4 ms·
What an excellent Hacker News Post. Please do write up a bit more about your method, what your students got out of the course specifically, and whether you've
by ghshephard 17y ago
What an excellent Hacker News Post. Please do write up a bit more about your method, what your students got out of the course specifically, and whether you've had success with it in other places. You have a clean, readable, and interesting writing style.
I think we can all recall a teacher or teachers in our life who truly made a difference in teaching us something - sometimes _despite_ our interest (or lack thereof) of learning it.
I was forced in University to take a course in Propositional Calculus (it was a breadth requirement for computing science) - it was mid-day so I attended the class (unlike early morning classes in which my attendance was abysmal) - I went in with zero desire - no coding, or even math. But, the timing was right so I just sat in the class.
The instructor spent thirteen weeks walking us through Reductio Ad absurdum proof, tautologies, conditional proofs, etc.. He gave us homework assignments that built on earlier knowledge, and just as we were getting into new material, he'd throw some earlier sequent proofs at us to solve and refresh our memories.
Here is the thing - I had _no_ interest in this course, the only thing going for it was it's timing, and repetition. I was _killing_ myself trying to learn integration by parts, linear algebra, discrete math, spending 5 hours outside of class for every hour in class trying to master those other course, and basically just sitting in this one distraction course. I was a C+ student in the math courses (after _massive_ effort) - I walked out of the Propositional Calculus course with an A+.
Sixteen years later I look back at University and can honestly say that the most useful course, that I _continue_ to have rock solid knowledge of PLUS use almost every single hour of the day was that stupid Philosphy 210 Propositional Calculus course. For the life of me I can't remember much of graph theory, and wouldn't be able to invert a matrix if you held a gun to my head, but, I'll sit in a meeting and see a ton of possible alternative and immediately start applying Disjunction elimination to break us out of a log jam.
There really is something to this spacing method.
- joe_the_user 17y agoIt could also be that propositional calculus is dead simple - or at least that has always been my impression of it. Calculus and linear algebra work on complex problems in a large domain. Propositional calculus has a small domain and fairly simple theories. I think in general, the knowledge domain is important. Linear algebra is a very unified field by itself but when you get courses that involve a grab bag of algebra, linear algebra, trigonometry and calculus, I think the "stew" they present is incredibly hard to comprehend on a high level and students wind-up either failing or learning by a horrible kind of rote. Uh, this is from biased personal experience. I indeed only taught one college math course when I doing my math MA, it was "Trignometry". It was a complete failure. I still blame the "grab bag" quality of the material but perhaps I was to blame instead.