3 ms·
Whether you approach society from a primarily cooperative (collectivist) approach or from a primarily competitive (capitalist) direction, both angles eventually
by ilaksh 12y ago
Whether you approach society from a primarily cooperative (collectivist) approach or from a primarily competitive (capitalist) direction, both angles eventually have the same problem: over-centralization, which stifles the freedom and diversity necessary for a system to evolve. Or, they may have a different problem with too much fragmentation and lack of coherence.
What we need is a system that is both holistic and coherent but also componentized and diverse.
There is quite a lot of techno-communist thinking going around that fails to recognize this problem of over-centralization which has numerous times in the past shown how dangerous and repressive it can be. A hierarchical system, like a tree, has vulnerabilities and entrenchment in each root or branch.
The last time I said something like this, a Marxist just told me I was asking for two contradictory things that was impossible, and implied that the answer was Marxism.
How can we have a system that is well-organized, with different parts that are aware of eachother and the big picture without a lot of redundancy and waste or counter-productivity, but at the same time is set up in a way that makes it free to experiment and form new directions and even refactor old ones?
I think that is actually a very hard problem, but one that can be solved. If anyone knows of a good approach let me know.