3 ms·
Actually it is not. In some respect their are probably less regulated and less constrained by what we think are the true "free" market (US). The lack of constra
by rdtsc 12y ago
Actually it is not. In some respect their are probably less regulated and less constrained by what we think are the true "free" market (US). The lack of constraints doesn't come from lack of laws or rules but from non-enforcement and corruption. And, well, nothing says free market like getting the quickest and fastest way to your goal -- bribe your way out, install and control lobbyists, buy up all the competitors and so on. So in that respect one can say they are more free than Americans. (But then again, if one considers the power of lobbying, and revolving doors between industries and agencies regulating then maybe US does have the free-est market of all -- the government is just a branch of each of the large companies).
On a side note of "free" markets: I often hear from deluded libertarians "oh man, FDA (or other such govt agency) is so evil, controlling our lives, so ineffective and corrupt it should be abolished, and people know better what it good to eat". That argument is fine and dandy because we know this "libertarian paradise" doesn't exists, so they can argue and compare a fictional (Ayn Rand-ian ?) universe with a real world and then criticize the real world based on it. Which like comparing Star Wars space ships to real world Navy ships. ("My dilithium crystals are 100x as powerful as your 2 nuclear reactors!")
My response is usually that I invite them to take a plane ride, not into another universe or the future, but across "the pond" to Africa or any 3rd world country with an effectively non-functioning FDA (or similar agency). Where anyone can sell you anything without any controls or checks or worrying about being punished. Vegetables laced with deadly chemicals but that look good on the exterior. You'll get cancer in a couple of years but good luck finding that one vendor. Things like that. The interesting thing is that these "free market" libertarian paradises exist, except they are always failed and corrupt states and they are pretty terrible places to live in.
- true_religion 12y agoI'd say the Liberarian (capital L) paradise is premised on the existence of easily transferred information about vendors and customers, and people having both the education and agency to make the best use of the free market. I mean pointing at failed states as examples of a libertarian state, is like pointing at the corrupt Italian city-states at an example of republicanism. Just because no good examples exist during this time period, doesn't mean no good examples can possible exist.
- rdtsc 12y ago> paradise is premised on the existence of easily transferred information about vendors and customers, and people having both the education and agency to make the best use of the free market. That is what I meant by comparing fictitious hypothetical entities to real life example. This is not unlike Communism. Every single failed instance of it was excused as "well it wasn't true Communism". At least one can say it was attempted. > I mean pointing at failed states as examples of a libertarian state, Well in my first part I alluded that perhaps China is closer to the ideal libertarian state because there are ways to bypass the governmental control (even though on paper they have more control). The fact that one can sell baby formula laced with chemicals on a large scale is kind of an example of that.
- icebraining 12y agoFree markets require respect for private property. China is a place where private property has only been respected by the law less than a decade ago, where the State owns all the land and you can only lease it, and even then you can get beaten to death if you refuse to accept an expropriation. You can't just say "deregulated == free markets". A free market economy is a market-based economy where prices for goods and services are set freely by the forces of supply and demand and are allowed to reach their point of equilibrium without intervention by government policy. This does not exist in China. China is a corporatist state, not a laissez-faire economy.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoThere are no functioning laissez-faire economies that I know of.
- icebraining 12y agoI don't disagree. It might be that they're impossible. All I'm saying is that China is not even close to one.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoChina is dysfunctional, where the maxim of ask for forgiveness (or avoid detection) reigns over ask for permission. Hong Kong and Singapore are often touted as the freest economically, but both are effectively smallish city states. Living in china makes you appreciate the USA's EPA, however.