6 ms·
Software Pipelining on the Mill CPU [video]
- hahainternet 12y agoI have yet to go through this talk but I have been waiting for this for a while. Mill is possibly the most interesting thing in all of computing right now.
- nraynaud 12y agoI really feel like a brainless fanboy too, I'm watching everything about this company. Not being an expert in CPU design, I know I lack the knowledge to criticize what I see, I'm just slurping marketing material straight from the bullshit hose, but I can't help myself, I love it.
- hahainternet 12y agoOne of the things about Mill that feels reassuring is that the information is being presented slowly, step by step to people who have good reason to give a shit. If it was purely marketing, they'd have a kickstarter up and be promising performance figures without a billion caveats.
- XorNot 12y agoHate to say it, but there's nothing new under the sun when it comes to marketing. Everyone tries everything and modifies based on how well it works. A lot of slow information is the same as trying to go for the quick money. At the end of the day, the problem with the Mill is there's no hardware implemented. No real world benchmarks to be had, and the world of hardware design is full of seemingly slamdunk ideas which have giant problems in actual implementation. This isn't to disparage the Mill or its team - but the content and results are important. Not the style of the message. Anyone can style a message.
- RyanMiller 12y agoI see this posted every time Mill gets linked. Could someone simply explain the significance of the Mill architecture?
- willvarfar 12y ago(Mill team, so biased; thanks for the chance to pitch ;) We are a DSP that can run general purpose code. Traditionally, to run general purpose code fast you needed an out-of-order superscalar architecture, as all the x86 and RISC cores are these days. DSPs have substantially better performance and substantially better efficiency, but have traditionally been ineffective executing general purpose code (such as the web browser you are using to read this). The Mill is a synergy of lots of small breakthroughs that together deliver significant improvements to general purpose single threaded code. Its been held that cores have stopped getting faster. We're faster. And we have similar as yet not filed improvements for multicore too.
- rrmm 12y agoCan you say anything about where you are on the path towards silicon implementation or is it all still under wraps?
- willvarfar 12y agoWe are working towards the FGPA. Its very early days, but the HW team is very experienced.
- thesz 12y agoWow. Finally. I've seen this Mill occdasionally pitching and always have been asking the same question: are your results from simulation or from FPGA? Now I know the answer. The most suspicious thing in Mill is that belt thing. To produce operands for N operations you need N*3 (2 for reads, one for write) ports of RAM. For even two operations that means 6 ports. No FPGA allow that out-of-the-box. Given that, you have to implement that in registers and logic, wasting FPGA resources. (AFAIK, silicon fabs also does not have such RAM blocks. you have to build them themselves, either from registers and logic (and make them slow) or using transistors (which make development process slow). this is THE source of relative slowness of Itanium and Elbrus thing from Russia.) If you want an advice, go for Tabula. You'll need many R/W ports per block of RAM, they seem to have those (12 ports RAM blocks). Maybe your design won't be as slow as I think it will.
- Lai0chee 12y ago/me has a deja vu. Looks like this is Transmeta v2. :-)
- ema 12y agoTheir risk profile is quite different from Transmeta. Transmeta was more of an all or nothing thing. Either they were better at running x86 in which case they easily could capture big segments of the market, or they were not in which case no segment of the market would be interested in them. The Mill on the other hand can just start with the segment of the market that is the least inconvenienced by having to recompile their code and expand from there. So basically it's easier for the Mill to gain a foothold (build the best cpu for one segment) but harder to climb up from there.
- ktsmith 12y agoThanks for that differentiator, Transmeta kept popping into my thoughts every time I would read about Mill as well.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- viggity 12y agothe long hair and beard makes me think this is legit. joking aside, seeing this talk makes me nostalgic for college and the long nights spent in the CprE labs. I ended up not in hardware/firmware because 4/5GL are so much more fun to work with and let me be so much more expressive. However, this shit is seriously cool. Can't wait to learn more. edit: also wanted to say the presentation is a perfect example of awesome UX. The animations are not superfluous as in most presentations and are quite meaningful and help the audience better understand the material. It is also an example of something with great UX, but poor aesthetics. Green/yellow text on a blue background, eck. Could have been worse though :)
- holoiii 12y agoDude looks like Gandalf
- nkurz 12y agoAlmost everything posted here about the Mill CPU has been in video form. I'm very interested in reading more about it, but don't have the patience for videos. I like to be able to skim, and to choose my own pace. As a result of this personal preference/failing, I know very little about the CPU or the company. Clearly the Mill team likes the video format, but are there written expositions for people like me? I have to think I'm not the only one who is video-averse. The very sparse FAQ on the website (http://millcomputing.com/category/faq/general/ http://millcomputing.com/category/faq/general/) says that there are a few white papers in process. Are any of these available yet?
- willvarfar 12y agoWe have an intro here: http://millcomputing.com/topic/introduction-to-the-mill-cpu-programming-model-2/ http://millcomputing.com/topic/introduction-to-the-mill-cpu-... (Although it doesn't cover things in as much depth as the talks) We are working on a public facing wiki, and do actually have some white papers drafted. But these talks are not your average talks, and well worth trying even if you don't normally ;)
- dkersten 12y agoBut these talks are not your average talks, and well worth trying even if you don't normally ;) For me its not that I don't watch videos, its just that either I don't have time to watch a video (whereas reading I can do as fast or slow as I want and I can skim), or it happens that I'm unable to watch a video for whatever reason but would be ok with reading (this happens a lot while I'm travelling - also the most likely time where I would like to read something like this).
- ahomescu1 12y agoSome of the talks also have the slides posted on the Mill website (in .pptx format, I think).