4 ms·
Are there any (new) technical info on this? I recall it's been discussed here before[hn] -- and as then -- I don't really see what's wrong with anonymous remail
by e12e 12y ago
Are there any (new) technical info on this? I recall it's been discussed here before[hn] -- and as then -- I don't really see what's wrong with anonymous remailers (the old kind). I suppose DKIM and DNSSEC might form the foundation for additional standards to augment mixmaster remailers: DKIM should allow for rudimentary SPAM filtering on the "in" side of the remailer network/onion -- and DNSSEC might be one way to at least get "any" domains "remailer" public key (so that you could send eg all gmail mail to eg: reamailer@gmail.com, with the actual mail wrapped inside) -- and "any" standard mail client could wrap up mail like that (as a minimum, optionally with an additional remailer added).
I don't know how big the need for is DKIM (from an anti-spam view) -- how many receive gpg-encrypted and signed spam anyway?
As I've mentioned before, I think this has similar problems as remailers -- as far back as 1996 intelligence agencies were running quite a few of them[1] -- and I imagine that would be the case going forward as well (ditto for tor nodes). I don't think that makes these things a wasted effort, just not a silver bullet.
Either way, having eg Apple Mail, Thunderbird and Gmail (yes, the webmail) automatically wrap any outgoing mail in a remailer-like envelope might not be a bad idea at all. And once wrapped, everything smtp (with the exception of content-based spam filtering at the intermediary servers) works just like it always has.
[1] http://www.hypertekst.net/misc/anon-remail/ http://www.hypertekst.net/misc/anon-remail/
[hn]
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6642106 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6642106
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6671219 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6671219
- mike_hearn 12y ago> I don't know how big the need for is DKIM (from an anti-spam view) -- how many receive gpg-encrypted and signed spam anyway? Modern spam filters (at sites like Gmail) rely very heavily indeed on the notion of reputation. Without something like DKIM it's hard to calculate accurate reputations: you can do it but it relies on lots of hacks and heuristics. So reputation mechanisms of some form are pretty vital.
- e12e 12y agoMy point was that spammers typically wouldn't gpg encrypt mail to the recipient, even if just through a generic mixmaster wrapper service (the service could filter on content and dkim as normal on the incomming side). So if setting up such a network, i don't know if dkim would be useful on the "inside" and/or for opaque/encrypted-to-recipient messages. I suppose one could simply recommend smtp servers to clear-sign any trusted (originating at smtp servers domain) mail and stash server gpg keys in dns...