4 ms·
What's the point of HN?
Is HN for discussion? If it is then why are dissenting opinions, that are well made and not troll-like, down-voted. Moreover if down-votes are intended to indicate only dissent (as I've been informed), not indicate low value remarks, then why is it considered beneficial to fade out such remarks.
Is HN supposed to be a sounding chamber or is the idea to foment useful discussion? Perhaps instead it's primarily just a link sharing tool?
The main stimulus to my question is how time and again good comments [that often I disagree with] are down-voted (presumably, vote numbers are hidden of course). Then the site admins deem that these comments need to be made difficult to read. This suggest that high-value discussion is not the point of the site; instead it serves to establish a narrow consensus and silence other voices.
So what is HN for?
- krapp 12y agoI believe that HN is an open forum that wants to be a closed forum. It appears to have been designed around the principle that a singular, consistent concept of "quality" exists, primarily due to the homogeneous nature of the original community, and the assumption that this community would likely find only a narrow subset of topics relevant. Fading out remarks is one example of such a bias in effect - were there only one type of poster and, predictably, one set of qualifiable opinions on HN, then the effect of censorship from a single user downvoting another and rendering their comments more difficult to read could be construed as acting on behalf of the community's standards as a whole, rather than reinforcing the bias of a particular subset or group. Although some faded comments are obvious trolls, rudeness or spam, disagreement for any reason (spoken or otherwise) leads to globally visual censorship. Arguably, the more faded a comment is, the more 'justifiable' that censorship can be, in terms of representing the community. However, this does suggest that barely faded comments are, themselves, more noise than signal. Also, more obvious examples of incorrect downvotes, i've found, tend to be corrected over time. Also, there is a subset of downvotes which were meant to be upvotes but they just fat-fingered the wrong button. There is also a principle at work behind several design aspects of the site, intended to stave off the "Eternal September" syndrome. Fading out unpopular comments, whatever the reason may be for that unpopularity, may be a way of discouraging participation of any kind with threads which could even remotely be considered of 'low quality'.
- jack-r-abbit 12y agoYes, there is a certain amount of hive-mind here and with certain topics you are best to not go against this groupthink if you value your karma. But since karma doesn't really have any value (beyond unlocking additional features) you should be able to speak your mind even if it is unpopular. Down-voting is not meant to be for well formed opinions you disagree with... but it does happen. More often, down-voting is for comments that are off point, personal attacks, general rudeness, and other things that are bad form.
- minimaxir 12y agoIt should be noted that there's a big difference between an unpopular opinion and a misinformed opinion, the latter of which typically causes downvotes depending on tone. I rarely see super-gray posts for going against the grain.
- jack-r-abbit 12y agoSome topics are worse than others. Threads about Snowden or piracy are usually littered with grey posts that go against the ideas that Snowden is a god and piracy is just fine.
- mkal_tsr 12y agoAnother one I found is that advocating for privacy is a quick way for downvotes. Lots of users here run businesses that thrive on user-generated data so it makes sense they would prefer more control and liberty with the data in their service, to the dismay of some users/consumers.
- minimaxir 12y agoThose topics are a fair counterpoint. :P
- deedubaya 12y agoIt's a forum where people can post their hard work, and the rest of the community can poke holes in it and leave snarky comments. Or a techy/nerdy link aggregator, maybe?
- pbhjpbhj 12y ago... and if people disagree with someone's well made snarky comments do you think that the site should try and make those comments hard to read?
- staunch 12y agoIt's where hackers come to share and shoot the shit. It used to be somewhat more welcoming and friendly when it was small. But it's grown like 1000x since those days. YC is working on it.
- jcr 12y agoThe underlying point of HN has always been contribution. Sure, that's a terribly bold assertion for me, a regular nobody, to make, but it's how I've always seen HN. Since this is the open Internet, I'm sure there's someone who will tell me that I'm wrong, or down-vote me because they disagree, but I'm fine with dissent. Dissent and disagreement are the price of admission when we voice our opinions. My personal opinion is mostly useless outside of a rare few places where I happen to have some experience. The important thing I try to remember is HN is full of people with a great deal more experience than I have in particular fields. I try to learn from their contributions, so I really do appreciate their efforts. One of the possible ways they contribute is by down-voting me or stating their disagreement with me. Either way, I learn something new, so I still appreciate their efforts. If pg replied to me and told me that I got it all wrong, and I got clobbered with a bazillion down-votes, then I'm the person who just learned something new, albeit the hard way. Everyone else also gets to learn from my rather public mistakes. Those funny little up and down vote buttons exist for good reason, but how to use them has never formally been defined (to my knowledge) by any of the people running HN/YC. The complete lack of defining usage has always seemed to be entirely intentional; with every feature of HN, you are expected and trusted to use it wisely. You are being trusted with privileges of voting, flagging, submitting, and commenting. If you abuse the trust and the privileges, you'll lose them. All people suffer from the same delusion; we believe our own interests are interesting to others. When you try to make a contribution of something interesting and useful, and you miserably "fail" by all noticeable metrics like points, then once again, you learn something new. I can honestly say that my interests are rarely interesting to others. If you don't believe me, go look at the "submissions" link in my profile to prove the point. Though you can't see the point counts on my comments, I'll openly admit that my comments fare no better than my submissions. If take a look, you'll see that I "fail" regularly, but I keep trying to contribute useful and interesting things. An important number to look at is the "avg" in the user profile. It is the average score on comments you make. The default value for each comment is 1, an "avg" below one means your comments are a hindrance in the eyes of your fellow HN contributors, and an "avg" above one means your comments are successfully contributing to discussions. If your "avg" is about 2, then on average every time you comment, at least one person appreciated the effort of your contribution, and put in their effort to up-vote your comment. Check out the avg for the HN user grellas [1]. Every time he puts in the effort to type one of his infamously fantastic comments, at least 53+ people appreciated it (and remembered to scroll back up and give him an up-vote ;-). Even if you disagree with him on something, you can still appreciate the effort he put into his contribution, and the experience and expertise behind his opinions... Yes, you can disagree with someone, and still appreciate their effort enough to return the favor in kind with your up-vote. Since there are no rules or guidelines on voting, you're free to use your votes wisely. I tend to lack useful experience and expertise on most subjects, so all I have is my generally uninformed opinions. Some people in my position will sit quietly and learn from others, but other people in my position will try to become informed enough to ask good questions. A good question is a contribution. I doubt the good questions get up-voted as much as the deserve since most of the attention goes to the person who shows up with a good answer. I really really try to remember to up-vote the good questions, but I'm sure I forget more often than not. Just like everybody else, I'm regularly distracted by the good answers, and after reading the good answer, the good question always seems less useful. I'd bet there's some cognitive bias at work in all this, but sadly, I can't name it. Sometimes good answers are opinions backed by experience and expertise, but other times good answers are backed by references. I'm just a sucker for up-voting answers with references, in fact, I scan for them. Down-votes happen to everyone, so learn what you can divine form the experience, and let it go. It's just a fact of life that someone on the Internet will probably disagree vehemently. Also, mistakes happen in voting, and there's no way to correct your own voting mistakes. The down-voting feature is a privilege you earn. I've always been strongly in the "up-vote-the-good-stuff" camp, so something needs to be fairly egregious for me to down-vote it. For me, vehemently disagreeing is never enough to warrant a down-vote. There needs to be some aspect of malice. The same is true and to a higher degree for flags. Just like everybody else on the planet, I've got a lot of practice being wrong and uninteresting, so I try to be tolerant with others. The site moderators do not make the down-voted comments fade, the HN forum code [3] running on the server does this automatically. The mods get unfairly blamed for a lot of things they don't actually do, and most of the misplaced blame is due to users not understanding or studying the available forum code and docs. HN was originally written as a test of a new programming language called "arc" [4], but most users are unprepared to invest the time to learn a new language and understand the forum code base. I am fluent, well, was fluent, in a few related Lisp dialects, and I've only put in the time to barely scratch the surface of how the HN forum code really works. The only person I have to blame for not knowing all the details is myself. A primary problem with all discussion forums and user supported link aggregation sites is the endless competition for both the attention and effort of others. Most of the HN Guidelines [2] can be written as a single guideline, "Don't be the jerk begging, baiting, or manipulating others for their attention and effort." If you're like me and reliably "fail" at contributing useful and interesting comments and submissions according to the flawed metric of points, then you still ought to be happy. You tried to contribute, and you had the courage to put your own interests out there for others to judge, but far more importantly, the lack of points also implies the lack of using attention grabbing engagement tactics, so you just succeeded at staying out of the endless fray of countless attention seekers. If linkbait outrage porn or regurgitation reporting is far more popular by the metric of up-votes over time, then I'm actually grateful that my interests are elsewhere. It just means I have a much better chance to contribute something different, unexpected, and hopefully interesting. Lastly you get the references, but please realize they are not intended to support my personal opinions. Those are my own, and right or wrong, I hope they're useful and interesting for you and everyone else. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=grellas https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=grellas [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html [3] https://github.com/HackerNews/HN https://github.com/HackerNews/HN [4] http://arclanguage.org http://arclanguage.org
- DanBC 12y agoYou make a mistake when you say downvotes are only for disagreement. Some people do not use them for disagreement and only ever use them to indicate unsuitable posts.
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoI would agree - I would be horrified to find people down voting because they disagreed with a statement of position or opinion. Downvotes indicate the comment is not part of a constructive conversation. We all want to find places where we can be heard and part of that price is listening to others. If you can't do both, you can't be part of a conversation.
- DanBC 12y ago> I would be horrified to find people down voting because they disagreed with a statement of position or opinion. Eh, I'm not bothered if people downvote to disagree. I'd rather they did that than bickered at me.
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoThat's because karma points aren't important. What if the downvoted were written in the anti-union blacklist handed round the mine owners, or added to the security clearance files or ... Open transparent discourse.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoI actually got in a discussion about it wherein I was saying "downvotes are for low value comments" and was heavily corrected by a site regular. IIRC they quoted pg at me and unfortunately since then I've felt HN's ethos is "downvote disagreement". Ah, found it, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7446824 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7446824 [you're in that thread DanBC!]. I thought how I asked the question indicated I disproved, but this should make it clear.