7 ms·
Atlantropa
- batmansbelt 12y agoWow that's pretty fucked. No one would even dream of anything so crazy these days. The world certainly has improved in the past 90 years.
- wyager 12y agoWhat is "pretty fucked" about this?
- limsup 12y agoDude, it's totally fucked. Like removing the sea from seaside towns. i'm sure if you're a mediterranean fisherman you would not be happy having the sea forcibly moved away from your home... The environmental impact is probably immeasurable.
- wyager 12y agoHow is this any worse than normal dam construction, apart from scale?
- lolpep8 12y agoScale.
- smacktoward 12y agoHow is a flood worse than a drop of water, apart from scale?
- mavdi 12y agoWise words.
- twright 12y agoThere would be some pretty vast ecological repercussions. Fish habitats and coastal ecosystems, would be immediately affected. Then, connecting rivers will cut deeper, unforeseeably altering each and every environment they affect.
- sneak 12y agoIf the engineering effort fails, an incalculable amount of life and property would be destroyed. Even if it succeeds, a huge amount of costly adjustment would be required by a very, very large number of people.
- jqm 12y agoCeasing to dream big isn't an improvement. But ya... it's probably for the best the project didn't happen (yet:).
- batmansbelt 12y agoPeople still dream big, but the ideas that destroy millions of lives and ruin habitats are falling out of favour.
- exratione 12y agoImposing large scale engineering projects of this nature will probably have to wait until after production and point control of self-replicating nanorobots, organic or otherwise, is fairly mature. At that point the cost reduces down to design and raw materials and looks feasible when compared to simply going to other worlds in search of additional space, or building arcologies, or other methods. Sadly much vision has been lost somewhere in the last century. People are much more conservative about preserving the present state of whatever exists, and have lost the sense of wonder and ambition that characterized the opening of the modern age of machinery.
- ertdfgcb 12y agoWell, he did think it would take over a century. It would be nice if this could be completed in our lifetime, but that was never part of the plan (at least not the original plan)
- twright 12y agoCan you say more about this ambition we've lost? In my eyes that ambition is more arrogance that we can control the forces of nature around us without consequence.
- junto 12y agoOne man's engineering visionary is another man's environmental disaster. Just an observation.
- aaronem 12y agoIt is the peculiar human genius that we adapt our environment to ourselves, as well as the converse; we're not the only species on Earth which does so, but we're the only one for which adapting our environment is the keystone of a species survival strategy so successful that we have made ourselves, and for the foreseeable future will remain, the entire planet's apex predator. Lately, we hear much of how this strategy is doomed to failure, of how such failure will come sooner rather than later, and of how anything less than its immediate and radical replacement will surely doom our species. I don't buy it for a second. That the developed world has some rough times ahead, I don't doubt. But we're smart apes, and mean, and tough to kill, and there are an almighty lot of us. Perhaps we're due a new dark age, and perhaps not. But if so, we'll come out of it eventually, and we'll be better and smarter still for it, just like we were last time. Be it ever so popular of late, the belief otherwise is, in my considered opinion, born entirely of arrogance, in two parts: first, that even we have the capability to so radically reëngineer this planet as to no longer support our species, and second, that our species is somehow apart from nature, such that the axiom that all species not killed outright by them eventually adapt to changes of environment, somehow does not apply to us. That humanity is special, I happily agree, but we are not gods.
- igravious 12y agoHilarious that the first two comments are diametrically opposed: "Wow that's pretty fucked" versus "Sadly much vision has been lost somewhere in the last century" I'm going to tread a line between the two and say that I miss the visionary engineering works of old but that I am not completely heedless of the Law of Unintended Consequences. I do think that the Straits of Gilbraltar should be either bridged or dammed. (I'm assuming damming means bridging.) Too good an economic opportunity to pass up.
- ch4s3 12y agoThere are a number of large predatory fish like Atlantic bluefin that migrate from the western Atlantic to the Eastern Mediterranean and a damn would likely disrupt their spawning cycle. That isn't the only trans-atlantic species, and you only have to remove 1 or 2 apex predators to disrupt whole ecosystems. The dam is a terrible idea.
- gbog 12y agoI don't know. Many people repeat this mantra and fear disruption of ecosystems, presumably because they like nature and want to keep it safe. I also like nature, but in another way: it is a formidable survival machine, and whatever happens to it, be it a comet or the regrettable loss of one fish, it will survive and flourish again, with even more diversity and colors.
- tinco 12y agoNo, not with more diversity and colors. The general idea is that when the balance is disturbed a whole range of specialist species will die and only generalist species remain. It can take millennia before specialist species reemerge. You'll end up with more rats and jellyfish, and less whales and elephants.
- gbog 12y agoBut meanwhile these generalist species have specialized, so it is just a regeneration cycle. Moreover I kind of agree with Taleb on the Black Swan / Antifragile theories: the more we protect something (our kids, world finance, ecosystems) the more fragile they become, and the more dangerously they fail when they fail (because they will fail, it's just a matter of time). I think this is well understood for startups and projects: fail early, often, learn from mistakes, what do not kill us makes us stronger, etc. This is obvioulsy the same when growing kids, and I personally take care that my 1.5 daughter is falling enough on the safe floor of our house and eat enough dirt in our courtyard, so she will not be fragile when going to kindergarten, where she will catch viruses anyway. I think this applies equally well or better on natural environment: if we protect an ecosystem in order to prevent it from disappearing, maybe we are just prevent a new, more solid and more adapted ecosystem to appear there. I know, this is pure heresy. I think we need more heresy.
- incision 12y agoAwesome, in the more formal sense. Reading about the intended colonization of Africa puts me in mind of something I read about Moroccan phosphate reserves [1] a while back. 1: http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/essential-element-becoming-scarce-experts-warn-of-impending-phosphorus-crisis-a-690450.html http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/essential-element-...
- desireco42 12y agoNo wonder they are digging out this Nazi projects now when they occupied us on Balkans. But as before, we will rise again and free ourselves. Not that everything Nazis did was bad, but this is classic megalomanic project, which honestly doesn't sound completely bad, but it is like those Chinese 3 gorges dam, huge and rife with potential problems.
- austinz 12y agoI don't think big projects are intrinsically bad because they are big, but it's probably true that something of this scale would have drastic, wide-ranging effects on climate, geological characteristics, rainfall, and many other aspects that might adversely affect millions of people. Due diligence would require us to study and characterize these effects before spending trillions of dollars on such a project.
- opminion 12y agoIn fact, the formation of the Mediterranean is mentioned in Episode 9 of Cosmos (2014), in the context of climate change affecting evolution. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lost_Worlds_of_Planet_Earth http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lost_Worlds_of_Planet_Earth
- acqq 12y agoNote also what I consider a spamming by "Cathcart, R.B." who probably added to the article himself the big list of his texts as relevant for the subject and even a clumsy attempt to the citation.
- jzila 12y agoThere's a documentary about the project here: http://vimeo.com/92381391 http://vimeo.com/92381391. Fascinating watch.
- dinkumthinkum 12y agoNice, this was interesting. Thanks for sharing; I never really see good documentaries on vimeo, but I don't go looking often.
- adrianN 12y agoIf you like this, you should get yourself a copy of "Engineer's Dreams" by Ley. It is fairly old and full of such grand projects. One of them, the Channel Tunnel, is no longer a dream.
- kumarski 12y agoany other book recommendations?
- chiph 12y agoIt's fiction, but still a fun read: Harry Harrison's A Transatlantic Tunnel, Hurrah! In Which Our Hero, A Descendent of the Traitorous George Washington, Builds a Railway Under The Sea, Wherein Passengers Travel To The Court of Her Britannic Majesty In Atomic Powered Comfort. http://www.amazon.com/Transatlantic-Tunnel-Hurrah-Harry-Harrison/dp/0765327864 http://www.amazon.com/Transatlantic-Tunnel-Hurrah-Harry-Harr...
- adrianN 12y agoI also enjoyed "Project Orion: The True Story of the Atomic Spaceship" by Dyson. It's about another grand engineering project at the edge of possibility: Building spaceships powered by nuclear bombs that theoretically could lift whole cities to the stars and accelerate to 3% of the speed of light.
- avz 12y agoBrings to mind Aral Sea where the diversion of rivers for irrigation projects have led to the shrinking of the sea area with disastrous consequences for local ecosystems and communities. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aral_Sea http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aral_Sea EDIT: There must be better ways to become a Type I civilization http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kardashev_scale http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kardashev_scale
- thisjepisje 12y agoDoes anything come closer to this than Flevoland? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flevoland http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flevoland Slightly related: "a narrow body of water was preserved along the old coast to stabilise the water table and to prevent coastal towns from losing their access to the sea."
- ern 12y agoWhen I read the first paragraph, I was immediately reminded of my feelings when watching the Star Trek:TNG episode, made in the late 80's where Picard considered quitting Star Fleet to head the Atlantis Project. When I watched that episode recently, I found the idea that future people would allow large alterations to the earth to be discordant. It is interesting that, according to the article, Roddenberry also incorporated the idea of a dam across the Strait of Gibraltar into one of his works. Today, I expect that terraforming Mars and mining the moon will face significant opposition. Would massive land reclamation projects like those in the Netherlands ever happen today, if a particular hyper-conservation Western mindset were in place when they commenced? We can't even let go of outdated urban streetscapes, and buildings past their useful lifespans[1], so it isn't far-fetched to think of moon miners having to recreate impact craters on the moon's surface after mining them, if mining happened in the first place. Large segments of humanity are becoming sclerotic. Even if [2] the positive effects of damming the Mediterranean (or terraforming central Australia or Antarctica) were found to outweigh the losses, and the impacts could be mitigated, it would still be extremely unlikely to happen, for sentimental reasons. [1] See recent news about Lloyds of London building, which has became an expensive burden, but can't be touched because of its "iconic" status [2] yes, obviously there are risks, and they would need to be weighed carefully.
- omegaworks 12y agoRealize you are considering completely altering the hydrology that has historically served as the cradle of humanity's longest-lived civilizations. This project would touch huge population centers, many different cultures that speak different languages. What happens when people that have lived in costal communities for generations suddenly find themselves landlocked? There's a reason this was an undertaking contemplated in the time period that it was. Herman Sörgel could propose this and simply not care what the consequences would be for the people that were already present. The Superior Race simply needed more Lebensraum, to hell with the inferior races. One man's sclerosis is another man's stability. This is not hyper-conservation Western mindset, this is living in a world where one remote political power can not radically alter the living conditions for millions of people that are not represented in that power.
- skrebbel 12y agoThe Atlantropa movement, through its several decades, was characterised by four constants: - ... - Pan-European sentiment, seeing the project as a way to unite a war-torn Europe; - White-centric superiority (and even racist) attitudes to Africa - ... It interests me how such a positive sentiment (Pan-Europanism) can be combined with a very negative sentiment (white supremacism) without any trouble. I'm not sure we can play the "they were different times" card so easily. Currently, the EU has open borders, so the Pan-Europanism part worked out quite well, actually. As a consequence, the outer borders of the EU have become rock hard, because once you made it to Spain or Italy, you made it to most of Europe. We treat Africans who try to make it across like animals - not out of some white supremacist sense, admittedly, but the effect is the same.
- nnx 12y ago"Most proposals to dam the Strait of Gibraltar since that time have focused on the hydroelectric potential of such a project, and do not envisage any substantial lowering of the Mediterranean sea level." This sounds a tiny bit more sane. What would be the capacity of such a gigantic hydroelectric dam?
- ARothfusz 12y agoIs there an explanation for how adding these dams lowers water levels?
- sbierwagen 12y agoThe Mediterranean loses more water to evaporation than it gains from rivers and rainfall. It's only at sea level because it's connected to the Atlantic at the Strait Of Gibraltar. Dam the Strait, and the Mediterranean goes down. That isn't just speculation, the Mediterranean actually was a dry sea, when the Strait closed 5.9 million years ago: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mediterranean_Sea#Geology http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mediterranean_Sea#Geology A better question is "how quickly would the Mediterranean dry up if you dam Gibraltar?" A thousand years? More? Would you have to dam every river that drains into the Mediterranean?
- adrusi 12y agoIf the dam's levees were closed, the water in the mediteranian would evaporate like it always does, but no new water would flow in from the Atlantic. This has happened before. From 5.9 to 5.33 million years ago, the strait was closed and the entire sea evaporated. It will happen again, when the northward moving African plate collides with Europe.
- matthewmcg 12y agoThis is not mentioned in the article, but plate tectonics actually closed the straight of Gibraltar and caused the Mediterranean to completely dry out for a period of hundreds of thousands of years. It eventually reopened with what may have been the largest waterfall ever. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Messinian_salinity_crisis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Messinian_salinity_crisis