9 ms·
Crows can perform as well as 7- to 10-year-olds on cause-and-effect tasks
- bane 12y agoCrows are impressive animals. The more we learn about animal intelligence, the more I wonder what exactly it is that we do with all this extra brain matter we lug around. http://www.fromquarkstoquasars.com/crows-could-be-the-key-to-helping-humanity-understand-alien-intelligence/ http://www.fromquarkstoquasars.com/crows-could-be-the-key-to...
- bambax 12y agoCrows can do amazing things; a documentary shows crows dropping nuts on roads, waiting for passing cars to crack them open. But the problem then is to get onto the road to eat the content of the nut without being run over. Well, crows learned to drop the nuts at pedestrian crossings, and wait for read lights stopping all cars, to go collect the reward. Problem solved.
- kryptiskt 12y agoI have observed crows doing this with chestnuts on a crossing. And also a crow burying a chestnut, noticing that it was observed by another crow, then pretending that it buried the nut in another spot and vigorously defending the fake location from the other crow.
- Bulkington 12y agoBut can they beat chickens at tic-tac-toe? http://www.nytimes.com/video/nyregion/100000001595360/tick-tack-toe-playing-chicken.html http://www.nytimes.com/video/nyregion/100000001595360/tick-t...
- steveax 12y agoI live in a neighborhood that has lots of crows and lots of walnut trees and not much car traffic. The neighborhood crows have figured out that dropping the walnuts in the intersections increases the chances of them getting crushed. I'm running my own little social experiment: whenever I'm walking in the 'hood and I see a crow drop a walnut, I walk over and crush it. So far the crows have not started dropping nuts near me when they see me, but I have hopes :-) Related, crow vending machine: http://www.ted.com/talks/joshua_klein_on_the_intelligence_of_crows http://www.ted.com/talks/joshua_klein_on_the_intelligence_of...
- oldmanjay 12y agoas soon as crows start performing experiments on humans, I might share your wonder.
- blendergasket 12y agoJust last night I watched a really, really great documentary on crow intelligence called "A Murder of Crows". I highly, highly recommend it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s472GjbLKQ4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s472GjbLKQ4
- pyre 12y agoDirector's Statement: http://www.cbc.ca/natureofthings/features/directors-statement http://www.cbc.ca/natureofthings/features/directors-statemen...
- tunap 12y agoNever saw that, thx. His leap of faith worked out well for them. Another good bird IQ documentary, Nova's Inside Animal Mind: Birds... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-spBaywak7M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-spBaywak7M An even better read, IMO, but I am partial to the Corvus corax... https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/254704.Mind_of_the_Raven https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/254704.Mind_of_the_Raven
- swamp40 12y agoStoffel the honey badger is pretty innovative as well, (especially considering he was never trained): http://www.wimp.com/badgerhoudini/ http://www.wimp.com/badgerhoudini/
- lotsofmangos 12y agoI sometime wonder if wild crows and ravens can understand a lot of human language, but have a cultural ban on revealing this too often due to how much trouble it tends to cause.
- nathancahill 12y agoIn Tolkein's universe, the ravens of Erebor could understand and speak Westron. As with the rest of his works, Tolkein drew from Norse mythology, in which Odin's messenger ravens brought him news from around the world.
- tinco 12y agoIn Tolkien's universe, there are trees that understand and speak Westron...
- pjmorris 12y agoGary Larson did a 'Far Side' cartoon where cows were standing, enjoying conversations in the field until one of them yelled 'Car!', where they all went silent and dropped to all fours.
- astrobe_ 12y agoThis echoes to a statement in the "A Murder Of Crows" documentary linked in this thread, which goes like "They are smart, but we are the smartest". If there is an intelligence vastly superior than ours, what are the chances that we find out it exists? Can an "inferior" intelligence identify an other one as "superior"? Put in another way: if a superior AI emerges from one of our experiments, will we be able to understand its output?
- boomlinde 12y agoI'd say that if it was in its interest to communicate something, an intelligent being would be better equipped to do so than an unintelligent being.
- Qantourisc 12y ago
- randall 12y agoAnother researcher thinks effects like this are due to language in humans. (Maybe not directly linked, but somewhat related) Basically the experiment was to have a rectangular room with 4 white walls, and then another box with one blue wall. Researchers put some food in the room to the left of the blue wall, showed it to a rat, then spun the rat around, and the rat got it right 50% of the time. (IE random chance.) Researchers did the same experiment with kids, and kids under 6 failed every time. Though after age 6, kids start using spacial language and can say the phrase "left of the blue wall", which implies to the researcher we use language to connect different disparate parts of the brain. More on this during this radiolab episode: http://www.radiolab.org/story/91725-words/ http://www.radiolab.org/story/91725-words/
- wyager 12y ago>which implies to the researcher we use language to connect different disparate parts of the brain I've always felt this was the case in my own mind. Language is the serialization format for abstract concepts. This is why I'm very interested in constructed languages. I think it might help human cognition if we had a more efficient serialization format for internal concept transport.
- skrebbel 12y ago> Language is the serialization format for abstract concepts. Woa nice! Good analogy. Will steal.
- catshirt 12y agoit's a definition, not an analogy. language is just our best tool for sharing feelings, concepts, etc. funny to think it's (probably) ultimately not the best tool for that. :)
- e12e 12y agoNot that I disagree with your point, but I don't think spoken/written language is our best tool for sharing feelings. I'd say body-language is better for that. Or certain forms of art (such as visual art or music). All forms of communication, obviously. Language probably is our best way of communicating abstract concepts, however (now, are feelings abstract or concrete? ;-).
- pinaceae 12y agowell, to take the other perspective: little kids are not smarter than little animals. it's not like the typical 7-10 year old kid is a fountain of smartness. supervision is still needed, it is not able to sustain its existence by itself, would starve or get killed through its own inexperience - which makes those little animals superior.
- Drakim 12y agoSurvival can be a result of intelligence, but good survival abilities does not imply intelligence in itself. Tons of things survive without much intelligence at all, such as bacteria, or jellyfish. In short, survival skills are not a good metric for intelligence, you can have one without the other.
- superuser2 12y agoThis is certainly true of the average 7-10 year old kid raised in suburbia by ordinary parents and educated and public school, but childhood and helplessness have been vastly prolonged artificially. Maybe not a 10 year old, but a 12 year old in the Industrial Revolution would have been earning enough to cover his costs and contribute to the family. A 14 year old could also be doing just fine as a mother. It's not as if teenagers' poor life-skills are functions of their age, we just choose not to let them have the requisite experience until they are "old enough." Children are technically capable of much more than we give them credit for, we just would rather they spend time gaining the education to be knowledge workers instead of replaceable cogs in factories. You couldn't just throw an average modern 10-year-old on the streets and expect him to be fine, but it's historical fact that it is possible for children not to be so helpless.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoA huge fraction of those historical self-sufficient kids also died young for preventable reasons.
- superuser2 12y agoBut is that because they were treated like adults, or because healthcare was primitive and unevenly distributed?
- whoopdedo 12y agoLooking forward to the Crow Computing revolution.
- linker3000 12y agoEnabled by crowed funding
- iagooar 12y agoYou, guys, just crowsed the line.
- cyorir 12y agoThis is kind of off-topic but birds can be pretty advanced in surprising ways. In particular, birdsongs can be pretty complex and some species have evolved specific cognitive functions for understanding, replicating, and producing birdsongs. It is conceivable that features evolved in relation to some tasks may also enhance behavior in other cognitive tasks. I would not be surprised if quite a few species besides crows perform just as well for the task mentioned in the article, and others. Here is a neat review relating to songbirds: http://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?p=3261 http://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?p=3261
- gulpahum 12y agoCrows and magpies are the smartest birds on earth. European magpies pass the mirror test, something very rare animals and only children over 18 months do: http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn14552-mirror-test-shows-magpies-arent-so-birdbrained.html#.U9K0T1YRZGI http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn14552-mirror-test-show...
- mross462 12y agoExcellent PBS Nature episode on the subject too: http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/episodes/a-murder-of-crows/full-episode/5977/ http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/episodes/a-murder-of-crows/fu...
- ziggrat 12y agoIn Islam we are told to love kids till 7 by holding them close to us. Just conversation and love. Tell them to pray when they are 10 and use harsh language if necessary after 10. I know i am talking to a highly intelligent audience in this forum, most of which is atheist. I love you as a fellow human and would request you to know about Islam through Quran not through the Media or by looking at Muslims(coz most of us are doing it wrong)
- ChikkaChiChi 12y agoYou may have been expecting to post this in another thread. Otherwise, it's off-topic.
- rsynnott 12y ago> In Islam we are told to love kids till 7 by holding them close to us. Just conversation and love. The Jesuits put this a little more sinisterly: "Give me the child until he is seven and I’ll give you the man".
- sys32768 12y agoThese smart crows make chimps seem like mere monkeys.
- CurtMonash 12y agoTwo reasons to think birds excel at spatial reasoning: 1. Migration. 2. Nest-building. If you gave the same pile of materials to a robin and to me, I think the robin might do a better job of building a nest with it. I base this conjecture upon robin nests I've seen around my house.
- chenelson 12y agoMost humans don't experience much of the z axis without tools. Brain-machine interface with weak AI (translation) could drastically alter the intelligence debate.
- beachstartup 12y agowhat in the world are you talking about? "most" humans exist in 3 dimensions (x,y,z), all the time, with or without tools.
- chenelson 12y agoI'm talking about spatial intelligence and not the difference between Aristotelian and Boolean logic. Obviously I have no idea what it feels like to stack shorter than a pancake (i.e., existing in 2 dimensions). Pedantry aside, the difference between existence and experience seems obvious. I've never seen a human fly and well over 99% of my work is performed in the x and y axis. When communicating directions, I'm rarely concerned about z. Simple graphing tools (e.g., paper and pen) can be used to illustrate my point further.
- erikpukinskis 12y agoWe'll go to amazing lengths to modify these tests so that crows can perform at a 7 year old level, and we all accept that as fair, but when someone talks about modifying tests so that kids of a certain class/race background can score highly everyone thinks you're cheating and violating the sanctity of the test. Imagine if Google made an alternate set of tests for low income applicants that let them in at a 200% higher rate and announced "low income applicants perform at 22 year old level in Google applications with modified test".