11 ms·
Judge rejects $324.5M settlement over Apple, Google hiring
- erobbins 12y agoGood. the decimal point needs to move (right) before this settlement can even remotely be considered fair.
- troydavis 12y agoAs an employer, I'd like to see it move right by two places. I'm not optimistic though.
- peterb 12y agoAgreed. Even 3 decimal places wouldn't do justice to what they have done to us. Fuck those greedy bastards. If we were smart we would unionize ... err, sorry, I mean form a professional association to represent our interests. Like doctors, lawyers, accountants, etc.
- lifeformed 12y ago$300 billion dollars isn't enough?
- 8154730 12y agoSo you think $324 billion dollars is appropriate? Wouldn't that essentially bankrupt all the companies involved? Who needs to worry about jobs when some of the biggest tech firms on the planet are wiped out! Not to mention that $324 billion spread across 64000 plaintiffs is $5 million each... You wouldn't be looking for that easy windfall, now would you?
- maxerickson 12y agoApple has ~$160 billion in cash reserves. Google has ~$35 billion. I'm not presenting that as an argument about the reasonableness of $300 billion, but it would likely not bankrupt them.
- gress 12y agoHow would an amount that is greater than the cash of the two combined companies not bankrupt them?
- Retric 12y agoIt need not be instantly due and there cash flow positive. 15b each per year and there done in 10 years and still profitable. Also, free cash is hardly their only capital. Google could for example sell YouTube. They could also sell bonds or stock etc. PS: Not that I think 300B is the right penalty, but there needs to be some real risks to prevent such behaviors or the penalties simply become yet another cost of doing business.
- gress 12y agoTrue but it seems hard to argue that the amount can reasonably be more than all of the cash on hand, since the companies wouldn't have been able to pay the employees anything like that amount, so it can't reflect the market value of the lost salaries.
- Retric 12y agoIt's common for lawsuits to be for damages * X where X is a distinctive. IMO 10B is about the limit for any kind of reasonable penalty though.
- revelation 12y agoYou go directly from "tech firms wiped out apocalypse" to "64000 plaintiffs [..] $5 million each" and don't notice the disconnect? Frankly, that needs to happen, and not only when theres cause. We need a Netflix chaos monkey that breaks up big companies and redistributes their wealth to let creative destruction create something better.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- 8154730 12y agoMy post is more about the hypocrisy OS peterb stating "fuck those greedy bastards" while also implying that every plaintiff should get $5 million.
- fleitz 12y agoThe only real effect of bankruptcy would be that guys like Page and Brin would be worth $13 billion instead of $26. Assuming that it would actually bankrupt them, how does bankruptcy cost jobs? The cash goes to employees who will likely spend / re-invest in the startup economy, this will likely create more jobs as there are economies of scale in software companies. The capital remains and would be sold to a new owner... since these companies are profitable the jobs remain and the company just has a lower bank account with new owners. If you had the opportunity to buy Google/Apple/Adobe for 50 cents on the dollar, why would you fire everyone? It makes no sense, they are all extremely profitable companies.
- LordKano 12y agoIf I go with your figure of 64,000 * 5,000,000, it's not the tech-apocalypse. It's not like that money is going straight into a crack pipe. People with a lot of technical know-how would suddenly be set loose in a cash rich environment full of new millionaires who are looking to build their own empires. That scenario could very well be a second dotcom boom. More to the point, when one of the little people gets caught breaking the law, we don't question the consequences their punishment will have on any industry. These companies not only broke the law but were terrible corporate citizens. Anything that doesn't hurt a lot will not be an appropriate punishment, it'll just be considered the cost of doing business.
- alexqgb 12y agoThe effect of this scenario on the high end real estate market in the Bay Area would horrifying / amazing depending on whether or not you were already holding property. Also, Tesla sales would go sub-orbital.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 12y ago"Wouldn't that essentially bankrupt all the companies involved?" Don'd do the crime if you can't do the time, etc.
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> Wouldn't that essentially bankrupt all the companies involved? The sensible thing to do in these types of circumstances is to pay the settlement using newly issued shares in the company. That dilutes the interest of all the existing shareholders (effectively the money comes out of their pockets because the price per share goes down) but it causes no damage to the company's operations.
- peterb 12y agoYes, plus the executives involved should be personally punished through financial loss and imprisonment.
- johnnydogma 12y agoWhy has no one mentioned jail time for breaking the law and potentially damaging people's lives and livelihood? Why do we always think money is the solution. Jobs is burning in Hell, so no hope there, but anyone else this can be attributed to should do time, not pay their body servants salary and laugh at how the poor struggle to eat.
- maxxxxx 12y agoI think after 2008 it's pretty clear that executives personally don't have to fear any consequences from wrongdoing. Either someone way down the chain of command goes to jail or the shareholders pay for a settlement.
- Consultant32452 12y agoIt would be interesting to see an analysis of what the economic impact of these depressed wages has been. $3 Billion is probably not too far off the mark. Probably not $3 Billion directly to the programmers impacted, but definitely to the broader economy.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Zigurd 12y agoAcross the industry, the number of employees affected is easily in the high hundreds of thousands, at a direct cost to them of tens of thousands of dollars per year. So billions to maybe low tens of billions is not an unreasonable range. And would that get trebled under California employment law?
- alexqgb 12y agoAs of April, Apple had cash reserves of about $160 billion. Just saying.
- gress 12y agoJust saying what? If you fine Apple $160B, then you have to fine Google a similar amount, since they are co-conspirators.
- alexqgb 12y agoWhat I'm saying is that the amounts of cash held by - and available to - these companies is so eye-poppingly astronomic that even an twelve digit settlement - which the law may allow - is nowhere near enough to bankrupt them.
- jasonlotito 12y agoThis, right here, at multiple levels. A company paying market rates have benefited from this collusion. Any company still paying market rates after this is knowingly taking advantage of this illegal behavior.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- justina1 12y agoI hope the perception leans more towards 'uber rich tech execs conspired to pay their employees less' and not 'some of the best paid employees complain about how little they make'.
- mcfunley 12y agoThere are plenty of reasons to be angry, why pick just one?
- Eduardo3rd 12y agoI think that's pretty unlikely. The tech industry has done a poor job of endearing itself to the rest of the economy over the past few years. My non-tech friends have been through the struggle of finding jobs in general throughout the recession. Few of them are going to shed a tear for engineers making less than fair market wages who already pull down six figures in their early twenties. Someone I know in SF posted a picture today of their new Audi with a caption about how they were finally a real adult now that they owned one. I think that's pretty disconnected from reality, and sadly I think it is somewhat typical of the mindset that a lot of engineers have in this industry.
- colechristensen 12y agoReality isn't real only if you're poor (and many of the poor in America live like kings compared to the poor in other parts of the world or in the recent past). There are a large number of fuzzy groups of people in the world whom have little concept of how it is to live in any group significantly distant from their own.
- fleitz 12y agoYep, it's poverty morality, as soon as you make 50 cents an hour more than the next guy you're rich, and have no right to complain about anything. Even when I was making $15 an hour answering phones, I'd hear no end about how the bus drivers on strike shouldn't get paid $20 an hour. Yet no one wanted to quit their job and become a bus driver.
- justina1 12y agoI'm curious if this will have any impact on the practice other than companies getting better at not leaving a paper trail. If it doesn't, the only people this settlement will help is those at the named companies and not the trickle down effect it's had on the rest of the industry.
- bjt 12y agoA case like this leaves institutional scar tissue. There will be new sections in HR policy manuals and training programs. Executives will be gun-shy about any conversations that even come close to those at the heart of this lawsuit. There will definitely be an effect. For a while. As time passes and this case fades from memory I expect such collusion to eventually happen again.
- fleitz 12y agoThat's the nature of all crime. Unless you're an idiot you either stop doing it, or get better at it. That's why when you commit a crime they send you to criminal school, so you can swap notes about all the other ways guys got caught.
- mcfunley 12y agoTheir collusion depressed the price of engineers generally. I spent a lot of the years in question ignoring recruiting emails from those companies, and this affected the amount my employer needed to pay me to do that. We should dig up the corpse of Steve Jobs and tar and feather it.
- esturk 12y agoWhile I don't think we should desecrate the dead, Eric Schmidt is live and well.
- stanmancan 12y agoThat last sentence right there is one of the few times I really wish I was able to down vote. I valued your opinion until you felt the need to include that.
- iancarroll 12y agoYou'll get it at around 600 karma, if you didn't already know.
- stanmancan 12y agoI wasn't aware so thanks for the heads up!
- LordKano 12y agoRather than taking that route, I think we should be asking if his estate is liable for damages because of his illegal actions.
- mrbird 12y agoDoes anyone know how many people are likely to actually be paid out as part of the class?
- gopher1 12y agoThere are 64,000 plaintiffs. Source: http://techcrunch.com/2014/08/08/judge-rejects-comically-low-324-5m-settlement-to-tech-workers-who-were-cheated-out-of-fair-wages/ http://techcrunch.com/2014/08/08/judge-rejects-comically-low...
- pkaye 12y agoGood thing it is no 65536 plaintiffs or the 16-bit counter will overflow!
- x1798DE 12y agoUntil someone uses a signed int16 in the payment calculation and all of a sudden everyone owes nearly twice as much as they were going to get.
- yonran 12y agoBy the way, Judge Lucy Koh estimated that fees would be $82885000, so each of the 64466 class members would have received $3750, not quite the “essentially zero” that Alex at TechCrunch claims in the article you link. Source: Judge Koh’s order http://www.scribd.com/doc/236255928/Apple-Google-Intel-Adobe-Wage-Fixing-Settlement-Denied http://www.scribd.com/doc/236255928/Apple-Google-Intel-Adobe...
- nostrademons 12y ago$3750 is about a week's pay for a tech worker, so essentially zero. Salaries jumped by about $30K/year when the pact collapsed, so the commenters above who are calling for the decimal point to shift a place to the right aren't all that unreasonable.
- cognivore 12y ago"The ruling by U.S. District Judge Lucy Koh in San Jose, California, said the proposed settlement amount "falls below the range of reasonableness," before dashing back to her new two million dollar home to pack for her European vacation.
- numlocked 12y agoIt's strange that even the NYT got this wrong -- the bulk of the agreement was not in fact about poaching engineers, but rather sales and product people[0]. [0] http://www.businessinsider.com/emails-eric-schmidt-sergey-brin-hiring-apple-2014-3 http://www.businessinsider.com/emails-eric-schmidt-sergey-br...
- spoondan 12y agothe bulk of the agreement was not in fact about poaching engineers, but rather sales and product people Do you have a better citation for this claim? The linked Business Insider article does not claim such a thing, and the court filings the article cites do not support the claim. The article cites Google's Special Agreement Hiring Policy that divides companies into three categories: Restricted Hiring, Do Not Call, and Sensitive. Only the protocol with respect to Restricted Hiring companies is constrained to Sales, Product, and G&A. Google's protocol for the Do Not Call companies seems to prohibit actively recruiting any employee at those companies. The article does not address whether other companies limited the scope of collusion to, "sales and product people."
- davidf18 12y agoThis collusion depressed the price of engineering talent but so does H1B Visas. Need to work on the current battle as well...
- piyush_soni 12y ago... Or get ready to compete a little? ;) Like getting to a level which justifies your high price and differentiates you from that cheap labor from Asia?
- jahewson 12y agoNational collusion against talented individuals born by chance within the boundaries of another administrative area seems more like an entrenched privilege than a worthy "battle", especially given how much of US companies' revenue comes from outside the US.
- MangezBien 12y agoIs there any recourse for the engineers who weren't directly affected by the collusion but were affected by the indirect effect on the market as a whole?
- suprgeek 12y agoI had two concerns when this was made public: that this was a laughably low amount considering the scope of the collusion and the time-scale over which it happened. that it looks like a good deal to all the companies concerned on two fronts - 325 Million is a pittance compared to what Apple, Google or Adobe make in a month. and the perception of the non-tech folks that this is about the rich whining about not getting caviar rather than a real issue. At least the first one is being addressed (somewhat). I hope the final settlement really makes them hurt financially so that it becomes one more item in the HR manual - "thou shalt not enter into illegal no-hire agreements even when pressured by an asshole" . For the second issue there needs to be some effort put in towards communicating with the non-programmer public and educating them about why shit like this is a VERY bad idea no matter who does it or who is impacted.
- oblio 12y agoDon't get your facts mixed up. 325 million is quite close to what Adobe makes per month. Google and Apple are 10x-20x50x bigger.
- adevine 12y agoThe fact that this settlement was rejected by the judge should be an embarrassment for the plaintiffs' lawyers, and IMO is a great example of the problems with the incentives in class action settlements. Basically, the judge is saying there is substantial evidence that the plaintiffs would win considerably more if the case went to trial. From the lawyers' perspective though, if they settle they get a sure thing, and, importantly, they don't have to do any more work. So in other words, if this settlement had been approved, the employees would have gotten a raw deal, while their attorneys would have gotten tens of millions for poor work on a pretty clear cut case.
- aceperry 12y agoThe plaintiffs have those companies "dead to rights."
- aceperry 12y agoThe plaintiffs have those companies "dead to rights."
- bkeroack 12y agoThe otherwise amazing book by Ben Horowitz (of Andreessen-Horowitz fame) called The Hard Thing About Hard Things has a chapter that basically lays out and encourages this type of illegal behavior (called "Is It Okay to Hire People from Your Friend's Company?"). It literally recommends that companies maintain a "do not hire" (aka "do not poach") list of other organizations from which HR is forbidden from recruiting. It also recommends calling the CEO of the other company on the down-low to ask permission before extending an offer. It really disgusted me when I read it. Such smart people doing such dumb things, and encouraging would-be CEOs to do the same.
- balls187 12y agoSeems taken out of context. Do not hire is different than do not poach. The wisdom I subscribe to is, if you have common investors, it's bad form to actively poach from portfolio companies. For companies that are later stage, it's bad form to poach key employee's from portfolio companies. Do Not Hire agreements between companies, however, seem unreasonable, except when there is clear cause for conflict of interest.
- bkeroack 12y agoThere is a difference between active poaching and simply getting a resume (or some other expression of interest) from somebody for an open position. a) If you get sent a resume in response to an open req and you reject them based solely on the current employer of the applicant being a "friendly company" ("do not hire" list), that is illegal and wrong. b) If you realize the applicant is from a "friendly company" and so you make a subtle threat along the lines of: "We are going to call your current employer to get a reference check before we decide to extend any offer, are you sure that's ok with you?" (also recommended in Horowitz's book), it's also wrong and unfair. I'm not a lawyer so I don't know if that is overtly illegal however.
- tptacek 12y agoIt is lawful to maintain a "do-not-hire" list of companies from which you disqualify candidates. It is possibly even lawful to do that with the intent of avoiding poaching and ill will. What's definitely not lawful is to conspire with the companies on that list to determine its makeup.
- olefoo 12y ago"Those who do not remember history are doomed to repeat it." -Santayana This is yet another iteration of American labor politics. That it involves workers with greater skills than in previous iterations is not germane. The reason that labor unions arose in the first place was that capitalists actively exploited workers. And, guess what? Capitalists still exploit workers, even when the workers tools are laptops and VMs rather than steam engines and Bessemer converters. How easily we forget that our grandfathers fought and died for the forty-hour work week. How easily we give that up, because we're working for "disruptive startups". If you want to know what previous iterations of no-hire agreements looked like; see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blacklist_(employment) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blacklist_(employment)
- dmix 12y agoThis is the market reacting to malicious behaviour by large organizations. As far as I can tell, in this situation it seems to be working. The court system nor the market isn't putting up with their shit. I'd much prefer courts handle this than solving the problem by creating a second problem. Which in your example, the unions themselves eventually become too powerful or negatively effecting the job market and upward mobility of smaller players. We would see benefits in the early days then eventually reach by a stasis where everything starts moving extremely slowly and consumed by bureaucratic process. Then only those embedded within the union system benefit, while competing global markets without constraints operate more efficiently. While smaller players in the job market start hiring less due to the high bar needed to hire union workers. I've witnessed this first hand as an electrician in my family ran a successful business, until the workers organized into a union and he had to shut it down because their demands made it completely unprofitable (they demanded expensive benefits programs and high wages, keep in mind we live in Canada with public healthcare). The workers lost their jobs and most ended up working for another much larger company. Unions create bigger companies and bigger unions.
- x0x0 12y agoThe court system isn't putting up with it? You must have a liberal definition of punishment, if you expect $300mm to change behavior. If you add a zero it may have an actual impact, but at $300mm it's possible the companies net saved money. edit: for a (very rough) estimate of how much money google saved, remember that in late 10 they gave their entire staff a 10% raise, effective 1 Jan 11. So if you look at their 2011 10k [2], a very rough underestimate of their comp expenses -- looking at R&D alone -- is $5,162 (numbers in millions). So if 1.1x = 5162, then x = 4692 and that 10% raise cost google $470m. A fine less than the savings of one year of your illicit behavior -- and for just one company! -- discourages behavior exactly how? [1] http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424052748703523604575605273596157634 http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB1000142405274870352360... [2] http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1288776/000119312512025336/d260164d10k.htm http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1288776/0001193125120...
- dreamdu5t 12y agoThere's nothing wrong with "collusion." Collusion is nothing more than free association. Same with "poaching" for that matter. There's nothing wrong with two people agreeing to work for each other. People should be free to negotiate their own agreements. The arguments for criminalizing such free association are based in sentiment not reason.
- asdfologist 12y agoCollusion leads to artificially suppressed wages, which makes the labor market inefficient, to the detriment of the employees. In general, completely unregulated free markets lead to monopolies and price manipulation, among other problems. So no, collusion is wrong.
- dreamdu5t 12y agoWhat's artificial about wages or prices determined through agreement (the market)? What constitutes an agreement's artificiality?
- asdfologist 12y agoConsider the extreme scenario where all companies collude, sending wages to near zero. Would you still call this "agreement"?
- jessaustin 12y agoI don't agree with GP's argument, but presumably in such a hypothetical new entrants to the market could get the best engineers by paying slightly more than the collusion wage. This phenomenon would tend to raise wages, but we shouldn't imagine that it would raise them back to a "fair" level.
- dreamdu5t 12y agoSure, let's consider it. Let's say all companies form an agreement to not hire from any other company. They're now in a situation where either they must terminate the agreement in order to hire, or bid against other companies for labor that is not currently working for any of the firms. Companies bidding over labor drives wages upwards... not downwards.
- chaostheory 12y agoI know this is illegal but I wonder whether any, most, or even all of the plaintiffs will be blackballed from most large companies in the future? Yes it's wrong, but in practice it's both easy to do and get away with it.
- yutah 12y ago'To match the earlier settlement, the latest deal "would need to total at least $380 million," Koh wrote.'
- yuhong 12y agoFrom https://plus.google.com/103157122834258782502/posts/dvxSd4wnkG6 https://plus.google.com/103157122834258782502/posts/dvxSd4wn... "I'll settle for a personal letter of apology, written by and signed by Eric, Larry and Sergey." AFAIK the SEC is already beginning to push for admission of wrongdoing.
- funkyy 12y ago$324.5 is just a wild number or is there a math behind it?
- GeneralMayhem 12y agoThis is still worrying. >In her ruling, Koh repeatedly referred to a related settlement last year involving Disney and Intuit. Apple and Google workers got proportionally less in the latest deal compared to the one involving Disney, Koh wrote, even though plaintiff lawyers have "much more leverage" now than they did a year ago. >To match the earlier settlement, the latest deal "would need to total at least $380 million," Koh wrote. $380 million??!!?!?! That's not really any better when they're suing for $3B, and having it come from a judge's mouth is NOT helping. I'm glad she turned down $324m, but the new number is still insulting.
- UntitledNo4 12y agoLeverage = $380 million. Now the judge tells them "you have much more leverage". So tey have to work out how much more leverage they have. 5 times the leverage would be $1.9 billion. That's at least how I understand the text, and I find it very honest of the judge. I guess she can't give them the exact sum she thinks is appropriate.
- jessriedel 12y ago> After the plaintiffs’ lawyers took their 25 percent cut, the settlement would have given about $4,000 to every member of the class. > Judge Koh said that she believed the case was stronger than that, and that the plaintiffs’ lawyers were taking the easy way out by settling. The evidence against the defendants was compelling, she said. Can anyone explain this from the perspective of the economic/sociological motivations of the lawyers? People often complain about a huge chunk of the money going to the class-action lawyers who are too eager to settle, but the traditional argument is that a fixed percentage structure (rather than an hourly or flat rate) gives the lawyers the proper incentive to pursue the interests of the class by tying their compensation directly to the legal award. Here's my best guess: Lawyers, like most people, are risk adverse for sufficiently large amounts of money. (They would rather have $10 million for sure than a 50% chance at $50 million.) On the other hand, the legal award will be distributed over many more plaintiffs. Since it will be much smaller per person, the plaintiffs are significantly less risk adverse. So the lawyers settle even thought it's not in the best interests of the plaintiffs. This suggests the following speculative solution for correctly aligning the incentives of the lawyers and the class action plaintiffs: either (a) spread the legal work over many lawyers such that the potential compensation for them is small enough that their utility function is at least as linear as the plaintiffs or (b) turn the class-action lawsuits legal team into a corporation which must answer to many shareholders. Proposal (a) has problems because it might require the number of lawyers to be comparable to the number of plaintiffs, which could be thousands or millions. Proposal (b) strikes many people as weird, and introduces other principal-agent problems, but it does have precedence: http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2012/04/30/looking-to-make-a-profit-on-lawsuits-firms-invest-in-them/ http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2012/04/30/looking-to-make-a-pro... Would love to hear an expert opinion on this.