4 ms·
"As doctors, trying an untested drug on patients is a very difficult choice since our first priority is to do no harm, and we would not be sure that
by aaronbrethorst 12y ago
"As doctors, trying an untested drug on
patients is a very difficult choice since
our first priority is to do no harm, and
we would not be sure that the experimental
treatment would do more harm than good."
Uh, we're talking about a virus with a 90% mortality rate. What are you afraid the drug might do? Kill them?
- sgift 12y agoDamage their genome? So, they live but their children will have horrible deformations? Or they live but their bodies get damaged so bad that they are basically bound to bed and medical machines for the rest of their lives? Or ... There are fates worse than death. And then ethics: Is it right to use patients who fear for their live as medical test subjects? Is it really an "informed consent" if a person who fears for its live gets promised a "possible cure", even if that cure could do ANYTHING? If someone tortured you and you started saying "I do everything, just stop it!" - would that be informed consent? Isn't Ebola a natural version of torture? And so on ... It's easy to say "it worked! We cannot justify to not help those people who will die anyway", but there is NO guarantee that it will work a third time. It could dissolve the organs of the next person. And then it wouldn't sound so great anymore, would it?
- swombat 12y agoIt's easy to say "it worked! We cannot justify to not help those people who will die anyway", but there is NO guarantee that it will work a third time. It could dissolve the organs of the next person. And then it wouldn't sound so great anymore, would it? Even if it dissolved the organs of the next 2 people it'd still be a better survival rate than Ebola itself (I understand this strain has a 60% mortality rate, not 90%), so yes, it would still be great. Either way, this is a choice that the patient should make for themselves. It may be ethically dubious to offer experimental drugs to dying patients, but it is obviously and completely morally and ethically reprehensible to deny a possible cure to someone who is dying and wants to give the cure a try.
- mentalhealth 12y agoThis is a poorly considered view of experimental treatments. Particularly in the case of aid work, experimentation on the patient population is not only unethical in every formalizable sense, it is quite likely to inculcate a sense of distrust in the treated (justifiably, and moreso if there are unanticipated side effects), making treatment and control of future outbreaks more difficult. A chance at life for a single patient may damage the chance for hundreds if not thousands of future patients.
- swombat 12y agoI'm not advocating experimentation on the patient population. I'm just saying it is frankly unethical and immoral to withhold a potential cure from a patient with a very high chance of dying, when you have that potential cure at hand and they are making an informed choice that they want to give it a try. I don't see how treating that one patient will prevent "treatment and control of future outbreaks", either.
- aaronbrethorst 12y ago> Damage their genome? So, they live but their children will have horrible deformations? Unfounded assumption. I'd love to be given the opportunity to maybe live, and have to avoid reproducing, instead of being forced to consider possibilities that may have no basis in fact. If I'm days away from dying, and my only alternative is that I can take a magic pill that means I shouldn't have children, then I won't have children. It's not exactly a dilemma. > Is it right to use patients who fear for their live as medical test subjects? Is it right to give someone the opportunity to control their own destiny? > Is it really an "informed consent" if a person who fears for its live gets promised a "possible cure", even if that cure could do ANYTHING? The 'cure' showed some positive preliminary results in lab animals. > It could dissolve the organs of the next person Ebola doesn't literally liquefy your organs, but the virus destroys your liver and kidneys.
- anigbrowl 12y agoUnfounded assumption. I'd love to be given the opportunity to maybe live, and have to avoid reproducing, instead of being forced to consider possibilities that may have no basis in fact. If I'm days away from dying, and my only alternative is that I can take a magic pill that means I shouldn't have children, then I won't have children. It's not exactly a dilemma. While I agree with your broad point, your reasoning here is facile because it assumes reliable foreknowledge. It's possible that you might not knoew that you shouldn't have children until after you've done so and things have turned out very badly; consider for example the administration of thalidomide during pregnancy, which turned out to produce horrific birth defects, or diethylstilberol, which turned out to cause tumors in the daughters of women who took it during pregnancy (a fact which was not discovered until many years after the drug was first administered). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diethylstilbestrol http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diethylstilbestrol Is it right to give someone the opportunity to control their own destiny? Get it wrong and you may be doing the exact opposite, as possibility you seem to have overlooked. Good intentions are not automatically ethical, unless those intentions have a sound probabilistic basis. Tort law is full of stories about people who thought they were helping and who ultimately made things much, much worse.
- psykovsky 12y agoLive or Life? http://www.englisch-hilfen.de/en/words/live_life.htm http://www.englisch-hilfen.de/en/words/live_life.htm
- therealmarv 12y agoAnything could happen. Imagine the Virus will adapt to this cure and is now more worse than before and is faster and will spread now more easily by air (no one can say that this will not happen with this cure). Or to say it in a more satirical way: Have not you seen any Zombie movies... it all started this way. This is like playing roulette and you will not know what impact this cure has in a bigger and longer perspective (not looking at an individual).
- copperx 12y agoI'm saddened that there's no way to 'downvote' here.
- MaulingMonkey 12y agoIf you earn enough meaningless internet points, there is. I suspect constructive disagreement as seen above is more effective though.
- victorhooi 12y agoRight, and we should go back to the Middle Ages, where people died from things like the common cold. Or where diseases like polio left children crippled for the rest of their lives? Or where diabetes sufferers went blind, or had bits of their legs fall off? Ugh. This is as bad as arguing with the anti-vaccination crowd. Look, pathogens will adapt. That's evolution - deal with it. But does that mean that as humans, blessed with our intellect and skills, we shouldn't try to improve our lot in life?
- therealmarv 12y agoYou are comparing apples with oranges. I'm definitely not anti-vaccination. But this serum is highly experimental and not widely available or even tested on humans. I even doubt that your FDA has the right to give an exception here. Who is responsible when something goes wrong or worse? Your FDA? For Liberia? Europe would e.g. never allow usage of this serum on humans (it's totally illegal) and there is a big reason to avoid that usage even if two individuals die. Would you say ok to every experimental serum which could cure and it is not well tested (for aids? for cancer?) ... and what about the 1600 Africans who are dying at this moment and are not US citizens?
- Xylakant 12y agoMortality rates for ebola outbreak vary by strand of virus between roughly 60% and 90%. This outbreak is so far on the lower end of the scale, so having a drug that reliably safes 30% and kills 70% would be a loss, whereas in other cases it might be a win. Untested drug, things can go wrong and you're giving it to people that are already in very bad shape.
- andy_ppp 12y agoYes but I doubt any drugs will kill 70% of people. In fact anything below a 60% death rate would be a net win, but certainly no-one is talking about such ridiculously high mortality rates from trial medications.
- lhc- 12y agoWithin the realm of tested drugs, then sure, you won't find any with that mortality rate. But this drug had never been given to a human. There's no safe way to predict the exact effect it will have, and there is a realistic chance it could kill the intended recipient. This wasn't even trial medication, it hadn't reached that stage yet.
- eliben 12y agoYes, but think about one specific person who found out she has it. Prognosis - 60% that you'll die if you don't try the drug. With such drugs there are just not enough statistics to come up with odds so early. So do you take it?