6 ms·
> your emails become the business records of a cloud provider That is simply ridiculous. Email stored by a cloud provider isn't a business record of the provi
by lisper 12y ago
> your emails become the business records of a cloud provider
That is simply ridiculous. Email stored by a cloud provider isn't a business record of the provider any more than the contents of a physical letter stored in a rented mail box is a business record of the box provider.
- 616c 12y agoAnd soon they will argue that your mail is not your mail, and subject to legal protection, when it is in any USPS facility because it is government assets until it touches your mailbox. Granted, they already track all metadata without opening it (if you believe that). This is attrocious. I come from a family of attorneys and I have told them I lost all respect for the system in which they operate, and Jeffersonian calls to refresh the tree of liberty have started to seem very real and urgent these days. In short, fuck these animals. I hope they choke.
- rayiner 12y agoA physical letter in a rented mailbox is also generally not data-mined for the commercial purposes of the service provider. I think cloud companies essentially want the 4th amendment benefits of treating the cloud like real world private areas (e.g. bank lock boxes), without any of the obligations that come along with that. The "reasonable expectation of privacy" in things like safe deposit boxes or storage units is based on the actual fact that service providers generally do not and cannot access the contents of those rented spaces. To apply that same reasoning to data stored in the cloud, we have to indulge in the fiction that various bots and sysops cannot in fact access that data, and do not routinely do so. That said, I think the cloud folks are ultimately going to win, on the basis of Riley v. California (which is noted in Brad Smith's op-ed). I think Riley is technologically ignorant in glossing over technical distinctions between local and cloud storage that are relevant to privacy, but it all but says the cloud is protected under the 4th amendment. I don't know what's left to fight over.
- niels_olson 12y agoGmail is not the only cloud. Does Apple datamine icloud.com or me.com emails? The fact that the email may exist on multiple servers around the world (aka, cloud) doesn't per se mean the company is abusing the customer's trust.
- 67726e 12y agoAre you telling me that a banker does not have the capabilities to access a rented lock-box? That only the renter has that key? What then happens if a renter dies and that key is missing?
- lost_name 12y agoIf you're referring to safe deposit boxes, I believe they drill the lock and replace it.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- lisper 12y ago> The "reasonable expectation of privacy" in things like safe deposit boxes or storage units is based on the actual fact that service providers generally do not and cannot access the contents of those rented spaces. And the "reasonable expectation of privacy" in cloud email is based on the fact that, while computers necessarily have access to the data (it is not possible to provide email service otherwise), humans generally don't.
- harryh 12y agoIf you don't think that humans have access to the contents of your cloud hosted email service then I've got a bridge to sell you.
- eitland 12y agoThey have access to it yes, they just risk being fired if they nose into data unrelated to their job. (That is, at least for employees at one of the big ones. ;-)
- lisper 12y agoExactly. Employees at the UPS store can steam open your physical mail too. The question is whether you have a reasonable expectation of privacy, not whether you have actual privacy.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- arebop 12y agoSo cloud companies that want to preserve user's rights w/r/t to user data and doing email should not be able to do spam detection? Should they be able to adjust the markup in HTML emails such that the composition of emails into the web UI does not compromise the well-formed-ness of the page? Should they not be able to provide a "search" feature to locate emails that are relevant to a user's query? These sorts of things are all capabilities I expect in a local mail client; I think it's a reasonable to apply 4th amendment protections to the user's data, even if computation done on behalf of the user (including selecting relevant ads) happens in a remote datacenter using code the user didn't write. It is pretty ridiculous to treat users' emails the same as a grocery store's payroll when deciding whether customers have constitutional privacy safeguards.
- rayiner 12y agoAt the end of the day, the lynchpin of the 4th amendment is an objectively reasonable expectation of privacy. Not merely a subjective desire that the government not see certain information. With that in mind, I just don't see how you can say you have an objectively reasonable expectation of privacy over e-mails in the cloud, when a system operator can pull up all your personal information going back years at the touch of a button. When the e-mail service not only has incidental access to the data, but actively looks into that "private" data and uses that "private" data for commercial purposes. It's a distorted, results-oriented definition of "privacy." That said, you're likely going to get precisely that results-oriented interpretation, because apparently the Supreme Court, like most users, doesn't fully understand the scope of how cloud providers access and use and commercialize your data.
- watwut 12y agoHow is that different from regular mail? Any postman can open the mail, copy/read the content and then close envelope. It is maybe 5 minutes of work.
- rayiner 12y agoIts different because not only do mailmen not open mail as a matter of course, for advertising or operational purposes, its a felony to do so.
- pappyo 12y ago>they want the 4th amendment benefits of treating the cloud like real world private areas (e.g. bank lock boxes), without any of the obligations that come along with that. and... >That said, I think they're ultimately going to win. Warning: Total Conspiracy Theory Ahead Could this be an end-around by Microsoft to eliminate one of Google's main revenue streams? Follow me for a second. 1. Let's assume Microsoft wins this court case. By doing so, e-mails will be afforded the same protection, under the law, as physical letters. 2. A Microsoft backed plaintiff sues Google for data-mining her email's content, arguing under the same 4th Amendment ruling. 3. After years of legal procedures and court battles, Google (and all other e-mail providers) are forced throw away their master keys. Essentially all email is blind to the providers. 4. Google loses one of their larger revenue streams. Everyone loves a good conspiracy theory, so indulge me for the moment. Why would this not work (And for the record, I'm sure it wouldn't. But I would honestly like to know why.)?
- ncallaway 12y agoI think it goes off the rails in step 2. Private organizations are not bound by the 4th amendment. For the most part, the constitution defines the powers and limitations of the federal government (and to some extent the state governments). The government is the entity bound by the 4th amendment, not private companies. I think a more likely scenario is that we end up with a court ruling that says something along the lines of: "In order to preserve the customer's 4th amendment rights, the company hosting the e-mail mustn't be using it for business purposes." So, Google wouldn't be able to simultaneously mine your e-mails and guarantee that your e-mails are protected under the 4th amendment.
- pappyo 12y ago>I think it goes off the rails in step 2. This went off the rails well before I started to write it. But let me push back on your thoughts. If I am understanding Microsoft's argument correctly for this court case, they are trying to equate e-mails to letters. And, by extension, equate themselves to UPS/USPS/FedEx whathaveyou. E-mails are private correspondence, just like letters in the post. And please, correct me if I'm wrong in this assessment. It is also a felony in the US to open someone's mail. So wouldn't that same protection exist in email? Which would mean nobody can look at an email correspondence unless they were either the sender or receiver of said email.
- sophacles 12y agoDoes anyone know the case law for services that filter a person's mail for them? E.G if I employ a service that will open mail for me to weed out the junk and send me the good stuff, do my letters become business records? What if I also employ them to (going a step further), pay any bills that come in from my bank account? I think that this line has already been drawn. Tangential question: since the Supreme Court recently decided "do it with software" by itself is not sufficient (by itself) for software patents, can that precedent also be used for differentiating between letters and email? E.g. - letters with software is not enough distinction for 4th amendment bypass?