8 ms·
They're Made out of Meat
- pdkl95 12y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7tScAyNaRdQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7tScAyNaRdQ The short-film adaptation of this was very well done. The David Lynch-influenced directing style worked well.
- tspiteri 12y agoTo me, it doesn't work at all. The whole point is that they are not-meat talking about meat. In the sketch, they look very meaty indeed, and their speech sounds like flapping meat, so that it does not work at all.
- mechanical_fish 12y agoThe core of the story is that the aliens can't accept the notion of a meat-based lifeform. The idea that they might not just be wrong, but also in serious denial, is a cute twist. Have you really never encountered an intelligent lifeform made entirely of meat who insists, often furiously, that an intelligent lifeform made entirely of meat is impossible? Because they're not exactly an endangered species around here.
- judk 12y agoEven as a vegan, this interpretation had never occurred to me but just blew my mind. Thank you!
- pdkl95 12y agoOne of the things I really liked about this adaptation is how the dialog between the two doesn't actually match their lips properly. The "incorrect" voices and the "obviously a disguise" fez always suggested to me that the English we hear was just for the benefit of the audience and that their actual communication was different. Of course, as with most art, opinions and interpretations will vary.
- pavel_lishin 12y agoIt looks like the sound is a little bit off, but it still looks like they're saying the same things we hear.
- mankyd 12y agoI simply assumed that they made themselves look like the locals. It doesn't mean that they are actually made of meat or see themselves as having any other resemblance to the humans. To give a silly analogy, imagine we visit the world of the Smurfs together. We both paint ourselves blue to fit in, but then you tell me: "they're made out of cake frosting". I'm going to give you quite a strange look when you say that, regardless of the fact that I'm painted blue.
- eterpstra 12y agohttp://thetruthpodcast.com/Story/Entries/2012/3/20_Theyre_Made_Out_of_Meat.html http://thetruthpodcast.com/Story/Entries/2012/3/20_Theyre_Ma... An excellent podcast/radio adaptation, along with an interview with Terry Bisson
- sjs382 12y agoGood thing I did ctrl+f before I posted this. This radio-drama interpretation is awesome.
- arethuza 12y agoMaybe they should talk to the "psychopathically righteous" GCU Grey Area - which apparently takes quite an interest in meat beings.
- midhir 12y agoSShhhhhhuddup man. I'm halfway through Excession!
- praptak 12y agoIt might look like they're conscious but in fact it's only their actions that closely resemble those of conscious beings. The actions are obviously fully automatic because how could meat be conscious?
- kps 12y agoIf you had a piece of meat than consumed English words and excreted correctly translated Chinese, could it be said that the meat actually understands Chinese?
- jimmaswell 12y agoHow complex does a system of algorithms have to be to "understand" something? Hard question.
- krolley 12y agoIt's a reference to the 'Chinese Room' thought experiment. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room
- DiabloD3 12y agoOne of my favorite stories ever. That, and The Last Question.
- boobsbr 12y agoThe Last Question was really nice. What a twist at the end.
- Kurtz79 12y agoSci-Fi stories with a final twist at the end are plentiful, some of my favorites: The Hunters - Walt Sheldon Impostor - Philip K. Dick
- namuol 12y agoAlso: All You Zombies by Robert A. Heinlein (http://faculty.uca.edu/rnovy/Heinlein--All%20you%20zombies.htm http://faculty.uca.edu/rnovy/Heinlein--All%20you%20zombies.h...)
- bjz_ 12y agoOoh, thanks for the tip - that was really good. http://www.multivax.com/last_question.html http://www.multivax.com/last_question.html
- erikb 12y agoWhat a long read. But an interesting story!
- acheron 12y agoIndeed. The Last Question is a genuine classic. Asimov said it was his favorite of his own stories.
- sillysaurus3 12y agoCould any life travel faster than the speed of light? (Including digital life.) Do we know much about dark matter yet? Could it travel faster than light, or is it bound by the same rules as normal matter?
- emmen 12y agoBarring significant new physics, nothing can travel faster than the speed of light. And that's really a very probably no - although you see popular science stuff written like it can solve the problem, it doesn't, and we have no real expectation that anything will. Dark matter, if it is matter (and there are good but not totally confirmed reasons to think it is) is just that...matter. It would really be not that special at all, except that it doesn't interact electromagnetically, but this doesn't particularly have deep implications - we already know about particles like that, neutrinos, but they happen to be lighter than the ones that would make up dark matter.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoWell, other than space itself, hence the whole inflation idea when the whole universe expanded faster than the speed of light.
- webignition 12y agoThe universe initially expanded very quickly but not at the speed of light. A university professor of mine[0] who was (perhaps still is) involved directly in international scientific efforts to examine the expansion of the universe once explained the speed of expansion of the universe to me in a way that made perfect sense. Unfortunately I can't remember the precise details but the concept relates to a change in scale of the distance between bodies. My best approximation is this: the measurable distance between two points can increase without either point moving if the nature of what is between the points changes. You can pseudo-simulate the concept as follows: 1. Open Google maps at a reasonable "normal" scale 2. Affix two dots to your screen and take a guess as to the distance between them as if the dots were actually on the map 3. Zoom out the map quickly as far as it will go 4. Guess again the distance between the dots The ground distance between the dots increases dramatically. One could argue that the dots moved apart at a great speed, possibly greater than the speed of light if the change in distance is sufficient. Clearly we know that the dots did not move. The scale of what was between them moved. During the initial stages of the universe things behaved very oddly. [0] http://www.brunel.ac.uk/cedps/electronic-computer-engineering/adacemics/prof.akramkhan http://www.brunel.ac.uk/cedps/electronic-computer-engineerin...
- lucozade 12y agoI don't know what all the fuss is about. I'm a Turing test.
- tomelders 12y agoIn a foreign country, half of 5 = 3. Based on that same proportion, what's one-third of 10? Also, what's your favourite Justin Beiber "song"?
- lucozade 12y agoJustin Beiber's a singer? All I had in my database was something to do with monkeys so I assumed he was a vet. Going to have to have a word with my programmer. Oh and I don't answer questions. Do you think I'm here to do your bidding or something?
- tomelders 12y agoI think this is a human.
- danielweber 12y agoSorry, but I'm still not letting you out of the box.
- alecco 12y agoTuring police: You're under arrest!
- arethuza 12y agoI believe the phrase is "retired".
- tim333 12y ago>We studied them for several of their life spans, which didn't take long. Do you have any idea what's the life span of meat? I'm wondering if we can fix that one.
- markyc 12y agoIt's a nice story, but not very logical If meat thinking beings were so unheard of, you'd think they'd be all over us, trying to get to know what makes us tick, and why not, talking to us. Like if we'd find a talking dog. Maybe a more logical conclusion would be if they'd go: "Oh, it's just another meat civilisation. Just let them wander around in the dark like all the others, there's no chance they'll ever find anyone". Not as funny, but more logical :D
- Kurtz79 12y agoThis story doesn't work for me, because the emphasis given to main word (which is the whole point I guess) I imagine "Meat" to be a very human concept, strictly related to food, and to our nature as carnivores. I can´t picture non carbon-based lifeforms talking about humans as "meat". The whole concept of "meat" would be completely, well, alien to them.
- rbanffy 12y agoKeep in mind they'd probably not be using English either.
- Kurtz79 12y agoThat´s the point, we have to assume that "meat" is the English word that in their culture would be the best translation for the concept of "Biological, carbon-based lifeform".
- rbanffy 12y agoThey mention they know some other lifeforms "made of meat" where the brain is made of something different, so, they may be familiar with the concept of meat while considering intelligent meat an extremely odd idea.
- Touche 12y agoThat's not the point of the story. The point of the story is to question your own assumptions.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- smcl 12y agoNot sure how appropriate or relevant this is, but both me and a friend read this and were reminded slightly of the stuff "written" by Matthew Holness' "Garth Marenghi" character. Sharing a couple of choice excerpts in case anyone is curious, but the real gold is in "Garth Marenghi's Darkplace" - a series set in 1980s hospital in Romford. Dead Centre - http://www.garthmarenghi.com/books/deadcentre.htm http://www.garthmarenghi.com/books/deadcentre.htm - "This near-legendary collection of short stories includes 'The Streaming Face' (about a boy whose face is turned into a river by a magical elk because he spat on a gnome)" Juggers - http://www.garthmarenghi.com/books/juggers.htm http://www.garthmarenghi.com/books/juggers.htm - "I wanted to write a book about the triumph of the female spirit over a gigantic lorry. Of course, looking back, I realise the truck actually represents AIDS.'"
- k__ 12y agoMe it reminded of Stanisław Lem. He often wrote stuff with an astronaut from the future, who meets other civilisations and often they are a little bit like the world now. So this guy goes there and is like "how crazy those aliens are, doing this and that" and the reader feels is like "well... he is totally right but that's how it's here in real life right now!!"
- puzzlingcaptcha 12y agoSimilar case with Janusz Zajdel. Notably both have been writing during the communist rule. Some amusing stuff had been passed under the nose of censors.
- ctdonath 12y agoThere was a marvelous episode of some "golden age" radio show that was giving "live updates" to a massive archeological find: the ancient island of Man Hat An was excavated, revealing wondrous finds... The Great Tomb of May Seas was opened, revealing all the treasures he needed for the afterlife such as huge rooms full of beds, clothing, entertainment, and even glass panels which magically showed events far away. Other such finds were noted, but it ended with clearing the great monument to their own doom, a stone-inscribed wall fearing the impending onslaught of the Post Men, whom "Neither snow nor rain nor heat nor gloom of night stays these couriers from the swift completion of their appointed rounds", whose ways younger documents noted "going Postal" being something to be feared.
- midhir 12y agoI can't help but make the assumption that the protagonists are machines and then wonder that they weren't 'invented' by a meat species at some stage in their history. The arrogance of the meat-species, eh! They could be cells of phosphorescent algae, communicating by radioactive emission, or collections of electrical charge in balls of substrate. Who the Hell knows. Great story!
- adventureloop 12y agoThere is an opera of this poem by Fredosphere. I think it comes out really well, but I always get strange looks when it comes out of iTunes. http://fredosphere.uni-nets.com/ http://fredosphere.uni-nets.com/
- adorton 12y agoThese aliens obviously haven't visited the Meat Planet: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZP7K9SycELA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZP7K9SycELA
- ck2 12y agoVersus what - molecules of minerals that randomly fuse together in a way that just happens to form an integrated circuit, memory and OS ? The thing about organic life is that it goes though millions of trials and errors before something survives long enough to have memory and inheritance.
- celerity 12y agoI first heard this performed on a podcast called, "The Truth: Movies for Your Ears." Very good podcast for dramatic stories, sometimes artsy like this one.
- calvin_c 12y agoGreat podcast certainly, and I found it much more enjoyable than the short film adaptation mentioned higher in this thread. I also liked the story on The Truth about the beings who discovered the Voyager 1 record (http://thetruthpodcast.com/Story/Entries/2014/5/14_Voyager_Found.html http://thetruthpodcast.com/Story/Entries/2014/5/14_Voyager_F...). Although the 'aliens' in that story were far too human and contemporary to take seriously, it worked as a great examination of how our civilization would react to a similar discovery. Although, like many Truth episodes, the light improv style works only well enough for it to be enjoyable. I much prefer their scripted and adapted stories.
- antirez 12y agoAt this level of evolution for the aliens it would be obivous that intelligence can come in different forms but the basic process is the same and mostly irrelevant.
- patio11 12y agoThe point is to satirize intelligent lifeforms less than 9 light-minutes from Sol, who think "alien" and immediately think "A bipedal humanoid with colorful skin and Buddhist-by-way-of-Native-American spiritual practices."
- antirez 12y agoI know, but science fiction satire can be written in a way to be still pseudo-scientific. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thiotimoline http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thiotimoline
- netcan 12y agoSweet. I wish there was a HN for short stories.
- jmcphers 12y agoIt's not HN-like, but this is one of my favorite sources: http://longreads.com/articles/search/?q=Fiction http://longreads.com/articles/search/?q=Fiction
- almosnow 12y agoI second this, if someone with spare time can hack a small website that does just this please do!
- krapp 12y agoSome of the communities on Livejournal or Dreamwidth are already kind of this.
- pavel_lishin 12y agoI'm sure there are subreddits dedicated to this. I'd start at http://www.reddit.com/r/scifi http://www.reddit.com/r/scifi and check out the sidebar.
- simias 12y agoalmosnow you're shadowbanned
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- simias 12y agoIt's quite a fun read but I don't understand why the author chose the word "meat". I mean, if for those aliens human biology is so weird and foreign, how could they have a concept of meat? Or meat flaps? That seems to imply that they're familiar with non-sentient meat, but what would that be? And if those aliens are so different from us they probably don't have the same concept of food as we have, so it wouldn't make a lot of sense to single out "meat" at all. The story works better for me if I replace "meat" with, say, "carbon blob" or something like that. I still the humour still works out and it's a less culturally-loaded phrase.
- xyzzyz 12y agoI think the idea is that they have plenty of contact with meat-based living forms, but none of them are intelligent or sentient.
- bencollier49 12y agoBut those would blow air through their flaps, though, right?
- torrent-of-ions 12y agoThe aliens don't speak English. I imagine the author chose the word meat in the translation into English for effect.
- Dn_Ab 12y agoI think once the aliens got past the whole meat thing they'd find much common ground as fellow bigoted beings.
- mechanical_fish 12y agoIt's a story about squick. The aliens aren't merely having trouble grasping the concept. They are revolted by the concept. Indeed, as you've noticed, their revulsion appears to be the thing which prevents them from getting the picture. It's not as if they haven't seen meat. They've even seen intelligent creatures that are almost entirely meat. That's all part of the joke. If these aliens could get past their squick they'd be clever enough to understand squishy brains, but they can't.
- fasteo 12y agoBrilliant
- Zikes 12y agoThis reminds me of a proposition put forth once (I think on tumblr of all places) that while humans are normally considered a "baseline" species in sci-fi, what would a sci-fi universe look like where humans were the superbeings? There were dozens of replies along the lines of: "I heard humans can survive losing a limb! Or even multiple limbs!" "Their strength and tolerance for gravity far exceeds our own!" "When one of their organs fails they can just swap it out with another compatible human that's died recently!" It's pretty funny to imagine, and it's a perspective not often seen.
- noblethrasher 12y agoI remember that. Here is the link by way of r/scifi : http://www.reddit.com/r/scifi/comments/1kl5ly/tumblr_for_once_has_a_great_idea_for_a_scifi_show/ http://www.reddit.com/r/scifi/comments/1kl5ly/tumblr_for_onc...
- tehmaco 12y agoA quick search turned up this: http://prokopetz.tumblr.com/post/57702943181/mikhailvladimirovich-bogleech-its-funny-how http://prokopetz.tumblr.com/post/57702943181/mikhailvladimir...
- shangxiao 12y agoThere’s mounting evidence that our primitive ancestors would hunt large prey simply by following it at a walking pace, without sleep or rest, until it died of exhaustion; it’s called pursuit predation. Basically, we’re the Terminator. Isn't that how the bushman in The Gods must be Crazy hunted his prey?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- aetherson 12y agoThe important factor is "without sleep." And, in fairness, it's not entirely about "just walking." Though it's counterintuitive, humans really do have more endurance than most large mammals. Here's a wikipedia on the subject: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persistence_hunting http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persistence_hunting
- romaniv 12y agoIs there any point toposting this aside from smug reassertion of the local hivemind's belief in equality of humans an hypothetical thinking machines? Because I don't see any insightful reasoning in this piece aside from simple reversal, which is only convincing if you already a believer. The reality is that we don't know how minds really work and we don't have thinking machines. The belief that the limited knowledge about brain chemistry "explains" consciousness is similar to the belief that knowing how semiconductors work "explains" hardware and software engineering. Edit: Down-votes on an opinion without any explanation in reply simply prove my point. This is a hive-mind belief and opposing world views are not tolerated.
- schrodinger 12y agoYou're reading too far into motivations for posting this story. I certainly didn't get that this is some reassertion of the equality humans and thinking machines, rather a lighthearted thought experiment about the possibility of life existing very differently than ours.
- pedrosorio 12y agoWhere does the story talk about "machines"? Or when you say "thinking machines" you really mean "thinking lifeforms whose physical cognition center is not meat-based"?
- lobo_tuerto 12y agoIf you like these kind of short stories, then you'd probably like this: http://www.galactanet.com/oneoff/theegg_mod.html http://www.galactanet.com/oneoff/theegg_mod.html
- superasn 12y agoThat is the most incredible short story I've read in a while. Thank you for sharing it! [1] Readability link: https://www.readability.com/articles/waawsj9b https://www.readability.com/articles/waawsj9b
- andrey-p 12y agoWhen you say "this kind" do you mean "free to read online and somehow ridiculously good"? Because that should definitely be an actual genre.
- tfinniga 12y agoThe author of the egg, Andy Weir, recently wrote a full-length novel (The Martian). The book started with Mr. Weir planning a series of mars missions, thinking about possible emergencies and what equipment should be sent to handle those contingencies. Eventually this turned into a story. It's not really like the egg at all, but I enjoyed it a lot.
- solomania9 12y agoSurprised nobody's linked to this video yet: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7tScAyNaRdQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7tScAyNaRdQ
- evo_9 12y agoIt would be cool if HN had a 'Classics' section or something like it where stuff like this could be permanently placed because this and a handful of other stories get reposted every 1.5 years or so. Fun read for sure and a good example of how a scifi story can be so simple but still have a lot to it.
- judk 12y agoI still remember a gem of a comment from last time, where someone miswrote the title as "They're made of meat" (without the "out") and a responder accused that person of completely missing the point of the story because "out" was critical to underdstanding.
- scintill76 12y agoI guess you're referring to this comment[0]. The "out" just seems like the cadence the author intended. I agree it sounds better and may lend a certain extra impact, but I don't know about "critical." Or am I missing something as well? Sorry if this is pointless, I just looked it up because I was wondering if there was some deep metaphor or something I was missing. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3549886 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3549886
- bjliu 12y ago"Sometimes I think the surest sign that intelligent life exists elsewhere in the universe is that none of it has tried to contact us." -Calvin and Hobbes http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-NIK_Cl9UvPE/UVNQLCNSQwI/AAAAAAAAACM/k60_z2eXr0c/s1600/calvin1.gif http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-NIK_Cl9UvPE/UVNQLCNSQwI/AAAAAAAAAC...
- dmitri1981 12y agoBTW, the movie of this, featuring the brilliant Tom Noonan and Ben Bailey is online at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7tScAyNaRdQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7tScAyNaRdQ .
- LordHumungous 12y agoThat was Snowden's secret.
- Gravityloss 12y agoStanislaw Lem has written a lot of stories, long and short, in a bit similar vein. About fifty years ago. The wittiest and most hilarious stuff I've ever read.
- kps 12y agoI confess that for the longest time I thought this was a Lem story.
- cyorir 12y agoI think there was a Lem work like this. Many of his works had robotic societies and cultures, and I think in one there is a reference to a creation myth about how robots formed. The idea that non-robots formed the robots was considered rubbish. I think it might have been a story in a compilation like the Cyberiad. Edit: I don't think this was the story I was looking for, but there is "Prince Ferrix and the Princess Crystal," contrasting robots and the general disgusting nature of squishy non-robots.
- kamaal 12y agoAlso see, The Black Cloud - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Black_Cloud http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Black_Cloud One of themes explored in science fiction often is the possibility of we coming in contact with life forms so different we wouldn't comprehend the very nature of it. If all the singularity, AI stuff ever comes true. Some day it will hardly make sense for any of us to even live inside a biological body.
- angersock 12y agoThis is basically the same response native coders have when encountering Javascript for the first time.
- deanjones 12y agoThis story was used by Stephen Pinker in "How the Mind Works" as part of an attempt to reject the validity of Searle's Chinese Room argument against Strong AI. IIRC Pinker's point was that Searle's argument rests on a narrow definition of what it means to "understand", and he used this story to illustrate his argument that a broader view of concepts like "understanding" is required. Personally, I wasn't convinced but I liked the approach.
- jimmaswell 12y agoIt should be obvious to anybody who knows a little about physics and programming that it's technically possible to have an accurate-enough physics simulation of the matter and energy in a brain, even if it would require more resources than are available, and therefore strong AI is theoretically possible, right? Unless someone believes a human brain requires some supernatural component that operates outsode of the known laws of physics, in which case there's no point discussing the matter with them. Otherwise I don't see how that argument could be legitimately refuted.
- squozzer 12y ago"For superior beings they sure like to rub it in." - Marge Simpson "Obviously, I. Asimov was a robot." - I. Doo Notremember
- cratermoon 12y agoI read this story decades ago. I challenge anyone who thinks of aliens in even vaguely anthropomorphic terms to read books like The Black Cloud (https://cmdev.com/isbn/0141196408 https://cmdev.com/isbn/0141196408) or Stanislaw Lem's Solaris (https://cmdev.com/isbn/0156027607 https://cmdev.com/isbn/0156027607).
- dmccunney 12y agoI know Terry, and saw him read this with fellow writer Jack Womack years ago. Terry was the enthusiastic describer of these weird biological critters, and Jack did the "Meat?" responses with a perfect voice and wonderful tone of incredulity. It's a lovely story, but everything Terry has done is worth reading.