4 ms·
At that scale, money isn't fungible. You couldn't double cancer research by making the total $180 billion. At least, not in the same way that you could double t
by graeme 12y ago
At that scale, money isn't fungible. You couldn't double cancer research by making the total $180 billion. At least, not in the same way that you could double the number of televisions you own.
There are only so many biologists, labs, etc. You can certainly entice more into the field with money, but I expect costs increase non-linearly with the number of scientists.
(I am not saying we can't do it. I'm saying it would cost much more than we expect from a linear extrapolation, especially in the near term. Imagine trying to use money to double, say, world food production – it couldn't be done, at least not in the short term.)
- judk 12y agoMost trained biologists leave the field due to lack of job opportunities. Labs are not hard to scale horizontally, and likely aren't even at capacity now due to lack of funded researchers.
- nmjohn 12y agoYep. A BS in biology provides virtually no job prospects. At all. Advanced degrees are only marginally better. Thank god I started programming when I was ~10 and was able to fall back on that after I decided against going to medical school, or I really have no idea what I would have done with my life.
- rjsw 12y agoIt was very noticable when I was at school that the biology teachers were a lot better than those for any other subject, there wasn't anything else that they could do.
- melling 12y agoI didn't say that if you doubled the money that you would double the research. In a $15 trillion economy, you'd think it would be possible to spend 10x on research. More private funding?
- melling 12y agoAlso, consider that $90 billion was over 40 years so we weren't talking short-term.
- adventured 12y agoIsn't it likely that the big problem is having enough highly capable leaders and researchers, and then knowing what directions to actually go in terms of spending vastly increased amounts of money (without simply wasting it foolishly)? It can take a lot of time just to find the path you should go down, and then to have the qualified people in place to go, and then to keep them in place long-term to sustain the effort. Very challenging stuff. How many top notch leaders can you cultivate to lead big research teams. People that have a comprehensive understanding of what targets to have for the research, people able to recruit the best brains to the cause. This seems to not be primarily a monetary bottleneck, but rather the inherently limited resource of how many really great people you can find to work on something at one time. It strikes me that humans also can only move so quickly, and that perhaps automated / machine learning, testing and solving is the long-term solution to speed of progress. I know a lot of progress is actively being made on this, I expect it'll drastically accelerate the pace of breakthroughs in curing illness. I think of it this way in premise: the current approach is the NIH trying to sequence the human genome; the future approach is Venter'ized.
- jrlocke 12y agoI think you would be well served to look up the meaning of fungible.
- graeme 12y agoYeah, it just occurred to me I used it backwards. I meant biologists/labs aren't fungible.