7 ms·
Most Math Problems Do Not Have a Unique Right Answer
- JibberMeTimbers 12y agoAs for the armor plating question, did the plate the engine because of its size? The engines combined make up a smaller surface area than the other places but it was still shot up quite a bit. It would be less weight and not to mention it would be more 'mission critical'.
- nielsbot 12y agomy guess is that "evidence" (in the form of bullet holes) shows hits on the engines are the least survivable. (I am only saying that because I was told that the intuitive answer of "armor plate the most struck parts" is wrong.)
- bagosm 12y agoNo I have read the story elsewhere, the reasoning is that if they were shot any more they wouldn't have returned at all (hence skewing the statistics). So they can take lots of hits on other spots and come back safely, but not so much on the engine so we protect the engine
- lotsofmangos 12y agoBullets can be considered almost random in where they will hit, so, if it gets back with lots of holes in the fuselage, it tells you that you can have lots of holes in the fuselage and it still gets back. If almost none return with hits to the engine, then almost every engine hit is bringing down a plane.
- kps 12y agoI've read this story before, but asserting it was the RAF rather than the USAAF, which triggered my urban-legend detector. In fact, the mathematical work was done by Abraham Wald¹, a Jewish refugee from Romania, at Columbia University in 1943. A reprint of his memos is available², as is a more accessible article about his work³; the specific one is Part V Subdivision of the Plane⁴ Into Several Equi-Vulnerability Areas: “Thus, for the observed data of this hypothetical example [italics added], the engine area is the most vulnerable in the sense that a hit there is most likely to down the plane. The fuselage has a relatively low vulnerability.” I haven't seen evidence that his work was applied to actual aircraft design using real data. ¹ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abraham_Wald http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abraham_Wald ² http://cna.org/sites/default/files/research/0204320000.pdf http://cna.org/sites/default/files/research/0204320000.pdf ³ http://people.ucsc.edu/~msmangel/Wald.pdf http://people.ucsc.edu/~msmangel/Wald.pdf ⁴ the flying kind
- jordigh 12y agoI want to add something here: great mathematicians compute too. They also know how to perform an algorithm. It is in performing, say, long division, that you start to notice things like when 10 is a primitive root modulo the divisor. Gauss spent his down time counting primes (in his head, he said). Riemann's notes were full of haphazard computations. Amidst his scratch work where the Riemann-Siegel formula appears, there's a computation of sqrt(2) to 38 decimal places for no discernible purpose. He probably was merely exercising, just like a musician practices scales. Erdős was able to memorise 10 phone numbers at a time from a glance at a phone book, amidst other calculating feats. I hypothesise that offloading this brain work to a machine atrophies your cerebral muscles. Exercises left to the reader are really exercises in an almost kinesthetic sense. The computations don't have to be purely numerical: even a diagram chase in abstract nonsense is a valuable exercise. Computation frequently leads to insight. As children are adding two-digit numbers, they start to notice shortcuts about how to perform the computations. These are their own little private theorems, so to speak. So when Devlin here is talking about "mathematical thinking" and the less importance that performing algorithms has today, I hope we don't forget that just because it's less important, it doesn't mean it's not important at all.
- Retric 12y agoHistorically that's true. But, I suspect there will eventually be a great mathematician who has also suffers from something like severe dyslexia which makes accurate computation vary difficult yet still makes significant contributions.
- tomrod 12y agoMy undergraduate mentor was this way. World-class mathematician with dyslexia.
- RogerL 12y agoI had a college professor like that. He was nearly unable to perform arithmetic, and would ask for the answer from the class. I wouldn't say he was dyslexic (I have no idea), but he certainly couldn't perform mental arithmetic. But he was fabulous at math. We'd often ask him questions far outside the realm of the textbook and class just for the privilege of seeing an extremely good mind tackle a problem. So I disagree with the OP. The fact that some mathematicians brains work that way is not evidence that they all do, nor is it evidence that it is helpful or preferable.
- edtechdev 12y agoAnd yet the way math is traditionally taught in schools and colleges, there is almost always is a unique right answer. There are alternative approaches to teaching math such as problem-based learning, active learning, and inquiry-based learning, that help students not only understand the math better, but learn why the math is useful and how to apply it in the real-world (transfer of learning). Students also are much more likely to continue on and succeed in future courses and graduate. Here are best practices for teaching calculus, for example: http://launchings.blogspot.com/2014/01/maa-calculus-study-seven.html http://launchings.blogspot.com/2014/01/maa-calculus-study-se... And research showing that in traditional lecture courses (vs. active learning courses), students are 1.5 times more likely to fail: http://news.sciencemag.org/education/2014/05/lectures-arent-just-boring-theyre-ineffective-too-study-finds http://news.sciencemag.org/education/2014/05/lectures-arent-... Underrepresented populations (minorities) and females are much more likely to succeed in active and inquiry learning math courses, too: http://theconversation.com/who-learns-in-maths-classes-depends-on-how-maths-is-taught-21013 http://theconversation.com/who-learns-in-maths-classes-depen...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- johnnwhite 12y agoI agree with the author entirely. But I still feel it's important to be able to do computation in your head if just to develop that "number sense". As a physicist, I use computers to do all my real calculations. But when I get the answer that seems wrong, I can mentally do some basic calculations that convince myself the computer-answer I got is probably off by a factor of two, and look for the bug.
- analog31 12y agoI think that if you want to understand how ordinary people use math, a good place to start would be by looking at their Excel spreadsheets. Excel is arguably the most widely used tool for computation and even programming. I've seen some impressive spreadsheets for solving complex problems, written by folks with no more than a high school education. With that said, I'd endorse a move away from solely algorithm based (standardized test based) learning.
- calhoun137 12y agoIt is refreshing to find an article with a false title that contains it's own refutation within the first five paragraphs: "The only career in which a high school graduate can expect to continue to work on [problems with a unique correct answer] is academic research in pure mathematics" Unfortunately for this article, the premise that mathematics is the same thing as engineering is false. If an engineering problem does not have a unique solution, its because of complications introduced by the real world. Any engineering problem which can be well-posed as a pure math problem, does of course have a unique solution; as the author concedes.
- carstimon 12y agoIt depends on what you mean by a math problem. It seems a common idea is: A math problem is a question asking for the set of solutions to some mathematical equation, and only the actual solution is useful. But I would include all of the following as math problems: -Prove that some equation actually has solutions -Find some bounds on solutions to that equation -How can I compute an approximate solution to that equation? -How good is that approximation going to be? -What's a way to try to separate large data sets into clusters? With regards to the first four: many equations people are interested in simply have no hope of getting a solution you can write down. Simple example: sqrt(2). A more complicated example: solutions to the Navier-Stokes equations.
- dbecker 12y agoSince uncountably many problems have unique right answers, I'd guess the cardinality of the set of problems with unique right answers is the same as the cardinality of the set of problems without. :)
- j2kun 12y agoCareful there. If you require one to be able to express a problem via some finite string (and via some universally fixed method for encoding problems as strings), then there are only countably many problems.
- dbecker 12y agoThough, if we apply your requirement, the set of problems without a unique answer must be countable as well. So, the cardinality of problems with a unique answer is still equal to the cardinality of problems without one.
- j2kun 12y agoYou're just using the terminology imprecisely is all. (Indeed, two things being countable does not mean they have the same cardinality; finite sets are also countable)
- dbecker 12y agoI think it's trivially obvious that both sets are infinite. There are infinitely many addition problems involving two numbers, and that's a subset of the set of problems that the article claims to be smaller.
- j2kun 12y agoI'm not making claims about the truth or falsity of your statement, just critiquing the logic and terminology you're using (the lack of a definition for a "problem," the minor misuse of the term "countable"). Regardless, I really hope you saw the article as something besides a mathematical claim, because it clearly did not pretend to be one.
- japhyr 12y agoI have a three year old son, and it is absolutely fascinating to watch his mathematical understanding develop. I've been a math teacher my entire adult life so I've had plenty of experience watching older students develop their understanding. It's entirely different watching your kid develop their understanding from scratch. I recently looked for some kids' books that would focus on the more interesting problems in math, rather than just counting. I was happy to find a few books that have helped him see math as more than just counting. My favorite so far is The Boy Who Loved Math: The Improbable Life of Paul Erdos. [0] I knew of Erdos, but I didn't know much about him. I learned from reading this book, and my kid loves it as well. He is fascinated with aging, and he now sees it as normal that someone would spend their whole life focusing on numbers. We are also starting to enjoy Bedtime Math: A Fun Excuse to Stay Up Late. [1] The idea is to give your kid some interesting math problems to think about at bedtime. We've found that it's a good way to help him think about things other than the dark, and strange noises while he's falling asleep. It's fascinating to watch this development. A few nights ago: "Did you know that one of the oldest questions people have asked is, How many stars are there in the sky?" "No, I didn't know that!" "How many stars do you think there are in the sky?" "Eight!" [0] - http://www.amazon.com/The-Boy-Who-Loved-Math/dp/1596433078 http://www.amazon.com/The-Boy-Who-Loved-Math/dp/1596433078 [1] - http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1250035856 http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1250035856
- nileshtrivedi 12y agoYou will love this blog: http://talkingmathwithkids.com http://talkingmathwithkids.com
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoThis too, http://jdh.hamkins.org/category/math-for-kids/ http://jdh.hamkins.org/category/math-for-kids/, which featured on HN a couple of months ago.
- tedunangst 12y agoHow is adding armor to the engine area not a unique right answer? I'll leave you to figure out why that is the best solution. If there is only a single best solution, isn't that then the unique right answer?
- j2kun 12y agoIt depends on the assumptions you make. For example, are the planes you're measuring a uniformly random sample of all planes you're interested in? The answer is different depending on how you answer this question.
- tedunangst 12y agoThat sounds like different problems have different solutions. "Most math problems are (initially) poorly defined" would have been a better title, I guess.
- djokkataja 12y agoI agree with your title suggestion. The author phrases the problem in an intentionally misleading way: "They examined the fuselages of all the damaged planes that had flown back after being hit to see where the most damage was. It turned out that the engines had an average of 1.11 bullet holes per square foot, the fuel system had 1.55, the fuselages 1.73, and the rest of the plane 1.8." He says that they checked to see where the most damage was, but really they were checking to see where the least damage was. If the planes were able to fly back with terrible damage to everything except for one part, then adding armor to that part is a pretty obvious solution. On the other hand, figuring out exactly how much armor to add is much more complicated, because you have the constraints of weight, production time, etc, plus you have to have some kind of estimate for the effectiveness of the armor in actual combat. I would probably go with "Most Real-World Math Problems Do Not Have a Unique Right Answer".
- j2kun 12y agoAnd, perhaps surprisingly, most mathematical work in the real world is spent figuring out which assumptions are useful to model the problem and which are not. You sound like you are claiming that modeling the problem is not part of the problem, but somehow "before" the problem is posed. It sounds like a fantasy to me.
- qnaal 12y agoThe idea that mathematics as a whole is intuitive (as opposed to specific facets of its machinations) is as pervasive as it is misleading.
- sethammons 12y agoHe linked to DragonBox Elements which I had not heard of. It looks really amazing. This one is for geometry, similar to how the previous DragonBox was for algebra. Awesome find!
- hebbarp 12y agoMost Math Problems Do Not Have a Unique Right Answer The title is both right and wrong. You are actually comparing school or college math with math applied in real world. School or college math works with few variables, for instance, and we consider most others remaining constant. Rarely have I seen school or college level students working with, say, derivatives of more than three variables. School or college math is an exercise to establish the rule, the rigour and in most cases to create an appreciation of what math can achieve. In real world, variables are plenty. If you take a handful to solve a problem considering other important ones to be constants, you will end up with one set of answers as against others if you had taken a different set of variables. Real world applied math is contextual. You remove context from the problem and real world math looks like school or college math. As demonstrated by the engine-armour-plate example, without the context of the airplanes returning after taking hits, the mathematicians would probably have gone with a statistical answer and would have been proven wrong! However, I do agree that most math problems may not have unique right answer. Of course, we are not talking of,say, square-root-of-two having two different answers. However, take an instance where the problem is:"Find a number that is a sum of two infinitesomely large numbers one ocurring at an infinitely large interval of time from the other. Does it essentially fall on the numberline?" Well the first reaction to this question is: well, yes. Because if we are sure to find those two numbers then we are more likely to find their sum which has to fall on the numberline. Now, a more discerning reader might pause and ask: can you define infinitely large number and infinitely large interval. Hence, a question like this may not have a unique right answer. If you allow philosophers in, you will definitely not have a unique answer :) Coming to a more basic argument: With math we are striving to arrive at a single agreeable solution. Whether it is statistics or calculus, we are interested in modelling the world to arrive at a set of recognizable pattern or a set of patterns. We apply the templates we learnt in school and college. For instance in arithmetic, numerals -- which are nothing but symbols -- help us reduce our problems into an expression which we can solve. The operations allow us to take these symbols through a set of processes that helps us model the problem. But thanks to the author, what is clear is that applied math is contextual and answer may vary with the change in context. While school math is merely an exercise in familairising ourselves with a template.
- jameshart 12y ago
- kazinator 12y agoIf we randomly choose a matrix A of NxN coefficients, we are quite likely to end up with a linear independence, meaning that Ax' = 0 where x' is the vector [x^(n-1) x^(n-1) ... x 1] is a system of equations with a unique solution. This is an example in which most problems derived from some real data in fact have a unique solution. In case the above isn't clear what I simply mean is that, for instance, if we randomly choose the coefficients for a system of three equations in three unknowns, we are in fact statistically unlikely to end up with an under-determined system (multiple solutions). Two or more of the vectors in the matrix would have to point in the same direction, which is unlikely for randomly chosen 3-vectors.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- gambogi 12y agoIt's too bad most of the discussion here is centering around the title, rather than the post
- skierscott 12y agoI'm a senior in college. I've learned about a host of mathematical concepts that are misunderstood by popular media (N dimensions, linear algebra, linear functions). Wanting to correct these topics, I wrote a blog post[1] about them. But this blog post blossomed into much more than I was expecting. I was expecting to cover only those specific details, but then I got into nonlinear problems that have no closed form solution and got into what mathematicians do. While I'm still learning and they're an experienced mathematician, I like to think I can understand what everyone else thinks and what mathematicians think. [1]:http://scottsievert.github.io/blog/2014/07/31/common-mathematical-misconceptions/ http://scottsievert.github.io/blog/2014/07/31/common-mathema...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]