8 ms·
Intellectual Ventures cuts 140 employees from its patent-buying workforce
- shmerl 12y agoI hope this whole racketeering workshop will be cut for good sooner than later.
- lotsofmangos 12y ago"Bloomberg BusinessWeek reports that IV kept asking the same companies to reinvest, and if they didn’t, the threat was that the company could always find something to sue one of the entities over." Say, nice corporation you got there. Shame if anything were to happen to it.
- higherpurpose 12y agoAlice effect?
- impendia 12y ago> The main issue debated is whether or not companies like IV hurt or help innovation with its business practices. This is an interesting point. Has anyone (without a direct financial interest to do so) made a credible argument that IV is anything other than harmful to innovation?
- asaddhamani 12y agoThere's this one article, it might not meet all your criteria though. [1] [1] http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2013/12/10/the-other-side-of-the-debate-over-patent-trolls/id=46671/ http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2013/12/10/the-other-side-of-the-d...
- lukifer 12y agoDevil's advocate: A secondary market for patents incentivizes investors to fund innovation, in the hopes of re-selling when/if the IP becomes valuable. That's the story, anyway. In the real world, I think patents are vastly net-negative towards genuine innovation, and in most cases, morally repugnant besides.
- jsmeaton 12y agoA secondary market for patents is fantastic. There are secondary markets for everything. The banking/venture system is designed to allocate scarce resources as efficiently as possible - why wouldn't the same thing exist for inventions? The real problem IMO is that patents are being issued for frivolous ideas. If patents really represented inventions of value, then the secondary market should be correctly allocating those patents to the right people. Unfortunately, patents do not represent inventions of value, because what we see is the secondary market identifying "infringements" everywhere, so it's more profitable to extort. If there are so many infringements, how is the patent possibly novel?
- lukifer 12y agoI agree that the practical problem with the current patent system is in implementation: the granting and enforcement of broad, poorly-defined patents, and the costs of litigation. Whether it's possible for a good implementation to exist, particularly in a long-lived form that copes well with radically new technologies, is debatable. My moral objection to patents can be concisely summed up by John Carmack: "The idea that I can be presented with a problem, set out to logically solve it with the tools at hand, and wind up with a program that could not be legally used because someone else followed the same logical steps some years ago and filed for a patent on it is horrifying." Anything that is so specific that it could not be reproduced by an independent human in a clean room (ie, the full text of Harry Potter) is well protected by copyright. Anything which can be reproduced through simple problem-solving can not be said to be "owned" by its creator. Patents outlaw thinking itself.
- axman6 12y agoWithout an excellent argument, I don't think I can agree. Many members of the public believe patents are a bad thing for society because 99% of all reporting on them is about the negative aspects; you rarely hear about the good that has come from them. It's the same reason people in the US feel less safe than ever from violent crimes even though the rates have dropped significantly. the norm is boring and the exceptions are newsworthy.
- chris_va 12y agoGood question, unclear answer. IV is not a typical patent troll, so the standard patent troll argument is hard to apply. They do not file large numbers of small lawsuits, but rather a small number of very large lawsuits (e.g. against the Intel/Ford/AIG types). They generally do loser pays, and a few other things that make them hard to bucket as a normal patent troll. IV spends a large amount of money (billions [1]) on purchasing patents. One might reasonably expect that to encourage innovation. As I understand it, most of those patents are not software patents, though (again I am not 100% sure) a large fraction of their lawsuits are based on software patents [citation needed]. One might reasonable expect that to discourage innovation. An interesting anecdote: Nest bought IV licenses to defend itself from Honeywell [2]. I would argue that Nest is a relatively decent innovation, so in this (very specific) case, one could argue that IV encouraged innovation. As I said, hard to balance. [1] http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/04/11/us-microsoft-apple-patents-idUSBREA3A0R020140411 http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/04/11/us-microsoft-apple... [2] http://techcrunch.com/2013/09/11/nest-buys-protection-licenses-patents-from-intellectual-ventures-to-fight-honeywell-others/ http://techcrunch.com/2013/09/11/nest-buys-protection-licens...
- shmerl 12y ago> IV spends a large amount of money (billions [1]) on purchasing patents. One might reasonably expect that to encourage innovation. I don't see how purchasing any kind of patents can encourage innovation. Innovation is encouraged by returns from the innovation, not by returns from sold patents. Recycling patents for profit is a completely parasitic business which has nothing to do with innovation.
- seanflyon 12y agoIf you give money to people in exchange for innovation that encourages innovation. That said, purchasing patents only encourages innovation if those patents are the product of innovation.
- shmerl 12y agoJudging by the current patent system, patents and innovation aren't equal in many cases. On the contrary, patents are often equal to the stifling of innovation. So giving money for patents is not equal to giving money for innovation in general case.
- baddox 12y agoThis is grasping at straws, but I could argue that IV has brought a lot of attention to the ludicrous nature of our IP system, which might lead to increased support of IP reform, which could help innovation.
- tzs 12y agoTheir partner programs where they partner with inventors to fund the development of inventions, and then handle the licensing and commercialization, seem like they could help innovation. Here's a description of their partnership with Caltech [1]: The partnership allows Intellectual Ventures to fund the inventive work of students and faculty in areas of interest to Intellectual Ventures, such as next generation data centers, dynamic surgical enhancements, and green and sustainable chemistry. Caltech will own the resulting patents and IV will receive a license to commercialize the technology. The inventors will earn a share of the profits from inventions that are commercialized, and will also have an option to create startup companies based on their innovations. I believe they have made similar arrangements with several other universities. [1] http://www.intellectualventures.com/news/press-releases/california-institute-of-technology-and-intellectual-ventures-partnership-to http://www.intellectualventures.com/news/press-releases/cali...
- asaddhamani 12y agoThis is that patent troll organization right? "the company has fallen on hard times as some of its bigger investors become less interested in buying into its funds." Good.
- ianlevesque 12y agoI imagine giving patents from your portfolio to patent trolling companies (Lodsys), who then sue your client's (Apple) partners, doesn't help.
- TheMagicHorsey 12y agoIV is a garbage company trying to portray itself as a bastion of innovation. There are certain severe "bugs" in the way our intellectual property laws work in the US. IV exploits these bugs to make Billions of dollars. IV is not concerned with whether something is good or not. They exist to make hay while the intellectual property laws remain broken. I had no idea they had 500 people working for them. That means that there are at least 500 people that are severely deluded, or morally repugnant. If you are an engineer or a lawyer familiar with the patent laws in this country, you can't read the claims asserted by IV and say that they are boosting "innovation" with a straight face. What they do is a dead weight loss on our economy. I feel sorry for the people that work at IV. They have whored themselves out for a little bit more money, instead of just working productively in this economy. I don't know how you can show your face in front of your kids and family knowing you go to work every day in an extortion racket. I would rather make a modest living and look at myself in the mirror with no shame.
- sonoffett 12y agoDo you find judgement and shame to be constructive communication tools for positive change?
- Natsu 12y agoThey appear to be widely and successfully used tools, but I don't like them.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoWell, if we look to religious texts, they have been the cornerstone of social control for millennia. There may be better tools, but judgement and shame have been undeniably effective.
- TheMagicHorsey 12y agoIf it shames people from joining them and filing garbage software patents, then yes. You aren't going to convince someone that works at IV one way or another. Its not like they haven't heard the arguments before. Its just that they don't care.
- aswanson 12y agoI dont get Myhrvold. He was wealthy beyond all get-out and, judging by his educational background, was probably intellectually curious at one point in his existence. Why would he direct the fall/winter of his life energy into this bullshit?
- judk 12y agoBecause he likes money, and likes what money buys, and likes what LOTS of money buys. It's not unusual by any means. Morally bankrupt, but not unusual.
- adventured 12y agoIt's entirely plausible - perhaps very likely - Myhrvold believes in what he's doing, believes in patents, believes patents help innovation, and so on. The world is filled with billions of people that believe truly crazy things, plenty of those people are smart and successful.
- shmerl 12y ago> Myhrvold believes in what he's doing, believes in patents, believes patents help innovation, and so on. I strongly doubt that. It's more likely that believes in filling his pockets using crooked means.
- shmerl 12y agoSimple. Being a parasite feeds his greed more than doing something useful for society.
- TheMagicHorsey 12y agoI believe its a deep feeling of inadequacy. We are not his peers. He considers Gates and Jobs as his peers. I suspect that despite his achievements he may have felt a bit like a peasant in their presence. He may have wanted to achieve their fame and wealth. He thought IV would be a good vehicle to achieve fame and fortune. I think he may not have understood the deep revulsion of the engineering world towards his methods. He may have initially thought we would consider him a savior working for our benefit ... after all I think he used to believe he was doing it for "inventors". Now he is too far gone probably. He either no longer cares what engineers and the world thinks, or he has deluded himself into thinking that his scamming is good for the world. Either way, he will probably carry this infamy to his grave. Although, I have to say, our country has a way of rehabilitating robber barons who give their wealth away. So his end-game may be to take his enormous wealth and use it to destroy some terrible affliction of mankind. I think it would be a triumph, and perhaps ironic(?) if he took his wealth and used it to reform the patent system. But short of that, he will probably be remembered by those of us in the tech and legal fields as a scammer and a scumbag of epic proportions, who was protected in his thieving by the laws of the USA. In any other time or place, such a man would have been tarred and feathered by a posse of his community for his conspiracies and crimes.
- kelukelugames 12y agoOne of the IV execs lived in my building. He was a self-obsessed douche.
- judk 12y agoOne the IV lawyers gave my kid a stuffed toy. I felt dirty accepting it, once I learned the provenance.
- lostcolony 12y ago540 left to go.
- ww520 12y ago20% for 140 people. That's 700 people. Do they really need that many people to buy patents?
- 51Cards 12y agoIntellectual Vultures would be a more apt name.
- bkruse 12y agoI was part of a "partnership" with IV and MagicJack. http://www.intellectualventures.com/news/press-releases/magicjack-vocaltec-completes-patent-deal-with-intellectual-ventures/ http://www.intellectualventures.com/news/press-releases/magi... Even though the PR seems to say that MJ is joining the force - you can clearly see that none of the original Vocaltec/Magicjack VoIP patents have been asserted against anyone else/used as defense in any patent lawsuit. By playing ball, we were able to use their patent portfolio to defend against the MANY patent lawsuits brought against MJ. It did help in a few cases when we were sued over a number of different VoIP and USB-related patents. From what I remember, though, it was expensive to be in their alliance and you had to contribute your own patents as well. The idea itself is interesting. I think a non-profit could better fill the need for everyone sharing a big patent blanket.
- bpdenimy 12y agoThe lawsuits that IV helped you defend against, were those from trolls or from practicing entities that had patents? I'm asking because I would think that having a bunch of patents would only protect you against practicing entities that are in violation of random other patents just by being alive, it wouldn't really stop trolls from trolling. Do I have that right? (Possibly an ignorant question, sorry.)
- bkruse 12y agoNot an ignorant question at all! All were from trolls/non-practicing entities except for one (which we settled). As soon as we went public, we became a target. It would come in the form of: "Hello, we are XYZ company are you are infringing on 1,324 of our patents related to computing and to communicating over USB - we would be happy to not move forward with our lawsuit for the sum of $500,000" We called it the reverse nigerian prince. It protected us from the vast majority of trolls - and it really came down to the "thump" test. The thump test is when company A asserts patents against company B. Company A comes storming in the court room (or via plain ole email) and drops it's stack of patents on top of the table. We now have to invalidate each and every claim which puts the vast majority of the burden on us. We would then turn around and drop our borrowed patent portfolio on the desk and it would thump pretty loud as well. That stopped 95% of the major patent lawsuits from moving forward, as stupid as it was. We took an aggressive stance to counter-sue for patent infringement and ALSO to invalidate via prior-art. Instead of sharks smelling blood in the water, we stopped getting the lawsuits because we aggressive sought to not only stop a lawsuit, but to invalidate the patent from ever being asserted again due to prior art which could be applied in any future patent lawsuit case (and in some instances, would invalidate the patent or have it "re-examined") Unfortunately, I feel there is still a very vulnerable phase of small business between profitable and not profitable enough to employ these strategies. As the MJs of the world (~$200M market cap) start to adapt - the trolls simply get change their nigerian email to $100,000 instead of $500,000 and start working their way down to smaller companies.
- thinkcomp 12y agoHere's a list of their shell companies: http://www.plainsite.org/tags/intellectual-ventures-shell-companies/ http://www.plainsite.org/tags/intellectual-ventures-shell-co...
- lawnchair_larry 12y agoHow did you miss LodSys?
- anactofgod 12y agoI'd be curious to know what returns have IV realized for it's investors to date? Also, "Bloomberg BusinessWeek reports that IV kept asking the same companies to reinvest, and if they didn’t, the threat was that the company could always find something to sue one of the entities over."? Sounds like an extortion racket.
- zak_mc_kracken 12y ago> Companies could buy into the fund, and in exchange, it potentially received legal protection from the patent portfolio. This is like a gun company asking you to invest in them and in exchange, they guarantee their guns won't be used to attack you. There's a word for this kind of practice: extortion. If anything, I'm sad that the 140 people being laid off only represent 20% of that scum company.
- MattyRad 12y agoKind of eerie when you realize you're looking into the portrait of someone without any conscious or ethics. I have little sympathy for the employees that got laid off, and am reassured that IV is finding it harder to operate. However, it's a bit disconcerting that they've claimed to "automate" their process.
- inthewoods 12y agoWow - I don't think I've ever seen a company discussed on HN that didn't have a single defender. IV may be the most hated company ever!
- shmerl 12y ago> Bloomberg BusinessWeek reports that IV kept asking the same companies to reinvest, and if they didn’t, the threat was that the company could always find something to sue one of the entities over. This is such a brazen shakedown, it's not even funny. Are there any laws which can be applied to prevent this?