4 ms·
Swarm of 100,000 generators will produce power on demand
- radu_floricica 17y agoWhy on earth would they want _less_ nuclear power? And replaced with low-efficiency gas, too. Are they sponsored by the Russians or something? Because from an ecological point of view I don't really see any reason.
- AndrewDucker 17y agoYou only run the numbers you need at any one moment, and you can power up/down extremely quickly. This gives you fantastic control over additional power.
- wizard_2 17y agoThere's delivery and demand advantage to decentralizing power generation. There's also a huge load balancing challenge associated with it.
- stcredzero 17y agoThese things can only deliver power to the local distribution node. As for load balancing, I don't think it's an insurmountable challenge to respond to the local distribution network's load. Microprocessors excel at this sort of thing. Install a large, over-sized hot water tank to the customers with this, and it's even easier. Install larger generators at local power-hungry businesses that also use hot water, and it's even easier.
- radu_floricica 17y agoFrom a programmer's point of view this may sound appealing, but this doesn't change the fact that economies of scale are HUGE with energy production. I don't even want to think what the efficiency of these toy generators is compared to a big power plant. Also, the power-up/down works only with centralized control. I doubt people will pay to have things installed in their homes which somebody else turns on and off. Sorry, but I can only see this as somebody's wet dream, completely ignoring reality. 5000 euros? Good luck! Solar water heating is 500, and it actually gives hot water for free, 8 months per year.
- tomjen2 17y agoNuclear power isn't very popular in Europe, partly because of what happened in Chernobyl, but also consistent with the more socialistic learnings. Also some claim that we don't have that many years of uranium left.
- colinprince 17y agoOkay, I gotta ask. What is intrinsically more socialistic about Nuclear power?
- tomjen2 17y agoMy bad English :) If was trying to say that Nuclear power wasn't that popular in leftist circles, and that they had more influence in Europe than America, therefore Europe didn't like nuclear power as much as America.
- AndrewDucker 17y agoExcept that 87% of France's power is produced by nuclear power plants...
- radu_floricica 17y agoI'm in Romania (Eastern Europe), and from here it looks pretty popular, a lot more then in US anyways. Both as percent of total energy production and of investments. Last I heard we had over 10% and going towards 20%. As for socialist bias... I have absolutely no idea what you're talking about.
- colinprince 17y agoThe savings in transmission would be large. Also, getting permission for transmission right-of-ways is getting more and more difficult.
- jasongullickson 17y agoSounds like a generator repair man's paradise...
- ekanes 17y agoAn example of pointing to the one big measurable thing "Hey, no big ugly power plant in the countryside" and missing the sum effects of 100,000 real actual people having these in their basements. It will "save" money, but actually each of these 100,000 people pays $7,000 to get started (and then saves some on their bills). It's innovative and the best-case scenario looks good, but the many unknowns and places it could go wrong make it likely a mistake down the road.
- jws 17y agoThe unstressed win here is the cogeneration. The waste heat is captured and used for building heat and hot water. That gets them the 92% efficiency number. On a CO2/(kwhr at the house) basis you can't beat that with centralized power plants.
- stcredzero 17y agoAlso, if they provision these households with something like the WhisperGen, then there's also a gain in efficiency from the use of a Stirling engine. There would also be a benefit from economies of scale. Right now Stirling engines are expensive because they are uncommon. Increasing demand for them would make their high efficiency cheaper, and therefore more widely available.
- ramchip 17y agoGas plants have an advantage over nuclear power stations in that the heat produced by the latter is wasted, the DIW energy expert said. And by the same reasoning, they have an advantage over solar stations... Reusing the heat will boost the efficiency a little (if you define it as pollution per kW/h generated), but it'll still be nowhere near nuclear power.
- sireat 17y agoThis does seem to bank on the fact of the big Baltic Sea pipeline Russia-Germany coming into service. I like the idea of a small power station, but if you are going to be paying $7,000 per installation, you might as well go solar or wind power(probably wouldnt generate as much power though).
- illumen 17y agoSeems likely that the gas part could be abstracted out... once the rest is working ok. Then people could have a choice of putting in a solar or a wind generator... or having all three. Gas lets them simplify the problem. Since the power generation is more easily controlled with gas, it makes the task less risky. It's also a multiple use thing... people already pay for heating, electricity, and for hot water, so this thing does all that for them too. So you can spread the cost over those things, plus you get paid rent, and money every year depending on how much power you generate. Finally you pay less on your electricity bills. As a bonus they get to pump money into a car company... which governments are wanting to do now to stop them dying. I wouldn't be surprised if there are government subsides people could get to cover the $7k too. Extending a mortgage for these things would be very easy to get as well. A very sensible approach all around... a good first step.
- nradov 17y agoWhat happens when Russia or Ukraine cuts off their gas supply again? David JC MacKay has some better ideas on alternatives to micro-CHP. http://www.inference.phy.cam.ac.uk/withouthotair/c21/page_145.shtml http://www.inference.phy.cam.ac.uk/withouthotair/c21/page_14...
- mmt 17y agoMy municipal power company has already implemented multi-stage gas-fired generation in its new power plant. Fortunately, I'm in California, where the weather is warm, so ideal here would be to use waste heat from an air conditioner to pre-heat water.
- kirubakaran 17y agoIts like EC2 for power generation.