5 ms·
"Could"? I give it 5 years. How do people see this as a good idea? There are already voluntary methods for this, so there is literally no good justification fo
by wyager 12y ago
"Could"? I give it 5 years.
How do people see this as a good idea? There are already voluntary methods for this, so there is literally no good justification for forcing a state-controlled version on everyone.
- lemonlyman87 12y agoExactly, but the bill makes it mandatory and default on for all smartphones in CA (which will probably lead to the same happening across the U.S.) - Ferguson protesters, watch out when police tell you to stop recording on your phones
- anigbrowl 12y agoThat is simply not true. The smartphone shall, during the initial device setup process, prompt an authorized user to enable the technological solution. [...] (2) An authorized user of a smartphone may affirmatively elect to disable or opt-out of enabling the technological solution at any time. [...]
- wyager 12y ago>An authorized user of a smartphone may affirmatively elect to disable or opt-out of enabling the technological solution at any time How much you want to bet that "opting out" happens on the government end and not the device end?
- dllthomas 12y agoThe advantage to mandatory and default-to-on is that it will be prevalent and will therefore decrease the expected value of mugging someone for their phone. That is a legitimate benefit, and is not worth nothing. I'm still not happy about the trade-off, if the disable doesn't depend on an owner-controlled code or similar.
- chenelson 12y agoFifteen years ago people were stealing mock-ups and pretending they had cell phones. I'm not sure those that commit felonies subscribe to the same value chain that you do. Besides, assuming the device doesn't self-destruct Mission Impossible style, at worst it'll still be worth parts to someone. So there will be many more parts available--and possibly more victims to make up the difference (assuming muggers are working for something).
- dllthomas 12y agoYou can't possibly believe those are reasonable points.
- chenelson 12y agoWhat--that trying to stop an opportunistic crime with white market reason is idiotic?
- dllthomas 12y agoInasmuch as that is even coherent, yes.
- chenelson 12y agoAssumption: A Kill Switch will render a $500 device worthless, and thus eliminate the incentive for theft. So, a couple of theft cases to frame: 1. People steal fake phones (shiny objects) that have NEVER worked, ie aesthetic value only. 2. Parts, such as replacement screens, are in great demand, and there are small urban retailers today that enjoy every opportunity to lower their costs, ie $5-50. Following 1991 crime statistics, over 2/3 of those arrested for robbery tested positive for a controlled substance. Does an addict have Free Will? Delayed gratification? What's a $100/day habit like? What is an addict willing to do for a Klondike Bar? (Answer: Anything.)
- 12y ago