7 ms·
> I wonder how long before someone gets the bright idea to claim eminent domain on drug (or other) patents for the sake of medicare Before doing anything that
by tzs 12y ago
> I wonder how long before someone gets the bright idea to claim eminent domain on drug (or other) patents for the sake of medicare
Before doing anything that radical, why not repeal the ban on Medicare negotiating drug prices? The "Medicare Prescription Drug, Improvement and Modernization Act" of 2003, which created the medicare prescription drug program, explicitly prevents Medicare from negotiating prices with the drug companies. The drug companies and the insurance companies decide the prices, and Medicare is stuck with that. This is one of the big reasons Medicare pays a lot more for drugs than the VA does--the VA directly negotiates with the drug companies the prices it pays.
There have been attempts to fix this. The House passed a bill in 2007 to do this, but Senate Republicans were able to stop it there. 6 Republicans joined Democrats in supporting it, but that was not enough to get the 60 votes needed to end debate, and the Republicans were ready to filibuster it if necessary. (They really hated it. Senator Cornyn of Texas said it was "a step down the road to a single-payer, government-run health care system"). President Bush promised a veto.
President Obama made repealing the ban on negotiation one of the key points of his campaign for 2008, but had to drop it from the ACA to get drug makers on board, and since then there has been no chance of getting such a thing past the Republican House.
- gradstudent 12y ago> (They really hated it. Senator Cornyn of Texas said it was "a step down the road to a single-payer, government-run health care system"). President Bush promised a veto. I don't understand why Republicans have such a raging hard-on against universal healthcare. Pretty much every country that has implemented such a program agrees it is a Good Thing and worth funding through new taxes.
- markdown 12y ago> I don't understand why... If American politicians sported their sponsors logos like nascar drivers do, things would become much clearer.
- tptacek 12y agoThe health care industry contributes substantially to both parties, even though the Democratic party supports single-payer. They contributed more to the GOP in the 2000s, but the GOP controlled the government for most of that time and held the presidency. Starting in 2008, health care resumed contributing more to the Democrats, as they did at the start of the Clinton administration. The idea that politicians assume public policy positions because they're captured by donors is sometimes true, but it's incorrect as often as not.
- markdown 12y agoParties don't matter, people do. They only need to contribute to a few key people to influence lawmaking. A significant number of politicians (of both parties) will oppose single-payer on principle. A significant number will oppose it based on what they think their electorate wants. Some will vote for single-payer on principle. And some are on the fence or just don't care. Lobbyists are paid big money to ferret out these few and influence them.
- deciplex 12y agoDon't try too hard to analyze the Republican platform, as it's mostly just an assortment of special interests without any real coherent underlying ideology, and don't fool yourself into thinking a single Senator or Congressman is capable of independent thought.
- krapp 12y agoPrimarily, because universal healthcare involves greater government expenditure and complexity, and Republicans consider both the extra cost and regulation an assault on capitalism and states' rights. This is the party which is politically beholden to a man who famously said he wanted to shrink government down to the size that it can be drowned in a bathtub[1], after all. Also, because it smacks of socialism, and socialism is considered a moral evil that creates an underclass of lazy underachievers who don't understand the dignity of a hard day's work and only want to feed at the government trough. And of course by implication vote for the other party. It's probably also worth pointing out that it being the way things are done in Europe and elsewhere only makes it even more offensive, because Republicans believe in American exceptionalism - which implies at its core that our way is Just Better, and everyone else is Just Worse. [1]https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Grover_Norquist https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Grover_Norquist tldr; money, politics and xenophobia.
- tptacek 12y agoI'm a Democrat and generally in favor of state-sponsored universal health care, but unlike other commenters on this subthread, I don't have a hard time seeing the issue Republicans have with single-payer healthcare. Single-payer essentially nationalizes more than fifteen percent of the US economy (by dollars). It would more or less make every doctor, nurse, and technician an employee of the US government. But much more importantly than that, it would remove broad market price discovery from allocation of medical services. Instead of prices rising or falling to match demand from actual consumers, things would cost what a system of bureaucracies would say they cost. Republicans aren't simply concerned about single-payer because they oppose entitlements (although they do). They also have a valid concern that single-payer would distort and degrade the health care system. (For what it's worth, I like the balance Obamacare tries to strike, and support anything that puts us further along down the road to the Swiss system of health care).
- gradstudent 12y ago> Single-payer essentially nationalizes more than fifteen percent of the US economy (by dollars). It would more or less make every doctor, nurse, and technician an employee of the US government. But much more importantly than that, it would remove broad market price discovery from allocation of medical services. Instead of prices rising or falling to match demand from actual consumers, things would cost what a system of bureaucracies would say they cost Eh? Universal healthcare doesn't mean price regulation. The price signals are still there but you now have a very large public buyer able to negotiate prices with very big private suppliers. How is that not better than the current system where large numbers of citizens cannot afford adequate healthcare and big companies can extort whatever price they want out of those seeking access to life-saving drugs? > They also have a valid concern that single-payer would distort and degrade the health care system. Degrade how? Universal healthcare can still work with e.g. privately-run hospitals and clinics. You don't need the government to hire all the medical practitioners; just pay for the cost of treatment.
- tptacek 12y agoIf there's a single federal buyer paying for 90+% of the market (look how much of the market for seniors Medicare covers), it's hard to see how the price signals continue to work the same way. The (slow, error-prone) political process is engaged in every buying decision. Already you can see that changes in the way Medicare reimburses and measures outcomes have impacts on the way services are delivered today, and Medicare is just a fraction of the overall market for health care in the US. The federal government doesn't hire all the practitioners. They just fix all the prices. At any rate, there's a difference between disagreeing with an argument and pretending that it doesn't exist, as other comments on this thread did. (I am in part assuming the mantel of the GOP argument against single-payer here; I prefer the Swiss system to the NHS, but unlike most Republicans I strongly believed that a national solution was needed for health insurance and financing.)
- refurb 12y agoNegotiation power isn't going to get you much. The Canadian gov't negotiates on behalf of 35M Canadians and gets big discounts. United Healthcare, the biggest US private insurance company, has 40M+ members. They negotiate, but they don't get much of a discount (typically). The real reason why European countries (and Canada) pay less is because they legislate discounts. They give the drug companies no other options. I would call it arm-twisting more than negotiating. And yes, Medicare doesn't negotiate, it legislates discounts. Medicare pays no more than the Average Selling Price for a drug (average price across all sales). It also legislated that the manufacturers pay a discount to cover the donut hole for Medicare Part-D.
- tzs 12y ago> And yes, Medicare doesn't negotiate, it legislates discounts. Medicare pays no more than the Average Selling Price for a drug (average price across all sales) ASP is a terrible price. The VA pays 42% of AWP (Average Wholesale Price). Drugs on the Federal Supply Schedule, which is what the Bureau of Prisons, the DoD, and most other government agencies use, are 53% of AWP. Medicare prices are 84% higher than Federal Supply Schedule. With their volume, Medicare should be able to get prices at least as good as what the Bureau of Prisons gets. [1] [1] http://www.ncpssm.org/Document/ArticleID/207/Price-Negotiation-Would-Dramatically-Lower-the-Cost-of-Prescription-Drugs-for-Medicare-Beneficiaries http://www.ncpssm.org/Document/ArticleID/207/Price-Negotiati...
- refurb 12y agoASP is not the best price, but it's certainly not "terrible". It's the average price including all discounts offered to private insurers. The 42% of AWP that the VA pays sounds awesome, but AWP is inflated (typically 20-40% more than list price). At any rate, yes, you are correct, the big four (DOD, BOIA, DOC and one I can't remember) get very discounted prices. However, they can also exercise a lot of control over what patients get without having to hear a lot of complaints. For example, the DOC is not using Sovaldi all that much, but if prisoners complain, not much is done. Now imagine if Medicare said "no, too expensive, we're not paying for that drug". Congressmen would be getting hundreds of calls from seniors and the AARP about denying the elderly population the latest and greatest drugs.