7 ms·
America can't be the world's tech leader without immigration reform.
- makecheck 17y agoI've seen firsthand the waits and the bureaucracy of some of these immigration documents. I can tolerate waiting; while frustrating, that's not the real issue. But it's hard to just live a normal life in limbo, with all the implicit threats. Your documents are tied to your job, so switching jobs will risk, at minimum, starting from scratch; and there is a chance of denial and deportation at every turn. You are also not immune to layoffs, so this can blow up in your face without warning, giving you a very short period of time to fix it. And in the end, even if you survive all the hoop jumps, there is still a chance you will be denied the documents that you've been waiting years to receive. Compare this to somebody just wanting to do essentially the same work in their home country, where they probably can, minus all the bullshit. This is why the U.S. is in danger: because immigrants can only take so much, and at some point, they simply will move all their ideas and capital back home.
- tokenadult 17y agoBut it's hard to just live a normal life in limbo, with all the implicit threats. Do immigrants have in all cases a home country to go back to with a better trade-off in this regard than the United States? As long as some countries are sufficiently lousily governed, the United States will always have a ready supply of some kinds of immigrants. The article's point is correct that persons who are able to set up new businesses with new technologies probably have better capacity to shop for a country to live in than most migrants.
- kansando 17y agoYes, but some previously lousily governed countries like China and India have become much better options than they were even ten years ago. The goal is not to have "some kinds of immigrants", it is to have the best.
- potatolicious 17y agoNot to mention that many of the "best" immigrants (i.e. highly trained, highly educated) have come from first-world industrialized nations to begin with. Political instability and threat of mortal danger is not the only thing that compels people to move.
- tokenadult 17y agoThe article is interesting in suggesting that comprehensive immigration reform is a political landmine for this administration, as it has been for previous administrations. A founder visa would be an interesting incremental change, especially favored by the readership of HN. Testimony in Congress before passing such a new law would surely bring up the issue of what happens when a start-up firm fails, as many do. A press notice for pg is of course interesting to readers of HN, and it will be one more proof of his notability (no longer doubted) on Wikipedia.
- hughprime 17y agoThe article is interesting in suggesting that comprehensive immigration reform is a political landmine for this administration, as it has been for previous administrations. The trouble is that the kind of "comprehensive immigration reform" which politically powerful constituencies are currently pushing is nothing like the kind of immigration reform which would actually be useful.
- vijayr 17y agoI'm an immigrant myself, and would love to see these problems fixed. At the same time, I do understand that U.S has bigger problems like healthcare that need to be fixed first. Realistically speaking, I doubt much will happen in the immediate future (next 1-2 years). One thing is sure though - what US is losing, other countries like Canada, UK etc (my roomate left for UK last month, after studying in US and working here for 4 years) are gaining.
- simanyay 17y agoI would not be so optimistic about other countries. Both United Kingdom and Canada closed their immigration programs (former closed the program completely while the latter removed all CS and IT-related professions from it). AFAIK, today only Australia has a meaningful immigration program, however, there is no guarantee that it won't be closed next year. European Union has really, really strict policies not only on immigration but on temporary workers. Edited: European Unions -> European Union
- mynameishere 17y agoPresumably, if we aren't the world's tech leader, some other country will be. India, China, ??? Who? And once you've decided "who?" ask yourself whether that country will somehow depend upon open-borders, and whether its prominent web magazines will propagandize relentlessly for the same. People who discuss this do not give two flies for America's "tech leadership" or whatever other baloney abstraction you prefer. It's a political subject only.
- netsp 17y agoMy issue with ideas like the "startup visa" is that they require restrictions and bureaucracies. You end up with more draconian restrictions on immigrants causing resentment. You end up with more distortion of market signals. What happens when a startup goes under? Visa cancelled? Well that's reason to pour more resources in or just pretend it's still alive. What happens if they do some consulting on the side to stay alive? What happens if it ends up all consulting? What happens if people come out with the intention of doing this. How are you going to stop it? Force them to develop products? What is a startup? Does a lawn mowing startup count? How about if they invent their own lawn mower? in 'The Founder Visa,' Graham proposes that the Governemnt could "use investment by recognized startup investors as the test of whether a company was a real startup." Recognised by who? Do you really want to erect an official barrier to entry for investors? What about an existing startup in country X that wouldn't mind moving to the US. Now they need an officially recognised investor. They don't need an investor. They need a visa. They can pay for it. The investor is in a position to sell a visa, even if it looks like he is just getting a good deal on some stock. It might even look like that to the investor. I offered a deal. They took it. The power to grant a visa is worth money and even if you can control the granter's morals or incentives (you can't), you cannot control the grantee's reasons for accepting a deal. 4 consultants doing remote work for mostly US clients decide they could double their (say $150k p/a) revenue by moving to the US and doing the same. Theoretically, they can afford up to $150k p/a for the visa. Say they take $100k "investment" form a recognised investor in return for a promise to pay $50k p/a. How would the visa process weed these candidates out. Review the business plan? Make sure that they are planning to build a business that scales? Consulting doesn't scale. Are you sure? Will we have a list of business plans that scale? The article mentions setting up "a board of investors, entrepreneurs, and tech lawyers who are used to vetting tech ideas; they'd review applications and choose which ones are worthy of a Founder Visa." This, it reckons, would be open to corruption. I don't think it is possible to have "controlled immigration" that is this controlled to this extent without these ugly issues.
- ujjwalg 17y agoI agree with you to a certain extent and would have upvoted if rather than pointing out all the ways of gaming it, you could have at least mentioned 1 way of solving the problem. I agree that people will be gaming the system. There is no policy which cannot be gamed, but we have to look at the bigger picture. How many VCs do you think will put their reputation at risk to earn $50k pa? I am not saying the solution the author mentioned is perfect, but its a start. A system can be put in place similar to O1 or EB1 visa but with startups in mind. Every startup will have to go through certain conditions to be eligible to apply. The founders can have 1-2 year temporary visa and if things work out great, they should be granted Green card, or they should be allowed to go through the cycle again.
- dtap 17y agoDoes anyone know where I can find the text of the proposal so I can send it to my congressman? Not PGs essay, but what the VCs are presenting to Congress. (i.e. Bill #)
- petercooper 17y agoForget tech leader - merely being the leader in terms of population growth or influence requires a significant boost in population. There are many people of means who would like to move to the US who could fill all those homes sitting empty and rejuvenate the economy.
- _ck_ 17y agoI won't even pretend to begin to understand the politics behind all this but I am confused - in a nation of over 300 MILLION people, we don't have enough skilled workers? Seriously? I'm not against immigration at all if people want a better life and they somehow believe it's here, but we also have double digit unemployment. I'm definitely missing part of the picture.
- padmapper 17y agoThere are 300 million people in the US, but in the very specific specialties at the cutting edge of science and tech, every person is significant, and can't really be substituted for by another. Letting in the best of the best is all kinds of win. See "Brain Drain/Gain": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brain_drain http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brain_drain Albert Einstein is one of the more famous examples, but there are quite a few others.
- _ck_ 17y agoI guess I am stumbling on the "worker" part of "skilled workers" needed. We're not importing inventors or CEOs (or "Albert Einsteins"), we're importing labor, people who know already how to create (technical) widgets from items A+B+C and there aren't enough of thees knowledgeable people already in the USA who know how to make A+B+C into widgets? So these people are skilled in that they learned how to make these widgets in another country outside the USA, but they want to create the widgets here instead? Did they stop making the widgets in the other country? Does it pay more to make widgets here? Why the USA specifically? (What exactly does the USA produce anymore anyway? Nothing is made here so what are they making?) Again, I'm not against immigration, but somehow I think this is a smokescreen. If someone wants to come to the USA to go to school, to live, I say welcome, we've got plenty of room, plenty of food, and we need the taxes paid. But let's not make up reasons to come here? There are thousands of college students graduating in the USA each year who are unemployed. If they don't have the exact skills needed I dare say a 4 year degree proves they can learn the skill rather quickly? I guess I need real-world examples to understand this better. I still don't understand why college students aren't being trained for these critical jobs, especially if they are in a tech sector which is always attractive.
- nick-dap 17y agoTwo words. DREAM Act. http://dreamact.info http://dreamact.info I was brought to the United States by my parents at a very young age. In the process I have inherited the title of an "illegal immigrant" from my parents. The DREAM Act is a legislation 10 years in the making. We have thousands of enterpreneurs, scientists, engineers, nurses, doctors, talent in every field imaginable going to waste in the United States; living in the shadows. Myself included. Last year I graduated from NYU with a dual degree in electrical and computer engineering. My graduate school plans were shattered because I could not prove my identify for the purpose of taking the GREs. I cannot work, open a bank account, drive, get health insurance, go to a bar, take an interstate bus or train, fly, live or breathe. Yet, I am lucky, because I live in New York City. Those living almost anywhere else in the country cannot go to college or call the police at fear of deportation. There are hundreds of thousands of us in the United States. I personally know hundreds of children, teens, and now young adults that have had their lives put on hold for Congress to "feel right" for immigration reform. I also know quite a few individuals who could not live like this anymore and have taken their skills elsewhere by going for voluntary departure (a path not open to all). Next time your legislator tells you that this is not the right time for immigration reform, remind them of the experience of our butchered youth, remind them of the DREAM Act. I am a 23 year old American with no relief, rights, or equality in sight. Tragically, I am not alone.
- netsp 17y agoTo expand on what you are talking about: The solution to the problems caused by restrictions on immigration is less restrictions on immigration. A super specialised policy/visa designed to milk some of the meatiest benefits from immigration is an ugly hack.
- nick-dap 17y agoI honestly don't know if thats the case. It is not unreasonable to demand from Congress that they pass multiple legislations that address an area as complex as immigration (or healthcare for that matter). We are eagerly following the all encompassing reforms, while what we actually need is for Congress to make legislation continuously. Who would have thought that this was their job? Instead we make a big deal about big legislations and watch senators flip charts and push rhetoric while working deals behind closed doors. When advocating for manageable legislation with a whole lot of support and little floor time I've personally heard: "We cannot do it now, because we do not have the White House." "We cannot do it now because we don't have the majority in the Senate." "We cannot do it now because we dont have the 60 vote super majority." "We cannot do it now because its just not the right political atmosphere." This Fall, if health care fails, they'll have a perfect excuse not to touch immigration with a 10 foot pole. "We cannot do it now, because obviously it wouldn't pass, look at health care." My personal favorite "It takes so much political capital to pass any immigration bill that legislators need to do it all at once and then not touch it for another 20 years." Ironically, that one comes from reform advocates. My personal favorite response to that was by Robert Kerrey (a former Senator, President of New School in New York) - "I got news for you, Congress comes back every year." In geek terms. Why not iterate and see what works? What we have, obviously doesn't. Any legislation that we come up with today is almost guaranteed not to work in 5 to 10 years.
- modeless 17y agoI just can't get on board for another specialized program with more regulations. I wish we could just open the floodgates and let people in; xenophobes and protectionists be damned. If they're motivated enough to actually pick up and move here they're the kind of people we want.
- giardini 17y agoThe argument: America can't be the world's tech leader without immigration reform. But even without immigration reform America _is_ the world's tech leader. So how did we ever get that way without that "immigration reform"? Obviously someone's pushing his own agenda. This article is from the corporations' point of view; other articles take the workers' view. Corporations want cheaper workers but workers want higher wages. The usual struggle. Nothing new here.