8 ms·
Don't be a jerk
Recently someone asked a question here on HN. I answered, and while it didn't take long, it did take a moment or two of my time. Freely given.
Then the question was deleted. No thanks, no acknowledgement, no reply. Just summarily deleted.
In the grander scheme of things it's small fry, but it irritated me. They probably don't care. After all, who am I to them? But still, it rankled a bit.
People - don't be a jerk. If you ask a question and someone answers, say thank you. They've taken the time, does it cost you too much to be polite?
Or am I just completely out of touch with reality?
- JTon 12y agoI'm with you. Seems like it should be common courtesy to me.
- forca 12y agoIndeed.
- jgrahamc 12y agoI wrote about this a long time ago: http://blog.jgc.org/2010/10/power-of-gratitude.html http://blog.jgc.org/2010/10/power-of-gratitude.html
- iancarroll 12y agoWouldn't it make sense to prohibit deleting after x comments have been made?
- bdcravens 12y agoI know I've had times when the answer/response made me look dumb, arrogant, etc, and I've been tempted to delete my comment. In those cases, it wouldn't have been the jerk thing to do, but the cowardly thing to do: if you say, own it, regardless of how it makes you look.
- gadders 12y agoI saw a great quote about this once when someone posted something stupid and after being torn apart, was asked if he wanted his original post deleted and he said "Nah - stupid is supposed to hurt."
- Swizec 12y agoIn times like that I always try to evaluate whether I'm doing/thinking something out of fear. If yes, then I have to go against the fear. It's the only way to eventually get better. Also that whole thing about the best way of finding good answers on the internet is not to ask questions, but to post wrong answers. I use that one a lot. It makes me look like an idiot, but golly do I learn a lot fast.
- BrandonMarc 12y agoHuh. Nice trick. Thanks!
- danielweber 12y agoMistakes are how we learn! Some of my best learning moments have been giving a wrong answer and then other people point out I'm wrong. (NB: it's completely possible for people to be polite when pointing out someone else is wrong.) OTOH, it takes a certain confidence to let your mistakes hang out in public. There is this feeling that everyone on HN is constantly judging all other people so we need to "look smart." When I was younger I tried to hide mistakes to look smarter. It's a bad habit in general. As a community I think we should encourage some kinds of mistakes.
- BrandonMarc 12y agoGood points ... of course, on the phenomenon of everyone constantly evaluating and knowing they're being evaluated: them little triangles, and the subsequent benefits / consequences, kinda encourage that. Bit of a double-edged sword, perhaps.
- lotharbot 12y agoWhen my wife was learning piano, her teacher used to tell her "if you're going to make a mistake, make it LOUD so we can hear it and correct it." Words to live by.
- smellf 12y agoDefinitely. On the other side, it's even worse if you're having a conversation with someone and they start editing their comments which you have already replied to, invalidating the entire thread of conversation and making you look like a dumbass.
- fideloper 12y agoOr, you know, reword it with the edit button. You'll probably get a better, more helpful response with a well-worded comment.
- m0nty 12y agoI took the time to email someone about a specific problem and didn't hear back - how long does it take to hit reply and type "Thx"? The effects are corrosive: why should I bother to reply next time?
- blowski 12y agoI will confess to being someone that often forgets to say thanks. My thought process runs something like "Gosh, that was really helpful, I should say thankyou. But thankyou isn't enough, I should think of a better way of saying thankyou." Then I forget to say anything at all for some time, and then I feel awkward because I left it so long to say thankyou. That's not an excuse. It's a total failure that I forget to say thank you properly whenever it's deserved (and even when it's not). It's something I am working hard to fix, but I still frequently mess up.
- HarshaThota 12y agoI have this issue too but more so because I feel like I am just adding to the noise when I don't have anything more substantial to say other than Thank You. "People are already overloaded with the amount of emails they get, do I need to it?" is how I've looked at it but perhaps but that's not the best approach.
- blowski 12y agoThis is true as well. I don't really like receiving emails that just say 'Thank you', and I'm never sure whether other people do or not. Some relatively high-profile and busy people have said to me in the past "Did you get the thing I sent? You didn't say thanks." so it's definitely a personal thing.
- eau 12y agoS/he probably did not learn about common courtesy growing up. Society will give this person a lesson one day...
- ColinCera 12y agoSome people are jerks. Some people are too frazzled to remember good manners. Some people were raised by wolves and aren't even familiar with the concept of manners. I don't expect people to say thank you when I answer a question. I used to, but that expectation was beaten out of me a long time ago. But I definitely appreciate it — it's a nice surprise — when someone does bother to say thank you, and I try to remember to always say thank you myself.
- themartorana 12y agoUgh. It hurts to hear/read it, but it's true - common courtesy is now "a surprise." If I didn't say "please" or "thank you" every single time it was called for, my mother would have taken me out of this world (you know, since she brought me in to it) years ago.
- danbucholtz 12y agoThis advice really applies to all walks of life. If you're running a start-up (mine is gopaperbox.com), this is how you should treat your customers. More than likely there is someone that does something similar to you. The best way to win is to treat your customer with the utmost respect and be as fair as possible to them. Cliche advice, yes, but it is absolutely integral to success.
- minimaxir 12y agoYou're being downvoted because you're self-promoting your startup for no reason, not because your content is low quality.
- sillysaurus3 12y agoIt seems like this is an instance of a more general trend: The commenting ecosystem is in decline. It's better than Reddit, but it's a shadow of what it once was. I've noticed downvotes are trending now. The downvotes do correct themselves... most of the time. But there's a lot more frivolous downvoting due to the influx of people that have attained downvote privileges but haven't really shunned the mindset of other community sites that encourage that sort of thing. Eight years ago, pg wrote about a problem that may be happening here now: http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/15n2/the_incontrovertible_truth_about_reddit/c15tz http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/15n2/the_incontr... It used to be that you could hold a contrarian opinion and not be at risk of being jumped on by the community or your position being misinterpreted. That seems no longer the case: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8143432 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8143432 The person you responded to may have deleted their question because they're worried about how people might judge them for merely asking the question. Since HN consists of people you may be working with in the future, people have to be more concerned about choosing their words (and questions) carefully. It's not so easy to just speak your mind or ask innocent questions anymore when your identity is tied with your handle. I don't know if there's a solution. There may not be another vibrant community of developers for another decade, for the same reason there isn't a second vibrant online auctioning site. Smart people are on HN because other smart people are on HN. The only solution I can think of is to resist letting irksome things irk you. Easier said than done, but it beats giving up.
- sdegutis 12y agoI've definitely seen people downvoting based on popular opinion rather than the merit of a comment. It's definitely a deterrent to me commenting if I think there's a chance people won't agree with me. My solution has really been to just stop commenting altogether, since "me too" comments are so useless.
- tannerc 12y agoIsn't that one reason why the karma level for downvoting was initially set as fluid on HN? I still can't downvote, but I rarely (if ever) come across an instance where I would use it here.
- 12y ago
- stevewilhelm 12y agoLife's too short; do things for your own edification and satisfaction, not for the praise or recognition of others.
- GhotiFish 12y agobut praise and recognition are satisfying!
- peterwwillis 12y agoMaybe they didn't like your answer. Maybe they didn't like their own question, which is why they deleted it. Maybe they'll upvote you instead of saying thanks. Maybe they aren't around to give a thanks reply or forget about it. Or maybe they just don't care. You're not completely out of touch, but it's unfair to put conditions on your answers. I recommend letting your kind deeds be their own reward and get on with your day.
- eduardordm 12y agoI usually check the ask section so I can read answers from you, patio11 and a few others. You have helped me a lot and I learned a big deal of interesting and helpful things. That said, thank you.
- Consultant32452 12y agoMaybe I'm doing something wrong but HN doesn't notify me when someone responds or something like other communication platforms do. If and when someone responds to a question on here I assume they are not ever going to check it again. I know I almost never do. The only exception is if there's sort of a conversation going on with responses every few minutes. Once it's been a few hours, or god forbid the next day, I'm highly unlikely to go back. Also, if it's a 1on1 discussion with someone via e-mail, skype, or some form of private message, I'll almost always say thank you. But if I put a question up on an open forum and one or more persons happen to respond I tend not to say thanks. I dunno why, it just doesn't seem to be common internet etiquette to do so. A quick google search on a couple big name technical help question sites shows that it's not very common for people to say thanks for open ended questions to the community.
- JshWright 12y agoClick the 'threads' link at the top once in a while. It adds a little latency, but I kind of appreciate the fact that it slows down the conversation a bit...
- ColinWright 12y agoOr use http://hnnotify.com http://hnnotify.com
- Consultant32452 12y agoThat's what I use, but I am generally only going to check responses on the most recently couple of posts. And I'm afraid the 2nd page suffers the same fate as Google results that are beyond the first page... never getting seen.
- thisjepisje 12y agoI always use the 'threads' button in the menu bar, good enough for me.
- bryanlarsen 12y agoThere's a 'comments' link in your profile. I check it religiously, there are very often interesting responses. Say thanks by upvoting.
- beachstartup 12y ago> People - don't be a jerk. If you ask a question and someone answers, say thank you. They've taken the time, does it cost you too much to be polite? this is why i am in the habit of top-quoting my replies if i put any effort or thought into it. when people are wrong, embarassed, or let something slip they shouldn't have, they're likely to delete. it's just human nature.
- markolschesky 12y agoThis is actually my #1 problem with Quora too. I try to write a lot of pragmatic questions to answers, mostly because I like the idea of helping folks. Unless I'm totally in left field, I feel like I'd like some acknowledgment that my answer was either what they were looking for (thanks!) or that they thought that it was incorrect (I disagree because...).
- jonalmeida 12y agoI find the same problem here as in SO. People like downvoting for what ever reason, but there's never any context as to why. If you feel a comment should be downvoted, go ahead, but provide a comment as well so the author knows why it was so. How are you supposed to be better yourself otherwise?
- pavlov 12y agoThat's a good point. Actually, it might work on HN if each downvote required an explanation. When you click the down arrow, it wouldn't apply immediately, but would first show you a text box for explaining the downvote (this would be just like the "Add Comment" page). The explanation would not be publicly displayed anywhere, but would be accessible to moderators. This could be an effective filter against frivolous downvotes.
- MisterNegative 12y agoYou are asking a question, and I see quite a few people answer. Since you expect others to show appreciation for your contribution, why have you not shown any towards them? Also name calling everyone that doesn't adhere your cultural rules is quite mean from my perspective.
- cinitriqs 12y agoAh well... I have a -4 downvote just because I accidentally replied to the wrong thread one day.. big deal... won't sleep any less over it... guess that's part of the internets...
- k2enemy 12y agoMaybe they didn't want to bring down their average comment score? I'm not saying that is a good reason, just a possible reason.
- korzun 12y agoWelcome to the internet. Maybe they erased the post by accident? How do you know that your answer solved their issue or was relevant? You might think that was the case but it might not be. In general, I think this is a extremely silly. I had instances where I would post about cloud infrastructure and somebody would crawl out of their hole to 'educate' me on colocation, thinking they are solving a ground breaking issue.
- scott_s 12y agoPlease don't fall back on things like "welcome to the internet." One, it's needlessly snarky. Two, we would like this place to be better.
- korzun 12y agoI'm glad you decided to pick out and focus on the first line from my comment.
- DanBC 12y agoWhy do people say things like this? That first line is what's attracting downvotes. It's what people are going to respond to. Someone is gently, politely, pointing out that the line "welcome to the Internet" is going to cause you problems and your response is to bicker?
- korzun 12y agoWhen I wrote that first line, I knew that somebody will completely ignore the rest of the comment and make a post about it. Adding nothing to the actual discussion. There is absolutely nothing serious about the first line. The rest of the post clearly indicates it. Reminds me of people who will show up to threads featuring proof of concept implementations and comment on how the code lacks unit testing.
- scott_s 12y ago
- 4k 12y agoMay be that person felt embarrassed/stupid after asking the question. Personally, it wouldn't compel me to write a post about it.
- S_A_P 12y agoThere always seems to be a touch of nostalgia for the good old days when situations like this come up. People undoubtedly yearn for the time when Hacker News was smaller and more close knit community. Ive been a member here for about 3 and a half years. I suppose that in that time, some of the quality has declined, but I really cant even say for sure that is the case. I think I have learned a lot here, and because of that I may perceive certain topics and discussions here not as stimulating as I did back when I joined. As for downvotes, I reserve that for obvious trolling and overly snarky comments that just seem to be aimed at stirring the pot. I have noticed that some genuinely funny comments or puns based on the discussion get downvoted, which I disagree with. It may not add to the intellectual value, but I enjoy a good laugh as much as I enjoy learning. I would agree with some of the sentiments here that the person probably deleted their question out of fear that they would "look dumb". I think experience has taught me that while Im not the smartest person out there, when something doesnt make sense to me, there is usually someone else that doesnt get it either. Ive also learned that people that react poorly to "stupid questions" are probably feeling defensive of their own knowledge/incompetence. Anyway, I agree Colin, there is basic courtesy that if you are asking for help, it should be acknowledged and thanked when its provided. Nobody knows everything, and asking for help isnt a bad thing. So OWN your questions folks!!!
- ascendantlogic 12y agoSmall communities become insular festivals of group-think. Large communities become whitewashed noise full of trolls. There doesn't seem to be a way to "win".
- Gormo 12y agoThere's always a healthy middle ground: form a community with healthy cultural norms in matters of politeness, courtesy, intellectual rigor - all elements of form - while encouraging the greatest possible diversity of substance. Make it clear to people that be adhering to the norms of form, they'll be a welcomed member of the community, without being censured for the actual substance of their arguments, but merely argued against politely by those who disagree. (Sure, there are people who take any counter-argument as a personal insult, but that's just one of the things we need strong cultural norms against.) I suppose it's a challenge to maintain this sort of pattern as a community scales, which is why sites like HN, Reddit, StackExchange, etc. all try to incorporate incentives and constraints into the mechanics of discussion to attempt to reinforce certain styles of participation, with varying success. In this situation, a simple mechanic to prevent people from doing what OP is complaining about would be to prevent comments from being deleted once they've been replied to. It bugs me when I see long streams of deleted comments on Reddit, too - it'd be an interesting experiment to treat posts and comments in a discussion forum like wiki pages - freely editable at any time by the poster, but with the full edit history always available to see.
- aharonovich 12y agoI wouldn't take it personally. It was kind of you to answer the question, but take into account that while you are (evidently) HN savvy, many are not and perhaps lack the skills to send you a personal note about them having to delete the question quickly.
- sosuke 12y agoYou aren't out of touch, I feel like the downvotes are being used more often on HN, maybe someone like dang could look at the actual data to see if there is any validity to the feeling.
- KedarMhaswade 12y agoIf you enjoyed responding (like I am doing now), then that's that. You got the worth of the time you spent. Of course, if one were _expecting_ more than that (e.g. others not being a jerk or even being nice), then its fulfillment is an added bonus. By not getting the bonus, should we be unhappy also about the salary that we already got? Or is this too idealistic an opinion? If the others' behavior _deeply_ affects us then we are too vulnerable, no?
- snowwrestler 12y agoI don't believe in deleting comments in general. I've said some stupid and mean stuff here on HN, and I think it's important to leave those up, especially if there are responses below them. If nothing else it helps me feel an incentive to be less stupid and mean the next time.
- free2rhyme214 12y agoIn my experience I've learned you can't control other people so telling them not to be a jerk would rarely cause them to change their behavior in the future. You can only control your reaction to them. The way I look at it, you don't have enough time to waste caring about how someone treats you bad or annoys you because there's more important things to do Now that need to get Done.
- dustingetz 12y agoi think you're out of touch. HN is valuable because experts sometimes post things here that you can't get elsewhere. Try to post comments that are valuable to everybody and further the discussion. Comments like "Thanks", and responses from non-experts, contribute to the discussion derailing. All it takes is one non-expert to make an incorrect side remark and the discussion risks derailing into a flame fest. Here is an example excellent, useful discussion with comments from experts: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8143905 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8143905 Here is an example of a not useful discussion with comments from non-experts: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8133835 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8133835 This post falls into the latter category which is probably why it just got nuked off the front page.
- jedanbik 12y agoI don't think there should be a downvote option. There should be an option for upvoting, and an option for flagging offensive content/content that is against the HN community guidelines. As it stands, there is no visual emphasis on high quality comments. There is a visual emphasis on low quality comments. Why is that? Apologies in advance if I am making an ignorant statement.
- lazyant 12y agoagree: 'upvote' or 'flag' and if you click 'flag' you have to choose an option like 'insulting' 'revealing personal info' etc
- jonalmeida 12y agoThis goes well with my idea of providing comments on why you downvoted to give the author context. It's somewhere down here.
- minimaxir 12y agoHigh-quality comments rank higher, so they're the first read and no signal is needed to differentiate them. You can flag comments by clicking the direct link to a comment too.
- rokhayakebe 12y agoJ, I cannot express how much I agree with you. The base logic in downvoting is so flawed it baffles me. How can you take away something from someone if you did not give it to them in the first place. Downvoting, especially without commenting, is exactly what the First Amendment was established for.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- DanBC 12y agoJesus fucking christ the first amendment has nothing to do with downvotes on HN. I would much rather have people downvoting comments they hate than have to read through tiresome boring arguments about stuff hat has been endlessly argued about in the past.
- jdhendrickson 12y agoIf your reply was technical in nature and their user name is their actual name it could simply be worry about being googled during a job application.
- teekert 12y agoWas it an "Ask HN:"? It Took em some tries until I figured out that was just it, add "Ask HN:" to the title. I have deleted 2 earlier tries. Didn't see any responses though, but perhaps I should have hit F5. It could have been that someone was just being naive.
- ColinWright 12y agoIt wasn't you. Mistakes do happen, and maybe the incident in question was just one of those, but the sentiment remains.
- jlees 12y agoAlso phrased as: Remember the person behind the keyboard is a real person. You might not agree with them, but they're a living, breathing human being who took time out of their day to type what they typed.
- Htsthbjig 12y agoTake a shower,take you partner or children with you and get out for a walk, look at the birds, the threes or the sea, or better go to a place where you can look at the thousands of millions of trillions of stars. Then you will realize that it doesn't matter. Seriously, it doesn't matter at all. Sometimes it happens to me too and I need to focus again on what is important and what is not.
- dickinurass 12y agoOut of touch and dumb, get educated child
- computerjunkie 12y agoThis is all too common with online communities, I am part of other online communities and you will always find people who post a question and receive great answers but the original poster will not even respond with a simple thank you. More stringent rules when joining the community possibly?
- nanoscopic 12y agoAre you sure that the original author deleted the question, or was it a moderator? You may be pointing a finger at the wrong person.
- thaumaturgy 12y agoFWIW, I've noticed that most of the Ask HN threads don't seem to get much participation from the person doing the asking -- so I've answering any of them, even on the really rare occasions when I might be qualified to answer or have an opinion on the question. It's sort of unfortunate to see the usual suspects, like patio11, putting effort into a comment on an Ask HN thread only to see no response from the submitter.
- blutgens 12y agowat
- macguyver 12y agoTotally agreed. I think the biggest issue with the Gen XYZ (I am part of X) is that we as a whole (a big generalization, of course there are exceptions) tend to be too self-centered. We are always concerned with our goals, our aspirations, and we don't think about, care for, or appreciate others nearly enough. Our parents' generations (baby boomers) had responsibilities that involved caring for siblings, raising children, tending aging parents, and they often put themselves LAST. Not to say that it's better, but after talking to friends my age who have started families, I think it really sheds light into why so many young people are lost, confused, and unfocused. People are wandering around wondering what their purpose is, why they're unhappy, this and that, when they just have to open their eyes to see how blessed they are, how good they have it. I think at the end, the purpose that Gen XYZ seek is right around them - if they will look up from their smartphone devices - human connection. We need to appreciate more what we have, the help that people give us, and start to give more to others and the world around us.
- capex 12y agoIsn't saying 'Thank you' against the ethos of HN?
- ColinWright 12y agoFrom https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html : Empty comments can be ok if they're positive. There's nothing wrong with submitting a comment saying just "Thanks." Filling a thread with lots of very short comments just saying "Thanks" is discouraged, but in a short exchange in an item that's not going to spawn a huge amount of discussion, saying "thanks" won't derail or pollute the thread. Quoting further: Which brings us to the most important principle on HN: civility.
- 0-o 12y agoThank you!