3 ms·
The article makes a giant leap right from the get-go: "As China becomes, again, the world's largest economy, it wants the respect it enjoyed in centuries past.
by adventured 12y ago
The article makes a giant leap right from the get-go:
"As China becomes, again, the world's largest economy, it wants the respect it enjoyed in centuries past. But it does not know how to achieve or deserve it"
In 1990 we would have been talking about Japan becoming the largest economy instead.
Turns out there are a lot of problems between here and there. For example, China is at a point where they're unable to grow their economy without taking on ever increasing amounts of debt. That has resulted in one of the greatest debt binges in world history in the last six years.
I'd argue it's far more likely China will see stagnation, and extremely challenging growth, over the next 30 years as a consequence of what they're doing to fake growth now, rather than see continual boom. Wherever China stops in their vast debt accumulation, the bill that will go along with it is going to be historical in scale. That will drag on their growth in a dramatic way for decades.
The Chinese boom ended in 2007/08. In the next few decades it will be very difficult for them to achieve even 3% to 4% real GDP growth. What is basically going to happen, is normalization. It seems to be a perpetual cycle of analysts and economists making terribly poor extrapolations for future outcomes based on temporary boom periods that originate from extreme lows.
- hga 12y agoAnother strong factor is the PRC's rapidly aging demographics thanks to the CCP's One Child Policy. They're looking at a demographic collapse not entirely unlike Japan's ... except it's happening before they get really wealthy, and without the (unsustainable though they might be) outside the family safety nets of "developed" countries. And all this in a regime of financial repression (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_repression https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_repression). Decline is at least as good a bet as postulating "extremely challenging" growth ... and perhaps the PRC's current aggressive foreign and military policies are in part in reflection of this. Certainly wouldn't be the first time that happened, that motivated a lot of French policy before WWI.
- adventured 12y agoYes, that is indeed a huge issue. I've heard it referred to China getting old before they get widely prosperous. The robotics revolution interests me greatly as it pertains to China's aging situation (and Japan's of course). Whether they'll fully embrace robotics, or seek to limit that and instead focus on maximizing human labor (which is currently vastly under-utilized, via their intentionally backwards farming system that keeps hundreds of millions of people artificially busy).