3 ms·
> Is there a reason why all USB sockets - including these > new diagrams - have a feeble looking centre part rather > than it being part of the outer rin
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
> Is there a reason why all USB sockets - including these
> new diagrams - have a feeble looking centre part rather
> than it being part of the outer ring?
The outer part is the RF shield. That increases reliability by protecting the low voltage (but high frequency) USB data signals from coupling to outside interference (50/60 hz stray emf from power lines, switching power supply noise, etc). The magsafe connectors are just pulling power so don't really need that level of shielding.
- MBCook 12y agoBut what about the Lightning connectors on iPads and iPhones? They don't have that outside shield but they carry high speed signals.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 12y agoThe lightning connector is pretty cool isn't it? Apple figured out you could build the RF shield around the signal lines in a single planar unit. If you look at the original 30 pin connector they did, they used a very similar scheme to USB the shield around the outside of the connector, the signal lines on the inside in a separate piece. I actually think it was the lightning connector that got the USB group to go back and look at their connector designs. The interesting bit about the shield on the lightning is the fairly tricky way they create an island in the middle of the shield and thread the signal lines through it. Makes for a more expensive cable I expect.
- 300bps 12y agoThe lightning connector is pretty cool isn't it? No. It's not. I haven't plugged my phone in since I originally bought it and I don't understand thinking that a connector is cool. For charging, every major mobile phone company except Apple supports Qi wireless charging. Source: http://www.qinside.biz/en/support/qi-enabled-phones http://www.qinside.biz/en/support/qi-enabled-phones For connectivity, every major mobile phone company supports wireless connectivity via Bluetooth or WiFi. I had an iPhone for 6 years (3g, 4, 4s) and saw all the competition fly ahead of Apple in terms of real features and screen size. My next phone may be an iPhone 6, but really Apple has a ton of catching up to do.
- jmgrosen 12y agoMy phone has wireless charging; I used to use it, but I eventually switched back to wired charging. Why? Two reasons, which I think are the biggest ones that explain why wireless hasn't completely taken over wired: efficiency and reliability. Especially the latter.
- freehunter 12y agoI used the wireless charging on my Nokia Lumia for two years, every night. Loved it. Problem is, it's dog slow compared to how fast my iPhone 5s charges. And when I tried to charge my Nexus 4 on the same charger as the Nokia (they use the same technology, why not?) it would go haywire and never actually charge. Apple may be behind their competitors in some way, but they have a way of not pushing out technology until they're sure it's going to work the way the mass market expects it to (which is how the general public lets them get away with calling everything "magic". To a non-technical audience, it might as well be). My Nokia is full of cool features that don't work. If the battery dies, it takes half an hour before you can turn the phone on again. My Nexus 4 has a big screen but the camera is shit and it can't hold a charge through the day. My iPhone doesn't have a single "wow" feature to me, but then again there are no features that make me think "this would be so cool if only it worked". The last non-iPhone I didn't truly hate was my Palm Pre+.
- lttlrck 12y agoYet every phone still has a power/data cable... cool or not.
- jcampbell1 12y agoIt seems like an RF shield on the male end is unnecessary. Apple's current iPhone connector does without it. I have no idea how they could see the lightning connector, then go and design a next gen standard that is across the board inferior. The Apple connector is sturdier, and has much more latitude for insertion angle. Surely Apple doesn't have a patent on a housing-less male plug. My guess is the housing serves more as a mount point providing the friction and spring, rather than being necessary for shielding.
- shawnz 12y agoAre you so sure that it is "across the board inferior"? I don't really know about the technical details, but the lightning connector is designed for pretty specific uses. Can it carry 10Gbps and 100W like this connector can? Perhaps the housing contributes to that ability.
- seanp2k2 12y agoMaybe not, but it can withstand multiple connections daily for 2+ years without failing, unlike the MicroUSB connectors I've had on my phones. Also, the connector is very sturdy, so it doesn't break off, even on cheaper cables. Additionally, I never plug it in upside-down, because there is no such thing. This is a good move for USB, and I personally can't wait until these become the new standard :)
- andmarios 12y agoI have my phone for 3 years, I charge it at least once daily and many times I use the cable to bring it to me, thus the phone ends up hanging from the micro USB connector. It still works perfectly, so I guess YMMV.
- mbell 12y agoYou have this backwards, the shield is there to prevent RF noise radiating _from_ the USB signal pairs, not to prevent outside noise coupling onto the signal pairs.