance into shopping carts and Ask-Toolbars into Java installers.
- TomGullen 12y ago> Why do these things have to be made illegal? To stop people doing it.
- lilsunnybee 12y agoYou've missed the point, which was that it's lamentable such clearly immoral business practices have to be made illegal to keep people from engaging in them. Disallowing such practices brings benefit only because employees and business owners were being so unscrupulous to begin with.
- yardie 12y agoHey AirBnB. I hope you're listening. Sneaking in service charges and "cleaning fees" is no bueno. I know it's not you doing the later but I hate it when I find an apartment at an appropriate price then good hoodwinked for additional services I don't particularly care for.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pmh 12y agoFWIW, I recall the latter being included in the nightly rate when I was searching for places. It does switch to an itemized list of expenses when you actually view a property though.
- smackfu 12y agoYes, that's true. It helps avoid people setting nightly rates low but then charging $100 cleaning fee.
- aero142 12y agoCleaning fees make perfect sense to me. When renting a house out, if I stay 1 night, the owner has to clean the house once. If I stay 1 week, the owner has to clean the house once. Seems like this is just matching pricing to costs.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- thomasahle 12y agoSorry, but this seems like a stupid law. Clearly fraud was already illegal, all that was needed were court cases clearly demonstrating these patterns. A law like this just encourages people to tweak their practices slightly and continue as before.
- makomk 12y agoFraud is still illegal. What this means is that people don't have to prove the practices in question are fraudulent, just that the companies used them.
- thomasahle 12y agoThat's exactly why it would be more scalable as a court decision. A law can never encompass every possible dark pattern, while a new court decision can be added every time somebody discover something bad, and sue. Additionally, court decisions will be more efficient, since once a pattern is found fraudulent, it is not only banned, but there is also a whole case of discussion to refer to. With a specific law like this, with no prior cases, we aren't really much further than we already were.
- Someone1234 12y agoYour argument falls flat simply because the reality on the ground was that existing laws and enforcement wasn't taking care of the problem. These new laws give more powers to consumers to effectively take the law into their own hands. Additionally fraud (at least in the UK) doesn't impact several of the practices as they weren't misleading, just obnoxious (like adding things to your cart, or fees not on the advert but on the final checkout page). > A law like this just encourages people to tweak their practices slightly and continue as before. By that logic why try and do anything at all ever? It is a very defeatist attitude that results in inaction.
- thomasahle 12y ago> By that logic why try and do anything at all ever? Just sue them, so that it becomes well known whether the practice is illegal. If it's not illegal, make a law covering the general problem, and let the court specify the individual matches.
- Shivetya 12y agoI seem to be missing something, are the direct fines for non compliance. Refunds and keeping an item are all nice and such but still requires action on part of the consumer. Some sites may factor that in and continue the process.
- zem 12y agoi was pleasantly surprised that the article called out specific, high-profile companies. all too often the writers simply pussyfoot around that part.
- ehPReth 12y agoRelated: http://darkpatterns.org/ http://darkpatterns.org/ - provides a list of common dark patterns with examples
- hyperpape 12y agoI'm surprised how hard it is for me to think of a case where including some extra by default makes sense for both the seller and customer. My initial reaction was a mixture of happiness about combatting hidden charges and suspicion that it might rule out some reasonable practices. I opt out of the sandwich drink and chips combo at a lot of restaurants, but most other patrons like it. But after mulling it over, I can't think of any of the latter that would apply to online sales.
- GhotiFish 12y agoThat's a reasonable worry. You never do notice things that are working correctly, because they are working correctly.
- dsirijus 12y agoAny sufficiently advanced business model is indistinguishable from a scam.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoThis is golden. Adding this to my quotes file. It's really true. Scams are just the extreme end of ways-to-profit-somewhat-legally spectrum of business models.
- thomasfl 12y agoI'm really looking forward to buy airplane tickets from Ryanair without having to remove insurance from my shopping basket manually. EU has been doing lots of good things to ensure consumer rights over the years.
- AJ007 12y agoFor those addressing a US audience, some of this stuff will get you in trouble with the FTC as well as State AG's. Other practices may bring in revenue now which will have to be paid out later from class actions. There are also strict rules regarding influencing how the designs of providing permission to call a user behave; these were updated with the TCPA and went in to effect earlier this year. Many companies remain out of compliance and subject to $2,000+ fines per individual called.
- andy_ppp 12y agoI find that Ebay makes it very unclear what the fees are if you sell something; this £0.50 to list something I assume they would have to say + x percent of the say price now? Be even better if they were force to list an estimated sale price and fee...
- twistedpair 12y agoLast time I listed something on eBay they nickled and dimed me hard, but it was clear that I was being nickled and dimed. Perhaps the only hidden fee was that you've got to pay through PayPal and take that 2-3% hit.
- rcthompson 12y agoI feel like this is at least partially a success story for people like those at darkpatterns.org who have put a lot of time and effort into documenting these abuses. It seems pretty likely that without someone cataloging all these abuses, they would have been able to stay under the radar and remain just something you have to put up with.
- mason240 12y ago>The “sneak into basket” pattern is now illegal. Full stop, end of story. You cannot create a situation where additional items and services are added by default. active.com is a horrible offender. If you sign up for an event, you are automatically enrolled in their $60/year subscription fee - which they don't charge for until a month later.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI am not sure this attempt at legislating good behavior will have much effect. Too often these things are easier for the bad guy to ignore than for the individual to prosecute. I've wondered for a while if there was a way of creating some sort of "Small Claims Court as a service" system that would not overly benefit cranks. Something where you could mail in a complain with attached details and have the prosecution engine just run through it. Someone gets a bunch of these and it upgrades to class action or something. The downside (and reason I've not done something like this yet) is that it also enables bullies and malicious prosecution. It is quite a challenging system (weirdly with many parallels in game design where you're trying to keep opponent factions "balanced")
- ZoFreX 12y agoFiling a small courts claim in the UK is really, really easy, doesn't require a lawyer, and actually favours the little guy. I don't think we really need a SCSAAS system. Historically, legislating this kind of behaviour has had a very big effect in the UK. We have strict trading and advertising standards and by and large people adhere to them. Companies that frequently flout the rules tend to get in more trouble once a journalist or watchdog gets wind of it and makes a big stink.
- blibble 12y agogovernment's done "small claims process as a service" already: https://www.moneyclaim.gov.uk/ https://www.moneyclaim.gov.uk/ fill in website, the letters go out automatically. if the person you're suing admits fault (or doesn't respond): the cheque normally turns up in a few weeks. otherwise will give you a court date.
- lorddoig 12y agoTake the number of times you've heard the sentiment "and this will protect consumers! yay!" - call it h (for hope). Now take the number of times you've heard such sentiments be justified in a logical, rigorous manner - call it j. Calculate an independent thought index, t, as follows: j / h. Call me if it's greater than 0.01. I'll be over here in the corner watching as we entrench half- (or hundredth-?)baked ideas into statute books that don't change for decades. The economic damage of these petty regs (enforcement, compliance, cognitive load on businesses, yadda yadda) far outstrips that which brought them into existence in the first place - that I'd put my life on (but good luck actually measuring it.) These kinds of 'consumer protection' laws are exactly the reason why the UK only has 5 major banks operating as a government-backed cartel - the laws became so complex that the market is impossible to enter now. Just ask Richard Branson - he wanted a bank for a long time, but the only way he could get one was to buy a preexisting one. This argument extends almost verbatim to the insurance and payment processing (and more) industries. The internet is what it is because it has been almost completely free (as in liberal) and had very low barriers to entry up until very recently. The day I have to fill in a government form to open a webshop else fear prosecution is the day we let another good thing die - and shit like this is a big step down that road.
- bh3244 12y agolaws should be based on logic and not emotion. unfortunately I doubt anyone will campaign against this and if they do they will be portrayed as pro-cronyism or that they are somehow for the things that this measure aims to prevent. the UK seems fond of things like this though. As I recall you must be 18 years old to buy a plastic knife, as it is considered a deadly weapon.
- lorddoig 12y agoAlthough that sounds completely believable, I think in this instance it's only sharp knives over a certain length, and if I'm not mistaken I think the age 16. But never fear, HM Government will no doubt fall over themselves trying to appease the relatives of the one teenager who managed to gouge their own brain out with a plastic knife (when it happens).
- 12y ago
- JohnTHaller 12y agoI've noticed that eNom/Bulk Register has stopped sneaking bogus 'mobile website converter trial' and similar nonsense into the cart when you buy/renew domain names as of late. They're designed to not have a fee for the first month, so they sneak it into your cart and then hope you don't notice when it starts automatically billing to your credit card a month later. I wonder if their disappearance is related to this?
- tn13 12y agoThis is ridiculous. So now every tom dick and harry trying to sell something online need to keep in mind a new government regulation which can be bypassed in 10 different ways by those who will do it nevertheless. At this rate government will even regulate the size and position of buttons. This is something the tech community should unwelcome rather than acting like cheerleaders.
- ck2 12y agoIn the US, hidden charges would be rallied against as "unamerican" and "let the consumer decide" (when consumers have virtually no such power because of lack of options/transparency).