5 ms·
China alarmed by US money printing
- savantguy 17y agoThe chinese are planning way ahead, think decades. Inflation != rising prices Inflation = Increase in the money supply Inflation HAS already happened, now the symptoms will start to accelerate. Hyperinflation is always a monetary event, not an economic event. Fiat currency is based on confidence in the government among other things. Gold is a bet against the government.
- philwelch 17y agoChina has some of the world's largest reserves of USD. It seems their bet is on the US government.
- Kadin 17y agoI agree with one of the commentators below the article ("B.Karn") that there always seems to be a bit of a "Clever Chinaman" undertone in these US/China articles. The Chinese do not have an enviable position; they're in serious trouble, and quite possibly in deeper trouble than the U.S. There's some not-well-concealed racism, reminiscent of the old "Crafty Jew" banker stereotypes, in the amount of credit the Chinese get. No matter what happens, it's always part of their master plan or to their advantage, at least as it's reported breathlessly in some quarters. It looks to me like they're screwed pretty badly, that they bet on the same sort of endless growth that burned everyone else, and their economic advice is the equivalent of the guy in the low-lying end of the boat giving suggestions on how everyone might bail faster.
- jhancock 17y agoThe quotes from Cheng Siwei come across just fine. I read it as pretty honest with a tinge of political cover. There is nothing in these quotes that is incorrect. They played a game that had this as its only outcome. Both the U.S. and China politicians have yet to answer for why they got in this game in the first place. We all know why this international debt bubble happened, greed. So far, there had been little political fallout from it. Not sure there should be. It happened in the open. Both the U.S. and Chinese populous got behind it and pushed forward. The conservative dissenters were a small minority in both countries.
- poutine 17y agoExactly. People have been going on how much the Chinese owe the US but it's that old classic line about "if you owe the bank a billion dollars". One of three things will happen: 1. A US president will stand up in front of the people and tell the country they cannot have schools, health care or the military as they must pay back the Chinese (and other creditors). 2. The US economy will grow faster than the debt. 3. The US will devalue the dollar through printing money until the debt is serviceable (perhaps in combination by some economic growth). Scenario 1 seems absurd. 2 has been the stated approach to debt to date but is no longer reasonable. 3 seems almost inevitable. The Chinese leadership wouldn't much care about the money since it's been an unwilling participant the whole way through, however they do fear the wrath of their people which has the potential to be cataclysmic. And seemingly being played the fool by the US will cause a huge loss of face indeed. It'll be interesting to see how they try to spin it internally.
- gruseom 17y agoI agree with one of the commentators below the article ("B.Karn") that there always seems to be a bit of a "Clever Chinaman" undertone in these US/China articles. B. Karn's comment (unless there's more than one) doesn't say that at all. So not only have you read that sentiment into the article, you've read a pointing-out of it into a comment. (I agree that such a sentiment has existed in such articles in the past, but not in this one. Perhaps I'm missing the radar for it.)
- joe_the_user 17y agoYes, The financial regime that China has been on for the last fifteen years was bound to come to the present bad end. They could have let their currency appreciate more earlier and things wouldn't have been as fragile as they are now. But China felt such a need for industrial growth that they were willing partners in the last fifteen years' increasingly unbalanced growth. China is not necessarily more to blame than the US for this mess but they are one of the entities to blame. They certainly signed up for this program.
- DenisM 17y agoIt's probably less of racism and more of narrative fallacy - people just like to think there is some sort of a plan and a story to go with it. But it's a keen observation.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoYes, and the more secrecy there is the more everything appears to be part of a grand plan. Another such fallacy is to always assume that what happens is the result of a successful plan, when it's most probably the result of many conflicting plans with variying degrees of success plus a lot of randomness mixed in.
- nick-dap 17y agoA couple of weeks ago a friend pointed me to a blog entry about the coming inflation since the Fed supposedly printed vast quantities of new money. The blog entry felt very religious in proving someone defined as "deflationists" wrong, so I didn't think much of it. I am very much interested in open government data so I wondered how much of the financial data is actually available from the Fed in its raw form. It started as me wondering how full of shit this guys is and turned into five to six hours of trying to understand the raw data that is readily available from the Fed online. Their website is surprisingly good. What I saw did not make me happy. The Feds actions resulted in an EXPONENTIAL increase in monetary base of our economy: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monetary_base http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monetary_base Note that all I did is plot the numbers that the Fed supplies: http://img180.imageshack.us/img180/2792/44768686.png http://img180.imageshack.us/img180/2792/44768686.png It seems that all those "bad mortgages" that the Fed bought were not bought with "debt." The Fed bought them with freshly printed bills. Go on the Fed's website and download the data for yourself, don't take my word for it. Regardless, I dismissed my findings as "I don't actually know what I'm doing" and forgot about it. This article however is absolutely in line with what I saw happening from the raw economic data, so it makes me wonder. We _did_ print exponentially more money than we have ever done before. Look http://img180.imageshack.us/img180/2792/44768686.png http://img180.imageshack.us/img180/2792/44768686.png The Fed literally DOUBLED the amount of money in our monetary base in a matter of months. I can't imagine the Fed being able to take that much money out of circulation in nothing less than years. I also can't image how that could not be a very bad thing. Another thing that I saw is a rather sharp increase in how much banks are keeping in reserves since the Fed now guarantees interest on reserves. http://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/press/monetary/20081006a.htm http://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/press/monetary/2008... All this money in reserves has nowhere to go but into the economy once banks start spending it. It also pisses me off that our banks were essentially given a lot of money (when you see a doubling of money in the economy, thats a lot) for them to sit on and for us to pay interest on it! I am failing to understand the Feds plan. Can anyone enlighten me or is it really this simple?
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoI think the concern is justified. However, considering Japan during the 90s and the Great Depression makes deflation appear much more dangerous and persistent than inflation because no one knows how to fight it once it's become entrenched. We know how to fight inflation. Interest rates can be raised without limit. They cannot fall without limit. The Fed can sell the bonds they are now buying back into the market and thus reduce money supply. And you need to consider two other facts. First, the monetary base you plotted is just a small fraction of overall money supply (M1, M2, M3). Other parts of the money supply are growing as well but not as fast. Second, money that isn't used has no effect on inflation. The speed of circulation is sharply reduced in recessionary times and that's why the amount of money has to be sharply increased to counteract that potential deflationary spiral. The line you want to plot is the amount of all monies (the Ms) normalized over the speed of circulation. That line is flat to falling, but it's true that there is a potential for a sharp rise down the road. Inflation is very likely in say two years time. It's very difficult, politically, to raise interest rates while unemployment is still high. And inflating debt away is rather convenient for a heavily indebted nation like the US as well.
- 00A5 17y agoAs we continue de-valuing the dollar, China and other investors will convert their assets (cash being diluted by the fed) to physical assets and ownership equity (real estate and stocks). It's in their interest, and we provide the money management services to handle-hold them through it. This is not alarmist, but the US will be somewhat different with significant ownership by Chinese investors (in addition to the existing Dutch, Japanese, Saudi investors).
- lsc 17y agoisn't this what they said about japan in the 80's? I mean, I'm not saying you are wrong, but I'm just saying that last time this happened we ended up buying our stuff back for pennies on the dollar.
- jhancock 17y agocool, then all these foreign property holders can pay the taxes that support our schools and other social services. Ownership does come at a cost ;).