3 ms·
We definitely need to get more creative with visas. Gov. Snyder here in Michigan has proposed in a meeting with President Obama that he help create 50,000 visa
by rmason 12y ago
We definitely need to get more creative with visas. Gov. Snyder here in Michigan has proposed in a meeting with President Obama that he help create 50,000 visas over five years for immigrants willing to live in Detroit. They would either have advanced degrees or exceptional ability in certain fields.
http://www.crainsdetroit.com/article/20140123/NEWS/140129933/snyder-seeks-50000-work-visas-to-lure-immigrants-to-detroit http://www.crainsdetroit.com/article/20140123/NEWS/140129933...
With 700,000 people living in a city that used to hold over two million there's plenty of room.
- HistoryInAction 12y agoActually, just to clarify some sloppy reporting in the Crain's piece, Gov. Snyder (@onetoughnerd) is requesting 50,000 immigrant visas, aka green cards. Big difference from non-immigrant visas. The specific visa requested is the EB-2, which basically requires a Masters or PhD as the credential needed to establish exceptional ability in a specific field.
- bilbo0s 12y agoThe main problem with that scheme is that it is designed to channel people to where he and the President WANT them... as opposed to where the United States NEEDS them. I think we should give out visas to Masters and PhDs and allow those people to go where they please. That way... we would get the best people as well... not just the most desperate.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoFrom a 'rate of employment in the population' perspective surely you don't want people immigrating who will replace native workers (or indeed any worker currently in post)? What's the benefit to the country if a new worker from abroad replaces a current worker but at a lower wage if that means the person 'usurped' needs state assistance or becomes under-employed (and bumps someone else from work to benefit-reliance)? Sure business owners probably benefit but such benefit seems pretty localised. How about if you let a lot of foreign workers come in who are well skilled and they flood a field in such a way that no students leaving college in that field can get a job. The incoming worker likely can accept lower wages which local [likely] debt-laden students can't. The field falls flat - the local population stop training in that field and you've either got a future skill crisis or a long-term reliance on immigrant workers. If you want to preference native/endemic population over immigrants at all then I think you need to be very specific in the immigration you allow.
- refurb 12y agoI like the creativity of the idea, but jesus, how would that work in reality? Do you have to prove residency in Detroit? Do you have to work for a company in Detroit? What if you pick up and leave? Do you get deported? How would they even track that?