3 ms·
I agree that the article is oversimplified and a bit overstated (you have to think about who it's written for and the context it's in), though I disagree with m
by WrennGo 12y ago
I agree that the article is oversimplified and a bit overstated (you have to think about who it's written for and the context it's in), though I disagree with many of your more specific criticisms. You criticize, for example, the Law of Equivalent Exchange as reflecting a primitive and pessimistic worldview, and also as being something that can be used to justify Luddism and ambivalence towards technology. But that's like blaming the shovel for digging the hole. Sure, it was used to dig the hole, but that hole was going to be dug either way (unless we take away ALL tools, including hands -- and THAT would be some extreme Luddism). If people want to rationalize and justify their prejudices, it hardly matters to them how they go about doing so -- as long as they do do so. Also, win-win situations exist within the Law of Equivalent Exchange -- it sounds like you think it could promote an overly position-based worldview (as opposed to a principle-based one), and I agree that, untempered with moderation, it could potentially lead to such a thing. However, if this advice is taken with moderation (as I suspect it typically will be), I see no harm in it, and actually some value in it.
-WrennGo
- ilaksh 12y agoThose worldviews are prevalent and that "law" is commonly used as one of the core belief nodes supporting those worldviews. Here's another example: tool selection by programmers. Many have a false belief that a programming language that performs must be difficult to use or require a lot of manual memory management or plumbing. This false belief is also supported by that incorrect belief node about the "law". Also, you know you don't have to sign your name on comments, right? It says your name at the top.