5 ms·
Chinese hackers have been incredibly good at infiltrating defense contractors around the world. This is just the latest in a very long list. These types of in
by bhouston 12y ago
Chinese hackers have been incredibly good at infiltrating defense contractors around the world. This is just the latest in a very long list. These types of intrusions really do reduce any technical military advantages the "West" has over China.
- atmosx 12y agoYes. Apparently Chinese are awesome at getting caught too. Especially in cases where you can't prove anything. Weird that Americans never get caught, who knows. Maybe US doesn't do that sort of things.
- nitrogen 12y agoThe US/Israel did get caught with Stuxnet, so either they wanted to be found or they aren't perfect at hiding either. Note that I'm not making any comment on the ethics; I'm just mentioning evidence of the other side's activity.
- jsolson 12y agoWere they actually "caught", or was it simply determined that the level of sophistication was something that could only have come from state-sponsored malware (a claim I find dubious at best, but whatever)?
- kyboren 12y agohttp://www.theregister.co.uk/2013/07/08/snowden_us_israel_stuxnet/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2013/07/08/snowden_us_israel_st...
- resu_nimda 12y agoI'm curious, why do you find that claim dubious? That is the conclusion of numerous top security experts, not just some pundits with an agenda. It seems like you're scoffing at the idea that only a national government could produce software that is "that good," or maybe even that they could at all, but mere code quality is not the whole basis for the claim. It's also the (initially) extremely precise target, the intelligence needed to affect the physical results they were after (disruption of uranium enrichment centrifuges), and the unprecedented effort to cover all tracks of the worm. Ralph Langner, whose team did a lot of the primary technical investigation into the worm, has said "the leading force behind Stuxnet is the cyber superpower – there is only one; and that's the United States." Here's his hour-long technical breakdown (with code): http://www.digitalbond.com/blog/2012/01/31/langners-stuxnet-deep-dive-s4-video/ http://www.digitalbond.com/blog/2012/01/31/langners-stuxnet-... His TED talk on Stuxnet: http://www.ted.com/talks/ralph_langner_cracking_stuxnet_a_21st_century_cyberweapon#t-11945 http://www.ted.com/talks/ralph_langner_cracking_stuxnet_a_21... A less technical article, which Schneier reposted as "the definitive analysis of Stuxnet [short version]": http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2013/11/19/stuxnets_secret_twin_iran_nukes_cyber_attack?page=full http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2013/11/19/stuxnets_se... There are also numerous bits of circumstantial evidence detailed on Wikipedia. A former Vice Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff was put under investigation by the DoJ last year for allegedly leaking info on Stuxnet and "Operation Olympic Games." At this point it's all but certain, I think one would need a pretty good reason to be doubtful.
- jsolson 12y ago> I'm curious, why do you find that claim dubious? That is the conclusion of numerous top security experts, not just some pundits with an agenda. It's entirely the notion that it could only have been state sponsored that I have trouble with. While there may be no organization with resources comparable to the US government to throw at cyber security in general, there are certainly organizations which can throw large resources at any given particular problem. Of course, other organizations that might have had the resources to create Stuxnet wouldn't have had the motive or the relevant context (knowledge of details of Iran's nuclear enrichment program) to do so. In that regard I don't doubt in the slightest that it was state sponsored malware, but I think it's dangerous to claim that anything could only have been state sponsored, as it accords a level of resourcing to the state that likely also applies to, e.g., organized crime or exceptionally large corporations who might not have our best interests at heart (not that I think the state always does either, mind you). That said, my original question was genuine. I didn't follow Stuxnet after the initial speculation that it looked like a state sponsored project, and thus I didn't know whether we'd been officially caught or whether it was still (extremely well founded) speculation.
- walshemj 12y agoThe fact that to build stuxnet required building an exact copy of the target uranium enrichment plant indicates that it was done by one or more states with deep pockets
- Gustomaximus 12y agoOr maybe the US are being caught but other countries don't typically publish the fact they are catching the US. I can't see chinese/Russian leadership announcing to the world their systems have been hacked.
- jandrewrogers 12y agoMany of the technical advantages that the "West" has over China with respect to weaponry are not based on things that are easily copied. The fundamental advanced technology behind most state-of-the-art weaponry is the ability to do bulk, ultra-precise fabrication of very exotic materials. There is an enormous gap between having the specifics of the design and implementing it effectively when it comes to advanced materials fabrication. There is quite a bit of arcane "magic" to it. This was the basic technology advantage the US had over the Soviets during the Cold War. Russians had access to our designs (the captured a lot of our weapons) but did not have the ability to fabricate the required materials at the precision required to effect their own copies of the capability.
- richmarr 12y agoThis advantage is either completely gone, or will be within the decade. China also has the advantage of being able to correct design mistakes, like the F35's lift fan.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Kalium 12y agoIn addition to the problems of fabrication and manufacturing, there is another issue. Specifically, China lacks the ability to design their own military systems. The ability to steal and maybe use the designs of others does not make up for this. Besides, it's never a purely technological advantage. There needs to be doctrine and well-trained troops in place too.
- phaus 12y ago>Besides, it's never a purely technological advantage. There needs to be doctrine and well-trained troops in place too. I was a Soldier for over a decade. Engineers and computer scientists are what makes our military great. Most nations have well-trained Soldiers. Many nations even have larger quantities of highly trained Soldiers than we do. The average citizen seems to think of basic training like its the Special Forces selection course. Basic training is incredibly easy. Its supposed to be easy, that's why its called basic training. Don't get me wrong, there are lots of good Soldiers in the U.S., but there is nothing inherently superior about the American fighting man. That kind of attitude makes it sound like we are some kind of master race.
- Kalium 12y agoI just meant that any given chunk of technology is pretty useless without people who can use it in deployment and tactical/strategic integration. I'm very familiar with the engineers and computer scientists you refer to.