11 ms·
Questions about Nasa's space drive answered
- didgeoridoo 12y agoDeep breaths. Probably experimental error. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof... God DAMN this is exciting.
- pantalaimon 12y agoAs the article points out in 8., there have been previous, independent experiences that support the results.
- didgeoridoo 12y agoWell yes, without those it wouldn't even be worth talking about. I don't think the several experiments so far rise to the level of "extraordinary", but now that this is capturing so much attention, I don't doubt we'll get there soon.
- tobinfricke 12y agoThese were other, earlier experiments, which the current experiment is attempting to duplicate. Importantly, while the new experiment has superficially "confirmed" the previous ones, it shows a much smaller effect. When the magnitude of the observed effect scales roughly with the margin of error of the experiment, one has very good reason to be skeptical ...
- baq 12y agothey found 91 mmN of thrust and they claim their detector is sensitive to about 10mmN. that's almost an order of magnitude. this doesn't mean that it sounds too good to be true. edit: fixed units - dont have easy access to micro, thanks for pointing that out.
- BugBrother 12y ago<Cough> You shocked me so much that I read the article! :-) (I follow the subject by browsing news now and then at http://talk-polywell.org/ http://talk-polywell.org/ which really is about the small fusion projects. That place should have more details then at Wired.) Use 'μ' for micro, 'm' is for milli.
- tobinfricke 12y ago"u" is an acceptable replacement for "µ". I've never seen "milimili" (mm) before. You can spell it out, like "91 micronewtons". You can also use exponential notation like 91e-6 N or 91x10^(-6) N. To be fancy you can copy-and-paste unicode characters and write 91×10⁻⁶ N.
- gambiting 12y agoI've seen "mm" used very frequently as millimetres. 1cm/2=5mm.
- rsynnott 12y agoThe previous tests were on an EmDrive, while the current one was a Cannae drive, which is a related but different design. The EmDrive guy claims the lower thrust is to be expected due to the design difference.
- keeperofdakeys 12y agoJust because something is able to be replicated multiple times, by different people, you still don't want to jump to conclusions. You just need to look back at polywater, http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/science/2013/11/polywater_history_and_science_mistakes_the_u_s_and_ussr_raced_to_create.single.html http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/science/201...
- tobinfricke 12y agoAnd several other effects, like N-rays, filed by some under the category of "pathological science" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pathological_science http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pathological_science). There's also that nice graph of measurements of the speed of light versus time, in which experiments tended to reproduce the results of (erroneous) previous measurements, due to confirmation bias.
- crusso 12y agoAnd Cold Fusion... ugh... I was at Georgia Tech in 1989 when they announced to the world that they had reproduced some aspects of the cold fusion experiment. So embarrassing. Reproducing an experiment, even with reputable scientists at NASA or reputable universities is in no way a guarantee.
- smackfu 12y agoThe problem with these kind of unusual scientific results is often the experiment itself, not the results. It starts as "we do X, and it has a result of Z, and that makes no sense." Someone usually figures out that it's really "we do X (and Y), and it has a result of Z, and that is completely expected based on Y, and X is irrelevant as expected."
- madaxe_again 12y agoIndeed. As to the whole "we don't actually understand how it works" - we still can't make up our minds as to how wings work, so this isn't overly novel. Sure, we can explain the outcome, but whether it's Navier-Stokes or Bernoulli or something else, we can't make up our minds. I suspect this will be similar for a long while - although puts physics hat on I think this is likely a relativistic temporal quantisation effect.
- ColinWright 12y ago> ... we still can't make up our > minds as to how wings work, ... Interestingly, I recently spoke to an aerodynamicist and mentioned this, and I was severely lectured. In the follow-up he mellowed a little, but I suspect the "we" in your statement refers to laypersons who don't have advanced training in aeronautics, and yet claim to understand about flow pressure, Bernoulli, etc. I've been convinced that the people who genuinely work with these things and study them properly, actually do know how wings work. You may not, I may not, the mythical "man on the street" may not, but there are people who really, really do.
- madaxe_again 12y agoNo, I've a masters degree in Physics, and did several research projects on turbulent/laminar flow. We have a detailed understanding of a variety of theories which correctly represent the lift effect experienced on a body moving through a flow, yet none of them do it perfectly or completely. We can implement the technology well, but not without the aid of wind-tunnels and brute-force computer simulations in order to validate our designs - had we a perfect mathematical understanding of lift - we would not need to. Another example from Physics - quantum mechanics. We can describe the properties of a QM system, its outcomes based on inputs, the probabilities of states - yet we have not got the blindingest clue as to how it works. We have theories, but again, none are perfect - for instance see the Pilot Wave formulation of QM, which implies a deterministic universe, and isn't wrong, but isn't generally accepted - even though it describes QM systems well, for what little of it has been formulated in the last century.
- 12y ago
- tobinfricke 12y agoI'd say that it's about on par with the faster-than-light neutrinos caper (tiny effect, violates known physics, probably result of experimental error, ...). Both would be very exciting if actually confirmed, but I personally found/find the chances too slim to (yet) get excited.
- antocv 12y agoWasnt the faster-than-light neutrino myster solved? It was an optical cable not plugged in all the way.
- ceejayoz 12y agoYes. Unfortunately, that's likely to be a similarity here.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- scott_s 12y agoSteven Novella (neurologist, active in the skeptical community) made a similar comparison: http://theness.com/neurologicablog/index.php/nasa-tests-em-drive/ http://theness.com/neurologicablog/index.php/nasa-tests-em-d...
- thisjepisje 12y agoWhere can I find blueprints?
- servowire 12y agoI'm also looking for this.
- marcosdumay 12y agoAt the paper. And it's crazy simple.
- thisjepisje 12y agoTime to mod my quadcopter :)
- servowire 12y agoI can't find prototype diagrams with dimensions or something, did you find any? Please link? The paper is $25 .... mmm http://arc.aiaa.org/doi/abs/10.2514/6.2014-4029 http://arc.aiaa.org/doi/abs/10.2514/6.2014-4029 This post has some more info https://plus.google.com/117663015413546257905/posts/WfFtJ8bYVya https://plus.google.com/117663015413546257905/posts/WfFtJ8bY...
- ElliotH 12y agoHere it is on scribd from some kind person http://www.scribd.com/doc/235868930/Anomalous-Thrust-Production-from-an-RF-Test-Device-Measured-on-a-Low-Thrust-Torsion-Pendulum http://www.scribd.com/doc/235868930/Anomalous-Thrust-Product...
- colanderman 12y agoRegarding the EmDrive… OK, so, there's microwaves producing forces on either end of the cavity, and one end is bigger and… wouldn't the forces be proportional to the area normal to either direction? i.e. one end may be smaller, it may even be a point (making the cavity a cone), but microwaves bounce off of the tapered neck of the cavity too.
- davedx 12y agoIs this the same thing as the Q-thruster? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_vacuum_plasma_thruster http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_vacuum_plasma_thruster
- noselasd 12y agoYes, the that wikipedia article eve references the very same device in question built by Guido Fetta that NASA tested.
- spingsprong 12y agoPlease be true, please be true! How big is a two megawatt nuclear power source anyway? A quick search showed nuclear power plants are in the hundreds to low thousands of megawatt range, and RTGs are in the tens to hundreds of watt range. I have no idea what something that lies between those two would be.
- runj__ 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micro_nuclear_reactor http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micro_nuclear_reactor Toshiba 4S gives 10 MW. "a 50 MW version [will be] available in the future"
- tgb 12y agoWikipedia gives the generator of Loss Angeles class nuclear submarines to be 26 MW [1]. I don't know whether you can make them as successful in space without the access to ambient water. [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Los_Angeles_class_submarine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Los_Angeles_class_submarine
- madaxe_again 12y agoThe principle problem to be overcome with this tech is going to be cooling - both for the power source and for the drive. It's going to require radiators the with a stonkingly huge area and Peltier shunts, unless we come up with a cunning means of dumping excess heat - potentially turning it into more energy to drive with, even, using the seebeck effect.
- bitL 12y agoSo what's the difference between what NASA does, what Chinese did with Em drive and what Russians have orbiting in Yubileiny satellite? More interesting question: can I make one at home? I can do magnetic levitation, both pushing and pulling with high-frequency electromagnets; it would be cool if I could do this as well and having floating objects in my home 8-)
- tobinfricke 12y ago"it would be cool if I could do this as well and having floating objects in my home" The reported thrust of the device is in the tens of micronewtons. Assuming it weighs 1 kg, you would need approximately a million times more thrust for the device to levitate (i.e. counteract its own weight) at the surface of the earth.
- servowire 12y agoBut in space a few micronewtons per Kg is pretty usable.
- readerrrr 12y agoThis is very exciting; a new propulsion method that already works much better than existing thrusters, doesn't need propellant and without requiring years of research. It sound too good to be true. My bet is on experimental error.
- vkal 12y agoI'm reading Contact by Carl Sagan right now and my heart kept fluttering as I read this article. I'm unqualified to comment on anything in this article, but this is really cool, and I didn't know Wired produced science journalism (or a highly technical Q/A) like this.
- noselasd 12y agoBesides the frequency of the electromagnetic waves , is this the same concept as the "Pioneer Anomaly" - where they eventually figured out it was thermal radiation emitted from its satellite dish which slowed down the spacecraft ?
- jahnu 12y agoAs far as I can tell it wouldn't matter what the cause of the apparent effect is. Not requiring reaction mass is what makes it interesting.
- Mandelbug 12y agoWhat? Of course the apparent affect matters. If the underlying physical principles can be understood, there is a possibility of increasing its efficiency for larger throughput. And if the underlying process isn't understood, there is no way to rule out something that isn't actually producing thrust or some other fluke. Finally, the whole point of science is to discover things. Not make magic :|
- jahnu 12y agoI don't mean to suggest it wouldn't be of interest. As you point out it would be of paramount interest to discover the physics behind it. The Pioneer Anomaly, however, was very very small indeed. This effect appears to be many orders of magnitude greater.
- ep103 12y agoI think what he means is even if it turned out to just be thermal energy, then that means this device has the capability of directing thermal energy as a viable proportion source, so its still pretty great : )
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mikeash 12y ago
- tgb 12y agoWired gets some flack these days but that was a thorough article. Maybe I need to read the actual paper now instead of just dismissing it off-hand.
- bad_user 12y agoGiven the steady push of this drive, if it actually works can it be said that a significant percent of light speed could be reached?
- madengr 12y agoPhotons (i.e EM fields) have no mass, but do carry momentum and can transfer it to charged particles (i.e. the solar sail). So if the drives uses EM field to transfer momentum to the quantum vacuum particles, wouldn't that upset the net-zero energy balance of the quantum vacuum? I though the particles are popping in and out of existence, hence net-zero energy?
- grondilu 12y agoI liked the comparison with high-temperature superconductors. We don't exactly know how they work either. But they do work.
- leni536 12y agoThe analogy is not perfect though. High-temperature superconductors are not breaking well established principles in physics. We just can't describe these superconductors well now. Most of the limitations describing solid state materials come from that we can't solve the Schrodinger-equation directly (even with simulation). So we have to make assumptions and reasonable approximations of the resulting wave functions of electrons. For many solid state materials there are standard approximations that are working really well but they are not working for all materials. We simply didn't find any working approximation for high-temperature superconductors (but I think there are some not well tested theories out there).
- mrfusion 12y agoWould this be how impulse drives are supposed to work in Star Trek work? Just curious.
- tobinfricke 12y agoAs you may be aware, Star Trek is a work of fiction.
- mikeash 12y agoAnd beyond that, a work of fiction that focuses on storytelling first, and science... well, not second, but maybe twenty-ninth or so. Which is not a criticism. Not all science fiction has to be hard. But none of the technology is a product of scientists sitting down and thinking about how the technology of the future might work. It's a product of writers thinking about what technology would make for good stories, and any explanation you come up with (e.g. impulse drives are reaction drives with warp fields that let them have an exhaust velocity higher than the speed of light) is a retrofit made up to appease fans and sell more books.
- mnw21cam 12y ago<nerd hat on> No, the impulse drives (according to the Haynes manual for the Enterprise) are standard reaction drives, with weak warp fields around them, so they can eject propellant faster than the speed of light.
- servowire 12y agoIf this works, and if it's scale able, it would be something like the impulse drive. A normal spacedrive for speeds far below C and without space-warp.
- tobinfricke 12y agoHere are two nice posts by physicist John Baez with some reasons to be skeptical about the "reactionless drive": https://plus.google.com/117663015413546257905/posts/WfFtJ8bYVya https://plus.google.com/117663015413546257905/posts/WfFtJ8bY... https://plus.google.com/117663015413546257905/posts/C7vx2G85kr4 https://plus.google.com/117663015413546257905/posts/C7vx2G85...
- spingsprong 12y ago"They're claiming to see a force one thousandth as big as the Chinese - probably because they are doing the experiment one thousand times more accurately. And still, some people are excited about this. " I think he's slipping from skepticism to cynicism here.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- crusso 12y agoDisagree. He's being prudent and rational to hold these experiments to the same standards that we hold other more mundane ones. Hoax phenomenon and devices always seem to fail in precisely the way that this one has. As you more carefully examine the test setups, suspicious conditions of the experiment persist (like the lack of using a vacuum in the vacuum chamber), and observed phenomenon continue to diminish as the accuracy of the test equipment improves. And I use the word "fail" knowing full well that they claimed that they had positive results. If they couldn't use best practices in performance of the experiment like evacuating the vacuum chamber and they couldn't even show that their null device that wasn't designed to produce the same effect didn't work, then they have some serious problems.
- readerrrr 12y agoHe seems to be makings some mistakes as well. He says: This is baloney too - but now it's graduate-level baloney. "Quantum vacuum virtual plasma" is something you'd say if you failed a course in quantum field theory and then smoked too much weed. There's no such thing as "virtual plasma". If you want to report experimental results that seem to violate the known laws of physics, fine. But it doesn't help your credibility to make up goofy pseudo-explanations. The original description might be clumsy, but the idea of empty space being full of virtual particles is not wrong. Here is Dr. Laurence Krauss's description of empty space: especially the idea that what we think of empty space is really not empty, correct? KRAUSS: That's exactly right. Empty space is a boiling, bubbling brew of virtual particles that pop in and out of existence in a time scale so short that you can't even measure them. Now, that sounds of course like counting angels on the head of a pin; if you can't measure them, then it doesn't sound like it's science, but in fact you can't measure them directly. But we can measure their effects indirectly. These particles that are popping in and out of existence actually affect the properties of atoms and nuclei and actually are responsible for most of the mass inside your body. And in fact, really one of the things that motivated this book was the most profound discovery in recent times, and you even alluded to it in the last segment, the discovery that most of the energy of the universe actually resides in empty space.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mrfusion 12y agoWhy does number 7 say a superconducting version of this drive does not require energy to hold things up? Are they just referring to how superconductors can float in an external magnetic field? That doesn't seem to give general purpose hover boards.
- nanofortnight 12y agoNot requiring energy is a mistake from Wired. A superconducting version of the drive would be able to provide much higher Q, and thus much higher static thrust to power ratio. It would also have much better performance at higher waveguide velocities. http://www.emdrive.com/theorypaper9-4.pdf#page=9 http://www.emdrive.com/theorypaper9-4.pdf#page=9
- pera 12y agoI don't know but wouldn't be awesome if we could finally create a hoverboard? :)
- pistle 12y agoUgh. That's a Buzzfeedy title if ever there was one. I'm surprised it isn't: Space Scientists Don't Want Obama To Know These 10 Secrets About Warp Drive
- nsxwolf 12y agoNASA Scientists Resonate Microwaves in a Cavity - You Won't Believe What Happens Next!
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoA less conservative projection has an advanced drive developing ten times as much thrust for the same power -- this cuts the transit time to Mars to 28 days, and can generally fly around the solar system at will, a true Nasa dream machine. If we had this plus a reduction of cost-to-orbit by a couple orders of magnitude, say getting prices down to $10 per kilo? Space travel would actually become a thing -- something available to most people. And we could lower cost-to-orbit in a lot of proven ways, like using mass drivers for non-human orbital insertions. This is firmly in the "too good to be true" category right now, but hell, I'm a believer. Even if we're wrong, even if there's some experimentation error, science still wins. People are being energized, lots of imaginative scenarios about space travel are playing out across the net, and so on. This is a very good thing.
- gus_massa 12y agoShort version: Unless they believe the machine breaks some of the fundamental physics laws, the device must emit something. With this definition using a red LED Laser powered by a 1.5V battery in the back of the spacecraft is a "no reaction mass" thruster. The problem is that the momentum / energy ratio has theoretical limitations, and they are getting too much momentum. Long version (based on a previous comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7162069 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7162069): I’ll try to explain what I had understood trying to find an explanations that don’t break the physics laws. To move the spaceship you need momentum. You must use some particles to carry the opposite momentum away. It’s not clear, but the main candidates are photons (aka light). (The other possibility is gravitons, but that would be even more amazing) The photons have no rest mass, but they have energy. So to produce them, you must "spend" some energy. The energy source can be carried in the ship (a nuclear reactor) or absorbed in place (solar panel). If you are using a nuclear reactor, a small par of the mass of the atoms is transformed into energy and you put that energy in the photons. So the net effect is that some of the mass of the spaceship goes away, and it's no long a "no reaction mass" ship. (The same idea is valid to electric batteries, but the mass difference comes from the chemical bounds and not from the nucleus.) If you use a solar panel, then when you absorb the photons the spaceship gains a little of mass. Unless you have a mechanism to dissipate the mass the spaceship would get heavier. Luckily, the photons that you are using for propulsion carry a little of mass (and the heat you are dissipating also helps). So this is essentially a solar sail, you get some photons, and send them in a different direction, and the change in the direction of the photons give some momentum to your ship. Perhaps a complex setup (solar panel + led) can be more directional that a simple setup (mirror). Perhaps you can gain a x3 or x6 efficiency. (But someone has to do the calculations, because this might break the second law, unless you get a laser light and also dissipate some heat without a specific direction, and the net result as good as a mirror.) In the previous comment, throwaway_yy2Di noted that with photons "the ratio a photon's momentum to energy is fixed at 1/c, which is 3.3E-6 N/kW". The problem of photons is that to get some moment you need a proportional amount of energy to create them. Another possibility is to create particle-antiparticle pairs and accelerate them, but this is even more inefficient that using photon and you get less than 3.3E-6 N/kW. The alternative solution is to accelerate other particles (for example the hydrogen atoms in the rocket fuel), you don't need energy to create them, because they are already there. So you can get more than 1/c=3.3E-6 N/kW, but it's not a "no reaction mass" ship. They claim 40 microNewton/28W = 1.4E-3 N/kW ~= 400000/c. This is in the like 400000 times the theoretical limit, so they have a measurement problem (or they'll get a Nobel price).
- cookiemonster11 12y agoIt's probably powered by N-rays.
- FiatLuxDave 12y agoI've read the abstract, but apparently Wired has access to more information. Any idea where the primary source for that information is? I'm interested to see what magnetic shielding was used and how well they characterized the magnetic field in the experimental volume. There was a mention of shielding against electromagnetic effects, but that could just mean a Faraday cage or Helmholtz coils, neither of which will reduce the B-field to zero. Because the device is based upon microwaves in a conducting cavity, I would think that the first place to look for a theory of operation would be E&M, not quantum. The level of force involved is the kind that you can see when interacting with the Earth's magnetic field. Normally we ignore the force produced by the interaction of currents with the Earth's field, because they are so small. Was a mu-metal shield used, and if so, what was the remnant field? Was a stronger field induced to see if that increased the force? I hope that the experimenters try this if they have not already.
- danbruc 12y agohttp://www.libertariannews.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/AnomalousThrustProductionFromanRFTestDevice-BradyEtAl.pdf http://www.libertariannews.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/An...
- FiatLuxDave 12y agoThank you! It's always best to read the actual paper. I note that not only is there no shielding to reduce the Earth's magnetic field, but there are large NeFeB magnets in the torsion balance assembly. I strongly suspect that the "missing momentum" is going into the object producing the magnetostatic fields which lie in the RF cavity, whether that be the Earth or the damping magnets. Not to say that this wouldn't be interesting (RF interaction with magnetostatic fields), but I don't think this has met the level of proof required of a claim of violation of momentum conservation.
- XorNot 12y agoOr the more obvious conclusion, which is Wired don't know how to read a paper, and nowhere in the actual experimental section do they say they pumped down the apparatus when they were actually testing.
- JulianMorrison 12y agoA superconducting version of the EmDrive, would, in principle, generate thousands of times more thrust. And because it does not require energy just to hold things up (just as a chair does not require power to keep you off the ground), in theory you could have a hoverboard which does not require energy to float in the air. If they have just solved flying cars and hoverboards, I think we can officially declare this to be the future already.
- MiguelHudnandez 12y ago> And because it does not require energy just to hold things up (just as a chair does not require power to keep you off the ground), in theory you could have a hoverboard which does not require energy to float in the air. An item where you could dump electricity into it once, cut power, and have it resist gravity -- forever, and for free! -- is absolute horse shit.
- FiatLuxDave 12y ago>An item where you could dump electricity into it once, cut power, and have it resist gravity -- forever, and for free! -- is absolute horse shit. Um, you are completely wrong. There is a difference between force and energy. It is certainly possible to expend a small amount of energy to create a force which lasts in perpetuity. Energy = Force x Distance, and if there is no displacement in distance, then no energy is spent by the exertion of a force. Not to say that making hoverboards and flying cars is an easy engineering proposition, but that is due to the parameters of the problem, not due to any intrinsic issue with the physics of providing a force against gravity. If people weighed a nanogram, or the Earth's magnetic field were 1 Tesla, or the electrostatic potential between the stratosphere and the Earth was 100,000 times stronger... any one of these and we'd have had hoverboards a long time ago. But that's just numbers. There is no problem with spending a finite amount of energy to create a perpetual force.
- fatmanscoop 12y agoEven using Energy = Force X Distance you need to overcome the force of gravity been exerted upon the object, this means you need to continually exert a positive for force to overcome this.
- jcfrei 12y agoHere's a demonstration video of the EmDrive in action: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=57q3_aRiUXs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=57q3_aRiUXs However this test rig apparently doesn't adhere to the same strict experimental setup used by NASA.
- mangeletti 12y agoShortest version: They think it works, but we don't know how. More tests will tell whether or not we have finally discovered the technology required to drive around easily in the solar system and propel skateboarding into the realm of Back to the Future.
- crusso 12y agoDoesn't this remind anyone of the not-so-long-ago overhyped E-Cat? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_Catalyzer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_Catalyzer
- tensor 12y agoNot at all. Unlike the e-cat, the design here is clear and it sounds like it's independently verified from the ground up with good experimental conditions. The e-cat had "secrets" that they wouldn't divulge and it's tests were also questionable with the machine being plugged into a power source the whole time.
- crusso 12y ago"verified from the ground up with good experimental conditions" No it hasn't. That's the hype. Read the Baez commentary referenced elsewhere. Research all the other physics breaking phenomenon that had experimental confirmation but were still shown to be wrong. It's not like this effect was just noticed yesterday. You'd think that for an effect that Shaw created a company for in 2000, we'd have solid experimental results by now that addressed every single problem. It mostly reminds me of the E-Cat in that there are people who want it to be true so badly that they cherry pick the results and statements that they want to believe while disregarding contraindications.
- snowwrestler 12y agoThe emdrive is being tested by NASA staff, who did not invent it. That alone is a very significant difference from the ecat, which was only ever demonstrated by its creator. Now NASA is still probably wrong, but if so, they are innocently wrong. They wouldn't gain anything by faking an effect. If anything, they are getting heaping abuse for reporting anything at all. Which I think is a problem for science. People should not be abused for honestly trying to test surprising things, even if they turn out to be wrong.
- crusso 12y ago
- Gravityloss 12y agoThe most important question that should have been top center: with reactionless propulsion it is possible to create a free energy device. Attach the thruster to a wheel. When the thruster is firing, it consumes constant power and the wheel accelerates, spinning ever faster. The wheel can be attached to a generator that produces power which is thrust times the rim velocity. Thus, after a certain speed, the wheel produces more power than the thruster consumes. This was discussed on a rocketry list.
- bellerocky 12y agoAnd where would the "free energy" be coming from? Pretty sure you'd be losing energy, as energy doesn't come from thin air.
- VikingCoder 12y agoAt least one of the theories on the article talked about pushing on virtual particles, like a submarine pushing on the water around it. This would imply to me that efficiency goes down with speed. Just a thought.
- Gravityloss 12y agoBut there is a problem with that, that there should be some kind of aether of virtual particles that would have small velocity compared to the thruster. Yet there is little evidence so far for such a thing. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aether_theories http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aether_theories
- ghshephard 12y agoI"m not following why you think the wheel generator will produce more power than is required to spin the wheel in the first place. Friction is a pretty big issue in your scenario. It seems orthogonal to the actual results.
- Gravityloss 12y agoThe whole thing was a thought experiment to show how extraordinary the supposed result is. Power of the wheel = thrust * rim velocity. That's just basic physics you should learn in high school. P_1 = F * v This means if your force, that is, thrust, is constant, you generate more power the faster you go. That's also why cars accelerate faster from 20 to 30 km/h than from 120 to 130 km/h - they have constant power which means they have more force at lower speeds and thus higher acceleration at lower speeds. The claimed thruster produces a constant thrust for a certain power, let's use a factor k for that: P_2 = k * F Now if we want perpetual motion, we can set P_1 = P_2, and solve F * v = k * F v = k If we let the speed be faster, we can actually generate power from the wheel in excess of what the thruster uses. We can also have some friction, let's say the wheel generator is 50% efficient. We then need to run the wheel twice as fast to get the same effect. There actually exists a trivial "reactionless" thruster if we use a flashlight and the light pressure. But it turns out the velocity is the speed of light then.
- VikingCoder 12y ago"Prototype engine weighs about 15 kilograms" "EmDrive, produced 91 micronewtons of thrust for 17 watts of power" http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=91+micronewtons+*+1+year+%2F+15+kg+in+mph http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=91+micronewtons+*+1+yea... 428 miles per hour, after a year. Am I doing the math wrong?
- jobu 12y agoBest part of the article is the answer to question 9: "9. Why isn't there a simple explanation of how it's supposed to work without violating the laws of physics?" "If the new drive results continue to be replicated, then theory may have to catch up." Reminds me of the quote: "In theory, there is no difference between theory and practice. But in practice, there is."
- michael_nielsen 12y agoEvery few weeks on Hacker News we have the following cycle: (1) News article! Prevailing view of physics overturned! Etc! Etc! Etc! (2) Many excited comments! (3) Much less excited comment, pointing to skeptical remarks by well-known professional physicists (e.g., John Baez, Sean Carroll). (4) Much to-and-fro. People who once saw a Discovery Channel special on physics now appear to believe that they're in a better position to evaluate the new claims than the people from (3). Now, points (1) and (2) do sometimes happen, without points (3) and (4). For instance, the neutrino faster-than-light claims attracted very cautious comment from professionals. In other words, point (3) was absent or rather muted. That's because the people who'd done the experiments were known for being extremely careful, and were, in fact, very cautious in their announcement. That kind of thing is genuinely exciting, and worth discussion. Another nice example of an exception is the Alcubierre drive. It satisfied (1) and (2) (or the 1996 equivalent), but (3) was absent, except that professionals noted that the drive required the stress-energy tensor to have some unusual properties, not satisfied by any known substance. Indeed, Alcubierre pointed this out himself. Again, genuinely exciting, and worth discussion. But when the professionals are loudly deriding a result, it'd be nice for the amateurs to make a serious attempt to understand why, and not just airily dismiss it.