10 ms·
I'm going to wholeheartedly disagree with you. I've posted here about this before - I got involved with weight watchers through my two roomates as moral suppor
by grecy 12y ago
I'm going to wholeheartedly disagree with you.
I've posted here about this before - I got involved with weight watchers through my two roomates as moral support for them, and have personally seen and been involved with many hundreds of people losing many thousands of punds - and keeping it off (that was over 10 years ago).
I've always thought of weight-loss like everything else we learn and do in life - start out simple and make it achievable while getting "beginner" results, then work your way up making it more and more complicated.
When you're 6 and learning to count, you are not taught differentiation and complex numbers.
When you're learning to surf, nobody would through you in at the world's biggest wave.
When you learn a new language, you don't learn the most complicated conjugations first.
Losing weight starts simply by reducing the amount of energy you're eating (calories) to a level lower than your body is using on a daily basis. I don't care if you eat raw sugar or fat, as long as you eat slightly less calories than your body is using for a prolonged period of time. (yes, you'll likely feel like shit if you eat raw sugar or fat, so I don't recommend it). Like you said, the body must obey the laws of thermodynamics. The longer you keep that up, the more weight you will lose.
I genuinely believe anything else at the "beginner" stage is noise and over complication. The mere fact so many books exist on the topic, and so many "new" theories come out each year is proof that it's too complicated for beginners.
Once you have some good "beginner results" and are losing weight consistently you will and start to move from morbidly obese to just obese down to a somewhat healthy range. THEN you can start making it more complicated, and start focusing on WHAT you're eating, not simply how much.
It's an advanced topic that isn't required for the basics. (just like you don't need complex numbers to count the number of marbles in your bag, or almost all other functions required in a normal adult life.)
- monting 12y agoDo you know how difficult it is in comparison, to lose weight using a low carb approach? Even if it's more difficult for some, it'll be easier for others.
- grecy 12y ago>Difficult What do you mean difficult? Just put less energy in your mouth than you're using. Want a Big Mac? Great! a beer here or there? no worries. Personally, I find it much more difficult to vet the "type" of food I'm eating. On average, just eat less energy than you're using. For most obese and morbidly obese people that's still an enormous amount of energy, so much so, they can continue to eat some pretty bad shit for a long time.
- demallien 12y agoHere's the thing. Your advice has been constantly given to people wanting to lose weight for half a century. During that period, despite the people receiving the advice wanting to lose weight, the population has become massively obese. Makes me wonder why you're so cock-sure of yourself. Anyway, Taubes deals very effectively with the argument you're presenting. The gist is that the number of kilo joules consumed does not have a particularly good correlation with fat stored, because the fat storage mechanism is mediated by insulin, which is heavily influenced by the consumption of carbohydrates.
- grecy 12y ago> Makes me wonder why you're so cock-sure of yourself. Because I've seen it work for hundreds and hundreds of people, and I know for a fact Weight Watchers (which is 100% what I'm talking about) has worked for millions of people. > The gist is that the number of kilo joules consumed does not have a particularly good correlation with fat stored, because the fat storage mechanism is mediated by insulin, which is heavily influenced by the consumption of carbohydrates. You're going to honestly tell me if I only put 9 gallons in my tank every day, but I burn 10 every day that I won't "run out" and burn up my reserve tank? You're wanting to make it so complicated you can't see the simplicity in front of you.
- cousin_it 12y agoI think you might be exaggerating when you say Weight Watchers has worked for millions of people. Here's a nice article about their success rate: http://fatfu.wordpress.com/2008/01/24/weight-watchers/ http://fatfu.wordpress.com/2008/01/24/weight-watchers/ It says it's extremely low, less than 1%.
- bollockitis 12y ago> I don't care if you eat raw sugar or fat, as long as you eat slightly less calories than your body is using for a prolonged period of time. Well, you might not care, but your body sure does. Your body responds very differently to sugar than it does to fat. And for some people—I would say anyone struggling to lose weight—this difference is the key to success. Yes, some people can lose weight eating nothing but carbs. There's a lot we don't know, and proponents of this theory will admit this. But one of the primary prinicples of this theory is that genetics plays a large role in human fat metabolism. Some people can eat whatever they want and remain thin, while others eat whatever they want and become obese. There is no such thing as a one size fits all diet.
- x0x0 12y agoYet somehow people weren't widely obese in the 60s. I have this fascination with random pictures: it's really interesting to look not at the focus but an the background. You see the stuff in houses, the items in shop windows, etc. The relevance here is look at pictures of the 60s and people's sizes. Skim eg these [1] and look at the older relatives in the wedding pictures. You'll see people who can stand to lose 25 pounds, but (I just got back from the midwest) you don't see people who could stand to lose 100+. Undoubtedly food has changed wildly in 55 years, but so also has the quantity. Not to mention all the estrogens from plastics. [1] http://www.buzzfeed.com/summeranne/adorable-real-vintage-wedding-photos-from-the-60s#47y9p4b http://www.buzzfeed.com/summeranne/adorable-real-vintage-wed...
- buckbova 12y agoMy guess is the folks smoked more cigarettes.
- thejdude 12y agoSure they did, but not everybody. There have always been adamant non-smokers just as there have always been convinced smokers.
- maxerickson 12y ago
- nostromo 12y agoNobody is arguing that reducing calories to below the amount spent will not cause weight loss. Of course it will. I know however that if I ate 1900 calories in sugar a day, let's say by drinking two 2-liter bottles of Coke, I would be constantly hungry. Eating 1900 calories in high-fat high-protein food however leaves me more than satiated. I think by focusing on the arithmetic in isolation you're making dieting much more difficult than it need be.
- buckbova 12y agoI agree. Would you lose more weight drinking two liters of coca-cola a day or eating the equivalent total calories in a high-fat protein rich food? I would think your body would burn through the straight sugar calories much faster than the protein. But consuming all the sodium in the coca cola product might cause water retention. Toss up. But most if not everyone's diet will never be that one-dimensional.
- toomuchtodo 12y ago> I would think your body would burn through the straight sugar calories much faster than the protein. But consuming all the sodium in the coca cola product might cause water retention. http://zestnzen.files.wordpress.com/2011/11/nutritionenergyhunger.jpg http://zestnzen.files.wordpress.com/2011/11/nutritionenergyh...
- joelrunyon 12y agoYou completed omitted any impact that hormones will have on this equation. The sugar you eat in Coke is going to send your blood sugar / insulin levels to sky rocket. High insulin levels cause fat storage. You could "lose" weight, but your body composition (or body fat percentage) certainly won't improve.
- evol262 12y agoThis isn't how homeostasis works at all. Insulin levels cause fat storage in order to lower blood sugar levels. If all you did was chug two 2-liter bottles of Coke, you'd temporarily go through lipogenesis, then go back through lipolysis to pull the stored calories back out for use later in the day. Insulin doesn't magically make you fatter if you're consuming the same number of calories. A high protein/fat diet is more satiating and you consume less calories, but insulin is not evil.
- beachstartup 12y agothis is like telling an alcoholic "recovering from alcoholism is simply reducing your level of alcohol intake to a level that isn't harmful." - yes, that's true. however it doesn't fix anything. obese people are not normal. if "just eat less" was even remotely possible, they would have done it already. the above statement literally adds nothing of value to the situation. there are millions, soon to be billions, of obese people in this world - telling them all to "just eat less" isn't a solution. it's just not. similarly, some people simply "drink too much" and can easily follow this advice. most alcoholics can't. here's the catch though - those who can just cut down, aren't alcoholics. do you see how this "just do less of X" logic is only descriptive, not prescriptive? there's a big difference. keto is a specific diet designed to combat a specific kind of overeater, and it is extremely effective at that. it also happens to work for lots of others such as athletes who want to cut fat extremely quickly. many overweight people are addicted to carbs and processed food, full stop period. because they eat too much carbs, they can not stop eating carbs, which pulls them into an insulin/fat storage/hunger spiral which is extremely, if not impossible, to pull out of. they have to just STOP, but the trick is replacing it with something else that will actually satisfy them. keto helps with that. it helps direct your eating choices in a sustainable way while returning hormone levels to that of a normal person, preventing the death spiral of hunger and eating. it also satiates hunger and allows people to eat foods they like without feeling deprived, a critical component of long-term success. in short - keto allows you to eat less, or to eat like a normal person. combined with the judgment call that fat is not bad for you per se, it's an amazing way of approaching this problem. don't forget the human element in dieting. pardon my language but "just eat less!" is worthless advice. utterly, devastatingly, uncompassionately worthless.
- grecy 12y ago> if "just eat less" was even remotely possible, they would have done it already..... - telling them all to "just eat less" isn't a solution. it's just not. In my experience, this is not true. Of the hundreds and hundreds of people I watched over many years lose combined thousands of pounds, I estimate somewhere around 75-85% of them had no idea how "calorie dense" some foods are in relation to others. And when I said no idea, I mean not even an inkling of an idea. I've seen hundreds of grown adults completely jaw-dropping shocked that an massive bowl of salad has the same amount of energy (points in WW speak) as a small piece of chocolate cake. I've seen them dumbfounded by how much energy is in a "meal" at a fast food joint. I've seen them argue and think the book is wrong that a piece of meat, or a glass of wine has so much energy in it, but a cucumber or multiple Apples has very little. Weight loss is a problem of education and understanding. >it also happens to work for lots of others such as athletes who want to cut fat extremely quickly. It's interesting you would suggest that the technique you're advocating works well for athletes... you're a Math teacher saying we should teach 6 year-olds Complex Numbers because it works well for Engineering Students. Athletes and people attempting to take the first steps to losing weight and understanding their bodies are not even remotely the same, and it's preposterous they would use the same technique to reach their goals. (Also note, your incorrect interpretation of what I said shows you yourself are not completely understanding what I'm saying or what you need to do about it. I never once said eat less. In fact, I've seen hundreds of people lose weight by vastly increasing the amount they eat by eating vast mountains of vegetables and some fruit, and eating many, many meals per day. They only need to decrease the amount of energy they're eating, not the raw amount.)
- ithought 12y agoWhat about inflammation? What happens to my body when I eat 800 calories of pancakes, syrup and hash browns, and start to sweat, feel sick and get tired?
- a8da6b0c91d 12y agoSugar does not cause inflammation. Sugar lowers cortisol and adrenaline levels. These stress hormones suppress existing inflammation. So in people with elevated catecholamine levels sugar intake tends to unmask damage and initiate a healing process. This is related to the reason people think low carb diets work. Low carb dieting sends stress hormones way up, because cortisol is necessary to break down proteins into needed sugars. People tend to feel pretty good at first in this state. The problem is it totally breaks down into bad endocrine and metabolic problems after two or three years. Nobody debates that ketogenic diets seem to work for weight loss in the short run; the issue is that in the long run they're a health disaster.
- ithought 12y agoI do not believe that is true. I can eat greasy hamburgers minus the bun and feel completely fine. I thought the body would use fat and ketones to convert to energy and only convert a very small percentage of protein to glucose. From the Harvard Medical School Family Health Guide: "Don't be so refined. The bolus of blood sugar that accompanies a meal or snack of highly refined carbohydrates (white bread, white rice, French fries, sugar-laden soda, etc.) increases levels of inflammatory messengers called cytokines. Eating whole-grain bread, brown rice, and other whole grains smooths out the after-meal rise in blood sugar and insulin, and dampens cytokine production." http://www.health.harvard.edu/fhg/updates/What-you-eat-can-fuel-or-cool-inflammation-a-key-driver-of-heart-disease-diabetes-and-other-chronic-conditions.shtml http://www.health.harvard.edu/fhg/updates/What-you-eat-can-f...
- a8da6b0c91d 12y agoThe cytokine release is exactly what I was describing. It only happens when there is damage and infection to heal. You do not see an inflammation response in a healthy person when they eat sugar/starch. The glycemic index stuff is pretty much nonsense. If you don't have type I diabetes your body is perfectly happy to sop up spikes of sugar and it does no harm at all.
- mistermann 12y ago> Like you said, the body must obey the laws of thermodynamics. Perhaps I'm reading more into it than you intend, but a pure thermodynamics view assumes if you eat an extra 1000 calories that it will be stored as fat, does it not? I know from personal experience this is simply not true. But maybe you're only referring to the weight loss end of the spectrum? In which case yes, there are certain laws that the body simply cannot defy - however, with very small variance in calories, evidence suggests the body can switch metabolism levels, so once again, it's not quite simple thermodynamics - conversion efficiency varies.
- perlgeek 12y ago> but a pure thermodynamics view assumes if you eat an extra 1000 calories that it will be stored as fat, does it not? Replace "will" by "might", and you're there. Thermodynamics just say the energy must go somewhere, but whether it's your fat cells or your excrements (or maybe some other channel I'm not aware of right now) is a matter of medicine.
- rasz_pl 12y agobody heat whole point of having high metabolism is your body simply gets rid of excess energy by heating up(100W on average?). Its burning calories while you sleep.
- SixSigma 12y agoAvg is 100W net - 9 MJ (megajoules), or 2000 kcal (food calories). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black-body_radiation#Human_body_emission http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black-body_radiation#Human_body...
- rsync 12y agoThank you. May I take this one step further ? The very first step is exercise. Walk. Do some yoga or martial arts. Resistance training (weights). There is very little point in discussing or pursuing any of this in the absence of daily, vigorous exercise.
- autarch 12y agoI've lost about 50 pounds over the last two years by reducing my food intake without any additional exercise. In fact, I can't really do much in the way of exercise because of chronic knee problems, which is one reason why I wanted to lose weight in the first place.
- rayiner 12y agoExercise is important for fitness, but it's really irrelevant for weight loss. For a male, running burns about 100 net calories per mile: http://www.runnersworld.com/weight-loss/how-many-calories-are-you-really-burning?page=single http://www.runnersworld.com/weight-loss/how-many-calories-ar... (depending on weight). To achieve a weight loss of one pound per week, you have to run five miles a day every day. If you're out of shape, that'll take an hour a day, every day, time you almost certainly don't have. Exercising your way to weight loss is an incredibly inefficient use of time. And telling people that they shouldn't even try to lose weight until they can fit in daily exercise into a schedule that's already full is needlessly setting them up for failure.
- runamok 12y ago> time you almost certainly don't have. As a runner for the past 23 years, you really, really do have a whole hour a day to dedicate to moving. I assure you that your body will fall apart sooner than later if you dedicate no time to keeping it strong and limber. I'd also say consumption is closer to 120 calories per mile. 3600 calories per lb. of fat so ~30 miles = 1 lb. I usually advise 5 times a week x 3 miles as a beginner program (after a moderate buildup of walk/run and less days per week). So every two weeks our subject would lose 1 lb. That's 26 lbs. in a year. Assuming these are 12 minute miles (which is just a bit faster than a walk), 12 x 15 miles = 3 hours a week. That is really a bare minimum of activity. If people start doing this at age 25 or so instead of trying to start at 45 when they are 60 lbs heavier than they should be it's not too difficult.
- cschmidt 12y agoI would have agreed with you completely before this summer. I had done weight watchers and lost weight, but as soon as I stopped tracking my diet (and restricting my calories), my weight drifted right back to where I started. Gary Taubes has a whole section in Why We Get Fat on how you can't keep weight off by temporarily restricting calories. This summer I've been reading a lot of books [1] on a low carb, moderate protein, high fat diet. It is called a LCHF or Keto diet. I now think that insulin resistance has a lot more to do with weight than I realized. I've lost 30 pounds this summer without counting calories (or weight watchers points). I just keep my carbs below 20g a day, and try not to eat too much protein. I'm not hungry, it doesn't take time to track, I feel really good, and the weight has some off so much faster than with weight watchers. [1] My summer reading, that has really changed my life: Why We Get Fat, by Gary Taubes http://www.amazon.com/Why-We-Get-Fat-About/dp/0307474259 http://www.amazon.com/Why-We-Get-Fat-About/dp/0307474259 The Big Fat Surprise: Why Butter, Meat and Cheese Belong in a Healthy Diet, by Nina Teicholz http://www.amazon.com/Big-Fat-Surprise-Butter-Healthy/dp/1451624425 http://www.amazon.com/Big-Fat-Surprise-Butter-Healthy/dp/145... Death by Food Pyramid: How Shoddy Science, Sketchy Politics and Shady Special Interests Have Ruined Our Health, by Denise Minger http://www.amazon.com/Death-Food-Pyramid-Politics-Interests/dp/0984755128 http://www.amazon.com/Death-Food-Pyramid-Politics-Interests/... Keto Clarity: Your Definitive Guide to the Benefits of a Low-Carb, High-Fat Diet, by Jimmy Moore, Eric Westman MD http://www.amazon.com/Keto-Clarity-Definitive-Benefits-Low-Carb/dp/1628600071 http://www.amazon.com/Keto-Clarity-Definitive-Benefits-Low-C... I was really surprised that most of what the medical establishment says about diet is so incredibly backwards.