9 ms·
A Diablo 3 Story
- Paul_S 12y agoThe story is fascinating but I cannot help but think what a massive waste of time and resources it is. And I thought hedge fund managers were not adding value to society. This puts things in perspective. I especially like the bit where he explains that botters were helping the virtual economy. From the article: "I know a lot of people will say that what I did was cheating or unfair, but everyone must realize that in the end what I did was completely legal." Sounds familiar?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- 650REDHAIR 12y agoPeople are having fun and enjoying the game != massive waste of time.
- qrazhan 12y agoI suppose you could say it is a waste, but this entire story essentially started out as a fun side project. It would also "be a waste" to sit at your computer for 12 hours a day playing D3 and flipping items on the Auction House, but that's just the way some people play the game. Do all of your side projects really add that much value to society?
- Paul_S 12y agoWhat I mean is some question whether hedge funds and the like add value to the economy - botting in MMO has the added characteristic of the economy not even being real (I know it involves real money but you know what I mean). I'm all up for reading books, playing games, watching films etc.. I question the need for high frequency trading in those leisure pursuits ;)
- hellodevnull 12y agoMaking millions on the stock market could be seen as a waste of time to somebody who's more interested in doing well on the Second Life game or whatever. If you look at things in terms of making money and contributing to the 'real world' then almost every hobby is a waste of time. I mean, does it really matter if it's real life or not? Money might be completely unimportant to somebody... if they already make enough from their day job they're free to do whatever's fun for them in their spare time.
- ivanca 12y agoActually, some parts of the economy are pretty much the same, do you know that people create fake scarcity all the time? Colanta, one of the big milk companies in the world actually throws tons of milk when it suits them, why? to avoid lowering the price of milk thanks to too much offer. And Market Manipulation is a very common practice in all industries, and even if it's illegal in most parts that's not enought to stop them, you can throw away a bunch of milk and say it was spoiled, who is going to say or proof otherwise? The exact same thing happens with value; value is created itself by offer and demand, you can say that mining gold doesn't create any value for society, or you can say that it does, it completely depends on your definition of "value for society". Some may say that finding golp helps thousands of jewelries and jewelry makers, that it brings money in to multinational companies and so forth. But at the end of the day you could say the same about this kind of bots, you are moving money from people that have resources to spend on digital goods transfer to third world countries like Bulgaria. That it also helps to the entertainment, where a lot of trades happens all the time giving entropy to the ecosystem.
- Paul_S 12y agoI know it's awfully arbitrary. I make terrible analogies but indulge me. I ask you to dig a hole and pay you 10$. I then pay you 10$ (or better still you pay me) to fill the whole. Was 20$ dollars worth of value created? Company makes MMO that is only fun if you grind to level 60. Guy pays third world country citizen to play the game for him until he reaches level 60. You claim that is a good thing because it gave a job to someone in the third world. I put it to you that is madness akin to digging and filling holes over and over. The company could sell you a level 60 character at no cost to them (changing a few bits on a server) and give the money to the third world citizen in aid (obviously not going to happen) and nothing would change except he could do something productive rather than slave away at a PC 12 hours a day (like we do).
- id 12y agoHe also seems to get very much joy out of people accidentally losing money to him. It's like those ebay sellers who sell empty packaging.
- frinxor 12y agoThats a terrible analogy. Ebay sellers are scamming. Hes taking advantages of mispriced items and arbitrage opportunities of others' ignorances. The real currency -> gold mistake is, granted, crushing for the seller making the mistake, but part of the game.
- ssully 12y agoThere are also people who just don't care enough to put in the time to sell items for their real value. I never sold much on the RMA, but when I sold stuff on the GAH I would eyeball the item and just throw a price on it that I think would get it to sell fast, but still get me decent gold. I didn't play Diablo to make money, I was there to have fun.
- duskwuff 12y agoThe author seemed pretty convinced that many of the prices he was spotting were probably supposed to be real-money prices -- e.g, an item that was supposed to sell for $100 would instead be sold for 100 gold. (Which is a trivial amount, even in game.)
- chii 12y agothis happens more often than you think in games that have two systems that can be confused with each other. EVE online is a good example (except instead of real currency, it's just mis-typed zeros and bad UI queues)
- Cthulhu_ 12y agoIt's more like ebay sellers accidentally mistyping their initial price / buyout value and still be required to send their item for that price. Actually that happens from time to time in for example webshops, accidentally listing items for $1 instead of $300.
- bussiere 12y agoexcept that he lives in bulgaria and he gives the average wage price 250/350 euros per month. That's add a little flavor on the whole thing for me :)
- fintechthrowaw 12y ago"And I thought hedge fund managers were not adding value to society"... Its always weird to me when people in the tech industry say that hedge fund managers/quants "add no value to society". The presumption that any individual's job "adds value to society" is really arrogant...do you really think that all the software engineers working at Google or FB or Twitter to make people click advertisement "add value to society"? Does my local grocer "add value to society"? Its such a vacuous statement. I apologize in advance if this is harsh, so I would offer you to read more about finance before you make blanket statements like "hedge funds do not add value to society"
- TheEzEzz 12y agoWorse case scenario: making people click google ads is just as mindlessly financially driven as eking out more alpha from an algo, in which case the googlers still win, because at least some of that money generated goes toward moonshot projects that may very well benefit society.
- fintechthrowaw 12y agoI respect Google, Facebook, and Twitter because of their ability to connect people and their genuine intellectual contributions to fields like information retrieval and AI, and sure, their moonshots. But I think its arrogant to say whether someone adds value to society because its an extremely complicated philosophical question (judging the guy playing the game saying he's wasting his time). I'm not sure its fair to characterize all hedge funds as simply trying to squeeze out alpha though either, there are many prominent activist investors who've pushed for greater corporate governance and transparency, in cases like MBIA, Lehman, Herbalife most recently, etc. And if you wanted to consider Google's moonshots, it should be only fair to consider the billions most of the hedge fund managers have given away in a dick-measuring contest to various charities and research initiatives. But I understand your argument and agree that a lot of financialization provides no benefit to anyone.
- chii 12y agoi think when someone laments that a high-frequency-trader/hedge fund managers don't add value, they really mean that they get an unfair amount of money for little visible work, and little visible benefit to somebody else in the world. I emphasis visible. I do believe that having arbitrage evens out the pricing of long term assets, and having traders do this continuously does indeed make the prices of things reflect reality. That they make a lot of money doing this seems unfair, but the world isn't fair.
- KVFinn 12y agoI've been poking at the open source hearthstone bot. And there's no market in hearthstone so there's no financial reason to running a bot (you can get like colored portraits or something if you win enough games I guess). But the idea of making the best AI for a wildly played competitive card game seems like a lot of fun. I really enjoyed the Google AI challenge one year and seeing if I could hit legendary with a bot would be even better.
- readerrrr 12y agoHow did the bot interact with the game? You could send key commands and text to the program, but you can't easily read the item price for example. That script at the end doesn't tell much.
- cheepin 12y agoYou can screen scrape the screen and do some rudimentary image parsing for OCR.
- Mandatum 12y agoWoW's botters took this one step further, disassembling the game to the point where they made WoW "clients" which could bot/gold farm at <15MB of memory - meaning you could have a hundred accounts botting on one PC.
- virtualSatai 12y agoDo you have any more info/articles/discussions?
- Mandatum 12y agoTrying to find it, it was a news article written as an interview with one of the original WoW Glider creators and his friend who also wrote bots.. Having trouble finding it..
- DownGoat 12y agoHere is a Defcon video about the topic https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hABj_mrP-no https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hABj_mrP-no
- gre 12y agoHere's a Blackhat video with a complete C# WoW client from 2006. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bKbZdlUFAK4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bKbZdlUFAK4 11:55
- sandymcm 12y agoRecommended reading for those interested in this story: REAMDE by Neal Stephenson. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reamde http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reamde
- alanfalcon 12y agoIn that it relates to a virtual world with real currency conversion, I guess. I felt that aspect of Reamde wasn't especially well thought out though still better than any other fiction attempting to cover similar territory.
- fenomas 12y agoI hate to dissent but I wouldn't recommend REAMDE under any circumstances. The first third or so begins lots of interesting threads about virtual worlds, economies and especially ransomware, but the book then morphs into a fairly standard-issue spy thriller, and leaves the most interesting subplots (the ones that don't involve commandos and terrorists shooting at each other) unexplored or unresolved.
- bjelkeman-again 12y agoI actually enjoyed it. Yes there was stuff that could have been explored more, but I still enjoyed it.
- hcarvalhoalves 12y ago100.000,00 €/year trading things that do not exist. Why am I even working?
- perryh2 12y agoDon't worry, the auction house no longer exists. :)
- readerrrr 12y agoItems mentioned in the article exist, even though you cannot touch them. Did you mean to use the term intangible or incorporeal? In that case you can sell insurance. :)
- panzi 12y agoYes, but these items are basically only flags in a DB under the power of Blizzard. It's not real in the sense that Blizzard could just enter whatever values they want in this DB and it would be perfectly legal. Conspiracy theory: Maybe the didn't ban bots that much so they could hide their own "bots" (a simple function in their servers that sells goods they just have created out of thin air by a simple insert statement).
- scrollaway 12y ago> Yes, but these items are basically only flags in a DB under the power of Blizzard. So is insurance.
- thret 12y agoMy biggest gripe with D3 was that the RMAH was not in HC mode. I made endless gold through the AH but sadly it could not be traded for cash.
- alanfalcon 12y agoSure you could, just not legitimately.
- xentronium 12y agoThey explicitly made a policy not to resurrect HC characters even if that happened due to a technical bug, server drop or whatever else. Would get messy with real money items.
- chii 12y agoit would make the game much more exciting - facing actual loss is exhilirating. Some people can't handle it though. In my experience playing EVE online (which exhibit similar characteristics, where you could have paid real money for in-game items, and yet lose them for real), players who can't handle this sort of loss tend to be adversely against the parts of the game that could force such losses. They then end up enjoying the game less over all. Players who bit the bullet and take these losses on the chin tend to have much more fun in the long term, and tend to make better guild mates too.
- thret 12y agoI disagree, I think the pain of losing your main HC character, all of your items and your highest paragon level would feel just as bad regardless of any extra money you'd sunk into it. Is the time and effort that hurts. But that is also the pleasure, the fear of that pain is what makes the game thrilling.
- frinxor 12y agoAwesome article. I remember running a bunch of D2 farm bots in high school, and waking up every morning to put them up on Ebay, ended up making a few hundred bucks - first time I've ever made any money. Really appreciate the writeup; it was very well written and its cool to see the guy figure it out and scale out from his initial experimentation.
- stillsut 12y agoMy (somewhat lonely) contention has always been that these 'waste of time' games are actually the source of many more of the best programmers/quants than after school classes like 'learn to program 101'
- dustingetz 12y agowho are the people putting 100 euro into digital goods in a single transaction?
- swanson 12y agoWould you rather grind for hundreds of hours to maybe get a rare item, or freelance for an hour and spend that $100 on the item you want?
- PhasmaFelis 12y agoI'd rather uninstall that shit and play a game that's fun immediately. Why on Earth would I spend either 100 dollars or 100 hours to be allowed to enjoy a game that I already paid for?
- xentronium 12y agoDiablo is a game about grinding. You finish the first run on lowest difficulty in 10 hours and after that you just have fun on increasing difficulty with better gear.
- gambiting 12y agoI spent easily a 100 hours on D3 before I decided to buy something from RMAH. I had lots of fun with the items I found, and then decided to spend 20-30 euros on some other stuff I wanted to experiment with. I did not do it to make the game fun - it was fun without it. I just wanted to add variety without playing for another 100 hours just to get the items I wanted.
- Djehngo 12y agoBecause the relationship between money and utility is not constant across the human population. If we consider a meal at a moderately fancy resteraunt then there are people without much money who would be aghast at spending that much on a meal. Conversely there are rich people who wouldn't even look at the menu-prices or the bill.
- SheepSlapper 12y agoI made about $65 playing D3, which turned out to be pennies per hour. But it paid for the game, and it made me feel good about wasting so much time. I also just sold a TF2 hat for $56... not sure how I feel about that one. http://i.imgur.com/Loqrvbw.png http://i.imgur.com/Loqrvbw.png
- zongitsrinzler 12y agoI can only guess that top traders in TF2 make the same kind of money as in this article
- chii 12y agohah, that would be quite awesome, if only it was possible to get the money out of steam (which seems not to be possible).
- Cthulhu_ 12y agoNot directly, but I'm sure you can come up with a scheme where you get friends to give you money IRL and you transfer Steam money or gift a game to them.
- ANTSANTS 12y agoTrade items for keys/purchase keys with Steam Wallet funds, sell keys via Paypal for slightly under the "legit" price, ???, profit. (for the uninformed, keys are basically virtual lottery tickets in TF2 and DotA2 whose "legit" price is pegged at $2.50 a pop)
- swanson 12y agoAnd with Blizzard getting a cut of the Real Money Auction House sales, there seems to be little incentive for them to really crack down on this. The perfect "crime"! Blizzard gets some extra revenue, deep pocket players have a constant selection of rare items to buy, botters make a nice chunk of change, semi-oblivious sellers turn their items into gold instantly (reminds me of payday loans) - everyone* wins! * Except the folks who list the RMAH price in gold and, of course, the normal players ;)
- EpicEng 12y agoOf course, the RMAH (and the GAH) are now gone completely, so they did, at some point, decide that it wasn't good for the game.
- chii 12y agoi m sure blizzard's main source of revenue is selling of the game, not from commission earned from the RMAH. RMAH is probably players away, and i m sure their measurments/analytics showed this and thus shut it down.
- Cthulhu_ 12y agoExcept they only did it a long time after introducing the RMAH - they were probably well past their peak income when it came to that income. If I were to make a random guess, I'd say that they made twice or thrice as much revenue from the RMAH than they did with actual game sales, and that's probably being conservative. I don't know why they finally decided to pull the plug, given all that money. Probably trying to salvage some goodwill before figures were leaked about how much they earned from it, although I'm sure those figures are out there already, given that Blizzard is a publicly traded company and their earnings are out in the open.
- jamhan 12y agoHow much of the real money actually came from stolen credit cards? I bet it was a significant percentage.
- listic 12y agoI am interested in game design, but don't have time to really play games, as of late. This write-up illuminated me on what really was going on in Diablo 3 and why Blizzard who supposedly worked hard on the Auction House feature, had to remove it in the end. So, does it mean that maintaining a stable virtual economy in an MMO is an insurmountable task even for a top-tier company?