9 ms·
When It's Bad to Have Good Choices
- hartator 12y agoIt's me or there are a lot of articles from the newyorker which make the HN top?
- sebastianavina 12y agoit's great! isn't it?
- edmccard 12y ago>there are a lot of articles from the newyorker which make the HN top? There has probably been a higher frequency lately since the New Yorker has gone no-paywall for the summer.
- segmondy 12y agoGreat articles make HN top, I don't care about the source.
- louischatriot 12y agoThis article really resonnates with me, having had to choose between two very interesting jobs. It took me 2 weeks to decide and was a really anxious period, whereas without a choice I would have taken either without a second thought.
- unchocked 12y agoThis validates something I've suspected for a while: that decisiveness is valuable in and of itself.
- jodrellblank 12y agoFrom 'Surely you're joking, Mr Feynman': The lieutenant takes me to the colonel and repeats my remark. The colonel says, "Just five minutes," and then he goes to the window and he stops and thinks. That's what they're very good at -- making decisions. I thought it was very remarkable how a problem of whether or not information as to how the bomb works should be in the Oak Ridge plant had to be decided and could be decided in five minutes. So I have a great deal of respect for these military guys, because I never can decide anything very important in any length of time at all. In five minutes he said, "All right, Mr. Feynman, go ahead." - http://quanta-gaia.org/reviews/books/FeymanJoking.html http://quanta-gaia.org/reviews/books/FeymanJoking.html
- taurath 12y agoSounds familiar. I wish the article had some sort of suggestion or hint as to what to do when you're really prone to anxiety. I have several very good options in my life right now and have made a tenative decision on what to do, but I'm finding I'm crippled by anxiety over my decision.
- lloeki 12y agoCelebrate[0] [0]: http://www.ted.com/talks/ruth_chang_how_to_make_hard_choices http://www.ted.com/talks/ruth_chang_how_to_make_hard_choices
- isomorphic 12y agopaulsutter gave a good answer to this elsewhere in the comments. But I would add this: All other things being equal (or roughly equal), pick one at random. Sure, there's opportunity cost, but there are also costs way beyond the time you take fretting over a decision. You said it yourself: You're "crippled" by anxiety. How is that better than making a random decision? Or just going with your gut?
- baddox 12y agoI think it's naive to assume that simply making a random decision would remove or reduce anxiety. Anxiety doesn't only come from the fear of regretting your decisions; it also comes from the fear of receiving a negative outcome, even if that outcome was "chosen" by a coin flip or a third party. Hence people are anxious to receive news after a job interview, or a call about a loved one's medical condition, despite both having nothing to do with their own decisions.
- dredmorbius 12y agoIt's not that making a random decision will remove or reduce anxiety. It's that making a non-random choice 1) won't improve the predicted outcome and 2) won't reduce or remove the anxiety either. Given the alternatives of either 1) not making a decision, 2) drawing out the decision for a long time, or 3) failing to act in time on the option, simply making a random initial commitment addresses the decisionmaking aspect. Many decisions are capable of being reversed or changed later. If you're ever in a situation where you must decide (stay or jump from a burning building, say), there's still likely to be an option which is least bad. Even those who jumped from the WTC on 9/11 were making a decision. The outcome wasn't optimal, but in the circumstances, it may well have been preferable to the alternative.
- JacobIrwin 12y agoI submit that "anxiety" here could be better defined as: the mental taxation of evaluating the opportunity cost for turning down each of the available alternatives, given a person's position on Maslow's hierarchy of needs
- lloeki 12y agoFor those who prefer video to text, Barry Schwartz (mentioned in the article) gave an insightful TED talk about this, as has Sheena Iyengar[1] (but I didn't know so haven't watched it... yet). Baba Shiv has an interesting take[2]. [0]: http://www.ted.com/talks/barry_schwartz_on_the_paradox_of_choice http://www.ted.com/talks/barry_schwartz_on_the_paradox_of_ch... [1]: http://www.ted.com/talks/sheena_iyengar_on_the_art_of_choosing http://www.ted.com/talks/sheena_iyengar_on_the_art_of_choosi... [2]: http://www.ted.com/talks/baba_shiv_sometimes_it_s_good_to_give_up_the_driver_s_seat http://www.ted.com/talks/baba_shiv_sometimes_it_s_good_to_gi...
- paulsutter 12y agoWhen faced with a difficult decision, it probably doesn't matter which choice you take. Emotionally it's difficult to accept this. But logically it's easy: - If one of the two choices was clearly better, it would be an easy decision - But it is difficult. Therefore, neither of the two choices is clearly better. - Therefore, it doesn't matter much which you choose. This doesn't work for people who feel irrational regret (ie, regretting a decision that turned out badly because of information that was not known at the time of the decision). Yes, irrational regret is very common. But it's just another logical failing that can be overcome. If you still feel anxiety when forced to choose between two good choices, go visit a third world country.
- lloeki 12y agoWell your reasoning is a bit of a shortcut, and Ruth Chang[0] goes all the way down the rabbit hole, without having to resort to third world country fallacies. [0]: http://www.ted.com/talks/ruth_chang_how_to_make_hard_choices http://www.ted.com/talks/ruth_chang_how_to_make_hard_choices
- sid6376 12y agoThanks for this. The gist of the talk is that each hard choice gives us an opportunity to shape who we are and decide who we want to be. Hence we should look at hard choices that way and not shirk away from them.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Throwaway823 12y agoIt's difficult or impossible to tell if you made the right choice though, so you have no way of knowing if you should regret your decision. If I visit the store and there are two boxes of cereal, or two deodorants, or two digital cameras, and I buy one of them, I start to feel unsure. It doesn't matter if the cereal I bought tastes good or bad, I'll always wonder if the other option would have been better. Until I taste the other cereal, I'm left questioning my decision, and being unhappy.
- jeorgun 12y agoIt seems to me that, in pretty much every field, the most rewarding tasks, often with the most highly regarded results, are the most constrained— rhyming schemes and meter in poetry, immutability in programming, whatever. It could just be freedom from the anxiety of choice (and just admiration for the creator's ability to succeed despite these constraints on the part of the audience). I feel like there's more to it than that, though.
- ctchocula 12y agoI've felt this when deciding what kind of yogurt to buy at the supermarket. There were simply too many varieties, so I often ended up not getting any, because I couldn't be bothered to decide.
- Throwaway823 12y agoThere are a couple of popular TED talks about choice. http://www.ted.com/talks/barry_schwartz_on_the_paradox_of_choice http://www.ted.com/talks/barry_schwartz_on_the_paradox_of_ch... It's something to keep in mind with your development work as well. Let's say you create an application to minify javascript. Your app has an input field, and a button that says 'Go', and that's it. Very simple, no confusion, people love it. However, you notice 5% of people don't use the app, because they want to keep comments in their minified code, and you don't include that option. A lot of developers decide they'll add a checkbox to include comments, because now everyone can be happy. It doesn't quite work that way, because now the 95% of people that don't want comments see this checkbox, and start to question themselves. Wait, why do people want comments included in their minified code, should I be checking this box? Is there something I'm doing wrong? Do most people check the box or not, I'd like to know to validate my decision, otherwise I feel uneasy. The more options you add, the more this has an effect. In the end, maybe the 95% are feeling so uneasy, 10% of them leave to another app, that just has a 'Go' button again, so they feel confident, and more happy. So, by adding the checkbox to include comments, the 5% of people that were asking for the feature now start using the app, but you lose 10% of the original audience because of the additional choice. It's a difficult balance, and you really need to focus on the majority, and be careful about building out features the minority are requesting. If you look at apps like Twitter or Snapchat (or Yo, on the extreme side, and not yet proven), they succeed by limiting the amount of choice available to users. Many developers would have added more options, or in the case of Twitter given users the ability to write longer tweets because it seems harmless, but at the same time, it would have caused the businesses to fail.
- saurik 12y ago> In the end, maybe the 95% are feeling so uneasy, 10% of them leave to another app, that just has a 'Go' button again, so they feel confident, and more happy. You can't knowingly hide from choice: the existence of a different application that only has the Go button is not an escape, it is just yet another choice. The exact same story you described within the microcosm of the single application now plays out between the two applications, as the prospective user wonders why the application with the checkbox exists, as its very existence implies that maybe they should carefully consider whether they should be checking that box. Only now there are even more complex issues to decide: do the two applications even work the same in the situation that don't check the box? Now, even if you kind of think you want the comments, maybe you should be using this new application because maybe it works better in some way you don't quite understand... so you have to research the two applications or even test them against your files, coming up with your own (potentially flawed!) metric of comparison. Your model thereby only works for the percentage of people who have only heard about one application or the other: anyone who saw both applications has also seen the checkbox, and the choice inherently must have been decided in order for them to now be using the second application. Even if the first application is discontinued, the user will forever wonder if the newer applications they are forced to use instead are flawed because they don't have the checkbox, and despite never having actually checked the box, might question sometimes why someone would have even added such a checkbox were it not sometimes a good idea, and now the uneasiness simply consumes what they are working on: the task of minifying JavaScript itself maybe can never be satisfying. To the extent to which people actually are "leaving" an application because it has too many options, I thereby argue the real problem is not decision fatigue or crippling doubt, but in fact simply "confusion": they don't actually know what all the options do, or find the process of setting the options frustrating, and thereby move to a simpler application not because it frees them from having to make decisions (as again: decisions can only ever accumulate, they can never be taken away), but because it makes the process of actually using the application more straightforward and less cluttered. You also can't model "limits" as removed decisions: Twitter limiting me to 140 characters actually makes my word choice really matter... I end up having to draft multiple versions of what I need to say in the hope of finding one that I can whittle to under 140 characters. I have friends help me decide which of the variants conveys the idea the best, and sometimes I have to decide to split the message into multiple parts (but as each will be replied to and retweeted separately, deciding what information needs to be replicated in both, but in a way that isn't awkward, is itself a difficult decision). I often just go "bah, this is too complex", and not send anything; whereas on Facebook or reddit, where I have no length limits, I tend to just type something and send it: with this comment, while I did a little editing afterwards, it was nowhere near the ordeal that happens when I have to start making decisions due to hitting a limit. I would in fact argue that all limits lead to decisions: a limit is effectively a constrained resource, and now you have to decide how to spend that constrained resource to best accomplish your goal; a system that does not impose a limit frees the user to always do what felt most natural in the moment, however wasteful. The argument with Twitter not breaking free of their SMS-limited history is usually along the lines of either "if the messages are so long people won't be able to quickly read a bunch of them", not "giving people the ability to type a lot means they will not bother typing at all"... I think we can attest to the shear volume of trite YouTube comments to demonstrate that people are quite happy stopping typing once they've stated their peace ;P.
- sitkack 12y agoThe decisions are difficult because the gradient between them is low. So as https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8124172 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8124172 says, just pick one. Humans are great a ranking from a low number of choices. Too many choices or of similar quality and our ranking mechanisms break down.
- scotty79 12y ago> Lipowski thought of Buridan’s ass: an apocryphal donkey that finds itself standing between two equally appealing stacks of hay. > ... > While Lipowski’s work received some immediate wide attention, it soon fell into relative obscurity. > ... > Schwartz would then popularize and rename as the paradox of choice No wonder. It's so much easier to be told that you are experiencing a paradox than to be told that you are behaving like an ass. Buridan’s or not.
- wmkn 12y agoThis article focuses on the choice you have as a consumer. Which brand, which flavor, which stack of hay? But I observe a similar crippling effect when working on software. Every step along the way of producing a software product involves making an incredible amount of choices. Choices like, 'what platform?', 'what programming language?', 'which algorithm?', etc. I believe that the the freedom we have as a software engineers forces us to make more choices than in any other engineering discipline. There is a certain anxiety involved in make such engineering choices. Will this choice work out in the end, or am I going to waste a lot of time implementing and later reversing this for the other option?
- godDLL 12y agoAnecdote/data-point 90% of my side-projects never got out of "playing with the tech stack" phase. It is definitely not optimal, but is pretty common methinks.
- scotty79 12y ago> The choices between those objects that they valued most highly were both the most positive and the most anxiety-filled. The more choices they had—the study was repeated with up to six items per choice—the more anxious they felt. This sounds like nothing more than loss aversion. Until you make the choice you have opportunity to acquire some valuable things. When you make the choice you've lost all the things you didn't choose. This leads to easy ways of alleviating anxiety. You just need to mentally devalue all the things you are supposed to choose from and when you make the choice, immediately devalue things you haven't chosen even more (getting hyped over the thing you just chose won't help because anxiety comes not for the lack of appreciation of what you gained but for too much appreciation for the things you've lost opportunity to obtain).
- judk 12y agoSadly this is the sort of rationalizing that uunderlies racism/tribalism: hating people who are different feels better than feeling left out of their goodness.
- scotty79 12y agoIn Poland there is very famous children's rhymed short story about a donkey regarding this paradox of choice, so polish children are very early confronted with this paradox and warned about possible consequences (donkey dies of hunger in the end). Rhymed form makes it stick so good that we even have a saying for describing person experiencing paradox of choice that is literally the first line of this story. Story: http://pl.wikisource.org/wiki/Chciwo%C5%9B%C4%87_os%C5%82a http://pl.wikisource.org/wiki/Chciwo%C5%9B%C4%87_os%C5%82a Saying: http://pl.wiktionary.org/wiki/osio%C5%82kowi_w_%C5%BC%C5%82oby_dano http://pl.wiktionary.org/wiki/osio%C5%82kowi_w_%C5%BC%C5%82o...
- blue1 12y agoThis article is a bit shallow. I recommend Schwarz's book, The Paradox of Choice; it's a fun read and I found it very insightful.
- gone35 12y ago"(...) a concept that the Swarthmore University psychologist Barry Schwartz would then popularize and rename as the paradox of choice." Last time I checked, there is no such a thing as "Swarthmore University": Barry Schwartz is affiliated with Swarthmore College instead [1,2,3]. Might seem pedantic, but the New Yorker of yore would never let such a slip --online or not. Such editing. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Paradox_of_Choice:_Why_More_Is_Less http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Paradox_of_Choice:_Why_More... [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barry_Schwartz_(psychologist) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barry_Schwartz_(psychologist) [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swarthmore_College http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swarthmore_College
- Tloewald 12y agoIt is a pretty big error by New Yorker standards. I expect it will be fixed.
- alexvr 12y agoI spent months of my freshman year highly anxious for similar first-world reasons. I excel at and enjoy lots of things and felt like school was making me commit to one field. I would spend days very inactive, stressing out about, for example, the pros and cons of being a game programmer versus an embedded software engineer or something. I could never seem to settle on one area. I thought game programming was a waste of engineering talent, but I found everything else about it extremely appealing. Luckily I'm over that crap now, as I accept what I knew all along: that it's not what you major in that defines you. It's what you do in life that matters. It also helps to be in a field that applies to virtually everything else (CS). I'd go even more crazy if I were in some highly specialized field. Strangely, I'd say the best cure for this is a brief existential crisis.
- kelukelugames 12y agoI was ecstatic when I got my first job offer. Then I got a second. And a few more rolled in. Choosing became the most stressful part of the job hunt. The companies I didn't pick made monster gains in the stock market --30% in one month. Cry me a river, right?
- gtremper 12y agoI feel realizing that one's stressing over "first world" types of problems just makes it worse by adding shame to the mix.
- joereggan190 12y agohttp://www.bungie.net/en/Clan/Post/164142/67254664 http://www.bungie.net/en/Clan/Post/164142/67254664
- Zigurd 12y agoThe article doesn't distinguish between freedom to choose, and getting a ridiculous amount of trivial choice blasted at you in order to sell things. The latter is unnatural and psychologically abusive, and could easily cause stress. But even supposed political freedom may be overrated. A demarchy might very well be better-performing, more representative, and less corruptible than an elected government. After all, term limits, devolution to more local government, and other "reforms" are just an approximation of demarchy. We sure don't get representation from our current system, but we do give authoritarians a veneer of legitimacy by voting. That's pretty stressful. This is relevant to the Internet because the value and effectiveness of ads are an ongoing controversy, while at the same time funding much of what we use.
- Sealy 12y agoCognitive dissonance is a similar concept that is not new. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_dissonance http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_dissonance As quoted from that article: "Cognitive dissonance is also useful to explain and manage post-purchase concerns. If a consumer feels that an alternate purchase would have been better, it is likely he/she will not buy the product again. To counter this, marketers have to convince buyers constantly that the product satisfies their need and thereby helps reduce their cognitive dissonance, ensuring repurchase of the same brand in the future." Sounds like the writer is referring to cognitive dissonance. Leon Festinger published his work on cognitive dissonance in 1959 making his discovery 11 years before Lipowski's publication in 1970 (as referenced by the article). Festinger in my mind is the godfather of this theory. Anyone agree? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leon_Festinger http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leon_Festinger
- dmnd 12y agoThis is why I hate that cinemas offer a choice between 2D and 3D. I just want to see whatever the director intended and not have to try to hunt down which version is 'better'. Offering a choice makes going to the movies socially into an awkward experience. Inevitably there are people with diverging strong opinions and suddenly a social get together turns into dispute mediation. I think that if there was only one option, people would just deal with it. Now I dread inviting certain people to the movies because I want a social experience without endlessly dragging up the 2D vs 3D debate.
- ggchappell 12y agoI wonder if this phenomenon might be the primary factor in certain kinds of delayed marriage. I'm thinking, for example, of two people in their late 20s who have been dating for 5 years, figure marriage is in their future, but don't "feel ready".
- dredmorbius 12y agoI see a lot of decisionmaking especially as it's foisted on the public in commercial choices to be largely false alternatives. That is, there are a large number of options presented, under the guise of "choice is good", for which the ultimate effects of the outcome are "it doesn't matter". The choices are also often not presented in a way that makes discriminating between alternatives straightforward. I'm reminded of a financial news program whose sponsor for a time was a credit card company bragging about "over 3,000 choices for consumers" in credit card options. That is, frankly, stupidly excessive. But there are ways to present choices in a way which offers a very high level of tailoring of options without overwhelming the user with those options. I like to use the example of automobile heating/cooling controls common in the 1980s-1990s (the tendency toward thermostatic controls is changing this now). For American car manufacturers, the preferred style was a heat control lever which went from low to high, a fan switch, usually with "flow", "lo", "med" ,and "hi" settings, and a vent + AC selector. This would allow for dash, floor, or defrost vents to be selected, as well as another addition set of vent settings in which AC was enabled. The presentation always struck me as confusing, and there were a number of vent/AC settings which weren't reachable. This is pretty typical: http://www.autopartsdb.net/images/productimg/C/CX1884.JPG http://www.autopartsdb.net/images/productimg/C/CX1884.JPG Imports from Japan and Europe typically had four controls: a fan switch, a heat slider or dial, and a vent selector, plus an independent AC control. The method seemed a lot more sensible to me: are you hot (turn up the heat) or cold (turn on the AC), how much air do you want flowing (fan) and where do you want it (vent selector). Figuring out how to set the controls always seemed far more intuitive to me than the American controls. Typical: http://www.autoecu.com/images/ebay/01%20-%2007%20TOYOTA%20HIGHLANDER%20MANUAL%20CLIMATE%20CONTROL%20REBUILD.jpg http://www.autoecu.com/images/ebay/01%20-%2007%20TOYOTA%20HI... One more recent modification is that often the AC is automatically activated (and sometimes cannot be deactivated) when defrost is selected, as the humidity reduction tends to improve defrost performance. There's a similar design issue I've noticed particularly with clothes washers, where one style seems to specify the type of article you're washing: "knits", "delicates", "colors", "whites", and the other the specific wash conditions you want: water temperature, a See: http://content.aolstatic.net/ProductImages/rvLarge/ZWG6141P_WH_WashingMachine_CP1_AR_L.jpg http://content.aolstatic.net/ProductImages/rvLarge/ZWG6141P_... (article descriptions) vs. load size, temperature, options, and agitator settings: http://www.ajmadison.com/ajmadison/images/large/GTWP1800DWW_control.jpg http://www.ajmadison.com/ajmadison/images/large/GTWP1800DWW_... My observation is that I know the settings I want to apply, and where "outcomes" controls are specified, I've got to translate these into the settings I hope to achieve. What I prefer are options which allow me to select for settings, preferably along a range (e.g., heater intensity, fan power). Another point is that in consumer goods, the distinctions between products very nearly always simply doesn't matter. In a Starbucks world, there's a coffee roaster I love which has an exceptionally simple product line. Light roast. Dark roast. Regular. Decaffinated. And you can get your beans whole or ground if you like. But basically four choices. The beans are, of course, excellent. I've elected for choice in many food purchases by avoiding mainstream grocery stores (the news late this week of P&G killing off a bunch of brands strikes me as comically irrelevant). While I've fewer "options" than MegaMonSantoFoods when shopping at Trader Joes, what I do have are generally simpler, less expensive, less processed, and healthier products. I've long since abandoned prepared breakfast cereals for oats (and add my own nuts, dried fruit, or other ingredients as I prefer). Fresh fruit and vegetables, meat, dairy, and eggs are generally non-branded. Store products for cleaning, or vinegar and baking soda (both of which are surprisingly difficult to find in straighforward bulk forms) work fine. And the costs are lower. My personal sense is that branding jumped the shark somewhere in the 1970s to 1980s, though we're only just starting to be aware of this in a broader sense.
- joereggan190 12y agohttp://www.bungie.net/en/Clan/Post/164700/67295913 http://www.bungie.net/en/Clan/Post/164700/67295913
- joereggan190 12y agohttp://www.bungie.net/en/Clan/Post/165438/67351226 http://www.bungie.net/en/Clan/Post/165438/67351226
- joereggan190 12y agohttp://labs.sapo.pt/~projects/Unite/ticket/141055 http://labs.sapo.pt/~projects/Unite/ticket/141055
- joereggan190 12y agohttp://strasbourg.craigslist.fr/res/4612013393.html http://strasbourg.craigslist.fr/res/4612013393.html