3 ms·
Let me be clear. I am not chiding you for pointing out that Scala does not have the backwards compatibility feature set it would need to compete with something
by kasey_junk 12y ago
Let me be clear. I am not chiding you for pointing out that Scala does not have the backwards compatibility feature set it would need to compete with something like C. Only that, C wasn't designed with backwards compatibility in mind, it just sort of arrived at it. Scala is most certainly sacrificing compatibility in the short term to allow for "improvability" for lack of a better term. I have no idea if that is a good or bad thing, but my intuition is as a new language with low uptake it makes some sense. A major challenge going forward is going to be maintaining the proper balance with regards to compatibility.
I couldn't agree more about SICP and TAoCP but you'll notice that neither is written in a widely adopted language.
I'm surprised that you actually use bare Tex. Even the most ardent users at this point will at least start with LaTex even though it isn't technically as portable...
Finally, how do you cook an egg not on the stove?
- taeric 12y agoI don't actually use Tex that often. That admiration just comes from realizing that all of my old .tex files still work. As do all of Knuth's. Has been educational going through some of them that I can get my hands on. I also think that the bare Tex that he writes is easily as readable as any of the latex I have ever written. Even the somewhat archaic looking cweb that he writes is actually more approachable than I would have expected. Egg cooking is just one of the most gadget filled areas of kitchen accomplishments I personally know of. Seems every time I'm in the grocery store I see some new little device that lets me microwave eggs "perfectly." A friend has a toaster that will toast your English muffin at the same time that it steams an egg. Neat and all, but amusing in how little work it actually saves.
- kasey_junk 12y agoAs someone who has spent a long time trying and failing (and taking classes) on how to cook eggs correctly, I completely understand the hopeful nature of an egg cooking gadget. That said, I've never found one I preferred to the standards. For what it's worth, I do prefer Scala to Java ;)
- taeric 12y agoI'm curious on how you are trying to cook your eggs, now. :) I fully acknowledge that there are some ways I don't have the patience to do. The double boiler method, for instance. I also just don't care for cream in my eggs. Plain scrambled works fine for my tastes. Regardless, I am not trying to deter folks from Scala. I don't necessarily hate Java, though. I have been less of a fan of static typing in recent years than I was before, though. My stance is more on tooling than it is on typing. (Granted, I realize that the typer is just a tool, as well. Seems common in the statically typed world, for all tools to converge into one, though.) Honestly, I could rewrite your sentence on cooking eggs correctly to "using the typesystem correctly" and it would be about the same for me.