3 ms·
I agree with all your theory. I thought the same thing. Then I went out and bought a programable thermostat, set it quite low overnight and during the day, and
by ams6110 12y ago
I agree with all your theory. I thought the same thing. Then I went out and bought a programable thermostat, set it quite low overnight and during the day, and warmer from 5-8 AM and 5-8 PM. My heating bill was higher than just maintaining 68-70 all the time. And that's not even counting the $100 I spent on the thermostat (now on a shelf in the garage, I put the old manual one back in its place).
- personZ 12y agoFrom a thermal energy perspective this simply isn't possible. However, some systems do lead to this because of flaws in the the implementation. My ground heat pump, for instance, has a backup electric heat system that it will automatically, and unavoidably, utilize if it hasn't reached the target temperature within a set, relatively short period of time. So in my very well insulated home I do indeed see significant cost increases if I do temperature setbacks, as the recovery period sees more expensive/less efficient electric heat kick in, versus just incrementally using the heat pump through the day. Some fuel-based systems go to a less efficient high-heat stage in the same sort of situation.
- davepage 12y agoA well designed thermostat should control the auxiliary and emergency heat when installed properly. http://www.behvac.com/troubleshooter41.htm http://www.behvac.com/troubleshooter41.htm http://support.nest.com/article/What-s-Emergency-Heat-and-does-Nest-support-it http://support.nest.com/article/What-s-Emergency-Heat-and-do...
- dredmorbius 12y agoI'd go with the resistance back-up heat argument here as well.
- mikeash 12y agoEither the laws of physics are different than well established theory says they are... or your thermostat didn't do a very good job. I vote for the second one.
- taejo 12y agoOr there is more than one physical effect in play: see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8112118 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8112118 -- there's air movement as well as heat, because your house is not a sealed box.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoPutting in heat over a short time, to recover from low temperatures, is different to putting in heat over an extended period. If your heater has very low efficiency at high heat output then it seems highly possible that extended low output could be better. It's a financial efficiency we're talking about primarily when people are looking to more efficiently heat their house. If you're heating with electric for example you can sometimes buy electricity far cheaper at night (demand is low and traditional production can be easily spun-down). Thus buying electricity all night and keeping the house warm, whilst using more electricity, could be cheaper than paying for peak rate electric. Physics alone could explain it in very rare circumstances - board construction that expands in warm air closing gaps, cool air opens gaps and causes more cooling. Heat exchange rate from in- to outside is then possibly greater at lower temperatures. Houses aren't simple to model.
- mikeash 12y agoVirtually all thermostat-controlled heating systems I've seen don't have different output levels, but are just on or off. So poor efficiency at high output wouldn't come into play. The rest is possible, but I'd file using expensive electricity instead of cheap electricity under the thermostat not doing a very good job, or more precisely the person setting it up not doing a good job of setting it up to run more cheaply.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoGas fired combi boilers (with centrally heated [pumped] cycling water) are pretty much the default in the UK. I've never seen one that didn't have output temp adjustments. I'd imagine that set highest (which should reach thermostat set target temp fastest) would produce greatest flue losses but I'm speculating there.
- happyscrappy 12y agoYou are heating the walls and floors which take a long time to come up to temp. I liken it to the difference between keeping large truck at 65mph compared to getting it up to speed.