8 ms·
BuzzFeed Raises $50M from Andreessen Horowitz
- minimaxir 12y agoNote: Original article title is "A Move to Go Beyond Lists for Content at BuzzFeed", which is not particularly explanitory, which is why I changed it in the submission.
- jedberg 12y agoHonest question: How do we as users know when it is ok to editorialize headlines and when it isn't?
- plorkyeran 12y agoDoes it matter? There's no punishment for having the title of your submission changed beyond wasted whatever effort you put into coming up with a new title. If you feel your title is better, submit it and see if the moderators agree.
- jedberg 12y agoThen why do the site's guidelines specifically state "Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait."? I'm fine with the mods changing the titles, but I don't like the fact that the rules don't apply equally to everyone.
- dang 12y agoThe rules apply equally to everyone. The article's title is currently "50 Million New Reasons BuzzFeed Wants to Take Its Content Far Beyond Lists". That's obviously linkbait, so we didn't revert the submitter's title.
- mbesto 12y ago> That's obviously linkbait This is a whole new meta that my brain is really having a hard time grokking.
- dang 12y agoSure, it's a meta ironic reference to Buzzfeed linkbait by the NYT, but the point stands. If I ironically mimic somebody screaming, I'm still screaming.
- jedberg 12y agoThe title wasn't link bait -- it was a journalistic choice by the New York Times author to mock BuzzFeed. Once again, I think you guys made the wrong choice. Once again, I'll point out that if you want to do heavy handed moderation, you need to spend more time understanding why something is the way it is, which means you'll need to spend more time doing it. Once again I'll point out that this is why we didn't do heavy handed moderation at reddit -- it's just too hard to get it right.
- burkaman 12y agoEditorialize is not a synonym for change. Editorializing is never a good idea, changing a headline is fine if you think the new one more accurately describes the content.
- jedberg 12y agoThat may be true, but from the guidelines: "Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait." So now I'm not sure which is ok, because the guidelines clearly state that I am supposed to use the original title. That makes me think that any change would be considered editorializing.
- minimaxir 12y agoThis was an unusual case, that was made more unusual that the headline was changed to make it even MORE confusing. That's why I added the clarification note.
- owenwil 12y agoInteresting, but not particularly surprising. Despite many people's hate for Buzzfeed they are quickly building up a powerful journalism team. I suspect they will be the biggest media/journalism/content powerhouse online within a few years (they technically already are).
- mkal_tsr 12y agoJournalism. Are you sure you understand what that word means and/or implies?
- freshhawk 12y agoIs that a loose use of the word journalism or is there work I don't know about? They definitely have a wildly successful content team but I don't follow buzzfeed closely.
- TruffleLabs 12y agoWatch John Oliver's Last Week Tonight video segment on native advertisement https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=E_F5GxCwizc https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=E_F5GxCwizc (10 min long). There is a bit on BuzzFeed where he points out that many of the posts that are "top" are really from paid advertisers. Saying BuzzFeed is developing a journalism team is probably not the best wording. I would suggest BuzzFeed is building up a great PR, advertising, and marketing engine. They will make money. But is it journalism?
- blumkvist 12y agoThey are developing long form features and op-eds, no?
- potatolicious 12y agoWithout a very thick, tall, barb-wire-topped wall between editorial and sales, BuzzFeed will never be a respectable source for journalism. So longer as they are running ads as content, no amount of long-form writing and New Yorker-esque vocabulary will move them from the "clickbait" side to the "journalism" side.
- danso 12y agoFWIW, here's Chris Dixon's blog post on the subject, which includes additional context on BuzzFeed's technological chops: http://cdixon.org/2014/08/10/buzzfeed/ http://cdixon.org/2014/08/10/buzzfeed/ > BuzzFeed has technology at its core. Its 100+ person tech team has created world-class systems for analytics, advertising, and content management. Engineers are 1st class citizens. Everything is built for mobile devices from the outset. Internet native formats like lists, tweets, pins, animated GIFs, etc. are treated as equals to older formats like photos, videos, and long form essays. BuzzFeed takes the internet and computer science seriously. The last line, about taking "computer science seriously"...maybe BF doesn't have a dev team of the likes of Google and Facebook, but it must certainly be one of the best in the media business. I've looked through their job postings from time to time, and unlike most major media companies, the job descriptions treat engineering/dev positions as the complex, specialized fields that they often are...what I mean is that at a news company, a dev is expected to do many different things...not because the news company really wants a "full stack" developer or will pay the salary for what that entails, but because there are so many legacy technologies to juggle, and since the traditional news company has only so much money to spend on tech...a Java developer could be expected to crank on the CMS and also figure out video delivery solutions for the media company's bespoke legacy system...and maybe also do some front-end design. At BuzzFeed, even though it seems the organization is relatively flat, with not many layers/walls between tech and editorial, when they want a MySQL developer, they just want someone who can do some serious administration and performance hacking...not a MySQL dev who also might also be expected to hack on some animal quiz code. I think besides the quality of their CMS (which is pretty damn good, no matter what you think of the editorial content)...one of their most impressive feats was rebuilding the entire site, basically from scratch, during the week that Hurricane Sandy flooded their servers in lower Manhattan. In fact, I believe Gawker had their servers in the same area, but was reduced to creating a Tumblr and posting to it for some time after the hurricane. edit: Also, another thing I admire: despite their technological chops, they tend to be fairly conservative about how they push the constraints of the web. Their lists are simply lists that work in any browser, any device...because text and static images work perfectly fine in conveying a message. Even their gigantic longform stories don't do crazy shit...for being a "gimmicky" tabloidesque site, BuzzFeed seems to have great confidence in the power of plaintext and big photos...compare this to major news organizations trying to parallax-scroll everything for every occasion.
- jseifer 12y agoYou won't believe what happened next.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- JonFish85 12y agoOne weird trick...
- JonLim 12y agoThe part that caught my eye is that Ze Frank is working there, and is leading the Motion Pictures division. That's... incredible. I'm looking forward to what they produce, video-wise, simply because Ze Frank is there to shepherd their efforts.
- oh_sigh 12y agoGreat word selection there. shepherd: "A person who herds sheep"
- mkal_tsr 12y agoI want to support Ze but not Buzzfeed, this is causing conflicting emotions for me :-(
- walterbell 12y agoHow many "quality journalism" articles or content pieces must an outlet produce per month, and to what level of traffic exposure must they promote those quality articles, in order to recruit more talent like Ze?
- mkal_tsr 12y agoI don't think it comes down to "quality journalism" it's all about money. That's what online "journalism" is ... ad revenue from clickbait titles. I have yet to see anything of high quality investigative journalism from Buzzfeed/ViralNova/Upworthy/etc. They're click-bait farms and they provide no real "journalism" value.
- hodgesmr 12y ago> "Most of BuzzFeed’s revenue is derived from BuzzFeed Creative, the company’s 75-person unit dedicated to creating [ads that pretend to be news stories]" Maybe BuzzFeed has cracked the code for online "journalism" being profitable. But if this is the method, I feel bad for consumers.
- JonFish85 12y agoYou mean like the New York Times' "Sponsored Content"?
- mambodog 12y ago[ads that pretend to be news stories] John Oliver recently commented on this stuff (so called "Native Advertising") on Last Week Tonight: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E_F5GxCwizc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E_F5GxCwizc
- logn 12y agoI don't see any reason to feel bad for consumers. Journalism couldn't get much worse than it already was. At least native advertising is still more explicit than, say, defense contractor GE beating the war drum via NBC/MSNBC. Or companies buying ad slots on major news networks as insurance against negative reporting on them.
- bellerocky 12y ago> Journalism couldn't get much worse than it already was. This is such a poor attitude that totally flies in the face of history and the situation for journalists in other places in the world, like Mexico, where hundreds of reporters have been executed in the last few years. Journalism as a profession is just fine, monetizing it might not be.
- logn 12y agoCorrection: Journalism in the US In the US, the profession is not fine. The major news outlets regularly bury stories the administration finds objectionable (e.g., NY Times on the Bush surveillance). They reiterate propaganda talking points (e.g., NY Times not using the word "torture" until this week). And they generally support the overall goals of each administration (majority of Americans believed Saddam Hussein was responsible for 9/11). Washington reporters are all too happy to be part of the insiders network and scorn people who aren't (such as Glenn Greenwald).
- staunch 12y agoQuality wins in the long run and BuzzFeed is not focused on quality. Their company should be called Linkbait, Inc. They're the problem, not the solution. I'd bet against this if I could.
- freshhawk 12y agoIf I believed quality won in the long run I would too, but I think this is a smart investment.
- pkfrank 12y agoI think that BuzzFeed's quality will drastically improve in time. To me, they're building a platform for journalism/media. They might be in the nascent stage where LinkBait is a dominant strategy, but I'd bet that high-quality journalism will become an increasingly integral part of BuzzFeed's business as it matures.
- afafsd 12y agoWhy should they succeed at making money by putting out high-quality journalism where others have failed? Quality journalism doesn't pay in a dollars in to dollars out basis. A carefully-researched article that takes a week-long trip to the Congo to write will get no more and possibly fewer clicks than "Ten Amazing Shark Facts That Will Make You Shit Your Pants" that takes twenty minutes on wikipedia.
- pkfrank 12y agoWell, perhaps the linkbait articles that you describe will help offset the cost of eventually producing high-quality journalism.
- freshhawk 12y agoThat's an optimistic view, especially as they are moving swiftly in the opposite direction with their "native advertising" push. That's why they are an attractive investment, and that is anti-journalism.
- underwater 12y agoBuzzFeed are the Zynga of journalism. Great at getting you in, but lacking in substance. When their current social network-driven linkbait approach starts to fail I don't see how they can differentiate themselves from other news sites. Zynga tried to turn themselves onto a destination and failed miserably.
- walterbell 12y agoIs there anything to learn from Demand Media's trajectory? They wrote search-engine-bait rather than social-network-bait, but didn't bother to create cover traffic / quality journalism.
- jhonovich 12y agoQuantcast, based on direct numbers from Buzzfeed, shows Buzzfeed's traffic essentially flat this year - https://www.quantcast.com/buzzfeed.com https://www.quantcast.com/buzzfeed.com Is this a concern? What is the future growth potential?
- lingben 12y agothis is not 1999, "eyeballs", I mean, "traffic" growth means little when you are able to monetize the traffic you have and grow that (even if your traffic isn't growing)
- trevmckendrick 12y agoI want to believe BuzzFeed has found the future of sustainable and profitable news. I get how being a full-stack tech news startup can do things like create great lists/linkbait. But I don't understand how the tech gets you profitable journalism and news.
- dragonwriter 12y agoJournalism and news have less connection to profit than linkbait does.
- trevmckendrick 12y agoI wasn't trying to be incredulous... genuinely looking for understanding in to how they get an advantage in journalism with modern tech!
- aligajani 12y agoBuzzfeed should pay a load of that to "Reddit"
- milge 12y agoInvesting in plagiarism sounds like a good idea. /s I'm currently looking for funding for a new startup. It's premise is based off of the ctrl+c and ctrl+v keyboard shortcuts.
- mkal_tsr 12y agoAs a result, any company invested in by Andreessen Horowitz is now of lesser value, lower integrity, and less worth of promotion in my opinion. We can talk and discuss and debate "free market" and monetizing content and whatever other rationalization you have for this investment, but in the end, BuzzFeed is not real journalism and does not conduct itself ethically (looking at you, BuzzFeed writers taking content from Reddit and only sometimes giving credit), and as a result, I think that's a message AH is sending, "integrity, ethics, and quality is not important, just $$$" Edit: once again, anything that goes against the grain of the HN-hivemind is being downvoted without explanation :-) For a site that prides itself in not being Reddit, HN sure acts like Reddit wrt downvotes.
- aaronbrethorst 12y agoA16Z also invested in PandoDaily: http://www.crunchbase.com/organization/pandodaily http://www.crunchbase.com/organization/pandodaily
- mkal_tsr 12y agoThanks! I'm going to add that site to my blacklist of sites not to visit. I'm serious on that. I can't vote investments out of office, but I can stop using sites/services and stop promoting them when they take investments from VCs/investors with questionable ethical investments. I'm sure it's a (somewhat) financially sound investment, but that doesn't mean I will go along with it as a consumer or (bootstrapped) startup founder. Honesty and integrity have become null and void in Silicon Valley and I'm completely fed up with the bullshit. Cut the crap already, ya know? It's the same beef I have with the founders that try to save face when a similar product or service comes out. I know they're frustrated/upset/disappointed, but the whole, "oh, they're a good service too, btw our product..." crap that I've seen on HN lately. I'm well aware that my idealism does not make perfect business sense, but business is not the end all be all of life, and I'm completely over Silicon Valley propping up bullshit to market bullshit with more bullshit on top. One of these days there will be a VC firm that only invests in transparent and ethically-sound businesses, and I will be doing whatever I can to give my money to those start-ups.
- 12y ago
- AVTizzle 12y agoAn interesting thing I think nobody seems to be talking about with this deal is the marriage between media platforms and venture capital [1] There are big incentives for investors to take part in media plays. Look at some recent patterns: - PandoDaily backed by Peter Theil, Tony Hseih, SV Angel Lerer Ventures, etc… - BusinessInsider backed by Bezos, Marc Andreeson, RRE, and more (to the tune of $30M+!) - Washington Post owned by Bezos - BuzzFeed itself was co-founded by Kenneth Lerer of Lerer Ventures (same team behind HuffPo) Even if there are firewalls and a commitment to journalistic autonomy/integrity, when you invested in a media company, your interests align with theirs from the very top. [1] http://crewlab.net/buzzfeed http://crewlab.net/buzzfeed
- adamnemecek 12y agoReminds me of The Onion's spoof of Buzzfeed called Clickhole http://www.clickhole.com/ http://www.clickhole.com/
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Kiro 12y agoSo I went to buzzfeed.com and was expecting misleading headlines. Instead I was met with "23 Adorable Quokkas That Will Instantly Make Your Day Better", clicked the link and saw 23 pictures of Quokkas. Most of the stuff on the site seems to be these kind of lists, which I honestly have nothing against. They are linkbaits, sure, but not misleading and I'm seldom disappointed after clicking one. I don't see BuzzFeed claiming to be The Economist or about high quality journalism at all. They seem to focus on serving articles that are easy to digest and sometimes that's exactly what I want.
- sytelus 12y agoIn one of the experiments, there were two groups: One was asked to write a original creative essay and other was asked to use a template created by an expert and just fill it out. One of such popular template comes in the form of "X number of reason why Y is not true". Although these bullet points doesn't seem such a "creative" content, in the experiment these kind of template-based approach won hands down VS asking people to come up with something original. Why? Because most people suck at being original and creative. It requires years of experience + some level of genius gene and avoiding pitfalls and keeping delicate balance to be original. So if you can't hire 75 Oscar Wilds, then your best bet to create the popular content is follow the templates. BuzzFeed's model is simple. You can hire pretty much average Joes who can be assigned some interesting topic everyday like "Cheap Private Islands". These Joes will then do research on Internet for few hours and fill out the template with what they found: "25 Amazing Private Islands That You Can Rent Now". Is this click worthy? Absolutely. I think people who frown upon this don't get "entertainment industry". When you want a TV series or a movie, the goal is not to educate you but entertain you. To provide you some amusement and excitement in your day - however short living that may be. If you click on BuzzFeed's link and if you found it did provided you amusement, they did your job and in return you gave them some CPI. This is no different than watching a soap opera. In other words, Internet is replacing TV as the source of entertainment and BuzzFeed is now a core provider of content in this arena.
- ehurrell 12y agoThis is interesting, especially in the context of this interview Andreesen did in Stanford Graduate Business School: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JYYsXzt1VDc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JYYsXzt1VDc where he talks about consuming news and how current news is ripe for disruption because it exists on a fragile framework of selling "objectivity", and he seems genuinely interested in how this can be changed. Buzzfeed has the audience, but maybe only a tangential focus on what we are used to as 'news', I wonder if this is the result of that thinking, ('what we know as news is changing') or something completely different.
- thathonkey 12y agoThe most puzzling part about this article is that apparently BuzzFeed has an editor-in-chief.
- zxcvvcxz 12y agoRelevant: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E_F5GxCwizc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E_F5GxCwizc
- alberth 12y agoMarc Andreessen, in March of this year, explains his perspective on journalism & BuzzFeed in the video below at 41:00 minute mark. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JYYsXzt1VDc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JYYsXzt1VDc He covers topics like: - why objective journalism started due to monopolies - technology in journalism - content creation This video should answer most of the questions in this thread as to why he'd make an investment. Edit: formatting
- jgalt212 12y agoWhen will advertisers understand that linkbait/clickbait is more effective at attracting bots than humans? Or do they already realize this? Does anyone have any metrics on where Buzzfeeds CPMs trade versus other news sites/blogs?