6 ms·
Antioxidants and Cancer: Have we got it Backwards?
- TrevorJ 17y agoWhile the logic here may be sound, you would expect the statistics to bear it out and since antioxidants are a well-studied area even weak correlation between antioxidants and cancer should be present in these studies and to my knowledge, it's not.
- jcl 17y agoIt's entirely possible that antioxidants make it less likely for you to get cancer but more likely to make cancer worse once you have it. Depending on how the two effects interact, the correlation could go either way. Interesting random blog page describing research that shows a fruit- and vegetable-rich diet may actually be bad for you: http://donmatesz.blogspot.com/2009/08/phytochemical-fallacies.html http://donmatesz.blogspot.com/2009/08/phytochemical-fallacie...
- TrevorJ 17y agoAh, that is a good point. I hadn't thought of that. It should be possible to test for that with present data though, so you would think that somebody would have uncovered it before now since antioxidants are apparently given to cancer patients as a form of treatment. If it increased mortality rates in cancer patients looking at the data should be able to uncover that.
- jcl 17y agoAfter a little more Googling around, it looks like there are some studies showing increased cancer rates when people are given antioxidants: http://www.cancer.gov/cancertopics/factsheet/prevention/antioxidants#2 http://www.cancer.gov/cancertopics/factsheet/prevention/anti... (And some going the other way, too.)
- noodle 17y agotwo notes from that blog posting: > Plants have no claws or teeth, nor can they run from predators, so they have chemical defenses instead. some do, sure. but plenty of plants rely on animals to disperse their seeds, and making it dangerous to eat them is an evolutionary mistake. fruits taste good because they want you to eat them, process their seeds, and 'deposit' them elsewhere in the world. >After 7.3 years of follow-up care, the two groups had almost identical invasive cancer incidence, 16.7% in the intervention group, and 16.9% in the control group. Increasing intake of produce appeared to have no effect on cancer recurrence despite changes in blood levels of antioxidants. and this couldn't have anything to do with anything else? environment? lifestyle? genetics? affluence? etc.? there's more than one way to get cancer, diet alone will not save you.
- jcl 17y agosome do, sure. but plenty of plants rely on animals to disperse their seeds... Yes, and that's noted in the article, a few paragraphs later: Some hunter-gatherer tribes do eat substantial amounts of fruits and vegetables (wild types, which have even higher concentrations of poisons), yet remain free of cancer and heart disease. Significantly, hunter-gatherers tend to consume more fruits than vegetables. Fruits have lower toxin levels and enable a plant to work symbiotically with animals/predators to increase reproductive success.
- noodle 17y agoindeed he does. but, at the end of a large "eating a lot of plants is bad for you" essay, to tack on the short note "oh wait, fruits? maybe those aren't bad for you" type of statement undercuts the credibility of the entire argument for me.
- randallsquared 17y agoIt does? I think the vast majority of plants that most people (at least, where I live) eat are non-fruit. Potatoes, beans, rice and other grains...
- pyre 17y agoWhat I got from that blog post was 'there are lots of bad things in fruits and vegetables along with the good things'. Isn't that the truth for anything? Unless we start making foods that are homogeneous mixtures, every natural food that we eat will have good and bad things in it. I somehow don't think that the solution is to have a diet that's heavy in meats and carbohydrates. I think that it would be interesting to take a look at cancer rates in Ireland (pre-potato famine). Most of the farmers/serfs there had a diet of mostly potatoes as I understand it. Did they have higher or lower cancer rates?
- bedris 17y agoThe sheer number of environmental, dietary, and lifestyle factors that would have to be adjusted for in a comparison of present-day cancer rates and those that took place ~160 years ago in Ireland would likely make any conclusions that you could draw conjectural, at best.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoThe problem with cancer rates from 200 years ago is that life-expectancy was so different and that they might not have have been able to identify the cause of death back then.
- biohacker42 17y agoI'm not sure if we have it backwards, but the article definitely oversimplifies it. It also makes some embarrassing points for ephasis, plants using antioxidants as defenses, green tea might be, but I doubt many fruits are NOT meant to be eaten by animals. The health benefits of a diet high in fruits and vegetables are supported by very strong science. We've also had some very good recent research into vitamins and other antioxidants in pill form. The news there is not so good, it seems vitamin pills may be worse then useless. With cancer it's more complicated. Some vitamins like C and D have proven anti-cancer properties but in doses that would kill you. In low doses C might actually be helping some cancers, as they can use it as well as healthy cells. In summary: Backward? No. Oversimplified? Yes, it is complicated.
- latortuga 17y ago>> The health benefits of a diet high in fruits and vegetables are supported by very strong science. Maybe check out http://high-fat-nutrition.blogspot.com/2007/12/fruit-and-vegetables-re-post.html http://high-fat-nutrition.blogspot.com/2007/12/fruit-and-veg... It is a blog post but it seems to have reasonable sourcing. However, I do agree with your conclusion: it's complicated!
- joe_the_user 17y agoComplicated, indeed... I don't see why one should necessarily assume that the diets might prevent cancer before it happens will cure cancer once it happens, yet it seems like the article is making something like an argument for this...
- billswift 17y agoThe actual data presented in the article suggests that anti-oxidants may aid the spread of cancer (metastasis) by reducing oxidative stress on dispersing cells.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- 17y ago
- run4yourlives 17y agoI am continually astounded by how much, and at the same time how little we know about how our own bodies work.
- hs 17y agoi'm more impressed with how much conflicting misinformations floating around while seemingly scientific claims like x improves y are abundant. sadly we don't often see the %quantitative improvements and fall into "every little bit helps" then we get another claim like "a prevents b", then blindly follows. while a and x are good in its own rights, the 'interaction' effect is so complicated that taking them will become net negative
- andrewvc 17y agoTrying to game the system as far as nutrition goes is a losing battle if history has shown us anything. Every time someone half-way understands some new aspect of nutrition we flood or deprive our bodies of something we've eaten successfullly for generations upon generations. I like Michael Pollan's simple advice: Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants. One other thing, from a behavioral perspective, if you come out with a new health food, people don't stop eating bad food and start eating more health food, they just add the health food on top of the crap.
- Mz 17y agoMy experience has been that most things are a two-edged sword. Saying some things are "bad" and other things "good" is usually a huge oversimplification that is tantamount to lying. I have my own pet theory on cancer. But that's probably not relevant to the discussion.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoAh, brilliant! I knew it from the age of 3 that eating chocolate exclusively is the way to go. Somehow my parents led me astray though. It's depressing :)
- hs 17y agono discussion about cancer is complete without mentioning "the china study" by Collin Campbell conclusion? eat whole food, plant-based diet and we don't need labels like vegetarian/vegan. why? because eating fried fries, potatoe chips, smoking, drinking, sodas, candies ... while correctly not including animals ... are not healthy
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]