8 ms·
Where I Should Live, According to Math
- rattray 12y agoI'm worried that the census data is too stale. Capitol Hill has been seeing rents skyrocket in the past few years. I think the same is true in Graduate Hospital, Philly. (I have lived in both Seattle & Philadelphia). I can't speak to the other areas, but running big numbers doesn't necessarily give you better information than people who were already living near "the good areas". And they've been rushing in to them, driving up rents, since before the census took its data. It's a frustrating phenomenon.
- timfrietas 12y agoI have a feeling you're right considering the Mission district is also in his results, and at ~2800 for a one bedroom it is one of the most expensive neighborhoods in the US.
- _delirium 12y agoI think part of the problem is that he's using median income for the census tract, not a measure of housing cost. The assumption seems to be that a census tract with a median income similar to his will be affordable for him. But there are many reasons that might not be the case. Some off the top of my head: presence of asset-rich but income-poor retirees with paid-off mortgages; longer-term residents grandfathered in to a gentrified area via rent control or other stabilization measures; presence of university students, who tend to both have spending power out of line with their actual income (due to family, loans, etc.) and access to dorm housing; bimodal distributions where a moderate median hides a neighborhood that's half unaffordable and half a ghetto; people with employer-subsidized housing (faculty housing, military housing); etc. Other income-based measures might give a better idea, though. Median income of working-age adults who've lived there <5 yrs could give an idea of what people who've recently made a similar move make.
- fishtoaster 12y agoI'd be curious how recent his affordability data is. He mentions Lower Haight and The Mission, which have an average 1-bedroom rent of 3000 and 3250 respectively[0]. They have, however, increased dramatically over the last few years, which may not be reflected in his data set. [0] http://priceonomics.com/the-san-francisco-rent-explosion-part-ii/ http://priceonomics.com/the-san-francisco-rent-explosion-par...
- thrownaway2424 12y agoYeah there is something fishy in this analysis if Russian Hill appears more affordable than DC suburbs.
- socialist_coder 12y agoYeah, I don't get that either. Something seems broken.
- scythe 12y agoHe used median income. Rich people in the DC suburbs tend to live in mansions, because they live in the suburbs. [Nouveau-]Rich people in the Mission live in 1-bedroom apartments because they're hipsters. The DC suburbs include some of the richest neighborhoods in the country, yes, richer than San Francisco (where do you think $2T annually in government spending goes?). Mill Valley also probably has a higher median income than the Mission, despite cheaper 1-br apartments.
- Bahamut 12y agoDC suburbs themselves aren't more expensive than SF or the Valley though in general, speaking as a recent DC transplant to the Valley. You can find a 1000 sqft 1 bedroom apartment just outside of DC and a few inside DC for about $2000 a month. Go a little further to even Fairfax and you can get a 2 bedroom one for even $1600 if you look carefully. While I haven't lived in the Valley long enough, I'm currently paying about $2100 a month for just 700 sqft, and other places are even worse around here. And income may be higher in some respects, but that is pretty much exclusively in the government sector or law.
- fibbery 12y agoI made an interactive map a year ago to explore the same question (where do you live taking into account factors like income, weather, walkability, crime, education, politics, etc), check it out if you are interested http://two88cities.herokuapp.com/ http://two88cities.herokuapp.com/
- avalaunch 12y agoThat is really awesome. I love it. The one thing that would make it really useful to me in the next year as my family decides where to move is the inclusion of public grade school/high school national rankings. I've been looking for some way to easily cross reference cost of living with quality of public schools.
- fibbery 12y agoNice idea, and super important for choosing where to live.
- pimlottc 12y agoI assume you just grabbed photos off Flickr? Some of them seem pretty random. I'm from Cleveland and I have no idea where this picture is from. http://farm4.staticflickr.com/3683/9286810188_548716198e_n.jpg http://farm4.staticflickr.com/3683/9286810188_548716198e_n.j...
- fibbery 12y agoYep, I just did searches on Flickr and grabbed ones that I liked tagged with the city, but they could be totally wrong!
- lotharbot 12y agoThis is beautiful. I'm curious, did you use it to move? Are you happy with the move? Would you change certain factors or add anything? I'm also curious about how you evaluated diversity. For example, my current city and one I'm intimately familiar with (Denver) scores only a 2 on diversity, while Boston scores a 5. Ethnically, both cities' largest demographic is non-hispanic whites (Denver 52%, Boston 47% -- not tremendously different; when you add in suburbs Boston is considerably whiter than Denver). The next two groups for Denver are Hispanic or Latino (32%) and Black or African American (10%), and for Boston Black or African American (24%) and Hispanic or Latino (17%). Again, these don't seem tremendously different to me. Denver has the largest Mongolian population in the United States, hosts one of the largest Native American Pow-Wows in the country, and has had 2 Black mayors and one Hispanic mayor (Boston has never elected a non-white mayor.) I realize there are other forms of diversity, but Denver does fairly well on those too (for example, 5.8% of Denver's population is LGBT; Boston is a slightly higher 6.2%.) Point being, I don't understand what criteria were used to score these cities on opposite ends of the diversity spectrum given that they both seem fairly diverse to my eye.
- aaronbrethorst 12y agofwiw, this is my neighborhood. I live on the very southern edge of that box.
- bndw 12y agoGreetings, neighbor
- Spooky23 12y agoBe careful with statistics. Spend some quality time in Cambridge in particular and you will soon learn why it's statistical makeup is what it is. Cambridgians are either rich or not. Also look at how he schools work. Cambridge and Boston for example, have mandatory bussing, so your kids won't go to a neighborhood school. You should try to use other factors to avoid living in a bad area. For example, penalize areas within 10 blocks of hospitals and large universities. Institutions usually maintain slummy property in the immediate vicinity to make room for expansion. Also look at property tax rate as a percentage of property value. Higher rate cities that have cheap rent aren't places where you want to live.
- galago 12y agoI work in Cambridge, and feel that your description isn't a bug, its a feature. Great cities generally have a dynamic mix of people.
- jeremyjh 12y agoThe author of the SP is using median income as a proxy to estimate how affordable the housing is to someone like himself. If there are no people at his income living there, then the type of housing he is looking for is not available.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- aaron987 12y agoCool project. I did something similar myself very recently, except I just used a spreadsheet, and I didn't look at the whole country. I was focused on cities out west. I found a list on Forbes of the 200 best cities to start a business (which I would like to do) and used that as a starting point. I then combined that with walk score, cost of living relative to minimum wage, average temperature (I want to be somewhere warm), and crime data. I even searched each city on OkCupid to see how many people had at least a 90% match to me relative to the city's population, which was an indicator that people in the area tend to think the way I do. In other words, it meant I would be able to make friends and get along with people if I moved there. Using all of that data, I gave each category a rank based on how important it was, and tallied the results. My top three cities were Vallejo, CA, San Francisco, and Olympia, WA. I've never been to any of those places, but I want to leave Ohio. At least now I know where to start looking.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoOlympia is a sleepy town without much tech. In general, big cities have big jobs.
- aaron987 12y agoGood to know thanks. I plan to visit the towns before moving there. Anyone have an opinion of Vallejo?
- flavor8 12y agoIt has ferry service to SF, so commute wise it's not terrible. Just be aware that the ferries don't run super late, so you'll be restricted when it comes to staying out late after work. Downtown is decent (although a shell of its former self), the waterfront is good, there's good sailing & kayaking opportunities, easy access to Napa & Sonoma, plenty of hiking around. Not a bad spot.
- rdl 12y agoVallejo is commute-to-SF, although fairly extreme, and pretty horrible for commute-to-Peninsula. In my experience, there isn't a whole lot in town itself; it's gone through a period of bankruptcy and sketciness, although not as dangerous as some other towns like Richmond, CA.
- davidy123 12y agoI guess if you want to pretend to live statistically. But once you actually move somewhere and try to live there you might find it's something else.
- dj-wonk 12y agoIt is a starting point. Any one statistic is just a summary. (We all summarize, one way or another.)
- freshyill 12y agoI like this. I, too, live near, but not in DC, and my situation is basically the same as his. I also like his conclusion of eh, we'll just move to Columbia Heights anyway. I would too, but this makes me notice one thing that that this whole thing is missing: schools. I don't know if there's any school data that could be applied to this, but I bet it would be a good way to narrow down some of the results.
- bndw 12y agoFor what it's worth, that's a nice neighborhood[0]. [0] I've lived within that area
- Dewie 12y agoWhy do you use a footnote when the footnote is immediately followed by the corresponing text? Just wondering.
- w1ntermute 12y agoIt's not a footnote, it's a citation for his claim.[0] 0: Footnotes are typically used to express parenthetical thoughts that are too unwieldy for inline inclusion, like this one.
- mgarfias 12y agoYou’re missing out living in the country.
- n72 12y agoAny thought to adding weather? I was in Seattle for two years for a startup and the gloom almost killed me.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoPhoenix or tuscon have lots of sunshine.
- myblake 12y agoTucson is really nice in a lot of ways, it doesn't have walkability though which is one of the main components used in the analysis. If it's just a proxy for a certain type of city culturally (as I suspect it is) then in some ways Tuscon could fit the bill reasonable well with much better weather. SF has pretty great weather if you're comparing it to the East Coast, too bad the affordability data is clearly stale.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoMore reasonable places in the higher desert: Salt Lake City, Santa Fe, and if you don't mind some snow...Jackson Hole. Only SLC has jobs...oh and there is Denver also. My dream is to live in Jackson Hole, but I think you need to be rich.
- dmishe 12y agoBut summer is so nice :)
- will_work4tears 12y agoAustin seems the obvious choice. Of course it's hotter than hell there, humid, and you probably have to have an eye out for Tornados. Personally if I had to pick anywhere but the Seattle area (perfect for me, the gloom doesn't effect me like it does others), it'd have to be either SLC or Boulder/Castle Rock (both near Denver). SF is probably better climate, IMO, and the idea appeals to me, but the cost of living combined with the traffic... no thanks. Seattle traffic is above what I consider acceptable, SF would kill me.
- kirinan 12y agoCapital Hill is one of my favorite places in Seattle. Lots of diversity and bars though some are a little shady. It doesn't surprise me that it has a high walk score. Lots of grocery stores, great places to eat all walkable if you live in the neighborhood. Though Id be weary though, its affordable because it does have a higher than normal crime rate, but to be fair Seattle has one of the lowest crime rates in the U.S and by many standards is extremely safe even in the most dangerous parts of the city. I wouldn't raise kids in Capitol Hill, though if I was single, interested in night life and wanted to be able to walk to things I cared about, then capital hill is totally for you.
- moron4hire 12y agoIf you want to stay in the DC area and want to live somewhere that isn't insanely expensive but also walkable, perhaps look into renting an apartment in Del Ray, Alexandria. Granted, I'm a bit biased, but it's a cool part of town and there are some affordable places to live, if you look hard.
- Bahamut 12y agoThat area, while cheaper, suffers from lack of easy Metro access though. You pretty much have to bus it to Crystal City for Metro access for the commute. As far as Metro access goes, Pentagon City and Ballston may be the cheapest places on the VA side of DC that have proximity to the metro & are close. The Maryland side is cheaper, but nobody likes Maryland :) .
- moron4hire 12y agoNo, there is a metro station down on Braddock Road that is a very easy walk from Del Ray. And you're right, nobody likes Maryland. Not even Marylanders.
- xxpor 12y agoUgh, how does everyone St. vs Ave. wrong in Seattle? The map should be 15th Ave and 23rd Ave. Seattle is the only city where I've seen people struggle with this.
- xxpor 12y agoThe box in the article is one section of Capitol Hill. If you're talking to younger people, they're more likely to think of Capitol Hill as near Broadway from Pike/Pine up to Roy, and from I-5 to 15th.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoIowa City is on that map. Medium-sized cities in 'flyover' states make sense - walkable, affordable. And Iowa City is a University town, so lots of things like culture and diversity. Of course I live outside town, even less expensive. For the price of my San Jose house on 1/4 acre, I have 80 acres in the country here.
- arxpoetica 12y agohttp://www.coeverywhere.com/CO_official/columbia-heights-washington-dc http://www.coeverywhere.com/CO_official/columbia-heights-was... <- where Dave Munson should live. :)
- tptacek 12y agoI'm not sure I understand the criteria. He'd like to move into DC, but DC is too expensive. So he devises a filter that spits out (among a small number of other optimal locales) the Mission and Russian Hill in San Francisco. Both are among the most expensive places to live in the country. For that matter, optimizing mostly for walkability, the filter spits out Lakeview in Chicago. But Lakeview is one of the most expensive neighborhoods in Chicago, and isn't significantly more walkable than many cheaper neighborhoods here.
- curtis 12y agoLikewise, Capitol Hill in Seattle is a very expensive neighborhood -- if you want to buy. However it's chock full of rental units. I suspect that apartment rental costs in Capitol Hill aren't anywhere as extreme as trying to buy a house. I'm not sure that makes it "affordable" by any normal definition, though.
- curtis 12y agoAlso on a re-read, I note that the author was not using housing prices as a measure of affordability: > Affordability wasn’t hard; I mapped all the census tracts in the country that had a median income within $10,000 of mine, both above and below. I can't speak to other neighborhoods, but in the case of Capitol Hill I suspect that this measure is a poor proxy for affordability. Capitol Hill residents might be disproportionately people who are willing to pay a premium to live in the City.
- gerbal 12y agoInstead of using income as a proxy for affordability, using actual cost of rent by census tract would be way better. The ACS data he used includes Rent values and property values, both of which are a much better measure of affordability than income. Or the sort of data provided by Kwelia. [1] http://kwelia.com http://kwelia.com
- TheCoelacanth 12y agoThat's going to be a terrible measure of affordability. Measuring affordability by median income will tell you that Loudoun County, VA (a suburb of DC) is the most expensive place in the US to live. However, it's actually much cheaper to live there than to live in DC, which is cheaper to live in than New York or San Francisco.
- thearn4 12y agoI did something similar, but a bit simpler and just within one one region of my state. I used a GA wrapped around google maps to minimize total expected driving distance between the university I was attending, the office of the job I was working at the time, the home of my g/f at the time, along with other objectives.