12 ms·
UK to allow driverless cars on public roads in January
- joncrocks 12y agoUK to allow tests of driverless cars on public roads to start in January. In the same way that has already begun in the rest of the world. Same legal/insurance issues stand (as elsewhere) and are likely the bigger barrier to adoption.
- matthewmacleod 12y agoThat's what it says, yes. Have such tests already begun the "the rest of the world"?
- nolok 12y agoThat's not what the title says.
- sysop073 12y agoI don't understand the distinction. If the UK is allowing tests of driverless cars, it must be allowing them on the roads, and of course "in January" means "starts in January", what else would it mean
- tlrobinson 12y agoWhile the title is technically true, it could easily be interpreted to mean anyone could buy or build a driverless car and drive it on UK roads starting in January.
- wlesieutre 12y agoDriverless cars are a risky unproven technology, and done wrong could easily kill people. It'd be like taking "FDA approves new drug for human testing" and making the headline "FDA to allow human use of new untested drug." Both are technically true, but the latter makes it sound like a widespread thing being done regardless of poorly understood risks. And that's misleading, since it's being done in very limited scope to help us understand and reduce those risks.
- silverbax88 12y agoIt is true that driverless cars are a risky unproven technology, while human-driven cars are a proven killer.
- Chronic29 12y agoSo tell your friends to stop driving.
- DanBC 12y ago"in January" could mean "only in January" rather than "for some unspecified length of time but starting in January".
- harty65 12y agoHowever the very first line of the article say's "from January", which implies the latter.
- missblit 12y agoIt's allowed in a few states in the US. Last time I went to California I saw one up close, that was pretty neat (though I don't know if it was driving itself at the time)!
- toomuchtodo 12y agoAudi is currently (as in this week) test driving self-driving cars on an elevated expressway in Tampa this week, that has been shut down for this purpose. http://www.wtsp.com/story/tech/2014/07/28/driverless-car-hits-tampa-bay-road-in-test/13258787/ http://www.wtsp.com/story/tech/2014/07/28/driverless-car-hit...
- joncrocks 12y agoAs tlrobinson says, I was trying to clarify the content of the article, as the title could easily be mis-interpreted to mean that there were no restrictions. In addition, I suspect that the cars will be 'self-driving' cars rather than 'driverless' (the distinction being that the former has a human behind the wheel, which can take the wheel at a moments notice). As for the rest of the world, from the article: The US States of California, Nevada and Florida have all approved tests of the vehicles. In California alone, Google's driverless car has done more than 300,000 miles on the open road. In 2013, Nissan carried out Japan's first public road test of an autonomous vehicle on a highway. And in Europe, the Swedish city of Gothenburg has given Volvo permission to test 100 driverless cars - although that trial is not scheduled to occur until 2017.
- Too 12y agoThe case of 100 volvo cars on the streets 2017 is a bit different than just allowing controlled tests on public roads, that is 100 cars given to customers for every day use, not engineers.
- seanflyon 12y agoI see a few driverless cars out and about each week.
- walshemj 12y agoVW has been testing the tech for decades looks like its almost ready for testing on the public roads. And I know they have been testing driverless farm machinery near where I live since the late 70's
- Someone1234 12y agoSince there are a total of zero commercially available driverless cars, was that distinction really required? Nowhere in the world has permitted non-test driverless cars because non-test driverless cars aren't a thing yet. The whole "rest of the world" remark seems like smug condescension. Which is a little odd as only a small handful of places even allow test-cars to be run on public roads. Plus isn't this a welcome addition? The UK's roads are quite a different test bed to many West coast US cities where there is no grid pattern, roads are smaller, and curvey.
- joncrocks 12y agoWell as this is a news site, the title could be interpreted as new, i.e. something new and interesting is happening. It would be perfectly possible (if not slightly, or very unfeasable) for a jurisdiction to be drafting laws regarding the legal use of new driving technologies, even before they before commercially available (arguably they would never be able to be commercially available until they were regulated/legal). Apologies is there was any condescension, I was only trying to convey that it's not that different to what's been going on elsewhere. I'm from the UK myself.
- pekk 12y agoI appreciated the clarification since I don't closely follow the situation, and the headline suggested to me that UK was somehow ahead of everyone else here.
- hueving 12y agoThere is no grid in most of the US either.
- alexhawdon 12y agoPerhaps less to do with the grid, but more the fact that your road systems were designed for the automotive era. In old residential areas driving can be very challenging after everybody's returned from home as streets barely wide enough for two cars to comfortably pass have cars parked up both sides. This obviously presents challenges such as driver etiquette (car needs to play nicely with others but still get you to your destination) and safety (children can lurk unseen between the cars and leap out out). Perhaps there are parts of America that are like this, but Hollywood hasn't shown many of them to me.
- smikhanov 12y agoWho will be a vendor of those cars? It seems to me that it's clear that driverless cars are the future, which is going to become real very soon. Any progressive government would (and should) allow such testing, even given the inflexibility of the state's bureaucratic machine. Allowing is an easy part. The hard part is actually building those cars and to my knowledge no UK firm does this at the moment.
- bluthru 12y agoMy guess is that a service like ZipCar will retrofit vehicles since car manufacturers do not have an incentive to reduce car ownership.
- jarek 12y agoSome car manufacturers will be perfectly happy to cannibalize the business, see e.g. Daimler's car2go
- timthorn 12y agoLots of the fundamental research is being done in the UK. Both academic (eg at Oxford) and also industry led. The fact that no major consumer automotive marques are British doesn't mean there isn't a very strong auto industry in the country.
- smikhanov 12y agoI mean more of a "who will build the technology to allow those cars be driverless", not who will build the car bodies themselves.
- suprgeek 12y agoWhen ever I see a new place or country allowing a test of these cars this wired article always comes to mind [1]. I think the two main questions will be liability & drivability - 1) when (not if) these cars get into a serious crash, who is to assume liability? Is it Google who created the algorithm? Is it the Audi integrator who fused Google technology into the Audi? Is it the fault of the mapping software that did not update the fact that the signals had been moved to a different position on that street? 2) More mundane - will a driverless car be able to drive every single place that a drivered car would? When a flash flood closes down the freeway will this autonomous beast be able to drive on the back road that is normally closed to traffic? Having said that I cannot wait for Cars-As-A-Service where the Cars park themselves & disappear when I don't need them and magically reappear when I do (without humans - Lyft, Uber et al. need not apply). [1] http://www.wired.com/2014/05/the-robot-car-of-tomorrow-might-just-be-programmed-to-hit-you/ http://www.wired.com/2014/05/the-robot-car-of-tomorrow-might...
- knocte 12y agowrt 1), I think it's preferable to study each scarce accident very closely to avoid it to happen again (like it happens in the aviation industry) rather than just being scared of the technology and remaining on the status-quo of allowing so many casualties each year because we still allow humans to drive.
- sudorank 12y agoExactly, once they get these vehicles right accidents will be a pretty rare thing. Until then it has to be a case of "tough" if you want to sue. The Victorians had the right attitude to future technology and it's something we need to get back to.
- andygates 12y agoNo, they had horrible workplace diseases and injuries and a dreadful attitude to health. If your business model includes telling potential litigants to man up, you're not going into space today.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- cordite 12y agoHow will the taxi unions feel when someone combines uber/lyft with self driving cars?
- stephenc_c_ 12y agoUber/Lyft will be the ones who make this combination. Why would they let someone else do it?
- simcop2387 12y agoI really hope one of them licenses the Johnny Cab name from total recall, and the likeness of Don Knotts. It'd be really cool to see something from the movies come to life like that and it'd probably end up a great way for other companies to sponsor taxis and get more exposure to people.
- purringmeow 12y agoThat occupation will disappear, save for a few high-end human driver services, IMO. After the taxis come the trucks. I am quite certain shipping companies will be the quick ditch humans. After all, this means no more travel expenses & salaries, no more breaks, probably automatic unloading too! Goods will get cheaper, although hundreds of thousands of people will be out of work. I am scared.
- zanny 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income Also, I think the shipping cos will do away with their drivers first. Highway traffic is easier to navigate with an algorithm - nearly trivial if you could compel a retrofit of all vehicles with a low power radio broadcasting its position, so that any autonomous vehicles around it can perceive it via its own sensors, any external gps radar, and the cars pings. Even without that, it is easier to juggle the variables of a high way (multiple lanes, moving in a direction, consider merge traffic, maintain safe stop distances, etc) than to try to navigate intersections and pedestrian traffic. Also, 18 wheelers don't need human interfacing, whereas self driving taxis require that licensed, but non-owners, sit in the drivers seat of the taxi since nobody will let self driving cars pilot themselves without someone to take manual control if necessary for a while. Albeit, that remains a problem with the 18 wheeler, but I see letting self driving tractor trailers without pilots come much sooner than self driving taxis without the passenger in the drivers seat.
- notahacker 12y agoFor the last decade or so, human learner drivers in the UK have had to pass a video "hazard perception test" based on their ability to recognise potential developing hazards (kids playing near the roads, a cyclist confronted by a line of parked cars, a vehicle approaching a junction onto your lane) at a very early point before their movements make their entry into the roadway inevitable. This strikes me as something which is particularly difficult for an algorithm to process effectively (without generating lots of false positives, which also fails that segment of the test) especially based on the fairly low resolution video human users are presented with in normal test conditions. Hope they're not going to waive that for the bots, even if they do have 360 degree vision and superior concentration and reaction times.
- Buttons840 12y agoThat's true. I think of turning right at a crosswalk where some pedestrian is really anxious for their turn to walk, so they're standing right on the edge of the curb. I always pay careful attention to them and rely on my human intuition of body language, eye contact, etc, until I feel comfortable that they're going to remain on the edge of the curb instead of steeping out in front of me during my turn. A robot can't do this.
- seestheday 12y agoA robot should have much faster reflexes than you do. Robots should be able to compensate for people actively running or diving in front of them. The situation you describe should be very easy to compensate for. Don't bother relying on body language or eye contact, just automatically sense the person shaped object, if it is close to the roadway, slow to a speed where you can avoid easily if they step out. Assume that they will. Heck, add in a buffer so you don't bother the passengers of the car by having to slam on the brakes.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- georgemcbay 12y ago
- kstop 12y agoBut that's the worst month they could have chosen! June would make a lot more sense.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoA friend of mine noted that you could put self driving cars on the road in Italy right now and nobody would notice :-) I agree with the consensus that driverless cars are inevitable. And knowing that they are inevitable is kind of like knowing a train is going to derail on a curve before it does. You get some time to think about what is going to happen next. In the train case you would do things like get movable property out of the way, for the cars you can think about things like a defensible yard barrier. Some people already do this for drunks, but putting a 12 - 14" 'step up' along the edge of the property that borders the street will stop most out of control passenger vehicles. Laws will get tested and litigated, new ways to analyze risk will be developed, planners will want to think about how they design roads/signage/maintenance around them. I suspect this a 'moonshot' technology, which is one where you can demonstrate it in 1969 but can't actually repeat it commercially until 50 years later in 2019.
- srl 12y agoI'd say that the defining aspect of the original 'moonshot' technology was there was (sadly) no opportunity for commercial gain. Contrast with here, where, for a myriad of reasons, people could easily be convinced to pay substantially more for a driverless car (once safety is well-established).
- rmason 12y agoDid anyone else notice in the video that neither one of them were using seat belts? I love this tech. but I am not sure I have this blind a faith in it.
- jeffjia 12y agoSelf-driving cars need to be trained to run on left side now.
- avz 12y agoreturn -EWRONGSIDE;
- 1587 12y agogood!
- yxhuvud 12y agoJanuary? Wouldn't it be smarter to start in the summer when the road conditions are optimal?
- Aardwolf 12y agoI think all weather conditions should be tested?
- gaius 12y agoAn autopilot, great. But driverless, as in, no way for anyone to take control? No thanks. There are plenty of places your GPS can't take you the last few hundred metres, nor would you want it to, you want to decide where to park based on a variety of factors.
- jaakl 12y agoWhen I will see "UK to ban manual driving on public roads"?