6 ms·
Summary: Because the energy of the Big Bang was moving, and the Schwarzschild radius is for stationary mass. And I'm sorry, but this explains NOTHING. Even for
by ars 12y ago
Summary: Because the energy of the Big Bang was moving, and the Schwarzschild radius is for stationary mass.
And I'm sorry, but this explains NOTHING. Even for moving mass the density was enough to make a black hole.
So presumably the density never actually got that high, or there is some other explanation we are not aware of.
He should have just said: We don't really know. Because we don't. Why is there this requirement that science be able to explain everything?
Is it because it's held up as an alternative to religion so people are petrified that if there are any holes people will say "sciences knows nothing, back to religion"?
(Now that I've setup my strawman I'm going to knock it down.)
First of all Science and Religion are not competing for adherents. You can believe that God created the universe and still want to investigate how he did it, and what the details are. Even if you believe the Big Bang never actually happened (i.e. it's an off-camera backstory), you can still be interested in investigating it because if God made it look like that then it's important.
Second the whole point of science is saying "I don't know", otherwise it's a religion, not science.
- trhway 12y ago>So presumably the density never actually got that high, or there is some other explanation we are not aware of. density don't need to be high to get a black hole - the more the mass the less its minimal density has to be when black hole can be formed - the Schwarzschild radius of our Universe (which is mostly space with the specks of matter) is on the scale of 10B+ light years for example. So depending on how it is calculated and a lot of other stuff - we still can be inside expanding black hole :)
- AnimalMuppet 12y agoDisclaimer: I'm speculating further than my knowledge of physics. But if you add dark matter, could that push the Schwarzchild radius of the universe to 13B light years? That is, to the (observable) radius of the universe? If so, then is it possible that the red shift of distant objects is a black hole effect (remember that in this scenario, we're inside the event horizon), rather than due to the expansion of the universe? Would this also explain dark energy? It would require that red-shifts in a black hole be non-linear in distance, which I think is plausible, and that they be non-linear in the right direction, which I don't know enough to say anything whatsoever about.
- coldtea 12y ago>First of all Science and Religion are not competing for adherents. Well, in abstract no. But then again, they are the result of people practicing them (science or religion), and those do compete for adherents.
- whyever 12y ago> Even for moving mass the density was enough to make a black hole. You are making an assumption here that is debatable. We understand very little of the physics close to the Big Bang. Those scales in energy, time and space are so extreme that quantum effects are expected to be dominant. However, all theory about black holes uses general relativity, which does not account for such scales. It is still an open problem to unite quantum physics and general relativity (i.e. this is basically what string theory hopes to achieve). > And I'm sorry, but this explains NOTHING. I think the point is that the assumption made to derive the theory about black holes from general relativity are just not met. The Schwarzschild radius is not defined for non-static spacetime, so it does not apply here. It is true that it explains nothing, but it also means that you cannot use the Schwarzschild radius in your argumentation.
- calinet6 12y agoIt's actually not that at all. This image tells it all: https://d262ilb51hltx0.cloudfront.net/max/953/1*QXypiHUwjJZrMtdhAQcpZA.png https://d262ilb51hltx0.cloudfront.net/max/953/1*QXypiHUwjJZr... What he was saying is, if there was just 1 gram per cubic cm less mass in the original universe, then it would expand too quickly to form any complex structures and the universe as we know it would not exist. And if it was just a few grams per cubic cm more massive, then it would collapse immediately as in the original question. The reason our universe did not immediately collapse is not a mystery. It was a tiny amount less massive than would be required for such a collapse. The reason it was perfectly on the line is no mystery whatsoever: if it were one gram over, it would collapse, and we would not exist, and thus we would not be asking the question. Same if it were one gram less; the universe would be too sparse for life to organize. This is not a miracle or a mystery, it's simply fact. Billions or trillions of universes might have sprung into existence over billions or trillions or perhaps even infinite aeons of time, each with different masses and parameters of physics. The one that produced an observer was observed. That's us, and that's it. No miracle, no mystery. It's like someone winning a lottery. The chances of a specific individual winning are next to nothing, but the chances of anyone winning are 100%. If a news crew then goes and finds the winner, they will surely find an astounded, surprised, and very lucky feeling person. But the news crew will not be surprised, since their observation is entirely expected and even guaranteed. Humanity is both the winner and the news crew in this situation, by the simple property of our ability to observe our own existence. This is called the anthropic principle. It also applies with zero modification to the question of why Earth appears to be such a perfect planet to support human life, especially as we begin to discover that there are literally trillions of planets in our universe. We should not be surprised that we observe the one that happened to have the conditions conducive to the evolution of a sentient observer. But you could be forgiven for feeling very lucky that you're one of them.
- jaekwon 12y agoI like this sentence... > The one that produced an observer was observed. I wonder if it applies in other contexts, specifically, er, quantum decoherence?
- 12y ago
- marcosdumay 12y agoThat summary is not entirely correct. It's not because everything was moving, but because space was getting bigger. A very different phenomenon. Why should he say that he does not know when the best accepted theory fits reality almost perfectly on that case? The correct thing to say is that he knows. Also, if you look carefully enough, we know of no matter that escaped the Universe, as far as we know, it fits exactly the property of the Schwarzschild's black holes.
- wyager 12y ago>First of all Science and Religion are not competing for adherents. In practice, how are they not? There are at least 3 major classes of popular religions that claim that the earth is only 6000 years old, among a smattering of other objectively false claims. One cannot correctly claim these facts are or might be true and also observe the scientific method. Yes, a hypothetical religion that posits nothing more than "there is a god" would not technically directly contradict the known body of scientific knowledge, but it would still contravene the scientific method.
- vacri 12y agoMost Christians don't claim the earth is only 6000 years old - that's only a particular brand of fundamentalist. There are plenty of religious people in science, even prominent in science - they are just mostly moderates, and learn to not publicise their religion to avoid conflict. The thing is that while the root of Christianity and science aren't compatible, the everyday practice of Christianity has little to do with that root. It's just some initial justificiation that doesn't really touch the everyday. The congregation are generally not so interested in the philosophical underpinnings than the daily practice. Praying to a saint that can't be proven, lighting a votive candle, or dropping money in the poor box does not compete with investigating atoms.
- wyager 12y ago>Praying to a saint that can't be proven [...] does not compete with investigating atoms. Yes, it absolutely does, because believing in the truthfulness of that person's sainthood (i.e. the existence of miracles) or the efficacy of prayer as a method of communicating with dead people requires the devotee to ignore scientific evidence to the contrary and/or believe something that has not been empirically deducted or otherwise formally proven. This is essentially the opposite of the scientific mindset.